Effects of Pulsed He + Irradiation on Tungsten Surfaces R.F. Radel, G.L. Kulcinski, S.J. Zenobia HAPL Meeting-ORNL March 22 nd, 2006 Fusion Technology.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik EURATOM Assoziation Interaction of nitrogen plasmas with tungsten Klaus Schmid, A. Manhard, Ch. Linsmeier, A. Wiltner,

Advertisements

Complex chemical interactions of lithium, deuterium, and oxygen on lithium-coated graphite PFC surfaces C.N. Taylor1, B. Heim1, J.P. Allain1, C. H. Skinner2,

IASFPWG – Seattle, WA Fuel Tank Ignition Experiments at Reduced Oxygen Concentrations International Aircraft Systems Fire Protection Working Group.

IASFPWG – Ottawa, Canada Limiting Oxygen Concentration (LOC) Work Update International Aircraft Systems Fire Protection Working Group Ottawa, Canada.

September 24-25, 2003 HAPL meeting, UW, Madison 1 Armor Configuration & Thermal Analysis 1.Parametric analysis in support of system studies 2.Preliminary.

1 EFFECTS OF CARBON REDEPOSITION ON TUNGSTEN UNDER HIGH-FLUX, LOW ENERGY Ar ION IRRADITAION AT ELEVATED TEMPERATURE Lithuanian Energy Institute, Lithuania.

Dynamic hydrogen isotope behavior and its helium irradiation effect in SiC Yasuhisa Oya and Satoru Tanaka The University of Tokyo.

Y. Ueda, M. Fukumoto, H. Kashiwagi, Y. Ohtsuka (Osaka University)

Peripheral Elements and Technology Associated with Pulsed Power Inertial Fusion ： Part 2 1 Koichi KASUYA 2 Department of Energy Sciences, Interdisciplinary.

John Pulsifer, Mark Tillack S. S. Harilal, Joel Hollingsworth GIMM experimental setup and tests at prototypical pulse length HAPL Project Meeting Princeton,

K.Umstadter –-Laser+D on W PISCES Effects of transient heating events on W PFCs in a steady-state divertor-plasma environment Karl R. Umstadter, R. Doerner,

1 Radiation Environment at Final Optics of HAPL Mohamed Sawan Fusion Technology Institute University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI HAPL GIMM Conference Call.

Unsteady Heat Transfer in Semi-infinite Solids Solidification process of the coating layer during a thermal spray operation is an unsteady heat transfer.

FETS-HIPSTER (Front End Test Stand – High Intensity Proton Source for Testing Effects of Radiation) Proposal for a new high-intensity proton irradiation.

R. Parker, (R. Scelle), (S. Gilliam), and N. R. Parikh University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC R. G. Downing National.

Ion-Driven Permeation of Deuterium through Tungsten Motivation Permeation experiment Results Next steps A. V. Golubeva, M. Mayer, J. Roth.

HAPL WORKSHOP Chamber Gas Density Requirements for Ion Stopping Presented by D. A. Haynes, Jr. for the staff of the Fusion Technology Institute.

Review of Results First Wall Helium Management & Refractory Armored Materials L L Snead, T. Hinoki, J. Hunn, C. Blue, N. Hashimoto (ORNL) R. Raffray (UCLA)

Integrated Materials Plan Progress: Helium Blistering and Refractory Armored Materials Lance L Snead High Average Power Lasers Workshop December 6, 2002.

Measurement and modeling of hydrogenic retention in molybdenum with the DIONISOS experiment G.M. Wright University of Wisconsin-Madison, FOM – Institute.

Long Term Exposure of Candidate First Wall Materials on XAPPER February – May 2004 Presented by: Jeff Latkowski XAPPER Team: Ryan Abbott, Robert Schmitt,

Study of a new high power spallation target concept

Fracture of Tungsten in a HAPL Chamber Jake Blanchard HAPL MWG Fusion Technology Institute University of Wisconsin September 2003.

O AK R IDGE N ATIONAL L ABORATORY U. S. D EPARTMENT OF E NERGY 1 Tungsten Armored Ferritic Steel Glenn Romanoski & Lance Snead June 2004.

Mark Tillack, John Pulsifer, Joel Hollingsworth, S. S. Harilal Final Optic Fabrication, Testing and System Integration HAPL Project Meeting San Diego,

Plan to Develop A First Wall Concept for Laser IFE.

Progress in Understanding the Performance of IEC Devices at the University of Wisconsin G. L Kulcinski, J. F. Santarius, G. A. Emmert, R. L. Bonomo, E.

Tshepo Mahafa P-LABS Necsa 1 CHARGED PARTICLE IRRADIATION EFFECTS ON ZIRCALOY-4 Necsa_Wits Workshop, 10 – 11 September 2015, Necsa, Pelindaba.

Update on ORNL Diagnostic and Tungsten Armor Efforts Keith Leonard, Glenn Romanoski, Lance Snead Oak Ridge National Laboratory Nalin Parikh UNC, Chapel.

