Tacoma Smelter, 1961. Tacoma Public Library Photography Archive An Historical Perspective on one company’s manipulation of the science of occupational.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Steve Babb, MPH CDC Office on Smoking and Health National Association of County and City Health Officials webcast January 24, 2007 The Health Consequences.
Advertisements

Occupational Disease and Experience Rating. Overview  Statistics suggest a high prevalence of occupational disease (‘OD’) in New Zealand.  Our no-fault.
The Clear Advantages of Smoke-Free Apartments. Three Stages of Truth All truth passes through three stages: First it is ridiculed Second it is violently.
Causality Causality Hill’s Criteria Cross sectional studies.
1 WORKER SAFETY AND HEALTH PRACTICES AT GASEOUS DIFFUSION PLANTS IN THE DOE COMPLEX: RESULTS OF HISTORICAL INVESTIGATION ( ) Ronald Stolberg Office.
TRP Chapter Chapter 2.3 Environmental impacts and health risks.
No Borders: Communities Living & Working with ASARCO A project by Anne Fischel and Lin Nelson, with the support of the Evergreen Labor Center.
Environmental exposures  Cancer risks:  Tobacco smoke  Radon in homes  Arsenic.
Toxics Use Reduction Institute Chemicals Policy in Europe: New Directions Rachel Massey Policy Analyst April 2006.
Pay Attention to Books' Deadly Dust Relationship of Lung Cancer and Heart Attack to Library Books' Dust By Hassan Bolourchi Chemical Engineer, Ph. D.
Announcements ●Exam II range ; mean 72
CEEH workshop February 2008 The importance of demographic changes Henrik Brønnum-Hansen University of Southern Denmark.
Lesson 2 Why is radon a health problem?. Slide 2-1 Radon and lung cancer Radon is largest source of radiation exposure to general public Radon is leading.
Environmental Health XV. Risk Assessment Shu-Chi Chang, Ph.D., P.E., P.A. Assistant Professor 1 and Division Chief 2 1 Department of Environmental Engineering.
Excess Mercury Levels Increasing; Survey Shows Fifth of Women of Childbearing Age Are Affected The study, which was commissioned by an environmental advocacy.
Excess risk of kidney disease mortality in a population living near industrial processes Susan Hodgson (MSc) 1, Mark J Nieuwenhuijsen (PhD) 2, Anna Hansell.
The Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) Interagency Testing Committee (ITC)
FHM TRAINING TOOLS This training presentation is part of FHM’s commitment to creating and keeping safe workplaces. Be sure to check out all the training.
Occupational Health Module 1 – History of Occupational Health.
LEGAL ASPECTS OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE. Industrial Hygiene  The science and art devoted to the anticipation, recognition, evaluation, control and management.
Radon Overview Introduction: Radon and Radon Exposure Health Effects.
TCEQ/NUATRC Air Toxics Workshop: Session V – Human Health Effects Nathan Pechacek, M.S. Toxicology Section Texas Commission on Environmental Quality
[Name] County Public Meeting To gather citizen input on the need for and scope of a law to protect the public in [Name] County from the health dangers.
Introduction to Health Care and Public Health in the US Public Health (Part 2) Lecture c This material (Comp1_Unit8c) was developed by Oregon Health and.
Section 10.2: Errors in Hypothesis Testing. Test Procedure – the method we use to determine whether H 0 should be rejected. Type 1 Error: the error of.
Ten Reasons Not to Use Pesticides April, Pesticides don’t solve pest problems.
ANALYTICAL STUDIES Prospective Studies COHORT Prepared by: Dr. Sahar Sabbour Community Medicine Department.
