S. Barbanotti - DESY Requirements Conformance for SRF Cryomodules Workshop 16/10/2014 – ESS, Lund XFEL cryostat main components: Quality Assurance and.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Trip Report on the visit to ICST of HIT, Harbin, China Derun Li Mike Green Steve Virostek Mike Zisman Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (from December.
Advertisements

NIOWAVE Requirements for Manufacturing Readiness: (Beamtube Assembly only) Due 1 month before start of manufacturing for CERN approval.
Materials Bratislava 11/12/13 April 2005 Presented by Peter Hanmore For the benefit of business and people TAIEX Workshop on the Pressure Equipment Directive.
U D T Workshop on the Pressure Equipment Directive, Warsaw June 2004 INTERFACES BETWEEN NATIONAL LEGISLATION AND DIRECTIVE 97/23/EC SYSTEM OF ENSURING.
Supplier Overview of Johnson & Johnson MD&D Supplier Quality Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) Receiving Inspection Process for Components and Finished.
Status report on “Industrialization studies” at LAL on power couplers for XFEL _____ TILC08 – Tohoku University 3-6 March 2008 Sendai - Japan G. Wormser.
From Research Prototype to Production
SFOBB East Span Seismic Safety Project Steve Margaris, Specifications Engineer, Caltrans.
ESS cavities interfaces
Beam Vacuum Quality Control Outline  VSC consolidation  VSC support  Organization  Status Cédric Garion on behalf of TE-VSC Cédric Garion TE/VSC Beam.
LCLS-II cryomodule alignment. 2 Wednesday meeting, 6/17/2015 Topics Alignment of Components inside the CM Tunnel Network Tolerances LCLS-II cryomodule.
Aloe Vera of America: A Quality IASC-Certified Producer of Aloe Vera Presented by Walt Jones.
FNAL Cavities for S1 Global Jim Kerby ALCPG 09. FNAL Deliverables Discussed in meetings 15/16 July and 10/11 Sept, and Webex and s 9/30/20092FNAL.
Thermosiphon Project - Condenser repair CERN – Geneva January 8 th, 2014 M. Battistin & all TS team ATLAS + EN/CV.
Assembly Organisation and Duration. Work Site Organisation STORAGE SMA18 UNLOADING CLEAN ROOM CERN-SITE CLEANING MANUFACTURE DIRTY TRIAL ASSEMBLY ISO7.
INSPECTION AND ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA. PRODUCT CONFORMANCE Dimensional conformance - within tolerances as defined on product drawing Dimensional conformance.
The HiLumi LHC Design Study is included in the High Luminosity LHC project and is partly funded by the European Commission within the Framework Programme.
ESS Spoke Cryomodules: QA / QC Plans Workshop on Requirements Conformance for SRF Cryomodules, 15 th -16 th October 2014 Denis Reynet, Veronique Poux Sebastien.
TD/MSD REVIEW CHARGE AND AGENDA Clas12 Torus CCM Production Readiness Review –Dec 4, 2013.
Accelerator/WP High Beta Structures Alan Wheelhouse HIGH-BETA CAVITY DELIVERY April 21, 2015.
Americas Cavity Specification C.M. Ginsburg (Fermilab) On behalf of the Fermilab cavity crew October 20, 2010.
LASA Medium-β Cavity Progress Update Paolo Michelato 2 nd ESS Collaboration Meeting - SRF Elliptical Cavities 15 th December 2015.
Shrikant_Pattalwar TTC 2015 Dec 1, 2015 SLAC 1 Horizontal Tests in a Vertical Cryostat Shrikant Pattalwar STFC Daresbury Laboratory UK.
Carlo Pagani University of Milano INFN Milano-LASA & GDE ILC and XFEL Cryomodules Preliminary thoughts for convergence ILC EDR Kick-off Meeting DESY,
Date 2007/Sept./12-14 EDR kick-off-meeting Global Design Effort 1 Cryomodule Interface definition N. Ohuchi.
S1-Global status report KEK Norihito Ohuchi 2008/11/171ILC08-GDE-Meeting-Chicago.
CM2 Repair Status 8/13/2012 Tug Arkan 1. Latest Status After the warm end couplers were disassembled, it was decided to disassemble all the lower aluminum.
Collaborating for Quality Quality Assurance (QA) & Quality Control (QC) in the Accelerator Project (ACCSYS) Matthew Conlon ACCSYS QA/QC
LCLS-II Prototype Cryomodule Vacuum Vessel and HGRP Tom Peterson 4 December 2014 Design Review.