Materials Studies on Z (x-rays) and RHEPP (ions) C.L. Olson, T.J.Tanaka, T.J. Renk, G.A.Rochau, M.A. Ulrickson Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque,

Compositional dependence of damage buildup in Ar-ion bombarded AlGaN K. Pągowska 1, R. Ratajczak 1, A. Stonert 1, L. Nowicki 1 and A. Turos 1,2 1 Soltan.

Update on Roughening Work Jake Blanchard HAPL MWG Fusion Technology Institute University of Wisconsin e-meeting – July 2003.

The effect of displacement damage on deuterium retention in plasma-exposed tungsten W.R.Wampler, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM R. Doerner.

The tungsten/F82H sample was impinged at 6 different locations with 6 different laser fluence energies to determine the critical energy that would result.

Overview of HAPL First Wall Materials Issues HAPL Materials and Design Team HAPL Average Power Laser Program Workshop Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory.

XAPPER Progress on the First Wall Battle Plan Presented by: Jeff Latkowski XAPPER Team: Ryan Abbott, Wilburt Davis, Steve Payne, Susana Reyes, Joel Speth.

1 1. Feb 2001:NRL 2. May 2001:NRL 3. Nov 2001:LLNL 4.Apr 2002:GA 5. Dec 2002:NRL 6. Apr 2003:Sandia 7. Sep 2003:Wisconsin 8. Feb 2004:Georgia Tech 9. Jun.

MOLIBDENUM MIRRORS WITH COLUMN NANOGRAIN REFLECTING COATING AND EFFECT OF ION- STIMULATED DIFFUSION BLISTERRING RRC «Кurchatov Institute» А.V. Rogov, К.Yu.Vukolov.

Temperature Response and Ion Deposition in the 1 mm Tungsten Armor Layer for the 10.5 m HAPL Target Chamber T.A. Heltemes, D.R. Boris and M. Fatenejad,

Plasma Processes, Inc. February 5-6, Engineered Tungsten for IFE Dry Chamber Walls HAPL Program Meeting Georgia Institute of Technology Scott O’Dell,

Surface Effects and Retention of Steady State 3 He + Implantation in Single and Polycrystalline Tungsten S.J. Zenobia, G.L. Kulcinski, E. Alderson, G.

10th ITPA conference, Avila, 7-10 Jan Changes of Deuterium Retention Properties on Metals due to the Helium Irradiation or Impurity Deposition M.Tokitani.

Effect of Re Alloying in W on Surface Morphology Changes After He + Bombardment at High Temperatures R.F. Radel, G.L. Kulcinski, J. F. Santarius, G. A.

Operating Windows in Tungsten- Coated Steel Walls Jake Blanchard – MWG Greg Moses, Jerry Kulcinski, Bob Peterson, Don Haynes - University of Wisconsin.

Mark Tillack, John Pulsifer, Kevin Sequoia, Akachi Iroezi, Joel Hollingsworth Final Optic Fabrication, Testing and System Integration HAPL Project Meeting.

HAPL Modeling  Ion and Heat Transport Qiyang Hu, Nasr Ghoniem, Shahram Sharafat, Mike Anderson Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering University of California,

IFE Materials Response: Long-term exposure to nitrogen and helium beams on RHEPP Tim Renk Sandia National Laboratories Beam Applications & Initiatives.

IASFPWG – Atlantic City, NJ Limiting Oxygen Concentration (LOC) Work Update International Aircraft Systems Fire Protection Working Group Atlantic.

Jan Low Energy 10 Hz Operation in DRFS (Fukuda) (Fukuda) 1 Low Energy 10Hz Operation in DRFS S. Fukuda KEK.

1 of 13 Mark Tillack, John Pulsifer, Sam Yuspeh, Matt Aralis HAPL Project Meeting October 2008 Madison, WI Progress on GIMM mirror development and.

IFE Ion Threat Spectra Effects Upon Chamber Wall Materials G E. Lucas, N. Walker UC Santa Barbara.

Investigation of the Performance of Different Types of Zirconium Microstructures under Extreme Irradiation Conditions E.M. Acosta, O. El-Atwani Center.

Progress on HAPL Foam Shell Overcoat Fabrication Presented by Jared Hund 1 N. Alexander 1, J. Bousquet 1, Bob Cook 1, D. Goodin 1, D. Jasion 1, R. Paguio.

XI Workshop on Resistive Plate Chambers and Related Detectors, INFN, 5-10 February, Aging test of high rate MRPC Wang Yi Department of Engineering.

350 MJ Target Thermal Response and Ion Implantation in 1 mm thick silicon carbide armor for 10.5 m HAPL Chamber T.A. Heltemes and G.A. Moses Fusion Technology.

M. S. Tillack, J. E. Pulsifer, K. Sequoia Final Optic Research – Progress and Plans HAPL Project Meeting, Georgia Tech 5–6 February 2004.

1 Radiation Environment at Final Optics of HAPL Mohamed Sawan Fusion Technology Institute University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI HAPL Meeting ORNL March.

