Equity and rationing in the English NHS Findings from a survey of BMA members July 2013.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Cancer Registration and Health Service Regulation Dr Jenifer A E Smith.

Advertisements

The Great British Care Show Yorks and Humber, 13th March 2013

Proposed integration of Medway NHS Foundation Trust and Dartford and Gravesham NHS Trust Better care together.

Supporting Carers in General Practice & role of RCGP GP Champions for carers Dr Sachin Gupta GP, Welwyn Garden City RCGP GP Champion for Carers, East of.

Is there a future for the NHS and how does Surgery fit within it? Chris Edmond Final Year Student, Cambridge University.

The Royal College of Midwives. In March 2014 the Government and employers took an unprecedented step and rejected the NHS Pay Review Body’s recommended.

Inefficiencies in provision of acute care with poor use of estate Dependence on hospital care with failure to transfer care to community Need for more.

7 Day Working A Practical Perspective Dr Janet Williamson, National Director, NHS Improvement.

The NHS White Paper A system not structure Outcomes focused Robust Quality & Economic regulation Empowered professionals in autonomous providers.

The ISABEL user survey Dr Jim Briggs Dr Tineke Fitch Healthcare Computing Group University of Portsmouth

ISABEL: The Use of a Web-Based Paediatric Clinical Support System Dr Tineke Fitch Dr Jim Briggs University of Portsmouth, UK

ISABEL: the use of a web-based clinical support system Dr Jim Briggs Dr Tineke Fitch University of Portsmouth, UK

ISABEL: the Use of a Web-based Clinical Support System Dr Jim Briggs Dr Tineke Fitch University of Portsmouth, UK

Primary Care: Working on a new set of standards

Healthcare Recruitment in the UK Celia Pappas EURES UK.

Promoting Excellence in Family Medicine Enabling Patients to Access Electronic Health Records Guidance for Health Professionals.

The National Health Service Healthcare in the United Kingdom By Vruti Dattani University of Cambridge.

THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Exhibit 1. Health Reform Proposal’s Projected Success in Meeting Goals “How successful do you think the comprehensive health reform.

Version 1 | Internal Use Only© Ipsos MORI 1 Version 1| Internal Use Only Sheffield CCG CCG 360 o stakeholder survey 2014 Summary report.

Department of Public Health and Primary Care Health Needs Assessment in Prisons: The Professional View and the Client View Helen Thornton-Jones

Snapshot survey of health leaders on NHS reform Survey results March 2013.

Service 19 TH JUNE 2014 /// SEPTEMBER 4, 2015 ALISON CLEMENTS.

Royal College of Surgeons – Regional Representatives Event Future medical workforce: Employer views 5 November 2009 David Grantham Head of Programmes,

HEE – Beyond transition and into the Future Abdol Tavabie Interim Dean Director for HEKSS February 2015.

Equity and excellence: Liberating the NHS. Background The Government’s ambition is for health outcomes and quality health services that are as good as.

The Cedars Surgery PPG/GP Practice Survey Results 15 th March 2013 Prepared for The Cedars Surgery by the Participation & Insight Team, KMCS. Confidential:

Equality and Excellence: Liberating the NHS Ian R Cumming 12th July 2010.

Makingadifference NHS SWINDON PRESENTATION FOR LINK MEETING 18 MAY.

 Commissioners in Somerset wanted to test whether outcomes based commissioning would lead to better outcomes and greater financial sustainability  External.

Working With Health And Developing the Local Offer Council for Disabled Children, May 2014.

Healthcare rationing is used by health insurers, the government and individuals to save money. Most of us believe that if there is a treatment available,

NHS Landscape in England Leela Barham RCN Policy Advisor 28 th June 2013 Presentation for GUNA.

UKMi Strategy 2007 Replaces 2000 Strategy Launched 31/10/2007 Takes account of political, policy, organisational and operational NHS changes Takes account.