- Generals for PED matters - Definition of pressure vessel and classes - Who is who according to PED - Definition of pressure vessel + codes for XFEL -
LCLS-II Button-type BPM (Review) Nikolay Solyak Review, FNAL, Dec. 12, 2014.
CM2 Helium Circuit Vacuum Leak & Repair Tug Arkan, 6/18/
Visiting DESY for S1-G module Norihito Ohuchi 2009/8/251 19th Biweekly Webex meeting (S1-G, Cryomodule, Cryogenics)
26 April, 2016 LCLS II Cryomodules and Cryoplant, Joe Preble LCLS-II Overview JLAB Organization for LCLS-II JLAB responsibilities & Schedule and Status.
W. Singer. SRF2011, July 25 ‐ 29, 2011, Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A. XFEL Cavity Recipe for Mechanical Fabrication and Treatment Waldemar Singer/DESY.
Shrikant_Pattalwar ICEC 26, March 7-11, 2016, Delhi 1 Horizontal Tests in a Vertical Cryostat Shrikant Pattalwar STFC Daresbury Laboratory UK.
LCLS-II Prototype Cryomodule FDR J. Blowers, C.M. Ginsburg, T. Peterson, R. Stanek, J. Theilacker (FNAL) 21 – 22 January 2015 Homework Responses.
LCLS-II Prototype Vacuum Vessel (VV) and Helium Gas Return Pipe (HGRP) FDR Planned Quality Control Effort (QC) Ken Premo 12/04/14.
Development of Cryo-Module Test Stand (CMTS) for Fermi Lab (R.L.Suthar, Head,CDM, BARC) Cryo-Module Test stand (CMTS) is a very sophisticated equipment.
Cryomodule Interconnect Installation Issues A Comparison of XFEL to LCLSII Karen Fant 7/29/2015.
ESS Cryomodule Status Meeting – Introduction | | Christine Darve Introduction to Cryomodules for the ESS 2013 January, 9 th Christine Darve.
Prototype Cryomodule FDR Ken Premo 21 – 22 January 2015 High Power Coupler Design.
K. Jensch - DESY Requirements Conformance for SRF Cryomodules Workshop 16/10/2014 – ESS, Lund XFEL cryomodules: Quality Requirements and Regulatory & Safety.
Collaborating for Quality through the Project Quality Plan Matthew Conlon ESS ACCSYS QA/QC Quality Learning & Planning.
WP High Beta Cavities Delivery
Crab Cavity Technical Coordination meeting:
Quality assurance for Manufacturing Dressed Cavities for SPS prototype cryomodule C. Parente (HL-LHC Technical Quality Officer) Date:
Preparation of functional/engineering specifications for HL-LHC
Ti/SS transitions A.Basti INFN-PISA*
Cryostat procurement, status and plan, QA/QC
Documentation (XFEL Naming convention, uploading…)
The 11T cryo-assembly: summary of design and integration aspects
WP 3 coordination meeting Saclay May 2008
Horizontal Tests in a Vertical Cryostat
XFEL Cold mass & vacuum vessel non-conformities Detected At saclay
MICE Coupling Coil Update
Teleconference ACS – FREIA 20th February 2018
ESS approach and support for Declaration of Conformity (CE-marking) Fredrik Håkansson 9th SRF ESS
Installation Binder / IRR – an example
A. Bignami on behalf of LASA SRF Group
ESS approach and support for Declaration of Conformity (CE-marking) Fredrik Håkansson 9th SRF ESS
Cryomodule ESS FAT & SAT SRF meetinG on 07/11/2017
INTERFACES BETWEEN NATIONAL LEGISLATION AND DIRECTIVE 97/23/EC
SNS PPU Helium Vessel Design and Assembly
Spoke section of the ESS linac: - Status of prototypes and CDS-SL
ESS High Beta Cavities Quality Assurance and Control - Learning and Planning Workshops, CEA Saclay, 30 June - 1 July 2016 Mark Pendleton STFC, Daresbury.
Bunker Project Schedule/Budget
CDS-EL IRR Closeout 28 March 2019 J.G. Weisend II, Chairman.
CE compliance -LLRF- Anders Svensson, ESS
Paolo Michelato LASA - Status of cavity documentation, fabrication, inspection and NCRs Laura Monaco INFN – LASA 10° ESS SRF Collaboration Meeting, 25.
Presentation transcript:

S. Barbanotti - DESY Requirements Conformance for SRF Cryomodules Workshop 16/10/2014 – ESS, Lund XFEL cryostat main components: Quality Assurance and Control

2 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Summary Main components in an XFEL cryostat Quality assurance and control of cold masses and vacuum vessels  Lessons learned Quality assurance and control of other components

3 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti What are we speaking about?

