Global Analysis, Combination & Complementarity The vision: explore 10 TeV scale directly (100 TeV pp) + indirectly (e + e - )

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Measurement of Relic Density at the LHC1 Bhaskar Dutta Texas A&M University Bhaskar Dutta Texas A&M University Measurement of Relic Density at the LHC.
Advertisements

The minimal B-L model naturally realized at TeV scale Yuta Orikasa(SOKENDAI) Satoshi Iso(KEK,SOKENDAI) Nobuchika Okada(University of Alabama) Phys.Lett.B676(2009)81.
Common Benchmarks for FCC Physics John Ellis King’s College London & FCC-ee/TLEP7 Workshop.
Nordic LHC Physics Workshop Stockholm Nov MSSM Higgs Searches at LEP Tord Ekelöf Uppsala University.
Comprehensive Analysis on the Light Higgs Scenario in the Framework of Non-Universal Higgs Mass Model M. Asano (Tohoku Univ.) M. Senami (Kyoto Univ.) H.
3.Phenomenology of Two Higgs Doublet Models. Charged Higgs Bosons.
Little Higgs Dark Matter and Its Implications at the LHC Chuan-Ren Chen (NTNU) XS 2014, 5/6/2014 In collaboration with H-C Tsai, M-C Lee, [hep-ph]
Discovery Potential for MSSM Higgs Bosons with ATLAS Johannes Haller (CERN) on behalf of the ATLAS collaboration International Europhysics Conference on.
Paris 22/4 UED Albert De Roeck (CERN) 1 Identifying Universal Extra Dimensions at CLIC  Minimal UED model  CLIC experimentation  UED signals & Measurements.
John Ellis King’s College London (& CERN) Supersymmetry, Higgs & LHC Physics What we (don’t) know What else is there? How to discover it?
Searches for New Physics Motivations Examples Searches so far Setting scene for LHC 1/12.
New Physics at the LHC/ILC B-L Workshop, LBNL September, 2007 Sally Dawson (BNL)
As a test case for quark flavor violation in the MSSM K. Hidaka Tokyo Gakugei University / RIKEN, Wako Collaboration with A. Bartl, H. Eberl, E. Ginina,
EuroGDR, 13 th December 2003 Dan Tovey CERN, 18/03/2004 G. Bélanger 1 Uncertainties in the relic density calculations in mSUGRA B. Allanach, G. Bélanger,
1Alan Barr PASCOS 09 PASCOS 2009 DESY 9 July 2009 …AT THE LHC DARK MATTER … Alan Barr University of Oxford On behalf of the ATLAS and CMS collaborations.
SUSY Dark Matter Collider – direct – indirect search bridge. Sabine Kraml Laboratoire de Physique Subatomique et de Cosmologie Grenoble, France ● 43. Rencontres.
Reconstruction of Fundamental SUSY Parameters at LHC and LC
From an obscure term in an equation to a headline discovery – and beyond John Ellis King’s College London (& CERN) Different Scales for Higgs Physics.
Tension Between A Fourth Generation And The LHC Higgs Searches Xiao-Gang He (SJTU&NTU) Xiao-Gang He and German Valencia, arXiv: Xiao-Gang He and.
International Conference on Linear Colliders Paris, April 19-23, 2004 Theoretical Introduction John Ellis.
Contents 1. Introduction 2. Analysis 3. Results 4. Conclusion Constraint on new physics by measuring the HVV Couplings at e+e- LC In collaboration with.
STANDARD MODEL. Theoretical Constraints on Higgs Mass Large M h → large self-coupling → blow up at low-energy scale Λ due to renormalization Small: renormalization.
Takehiro Nabeshima University of Toyama ILC physics general meeting 9 jun Phenomenology at a linear collider in a radiative seesaw model from TeV.
Flavour and CP Violation in Supersymmetric Models John Ellis Theory Division, LHCb, Jan. 27 th, 2009.
Warszawa ECFA Alternatives, EW, Top (and QCD) Summary On behalf of all speakers ECFA 9-12 June Warszawa – Helenka Przysiezniak U.of Montreal + CNRS.
Supersymmetric Models with 125 GeV Higgs Masahiro Yamaguchi (Tohoku University) 17 th Lomonosov Conference on Elementary Particle Physics Moscow State.
By Mengqing Wu XXXV Physics in Collision September 15-19, 2015 University of Warwick Dark matter searches with the ATLAS detector.
LHC Physics – A Theoretical Perspective Some of the questions being studied at the LHC John Ellis King’s College London (& CERN)
Neutralino Dark Matter in Light Higgs Boson Scenario (LHS) The scenario is consistent with  particle physics experiments Particle mass b → sγ Bs →μ +
1 Summary talk for ILC Physics Yasuhiro Okada (KEK) November 12, 2004 ACFA LC7, Taipei.