SO WHERE ARE WE GOING NEXT?. “We will also encourage more widespread use of patient experience surveys and real-time feedback. We will enable patients.

Plan for the day MorningLunchtimeAfternoon Making every contact count Market place and networking Moving forwards, innovations and solutions.

How online feedback is changing the NHS. People are talking about healthcare services all over the internet Photo courtesy flickr.com It’s already happening…

© Nuffield Trust 27 February 2012 A survey of GPs in England on the rationing of health care Survey results.

Christian care in the context of health reforms Opportunities and Challenges for the Churches.

Swindon Local Involvement Network Open Meeting 18 th May 2011 Lyn Hill-Tout Chief Executive Telephone:

The New NHS Opportunities for Optometrists Chris Town Acting Chief Executive Cambridgeshire PCT.

Clinical Commissioning Group’s one year on: member engagement and primary care development Ruth Robertson Holly Holder Laura Bennett Shilpa Ross Jennifer.

Presentation heading Presented by / Sub-heading Commissioning Explained Sarah Freeman Local Service Specialist – West Midlands Team.

BHIVA PROMS / PREMS PROJECT A Community Consultation.

Ms. Nixon-Williams Grade 6 Honors Fractions, Decimals, Percent, Ratios Grade 6 Honors Fractions, Decimals, Percent, Ratios.

LMCs, the GPC, the NHS and All that Jazz LMCs, the GPC, the NHS and All that Jazz Dr James Gillgrass Chief Executive Surrey and Sussex LMCs.

Engaging with Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs)

Clinically-led commissioning in the English National Health Service: The challenges ahead.

National Dementia Declaration. uk FROM HERE…

A View from the NHS Working with People with Borderline Personality Disorder.

Reshaping the Medical Workforce in Scotland Update to NDPIG – July 2010 Alastair Cook Senior Medical Officer SGHD Senior Medical Officer SGHD.

Transforming Patient Experience: The essential guide

DR NAGPALS SURGERY PATIENT SURVEY RESULTS

CCG commissioning and mental health Mark Burdon, Commissioning Manager (Mental Health), South Tees CCG CCG commissioning and mental health Mark Burdon,

©SHRM 2007SHRM Weekly Online Survey: November 13, 2007 HR Technology Systems Sample comprised of 336 randomly selected HR professionals. Analyzing 336.

Gurdeep Singh Mannu Academic Clinical Fellow Oxford BMA Academic Trainees' Conference 2 November 2013.

Trakcare Easy Access to evidence Background and demo Katie Edwards Knowledge Manager NHS Education for Scotland

Our year Arlene Wilkie, Chief Executive

Our application to become an NHS Foundation Trust.

Healthcare Commissioning Paul Calaminus 27 th April 2016.

NCAS Consultation Update 22 nd February 2011 Alastair Scotland Kevin Hunt Dee Mullner National Clinical Assessment Service.

Liberating the NHS: Developing the healthcare workforce Workforce planning, education and training Consultation Engagement.

The Prime Minister’s Challenge Fund Transforming General Practice in Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire Area Team.

Yorkshire and the Humber Emergency Surgery Survey Jon Ausobsky RCS Director for Professional Affairs Yorkshire and the Humber & Alison Young Regional Coordinator.

Dr. Andrew Foulkes Medical Director Surrey and Sussex Area Team Clinical Senate Summit A&E, Acute Medicine and the Medical Specialties.

Bringing excellence to life Community Based Peritoneal Dialysis (PD) Clinic: Nurses and Patients’ Experience Charelle S. Serrano Peritoneal Dialysis -

The National Data Guardian’s Review of Data Security, Consent and Opt-Outs IGA Conference 2016 Dame Fiona Caldicott 16 March 2016 N ational D ata G uardian.

Reforms and Cuts: Working together to secure the future of SLT services Kamini Gadhok - Chief Executive Officer Derek Munn – Director of Policy and Public.