Exposures of Candidate First Wall Materials C.L. Olson, T.J. Tanaka, T.J. Renk, G.A. Rochau Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM R.R. Peterson.

Micro-engineered Armor:

Exposures of Candidate First Wall Materials

Unsteady Heat Transfer in Semi-infinite Solids

Surface Analysis of Graphite Limiter and W-coating Testing on HT-7

Ion Implantation and Temperature  HEROS Modeling

Update on Helium Management and Tungsten Bonded Ferritic

Presented by T. Sugie (ITER-IT) N. Yoshida (Kyushu University, Japan)

Tungsten Armor Engineering:

Helium Behavior and Surface Roughening of Solid Tungsten

Elina Pajustea,b*, Gunta Kizanea, Ieva Igaunea

Paper TH/P Summary Slide (Simulation of Beryllium Erosion and Surface Damage under ITER-like Transient Plasma Heat Loads) It is expected that the.

Deuterium retention for sample temperature of 500 K

Presentation transcript:

Effects of Pulsed He + Irradiation on Tungsten Surfaces R.F. Radel, G.L. Kulcinski, S.J. Zenobia HAPL Meeting-ORNL March 22 nd, 2006 Fusion Technology Institute University of Wisconsin-Madison

Progress Since Last Meeting Pulsed helium source was used to irradiate tungsten samples at 1150 °C to 1x10 19, 6x10 18, and 1x10 18 He + /cm 2 FIB and SEM analysis has been performed to evaluate pulsed surface damage relative to previous experiments SiC samples have been received from ORNL Paper was submitted to Journal of Nuclear Materials: –R.F. Radel and G.L. Kulcinski. “Implantation of He + in Candidate Fusion First Wall Materials” (presented at ICFRM-12 conference) 1

The Campaign to Assess Ability of W Coatings to Operate in HAPL Environment is Proceeding Polycrystalline Single CrystalMetallic Foams He + & D + Fluence Effect – 800 ° C Large, medium, & small grain size W on TaC – (He + ) °C Medium grain size W on HfC (He + & D + ) – °C Large, medium, & small grain size W on TaC – (D + ) 800 °C Simultaneous He + & D + Helium Retention He + & D + Fluence Effect – ° C Temperature and Voltage Effects Simultaneous He + & D + Helium Retention W-Re Alloy Pulsed Irradiation Completed In progress 2

New Design Allows Pulsed IEC Operation Currently able to pulse up to 110 kV Operation has been performed with pulses as short as 100  s Capable of running D 2 and He fuel gas 3

Pulsed IEC Irradiation Better Simulates HAPL Flux 4

Pulsed Irradiation Caused Increased Damage to Tungsten Surface at He + /cm 2 1  m 40 kV, 60 mA Pulsed ( °C baseline) 12 minute runtime 30 kV, 6 mA Steady-State ( °C) 3 minute runtime 1 ms pulse width, 25 Hz steady-state 1  m 5

Pulsed Irradiation Caused Increased Damage to Tungsten Surface at 6x10 18 He + /cm 2 1 ms pulse width, 25 Hz steady-state 40 kV, 60 mA Pulsed ( °C baseline) 72 minute runtime 30 kV, 6 mA Steady-State ( °C) 18 minute runtime 1  m 6

Pulsed Irradiation Created Coral-Like Tungsten Features at He + /cm 2 1 ms pulse width, 25 Hz steady-state 40 kV, 60 mA Pulsed ( °C baseline) 2 hour runtime 30 kV, 6 mA Steady-State ( °C) 30 minute runtime 1  m 7

FIB Analysis Reveals Increased Porous Layer in Pulsed Samples = 290 nm /cm /cm 2 Pulsed (40 kV) Steady-State (30 kV) (1150 °C baseline) (1150 °C) = 90 nm = 700 nm = 300 nm 2  m

Mass Loss was Measured for Pulsed Tungsten Samples 1x x x10 18 Mass Loss (2 g sample) mg mg mg Thickness Loss  m  m  m There has been no observable mass loss at fluences below /cm 2 for steady-state irradiation at 1150 °C Measured mass loss and corresponding thickness loss for pulsed irradiation is shown below: Reference HAPL W armor could lose 200  m/FPY (~300 kg/FPY) due to low energy He irradiation alone 1 ms pulse width, 25 Hz, 1150 °C 9

Conclusions Switching from steady-state to pulsed irradiation at 1150 °C resulted in an increased surface roughening over to He + /cm 2 range Porous layer in tungsten was ~3x thicker after pulsed irradiation compared to steady-state Mass loss of tungsten armor in Reference HAPL design could be as much as 200  m/FPY (~300 kg/FPY), which is well beyond calculated physical sputtering values 10

Future Work Expand pulsed operation to pulse widths that are closer to Reference HAPL conditions 11

Future Work, cont. Begin irradiation of SiC samples Unirradiated SiC 12

Questions? Ross Radel University of Wisconsin-Madison 1500 Engineering Drive Madison, WI (608)