Philosophes #4 Assess the impact of the Scientific Revolution on religion and philosophy in the period of #5 Analyze the ways in which enlightenment thought addressed religious beliefs and social issues in the 18 th century
Descartes Mind Does not obey physical laws Body Obeys physical laws (mechanical) Mind controls the body? – And/or …Body controls the mind? Deduction – Rational speculation – Internal reflection
Beccaria On Crimes and Punishment – Punishment needs to be just and effective No torture No death penalty (capital punishment) – Why law? Greatest happiness for the greatest number – Not religion Rational laws of nature = positive law
Rousseau & Voltaire Type of Government Voltaire – Constitutional monarchy Distrusted democracy – He “would rather obey 1 lion then 200 rats of his own species” Propagated the idiocy of the masses Rousseau – (Direct) Democracy Distrusted representative democracy – “any law which the people has not ratified in person, is void”
Outlook on Life Voltaire – People too optimistic People foolish – People intolerant of other ideas Rousseau – People want power – People born good and free People who are strong imprison weaker people Perfect Society Voltaire – People must work to make society better – “Everything happens for the better” is not true Rousseau – If people lived alone on island, society would be perfect – Government makes a society less perfect
Voltaire Freedom of Speech & Religion “ I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it”
Religion Voltaire – Separation of Church and State – Wanted religious tolerance for all Rousseau – No view listed SIMILARITIES – Ideas that went against all other Philosophes – Wanted people to be free – Both had traditional views on women
Rousseau
Montesquieu Spirit of the Laws – “separation of powers” Why? Avoid Absolutism Who would he disagree with? Freedom – Against slavery Women – Head of government Yes – Head of family No