Methods Three questionnaires were designed with reference to national guidelines and the PCRMP’s recommendations. These questionnaires were sent to PCTs,

Yorkshire and the Humber Emergency Surgery Survey Jon Ausobsky RCS Director for Professional Affairs Yorkshire and the Humber & Alison Young Regional Coordinator.

PATIENT CHOICE.

Presentation transcript:

Equity and rationing in the English NHS Findings from a survey of BMA members July 2013

Background Online survey sent to 2,000 doctors working in England in July 2012, via the BMA’s Intouch Research Panel Doctors surveyed were a broadly representative sample of consultants, junior doctors, GPs, staff grade, specialty doctors and associate specialists 575 doctors completed the survey, giving a response rate of 29 per cent Three BMA discussion papers provide a fuller analysis of the findings and the implications for policy. See

1.Which of the following most closely aligns with your understanding of the term universal? Percentage Everyone has access to the same range of services44.0 Everyone has access to the same quality of services20.0 Access to services is based on need 15.0 NHS offers a range of services that meets the needs of everyone11.0 NHS offers a range of services that it is feasible to offer9.0 Every possible service is available on the NHS1.0

2.Which of the following most closely aligns with your understanding of the term comprehensive? Percentage* NHS offers a range of services that meets the needs of everyone37.0 NHS offers a range of services that it is feasible to offer34.0 Access to services is based on need 9.0 Everyone has access to the same range of services9.0 Every possible service is available on the NHS7.0 Everyone has access to the same quality of services5.0 * The percentages do not add up to 100 due to decimal rounding

3.How universal is the NHS? Defined as ‘access based on clinical need, not ability to pay’

4.How comprehensive is the NHS? Defined as ‘a range of services that meets the needs of everyone’

5.How much importance do you attach to universality vs. comprehensiveness? Universality defined as ‘access based on clinical need, not ability to pay’ Comprehensive defined as ‘a range of services that meet the needs of everyone’

6.At what level of the health system should the following be applied? Percentage (all respondents) NationalRegionalSub-regionalLocal Restrictions around who can receive certain services/treatments Reductions in what services/treatments are available on the NHS Regional given as NHS England sectors (4) Sub-regional given as NHS England local area teams (27) Local given as clinical commissioning groups (211)

7.Which national body should make decisions on restrictions around who can receive certain services/treatments? National bodyPercentage* All RespondentsGP Commissioners NICE Department of Health NHS England Elected officials/Parliament * Percentage of respondents who answered ‘national’ to question 6

8.Which national body should make decisions on reductions in what services/treatments are available on the NHS? National bodyPercentage All respondentsGP commissioners Department of Health NICE NHS England Elected officials/Parliament * Percentage of respondents who answered ‘national’ to question 6

9.At what level of the health system should the following be applied? Percentage (all respondents) NationalRegionalSub-regionalLocal Maximum waiting times Decisions around access to new drugs/technologies Minimum waiting times

10.Which national body should make decisions on maximum and minimum waiting times? National bodyPercentage* (all respondents) Maximum waiting timesMinimum waiting times Department of Health Elected officials/Parliament NHS England NICE * Percentage of respondents who answered ‘national’ to question 9

11.How much importance do you attach to local autonomy and freedom vs. national uniformity?

12. Assuming there will always be a shortfall between demand and available resources in a given year, which of the following are most acceptable to you? Rationing by selection phrased as ‘tighter restrictions around who can receive certain treatments/services’ Rationing by denial phrased as ‘reduction in the range of treatments/services that are available’ Rationing by delay phrased as ‘patients wait longer for treatments/services’

13. Assuming there will always be a shortfall between demand and available resources in a given year, which two of the following are most acceptable to you? Rationing by selection phrased as ‘tighter restrictions around who can receive certain treatments/services’ Rationing by denial phrased as ‘reduction in the range of treatments/services that are available’ Rationing by delay phrased as ‘patients wait longer for treatments/services’