The Tail at Scale Dean and Barroso, CACM Feb 2013 Presenter: Chien-Ying Chen (cchen140) CS538 - Advanced Computer Networks 1

Interacting with Web Services Internet What causes variable response time? Response Time Request Latency 2

Factors of Variable Response Time Shared Resources (Local) –CPU cores –Processors caches –Memory bandwidth Global Resource Sharing –Network switches –Shared file systems Daemons –Scheduled Procedures 3

Factors of Variable Response Time Maintenance Activities –Data reconstruction in distributed file systems –Periodic log compactions in storage systems –Periodic garbage collection in garbage-collected languages Queueing –Queueing in intermediate servers and network switches 4

Factors of Variable Response Time Power Limits –Throttling due to thermal effects on CPUs Garbage Collection –Random access in solid-state storage devices Energy Management –Power saving modes –Switching from inactive to active modes 5

Component-Level Variability Amplified By Scale Latency variability is magnified at the service level

Request Latency Measurement 7 Key Observation: –5% servers contribute nearly 50% latency. 50%+

Key Question What would you do with that 5% servers which contribute 50% latency? 8 Eliminateall interactive request latencies. Live with But it’s infeasible to eliminate all variations!

Reducing Component Variability Differentiating Service Classes –Differentiate non-interactive requests High Level Queuing –Keep low level queues short 9

Reducing Component Variability Reduce Head-of-line Blocking –Break long-running requests into a sequence of smaller requests. Synchronize Disruption –Do background activities altogether. 10

Living with Latency Variability Within Request Short-Term Adaptations –Handles latency of 10+ ms –Takes the advantage of redundancy Cross-Request Long-Term Adaptations –Handles latency of 10+ seconds –Takes the advantage of partitions 11

Within Request Short-Term Adaptations Hedged Requests –Send redundant requests. –Use the results from whichever replica responds first. –The overhead can be further reduced by tagging them as lower priority than primary requests. 12

Within Request Short-Term Adaptations 13 Tied Requests –Hedged requests with cancellation mechanism.

Within Request Short-Term Adaptations Alternatives: –Requests to the least-loaded server. (Probe and Submit) –The Distributed Shortest-Positioning Time First System method. 14

Cross-Request Long-Term Adaptations Conventional Data Partitions Micro-Partitions –Like the notion of virtual servers in distributed hashing table (DHT). Selective Replication Latency-Induced Probation 15

Large Information Retrieval Systems Google search engine –No certain answers “Good Enough” –Google’s IR systems are tuned to occasionally respond with good-enough results when an acceptable fraction of the overall corpus has been searched. 16

Large Information Retrieval Systems Canary Requests –Some requests exercising an untested code path may cause crashes or long delays. –Send requests to one or two leaf servers for testing. –The remaining servers are only queried if the root gets a successful response from the canary in a reasonable period of time. 17

Large Information Retrieval Systems Canary Requests –May introduce extra latency. –Comparing to the consequence of long delays, it’s worth to apply canary requests. 18

Hardware Trends and Their Effects Hardware will only be more and more diverse –So tolerating variability through software techniques are even more important over time. Higher bandwidth reduces per-message overheads. –It further reduces the cost of tied requests (making it more likely that cancellation messages are received in time). 19

Conclusion Variability of latency exists in large-scale services. Live with variable request latency –Infeasible to eliminate variable request latency in large-scale services. The importance of these techniques will only increase. (scale of services getting larger) Techniques for living with variable latency turn out to increase system utilization 20

Discussion How to minimize interactive request latencies in large-scale web services? Under what condition a request will get worst latency? Why Google uses canary-requests despite its introduce overhead? How much time should it wait until canary requests respond? 21