Treaty of Versailles: Interpreting Cartoons What is the link between the Treaty of Versailles and 3rd October 2010? Watch the clip http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/germany/8029948/First-World-War-officially-ends.html Clip is about the final reparations payment made by Germany last year after repayments were stopped by Hitler, and were continued when Germany was re-unified.

Learning Objectives To develop skills of source analysis through making inferences To identify and explain why there were different attitudes to the Treaty of Versailles

Source Analysis; What can cartoons tell us? What can you infer from the source about attitudes towards the Treaty of Versailles?

MAKING INFERENCES Step 1: In one colour, label WHAT you can see (e.g.)

The caption says “Future cannon fodder” The child is crying Clemenceau says the child crying is “Curious” The child is naked

MAKING INFERENCES Step 2: In another colour, explain what you think the MEANING of these things are or what they symbolise.

The caption says “Future cannon fodder” The child is crying This means that the child will be of the generation that is used for “cannon fodder” in the next war. Because he will be of military age in 20 years and knows that the future will hold. Clemenceau says the child crying is “Curious” The child is naked Clemenceau does not understand what the consequences of the treaty will be. This means that he is innocent, helpless and vulnerable.

MAKING INFERENCES Step 3: Identify the Nature, Origin and Purpose (NOP) of the Cartoon.

It appeared in the Daily Herald, a British newspaper on 17th May 1919. 'Peace and future cannon fodder' - a cartoon by the Australian artist Will Dyson.   It appeared in the Daily Herald, a British newspaper on 17th May 1919. Satirical cartoon Part of the Commonwealth – on the same side as Britain. Britain was part of the Big 3 and had helped to defeat Germany. Pupils may need the word satirical to be explained again. Few months after the Treaty was negotiated.

MAKING INFERENCES Step 4: Does the NOP affect how reliable what the cartoon tells us is?

It appeared in the Daily Herald, a British newspaper on 17th May 1919. 'Peace and future cannon fodder' - a cartoon by the Australian artist Will Dyson.   It appeared in the Daily Herald, a British newspaper on 17th May 1919. Satirical cartoon Designed to make leaders look bad – making fun of them Part of the Commonwealth – on the same side as Britain. Could be biased against Germany Britain was part of the Big 3 and had helped to defeat Germany. Pupils may need the word satirical to be explained again. Few months after the Treaty was negotiated. Could be biased against Germany Cartoon from same period, would most likely know a lot about the treaty and public opinion

MAKING INFERENCES Step 5: Tying it all together and answering the question.

What can you infer from the source about attitudes towards the Treaty of Versailles? The source infers that… The source implies that… The source suggests that… The nature of the denotes… The origin of the source suggests… The purpose of the source infers…

You will be given a National Curriculum Level for your answer. What can you infer from the source about attitudes towards the Treaty of Versailles? Step 1: In one colour, label WHAT you can see. Step 2: In another colour, explain what you think the MEANING of these things are or what they symbolise. Step 3: Identify the Nature, Origin and Purpose (NOP) of the Cartoon. Step 4: Does the NOP affect how reliable what the cartoon tells us is? Step 5: Tying it all together and answering the question. Give the pupils 1 of the 6 cartoons for them to answer the question about. If you wish pupils can choose their own. For lower ability groups you may like to select one to do together and then have them all write up the same cartoon. You will be given a National Curriculum Level for your answer.

A British cartoon published in August 1919. Pupils who have worked on this cartoon can feedback to the class as to what the cartoon means and what they have inferred from it.

A cartoon from a German newspaper along side a news story explaining the outcome of the Paris Peace Conference. Pupils who have worked on this cartoon can feedback to the class as to what the cartoon means and what they have inferred from it.

A cartoon from a German newspaper along side a news story explaining the Treaty’s terms on Germany’s Army. Pupils who have worked on this cartoon can feedback to the class as to what the cartoon means and what they have inferred from it.

A German-Swiss Cartoon about the peace treaty published in July 1919. Pupils who have worked on this cartoon can feedback to the class as to what the cartoon means and what they have inferred from it.

A German cartoon published in September 1919. Pupils who have worked on this cartoon can feedback to the class as to what the cartoon means and what they have inferred from it.

An Australian cartoon published in August 1919. Pupils who have worked on this cartoon can feedback to the class as to what the cartoon means and what they have inferred from it.

Before the Before : After the After Causes and Consequences of the Treaty of Versailles Draw and complete the table below. What do you think the consequences of the Treaty will be? 5 years before 1 year before 1919 14 years after 20 years after Treaty of Versailles Plenary: Some students will know the exact consequences of the Treaty of Versailles; 1933 Hitler becomes Chancellor and 1939 Outbreak of 2nd world war. Some pupils will need prompting and can refer to the sources they have looked at in the lesson for pupils. Stretch and Challenge: Push pupils to explain how the treaty might have contributed to Hitler coming into power.

Bonus Task; Cartoon Competition Design your own cartoon about the Treaty of Versailles for a newspaper in 1919. Decide on the NOP of your cartoon (are you British? German? Etc. and include it underneath your cartoon). Write a caption. Annotate and explain your cartoon.