1 Supersymmetry Yasuhiro Okada (KEK) January 14, 2005, at KEK.
Strategies to Search for Supersymmetry John Ellis Warsaw, May 18th, 2007.
Low scale supergravity mediation in brane world scenario and hidden sector phenomenology Phys.Rev.D74:055005,2006 ( arXiv: hep-ph/ ) ACFA07 in Beijing:
SUSY fits: Implications of LHC data on Constrained SUSY Models Albert De Roeck on behalf of the Mastercode collaboration Exp O. Buchmueller, R. Cavanaugh,
Programme of Lectures Motivations and introduction What we know now The future? –Supersymmetric Higgses –Higgs factories.
Contents 1. Introduction 2. Analysis 3. Results 4. Conclusion Presice measurement of the Higgs-boson electroweak couplings at Linear Collider and its physics.
22 December 2006Masters Defense Texas A&M University1 Adam Aurisano In Collaboration with Richard Arnowitt, Bhaskar Dutta, Teruki Kamon, Nikolay Kolev*,
John Ellis Physics Challenges at the High-Energy Frontier Where do we go from here? After the Higgs, LHC Run 1.
Lepton Physics One of the four pillars: Tera-Z, Oku-W, Mega-H, Mega-t John Ellis M = ± 0.8 GeV, ε =
Neutralino relic density in the CPVMSSM and the ILC G. Bélanger LAPTH G. B, O. Kittel, S. Kraml, H. Martyn, A. Pukhov, hep-ph/ , Phys.Rev.D Motivation.
Overview of Supersymmetry and Dark Matter
Long-lived superpartners in the MSSM Alexey GLADYSHEV (JINR, Dubna / ITEP, Moscow) PROTVINO, December 25, 2008 PHYSICS OF FUNDAMENTAL INTERACTIONS PHYSICS.
1 Higgs Physics Yasuhiro Okada (KEK) November 26, 2004, at KEK.
The effect of ATLAS Run-1 supersymmetric searches in the pMSSM Chaowaroj Wanotayaroj Center for High Energy Physics, University of Oregon On behalf of.
Supersymmetry Basics: Lecture II J. HewettSSI 2012 J. Hewett.
The Search For Supersymmetry Liam Malone and Matthew French.
Jonathan Nistor Purdue University 1.  A symmetry relating elementary particles together in pairs whose respective spins differ by half a unit  superpartners.
Impact of quark flavour violation on the decay in the MSSM K. Hidaka Tokyo Gakugei University / RIKEN, Wako Collaboration with A. Bartl, H. Eberl, E. Ginina,
The Higgs Boson & Beyond What is Higgs telling us? What else is there? How do we find it? John Ellis King’s College London (& CERN)
WIN 05, Delphi, Greece, June 2005Filip Moortgat, CERN WIN 05 Inclusive signatures: discovery, fast but not unambiguous Exclusive final states & long term.
03/31/2006S. M. Lietti - UED Search at SPRACE 1 Universal Extra Dimensions Search at SPRACE S. M. Lietti DOSAR Workshop at U.T. Arlington.
STAU CLIC Ilkay Turk Cakir Turkish Atomic Energy Authority with co-authors O. Cakir, J. Ellis, Z. Kirca with the contributions from A. De Roeck,
Marc M. Baarmand – Florida Tech 1 TOP QUARK STUDIES FROM CMS AT LHC Marc M. Baarmand Florida Institute of Technology PHYSICS AT LHC Prague, Czech Republic,
Searching for Supersymmetry Bruno Zumino Memorial Meeting, CERN April 27 – 28, 2015 John Ellis King’s College London & CERN.
Lei Wu arXiv: JHEP 1402 (2014) 049 In collaboration with: C. Han, A. Kobakhidze, N. Liu, A. Saavedra and J.M. Yang Light Higgsinos and Naturalness.
Hong-Jian He Tsinghua University 9th ACFA ILC Workshop Physics Session Summary Feb. 4-7, 2007, IHEP, Beijing.
The Future Circular Collider Vision Exploration of the 10 TeV scale Direct (100 TeV pp) + Indirect (e + e - )
John Ellis The SUSY Marathon: LHC Run 1 and beyond The first big LHC discovery The second big LHC discovery?
Jieun Kim ( CMS Collaboration ) APCTP 2012 LHC Physics Workshop at Korea (Aug. 7-9, 2012) 1.
New Flavours of LHC Physics
Beyond SM? Where are we going? How do we achieve our goal?
Complementarity between FCC-ee and FCC-hh Searches for BSM Physics
Dark Matter Phenomenology of the GUT-less CMSSM
SUSY searches 11 papers completed Completely solves hierarchy problem
SUSY post LHC-8: what’s excluded, what’s not
MSSM4G: MOTIVATIONS AND ALLOWED REGIONS
Cosmology study at CEPC/SppC on behalf of the TeV cosmology working group Bi Xiao-Jun (IHEP)
Collider Phenomenology of SUSY Cosmic Connections &
SUSY SEARCHES WITH ATLAS
Presentation transcript:

Global Analysis, Combination & Complementarity The vision: explore 10 TeV scale directly (100 TeV pp) + indirectly (e + e - )

The Objectives How do FCC-hh, FCC-ee and FCC-he complement each other? Cf, LEP and LHC What are the synergies between them? –And between them and other accelerators (LHC)? Depend on inputs from specific FCC-xx analyses Broad subject: not really started Illustrate with specific physics examples –Higgs and precision electroweak –Supersymmetry –X(750)

Possible FCC-ee Precision Measurements Z peak ± 4 GeV for α EM, line shape WW threshold t tbar threshold FCC

Possible Future Higgs Measurements Need to reduce theoretical uncertainties to match Essential for new physics interpretations

Possible Future Higgs Measurements

Standard Model Effective Field Theory Higher-dimensional operators as relics of higher- energy physics, e.g., dimension 6: Operators constrained by SU(2) × U(1) symmetry: Constrain with precision EW, Higgs data, TGCs...

FCC-ee Higgs & TGC Measurements LHC constraints FCC-ee constraints: see Λ ~ 10 TeV? JE & Tevong You, arXiv:

Shadings of green: –Effect of including TGCs at ILC FCC-ee Higgs & TGC Measurements Shadings: –With/without theoretical EWPT uncertainties JE & Tevong You, arXiv: EWPTs and HiggsHiggs and TGCs Should extend to include prospective FCC-hh measurements of TGCs, …

What H Physics can FCC-hh do? Sub-% measurement of H to 4l/γγ? 1% measurement of H to μμ 5% measurement of 3-H coupling? Sensitive to 4-H coupling? Hong Kong Big statistics!

What H Physics can FCC-hh do? One thing is to have a large σ Another is to have small uncertainties Hong Kong Studies in progress

Measurement of 3-H Coupling The story so far More decay modes, improved selections,. Studies in progress

FCC-ee Sensitivity to 3h Coupling Loop corrections to σ(H+Z): 3h correction δ h energy-dependent δ Z energy-independent: can distinguish McCullough

A First Look at 4-H Coupling Is this possible?

