Planning for Helioseismology with SO/PHI Birch, Gizon, & Hirzberger Max Planck Institute for Solar System Physics.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Study of Flows in the Deep Convection Zone ( Mm depth) Tom Duvall Shravan Hanasoge “ASH team”
Advertisements

Turbulent Convection in Stars Kwing Lam Chan Hong Kong University of Science and Technology “A Birthday Celebration of the Contribution of Bernard Jones.
Wave propagation in the upper convection zone Robert Cameron Laurent Gizon Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research.
SDO/HMI multi-height velocity measurements Kaori Nagashima (MPS) Collaborators: L. Gizon, A. Birch, B. Löptien, S. Danilovic, R. Cameron (MPS), S. Couvidat.
Numerical Simulations of Supergranulation and Solar Oscillations Åke Nordlund Niels Bohr Institute, Univ. of Copenhagen with Bob Stein (MSU) David Benson,
1 The Sun as a whole: Rotation, Meridional circulation, and Convection Michael Thompson High Altitude Observatory, National Center for Atmospheric Research.
Probing the Sun in 3D Karen Harvey Prize Lecture Boulder 2009 Laurent Gizon Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research, & Goettingen University, Germany.
1. 2 Apologies from Ed and Karl-Heinz
Emergence and Evolution of Active Regions A.C. Birch, H. Schunker (MPS), D. C. Braun (NWRA)
Simulation of Flux Emergence from the Convection Zone Fang Fang 1, Ward Manchester IV 1, William Abbett 2 and Bart van der Holst 1 1 Department of Atmospheric,
Global Dynamics Rachel Howe, NSO Session H10. Synopsis Achievements from GONG/MDI –Nearly a full 11yr cycle of observations –Zonal flow pattern in bulk.
Initial Analysis of the Large-Scale Stein-Nordlund Simulations Dali Georgobiani Formerly at: Center for Turbulence Research Stanford University/ NASA Presenting.
Solar Convection Simulations Bob Stein David Benson.
TIME-DISTANCE ANALYSIS OF REALISTIC SIMULATIONS OF SOLAR CONVECTION Dali Georgobiani, Junwei Zhao 1, David Benson 2, Robert Stein 2, Alexander Kosovichev.
A particularly obvious example of daily changing background noise level Constructing the BEST High-Resolution Synoptic Maps from MDI J.T. Hoeksema, Y.
HMI – Synoptic Data Sets HMI Team Meeting Jan. 26, 2005 Stanford, CA.
Data for Helioseismology Testing: Large-Scale Stein-Nordlund Simulations Dali Georgobiani Michigan State University Presenting the results of Bob Stein.
Convection Simulations Robert Stein Ake Nordlund Dali Georgobiani David Benson Werner Schafenberger.
Braun AIA/HMI Feb Helioseismic holography of Solar Subsurface Flows : progress & prospects NorthWest Research Associates Colorado Research Associates.
Summary. Two directions in modeling Adopting physical (realistic) models Creating artificial data sets with simplified physics.
Generation of Artificial Data in Support of SDO-HMI Nagi N. Mansour, NASA ARC Alan Wray, NASA ARC Thomas Hartlep, Stanford CTR Alexander Kosovichev, Stanford.
An introduction to the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) Chia-chi Wang Dept. Atmospheric Sciences Chinese Culture University Acknowledgment: Prof.
Supergranulation-Scale Simulations of Solar Convection Robert Stein, Michigan State University, USA Aake Nordlund, Astronomical Observatory, NBIfAFG, Denmark.
Local Helioseismology Laurent Gizon (Stanford). Outline Some background Time-distance helioseismology: Solar-cycle variations of large-scale flows Near.
M1-H2: Magnetic Activity Science Goals and Approaches DRAFT! Chair(s): Abbett/Hoeksema/Komm.
Detection of Emerging Sunspot Regions in the Solar Interior Stathis Ilonidis, Junwei Zhao, and Alexander Kosovichev Stanford University LoHCo Workshop.
Nonlinear effects on torsional Alfven waves S. Vasheghani Farahani, V.M. Nakariakov, T. Van Doorsselaere, E. Verwichte.
Numerical simulations are used to explore the interaction between solar coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and the structured, ambient global solar wind flow.
Sensitivity Kernels for Local Helioseismology Aaron Birch NWRA, CoRA Division.
P MODE TRAVEL TIME IN ACTIVE REGIONS USING TIME-DISTANCE METHOD CRAAG, Observatory of Algiers, BP 63 Bouzareah 16340, Algiers, Algeria. (1)
1.Introduction 2.Description of model 3.Experimental design 4.Ocean ciruculation on an aquaplanet represented in the model depth latitude depth latitude.
Supergranulation Waves in the Subsurface Shear Layer Cristina Green Alexander Kosovichev Stanford University.
Imaging Solar Tachocline Using Numerical Simulations and SOHO/MDI Data Junwei Zhao 1, Thomas Hartlep 2, Alexander G. Kosovichev 1, Nagi N. Mansour 2 1.W.W.Hansen.
Solar activity as a surface phenomenon Axel Brandenburg (Nordita/Stockholm) Kemel+12 Ilonidis+11Brandenburg+11Warnecke+11 Käpylä+12.
The Sun as a whole: activity as seen by helioseismology
Using Realistic MHD Simulations for Modeling and Interpretation of Quiet Sun Observations with HMI/SDO I. Kitiashvili 1,2, S. Couvidat 2 1 NASA Ames Research.
Flows in the Solar Convection Zone David Hathaway NASA/MSFC National Space Science and Technology Center 2004 July 21 David Hathaway NASA/MSFC National.
The need for physics-based inversions of sunspot structure and flows D. Braun, A. Birch, A. Crouch NWRA/CoRA M. Rempel NCAR/HAO.
台灣清華大學, 物理系 Helioseismology (II) Global and Local Helioseismology ( , 北京 ) 周定一 Dean-Yi Chou.
The Solar Dynamo NSO Solar Physics Summer School Tamara Rogers, HAO June 15, 2007.
Adaptive Optics in the VLT and ELT era Atmospheric Turbulence
The Sun as whole: activity as seen by helioseismology A.C. Birch (Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research)
Tests of the Ring-Diagram Inversions A. Kosovichev.
Emerging Flux Simulations & semi-Sunspots Bob Stein A.Lagerfjärd Å. Nordlund D. Georgobiani 1.
1. Short Introduction 1.1 Overview of helioseismology results and prospects.
The Solar Interior NSO Solar Physics Summer School Tamara Rogers, HAO June 14, 2007
The Current Status of Sunspot Seismology H. Moradi, H. Schunker, L. Gizon (Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research, Katlenburg-Lindau, Germany)
Self-assembly of shallow magnetic spots through strongly stratified turbulence Axel Brandenburg (Nordita/Stockholm) Kemel+12 Brandenburg+13 Warnecke+11.
Travel Time Measurements Markus Roth 1, Laurent Gizon 1, John G. Beck 2 1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung 2 Stanford University HELAS Workshop.
Flows and Cycles Large scale flows and stellar magnetic cycles Markus Roth Wiebke Herzberg René Kiefer Ariane Schad Guy Davis (UoB) Retreat of the Stellar.
日震学的未来与展望 赵俊伟 斯坦福大学汉森试验物理实验室. Outline Some outstanding problems HMI time-distance pipeline Validation of local helioseismology results.
Prograde patterns in rotating convection and implications for the dynamo Axel Brandenburg (Nordita, Copenhagen  Stockholm) Taylor-Proudman problem Near-surface.
WG1-1: Sub-surface Structure and Evolution Motivation: A research program on space weather that ignores the sub-photospheric evolution of magnetic fields.
Photospheric Flows and Structures Mark Rast Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics Department of Astrophysical and Planetary Sciences University.
Simulations of Solar Convection Zone Nagi N. Mansour.
Helioseismology for HMI Science objectives and tasks* Data analysis plan* Helioseismology working groups and meetings *HMI Concept Study Report, Appendix.
Rachel Howe.  Rotation profile  Rotation changes over the solar cycle  The torsional oscillation  Tachocline fluctuations  Frequency and parameter.
The HMI Instrument. HMI Science Goals Line-of-Sight Observables.
An update on convection zone modeling with the ASH code
Solar Surface Magneto-Convection and Dynamo Action
WG1 – Sub-surface magnetic connections
October 14, Wednesday 12. Solar Convection
Gyrofluid Turbulence Modeling of the Linear
HMI Investigation Overview
Forward Modeling for Time-Distance Helioseismology
Validation of Helioseismic Fourier-Legendre Analysis
Holography Applied to Artificial Data
Supergranule Scale Convection Simulations
holographic measurements of simulated flows
Separating E and B types of CMB polarization on an incomplete sky Wen Zhao Based on: WZ and D.Baskaran, Phys.Rev.D (2010) 2019/9/3.
Presentation transcript:

Planning for Helioseismology with SO/PHI Birch, Gizon, & Hirzberger Max Planck Institute for Solar System Physics

Outline Motivation Synthetic data for helioseismology with PHI Forward modeling Some potential targets

Motivation Which helioseismology observations would most efficiently provide new science? How to model new approaches to helioseismology (e.g. stereoscopic imaging of base of convection zone)?

The two ingredients Synthetic data – Predict noise levels and systematic effects Forward models – Predict signal that would be expected for particular targets of interest – Enables estimates of required observation duration T (S/N goes as T 1/2 for steady signal)

Synthetic data: an example (see Loeptien poster) Begin from Stein & Nordlund simulation of solar convection Simulation domain 96x96x20 Mm 3 We have about three hours of data (one minute cadence) now at MPS Compute line profiles (Spinor) Simulate instrument effects (SOPHISM, poster #57)

Synthetic data: example results See poster by Loeptien, and poster #57 for SOPHISM code

Synthetic data: power spectra See poster by Loeptien

Forward models: approaches First Born approximation (single scattering) – Useful for weak perturbations – Can apply adjoint method (e.g., Hanasoge et al & 2012) to include systematic effects Numerical wave propagation – Generate forward models for arbitrarily strong perturbations (e.g., sunspots: Cameron et al. 2011) Realistic simulations – Directly simulate feature of interest (e.g, Rempel et al. 2009)

Forward models: wave propagation Gizon et al Cameron et al. 2008

A few potential targets Near-surface shear layer in rotation Radial shear reverses sign around 50° latitude Flows of order 10 m/s, global scale Use FDT Polar convective flows (at supergranulation scale) Flows of about 150 m/s, length scale 30 Mm Use HRT Active longitudes at base of convection zone Stereoscopic helioseismology Use FDT plus another helioseismology instrument Test of concept and exploration

Future work Continue working with convection simulations – Noise levels for local helioseismology – Data compression – How does PHI see solar oscillations? Develop simulations for FDT – Global-mode summation + Spinor Forward models for interesting targets Ideally, this would be a community effort There is a lot to do!

The End