4 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Components under the WP03 responsibility Cryostats and cold masses produced in China and delivered to DESY  Quality control at the company and at DESY Cryostats and cold masses produced in Italy and delivered to CEA-Saclay  Quality control at the company Ti end-connections, quadrupole-pipes, filling lines, flanges produced or assembled in house by DESY  Quality control at DESY

5 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Part 1 COLD MASS AND VACUUM VESSEL

6 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti It all starts like this…

7 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti …then it‘s more like this…

8 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti.. and at the end it looks like this.

9 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti And how do we control what we get? (1/2) Specifications, drawings, additional procedures (shipping conditions, painting, required dimensional controls) are defined at the very beginning of the work. The production is mainly regulated by the requirements for the PED certification; this means:  Verification by the manufacturer of production drawings and procedures  Use of certified materials, with traceability of the material certification on the single components  Approval by the manufacturer of the welding documentation:  weld design  welding procedures  welding personnel certification  The type and “quantity” of NDT tests on pressurized components are defined by the norm  NDT personnel has to be certified

10 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti And how do we control what we get? (2/2) Additional requirements are set by DESY as manufacturer:  Dimensional control of some sensitive components  Traction test of cold mass supports  Spot visual and destructive tests on pipes and welds (endoscope)  Regular visit to the production site during fabrication

11 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Examples (1) Verification of welds

12 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Examples (2) Tranction test Distuctive test on weld

13 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Examples (3) Dimensional survey

14 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Additional incoming controls at DESY Repetition of dimensional control with laser tracker Verification of main flange surfaces (no transport damages) Check of part list Verification of position of main pipes  many hours needed only for the QC

15 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Documentation For each CM and VV assembly, the complete documentation includes all the PED relevant certificates, test records, procedures, and the additional test records required by DESY The package is handled as follow:  The documentation of the main components is uploaded directly by the producer into the EDMS system  The documents are reviewed internally by DESY experts  The documentation is accepted (or rejected) by the WP03 co-leader responsible for the procurement This procedure has to be repeated for 100 components  quite time consuming Missing documentation delays acceptance of the components and PED certification  the delivery of a complete documentation is not just a “detail”, it’s a part of the whole production process

16 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti How did it work so far? Main non-conformities discovered:  11 cold masses not conform at incoming dimensional control in DESY  Rework at companies needed  Requires a lot of extra work (unpacking, packing, transport, …) and it‘s very time consuming  Components of the cavity support system (needle blocks and plates, bushes...) not acceptable (threads not working, parts dirty, …)  Sent back to companies  Effort needed to agree with the companies of the quality level required  Lot of „small“ non-conformities discovered in DESY, i.e. thermal shield profile, flanges not leak-tight, copper braids too short …  Fixed in house  Major NCs fixed by company personnel on DESY/Saclay site  Also very time consuming (small work for 100 times)

17 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Lessons learned – big subassemblies QA/QC process should be defined before the delivery of the first components  guarantee uniformity of the verified products, no “special cases”  allow the estimation of the time to be allocated for the QC The producer should be informed of the main QC points before the beginning of the production  awareness of the producer on the critical points of the product  possibility to do internal checks at the company before long transports Documentation is not a side aspect, it’s an integral part of the production In house verification of the delivered parts is very time consuming  alternative solution: quality control personnel permanently present at the producer during fabrication (at least for the first few components)

18 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Part 2 OTHER COMPONENTS

19 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti QA / QC of components assembled in house (1) Preparation of documentation:  Complete set of drawings  Welding documentation  Specifications for all ND tests (VT, LT, PT or RT)  Reports of ND tests Execution of assembly (cutting, welding, feedthrough assembling) performed following the specifications

20 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti QA / QC of components assembled in house (2) Traceability of the documentation: everything is uploaded in the EDMS and connected to the physical parts Inspection reports and Conformity declarations are issued by DESY as manufacturer  Parts ready for use in a PED assembly

21 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Other components Components delivered to DESY ready for used are either CE stamped or certified as “part of a pressure vessel” After a quick visual inspection and documentation check, these components are directly integrated in the main assembly Examples:  Ti-bellows  Ti-pipes for the cavity repair activity  Transition joints  Gate valve supports

22 Requirements Conformance for SRF cryomodules Workshop, ESS, Lund – 16/09/2014 S. Barbanotti Thank you for your attention!