Precision FCC-ee Measurements Precision Higgs Precision Electroweak Buchmueller, JE et al: arXiv:

FCC-ee Z measurements FCC-ee + LHC 3000/fb Measuring CMSSM with FCC-ee Buchmueller, JE et al: arXiv: Assuming best-fit point after LHC Run 1 68% CL region 95% CL region FCC-ee H measurements

Where May CMSSM be Hiding? Relic density constraint, assuming neutralino LSP JE, Olive & Zheng: arXiv: Stop coannihilation/ focus-point strip Stau coannihilation strip Excluded by b  s γ, B s  μ + μ - Excluded by ATLAS Jest + MET search Excluded because stau or stop LSP LHC 300 HE-LHC LHC 3000

Squark-Gluino Plane Discover 12 TeV squark, 16 TeV 5σ

Compatible with LHC measurement of m h May extend to m χ = m stop ~ 6500 GeV Exploring the Stop Coannihilation Strip LHC 300 (monojets), MET LHC 8TeV LHC 3000 (monojets), MET HE-LHC (monojets), MET 100 TeV (monojets), MET JE, Olive & Zheng: arXiv:

Contributions of Higgs and electroweak precision observables to global χ 2 function along stop coannihilation strip FCC-ee vs FCC-hh: possible test of supersymmetry at the loop level Impact of Precision and Higgs Measurements Buchmueller, JE et al: arXiv:

Possible Future X Signal Assuming production by gluon-gluon fusion Normalized to σB(γγ) = 6 fb PDF, ren’n scale 100 TeV ~ 30% Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Alternative Higgs Doublet Scenario After singlet, doublet? Heavy Higgses in 2 Higgs doublet model: Φ = H, A Nearly degenerate in many versions, e.g., SUSY Expect t tbar decays to dominate Can accommodate Γ Φ ~ 45 GeV (ATLAS) Need larger enhancement of loops compared to singlet model Rich bosonic phenomenology Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Lineshape in pp Collisions +MSSM: tan β = 1 M H – M A ~ 15 GeV Γ H, Γ A ~ 32, 35 GeV σB(A  γγ) = 2 ✕ σB(H  γγ) Asymmetric ‘Breit-Wigner’ Resolvable? Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Possible Φ = H,A Signals Normalized to σB(γγ) = 6 13 TeV Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Possible H ± 14, 100 TeV for varying M H± ≠ M Φ in general Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Cross Sections for Vector-Like Q Pair-production at LHC, future circular colliders Present lower mass limit ~ 800 GeV Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Cross Sections for Vector-Like L Pair-production at LHC, future circular colliders Present mass limit < 400 GeV Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Indirect Sensitivity of FCC-ee? To mixing between H(125) and X(750)? To vector-like fermions via electroweak precision and Higgs measurements? To other indirect effects in two-Higgs doublet models? Other models? Should we wait and see?

Global Analysis, Combination & Complementarity Will depend upon inputs from both FCC-ee and FCC-hh (and FCC-he) Core business: probes of any new physics at the quantum level –E.g., Higgs, supersymmetry, X(750) (?) Effort needed from both sides: –Accuracy of possible FCC-hh measurements? –FCC-ee sensitivity to new physics ≠ H, SUSY If X(750) exists, it will change everything!

Back-ups

Indirect Stop Limits from Precision EW Data Solid lines = full calculation, dashed lines = EFT Drozd, JE, Quevillon & You: arXiv:

Possible FCC-ee Precision Measurements

Reaches for Sparticles LHC: HE-LHC, FCC-hh

Reach for the Stop Discover 6.5 TeV 5σ, exclude 8 95% × possible tip of stop coannihilation strip Stop mass up to 6.5 TeV possible along coannihilation strip

Single Vector-Like Q, L Production Single production at LHC, future circular colliders Assuming mixing angle with light fermions ξ = 0.1 Djouadi, JE, Godbole, Quevillon, arXiv:

Largest possible mass in pMSSM is along gluino coannihilation strip: m gluino ~ m neutralino Extends to m χ = m gluino ~ 8 TeV How Heavy could Dark Matter be in pMSSM? JE, Luo & Olive: arXiv: Nominal calculation Cosmological dark matter density

Reaches for Sparticles Model with compressed spectrum: small gluino- neutralino mass difference Large mass possible in gluino coannihilation scenario for dark matter 