Using a Comprehensive Occupational Exposure Database to Integrate Members of the Occupational Health Team and Improve Your Occupational Health Program.
Environment & Human Health
FAMILY HEALTH PROMOTION
TOBACCO FREE CAMPUS Employee Focus. 2 DELL CONFIDENTIAL Tobacco Free Campus (TFC) Policy (Dell – US) In an effort to promote the health and welfare of.
Improving Life, One Breath at a Time LUNG-USA
Reclaimed Wastewater Quality Criteria, Standards, and Guidelines
NATURAL RESOUCE DAMAGE ASSESSMENT AND RESTORATION Shelly Hall – Assistant Solicitor Branch of Environmental Restoration Branch of Environmental Restoration.
Health Effects of Air Pollution
Air Pollution Inwood Intermediate School 52
The Health Costs of Pollution. How many chemicals are out there? In the US we introduce 1,000 new chemicals every year. In the US we introduce 1,000 new.
Public Health and Risk Assessment (2nd of 10 Lectures on Toxicologic Epidemiology) Michael H. Dong MPH, DrPA, PhD  readings.
Chapter 15.3 Risk Assessment 2002 WHO report: “Focusing on risks to health is the key to preventing disease and injury.” risk assessment—process of evaluating.
Coffee and Cardiovascular Disease
Part 1d: Exposure Assessment and Modeling Thomas Robins, MD, MPH.
Chapter 15.1 Links Between Human Health and the Environment emerging diseases (avian flu, SARS, Ebola) appear as we continue to manipulate the natural.
NUATRC/TCEQ Air Toxics Workshop October Air Toxics Air Toxics: What We Know, What we Don’t Know, and What We Need to Know Human Health Effects –
THE OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ACT Brendon Clair.
Environmental Risk Analysis Chapter 6 © 2004 Thomson Learning/South-Western.
NIOSH AND OSHA REGULATIONS AND CONTACT LENS USE BY: DR. MARK W. BURCHAM.
Part 1b Part 1b NATURE OF THE ENVIRONMENT AND POPULATIONS; BASIC CONCEPTS OF EXPOSURE, DOSE AND RISK.
The Environment and Human Health
Promoting Patient Involvement in Medication Decisions David H. Hickam, MD, MPH Professor, Dept. of Medicine Oregon Health & Science University Portland,
Science of Toxicology The science of toxicology (tossicologia) is based on the principle that there is a relationship between a toxic reaction (the response)
Is Alcohol Consumption Correlated with Higher Rates of Cancer? Sammy Draper ‘14 and Amara Weiss ’14 Environmental Studies Department, Colby College, Waterville,
By: Thien Bui and Reshma Neupane 1. Lung Cancer Lung Cancer is an uncontrolled growth of abnormal cells in one or more lungs 2 Common Types of Lung Cancer:
The Scientific Method involves a series of steps that are used to investigate a natural occurrence.
Corporate manipulation of environmental health research: A comparison of four industries Jenny White, MSc, MPH Lisa Bero, PhD Dept. of Clinical Pharmacy.
By: Dr Khalid El Tohami INTRODUCTION TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND EPIDEMIOLOGY (1)
OSHA Final Rule: Occupational Exposure to Respirable Crystalline Silica OSHA has amended its existing standards for occupational exposure to respirable.
Lecture 4: Risk Analysis
Health Effects of Secondhand Smoke (Environmental Tobacco Smoke)
Rules and Regulations GOVT 2305, Module 14.
Environmental Protection Agency
ASARCO’s Tacoma copper smelter
POLYCYCLIC AROMATIC HYDROCARBON (PAH’S)
Causes of Parkinson’s Disease
Tomeka S. Nailer, Luma Akil and H. Anwar Ahmad
Chapter 15 & 16 Lecture Risks and Pests
ACID RAIN.
Jane Lassey HM Inspector of Health & Safety Head of Operations Wales
Chapter 13 Environmental Health
History of Environmental Law
Pay Attention to Books' Deadly Dust Relationship of Lung Cancer and Heart Attack to Library Books' Dust By Hassan Bolourchi Chemical Engineer, Ph. D.
Presentation transcript:

Tacoma Smelter, Tacoma Public Library Photography Archive An Historical Perspective on one company’s manipulation of the science of occupational arsenic and lead exposure: The American Smelting and Refining Company (ASARCO) This research has been funded by the US Environmental Protection Agency under the Science to Achieve Results Graduate Fellowship Program. The EPA has not officially endorsed this presentation and the views expressed herein may not reflect the views of the EPA. Marianne Sullivan

ASARCO (American Smelting and Refining Company) Company history Currently in bankruptcy Claims by the EPA, states and private parties for environmental damages

Involvement in environmental and occupational health research First US company to develop research department devoted to study of air pollution- outgrowth of disputes over smelter smoke damage Department of Hygiene formed in 1945 to study worker health Agricultural research and worker health merged into Department of Environmental Sciences in 1966

Lead and occupational health mid- 1960s Growing concern about lead exposure by the mid-1960s Patterson’s paper USPHS activities on lead ASARCO proposes study of Selby smelter workers

Dr. Pinto to NY managers, Selby lead study (Oct. 1965) “Such a study would probably show these men have little or nothing wrong with them. I believe such as study would not show an increased amount of cancer, diabetes, emphysema, arthritis, neuritis or any one of a number of other relatively common medical conditions. There is a possibility some chronic kidney irritation might be found. If we control the study, we can make the final decision as to whether or not the results would be published. To be able to tell the world a lot of this scare publicity about lead is nonsense would be very much in our favor.”

1966 ASARCO lead study Worker deaths among lead smelter and refinery workers Philip Enterline, statistician at University of Pittsburgh conducted analysis Finding: greater than expected cancer deaths (type/s of cancer unspecified) No excess deaths from nephritis, hypertension, vascular lesions of the CNS

Nelson to New York managers: don’t publish the findings (July 1966) “Were it not for the cancer data, I would recommend prompt publication of our information in a paper in an appropriate journal. What we have is, I believe, the only study of its kind in the world, and it would help the lead industry refute some of the false popular beliefs about lead. But the cancer figures stop us cold for the moment. It wouldn’t do for us to substitute a popular fear of cancer from lead for one of kidney disease from lead. We shall continue our study on the deaths.”

Tacoma smelter and arsenic research Copper/custom smelter in Ruston, Washington Smelted high arsenic ore, only US producer of arsenic after 1965 Closed in 1985 but is the subject of on- going superfund clean-up Worker exposures to arsenic were considerable

Studies of Tacoma smelter workers Snegireff LS and Lombard OM. Arsenic and cancer: observations in the metallurgical industry. AMA Arch Ind Hyg Occup Med 1951 Conclusions: “The handling of arsenic trioxide in the industry studied does not produce a significant change in the cancer mortality of the plant employees; hence, other factors in addition to arsenic must be considered significant in the causal relationship to cancer.” Research funded by ASARCO, Plant A was the Tacoma smelter

Tacoma worker studies, continued Context: Delaney Clause, industry concern that arsenic would be prohibited as residue on food Pinto SS, Bennett BM. Effect of arsenic trioxide exposure on mortality. Arch Environ Health 1963 Conclusions: “This comparison shows there were a few more deaths in the non-arsenic exposed respiratory cancer group than were to be expected by calculation, and further study of these cases is continuing. At present we can say arsenic trioxide was not one of the possible external factors associated with this problem”

National Cancer Institute Anaconda copper smelter worker study Lee AM, Fraumeni JF. Arsenic and respiratory cancer in man: an occupational study. JNCI Three to eight-fold increased risk of lung cancer Pinto and Nelson intended to influence the findings

Lee and Fraumeni, published version Published version of abstract placed more emphasis on sulfur dioxide or other “unidentified chemicals” as cofactors in lung cancer etiology Whether or not ASARCO responsible for the change in the abstract is unknown Both authors unaware of ASARCO’s intent

Other Tacoma smelter worker studies Milham & Strong, 1974 –increased lung cancer mortality in Tacoma smelter workers 1975 ASARCO admits to increased lung cancer deaths in Tacoma smelter workers (published in 1977, Pinto-Enterline) –Tried to cast doubt on arsenic as etiologic agent –Promoted threshold concept Enterline’s subsequent studies (1987, 1995)

Summary Purpose of research –influence scientific opinion on occupational hazards –protect economic interests Did not publish unfavorable research which showed workers at risk; withheld data from workers and health officials Argues for the need for strong system of worker protection and independent studies of occupational health risks