System Restoration & Blackstart Standards Drafting Team Presentation to Texas RE Reliability Standards Committee March 4, 2009 Rick Terrill Confidential.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
2004 NERC, NPCC & New England Compliance Programs John Norden Manager, Operations Training, Documentation & Compliance August 31, 2003 RC Meeting.
Advertisements

Document Categorization Steve Ashbaker Director of Operations Joint Guidance Committee WECC Leadership Annual Training Session Salt Lake City, UT May 6-7,
STATUS OF BULK ELECTRIC SYSTEM DEFINITION PROJECT
PER Update & Compliance Lessons Learned
FRCC Fall Compliance Workshop October , 2013
State of Standards and Standards in Development Sean Cavote, Manager of Standards Development WECC Operating Committee Meeting March 26, 2015.
[INSERT APPLICABLE REGIONAL ENTITY NAME/LOGO] [ENTITY NAME] [FUNCTION CERTIFYING] Certification [LOCATION] – [DATES OF ON-SITE VISIT] [Presenter Name,
Compliance Application Notice Process Update and Discussion with NERC MRC.
RFC Webinar June 17, 2009 Presented By: Mark Kuras Chair, UFLS SDT.
Date Texas RE Board Update to TAC November 5, 2009 Susan Vincent Director, Legal Affairs.
June 6, 2007 TAC Meeting NERC Registration Issues Andrew Gallo, Assistant General Counsel, Litigation and Business Operations ERCOT Legal Dept.
WECC Standards Update Steve Rueckert – Director of Standards W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
Critical Infrastructure Protection Update Christine Hasha CIP Compliance Lead Advisor, ERCOT TAC March 27, 2014.
Current Status Of The ERO Transition Activities To Comply With The 2005 EPAC ERCOT Board Meeting February 21, 2006 Sam Jones, COO.
1 Texas Regional Entity Report December Performance Highlights ERCOT’s Control Performance Standard (NERC CPS1) score for October – Initial.
Andy Meyers OC Update ISAS April 2014 Salt Lake City, UT.
Implementing the New Reliability Standards Status of Draft Cyber Security Standards CIP through CIP Larry Bugh ECAR Standard Drafting Team.
Update On The ERO Transition Activities To Comply With The 2005 EPAC ERCOT TAC Meeting March 9, 2006 Sam Jones, COO.
Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement Audit Program Background Information.
Texas Regional Entity Update Sam Jones Interim CEO and President Board of Directors July 18, 2006.
Project Definition of Bulk Electric System Presenter: Peter Heidrich – Drafting Team Chair Date: March 1, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 18, 2014.
1 Texas Regional Entity 2008 Budget Update May 16, 2007.
Critical Infrastructure Protection Update Christine Hasha CIP Compliance Lead Advisor, ERCOT TAC March 27, 2014.
July 2008 CPS2 Waiver SDT Technical Workshop for Draft BAL-001-TRE-01 Judith A. James Reliability Standards Manager TRE.
Project System Protection Coordination Requirement revisions to PRC (ii) Texas Reliability Entity NERC Standards Reliability Subcommittee.
Board of Directors Meeting February 26, 2013 Standards, Registration and Certification Report.
Project (COM-001-3) Interpersonal Communications Capabilities Michael Cruz-Montes, CenterPoint Energy Senior Consultant, Policy & Compliance, SDT.
Item 5d Texas RE 2011 Budget Assumptions April 19, Texas RE Preliminary Budget Assumptions Board of Directors and Advisory Committee April 19,
Project Real-time Monitoring and Analysis Capabilities Mark Olson, Senior Standards Developer Texas RE NSRS October 5, 2015.
Bill Lewis, Compliance Team Lead NERC Reliability Working Group May 16, 2013 Texas RE Update Talk with Texas RE April 25, 2013.
Paragraph 81 Project. 2RELIABILITY | ACCOUNTABILITY Background FERC March 15, 2012 Order regarding the Find, Fix, Track and Report (FFT) process  Paragraph.
Company Confidential Registration Management Committee (RMC) AS9104/2A Presentation San Diego, CA January 17, 2013 Tim Lee The Boeing Company 1 Other Party.
Problem Areas Updates Penalties FRCC Compliance Workshop September / October
Page 1 of 13 Texas Regional Entity ROS Presentation April 16, 2009 T EXAS RE ROS P RESENTATION A PRIL 2009.
November 2, 2006 LESSONS FROM CIPAG 1 Lessons from Critical Infrastructure Group Bill Bojorquez November 2, 2006.
Overview of Texas RE Reliability Standards Process and 2008 Year in Review Judith James Manager, Reliability Standards.
Texas Regional Entity Report Mark Henry June 6, 2008.
Project Update TOP/IRO Reliability Standards NERC ORS May 6, 2014.
RSC An Overview of Fill-In-the-Blanks (FIB) Reliability Standards Farzaneh Tafreshi Manager, Reliability Standards Texas Regional Entity
WECC Standards Update Steve Rueckert – Director of Standards W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
Evaluate Phase Pertemuan Matakuliah: A0774/Information Technology Capital Budgeting Tahun: 2009.
Texas Regional Entity ROS Presentation January 15, 2009 T EXAS RE ROS P RESENTATION J ANUARY 2009.
Projects System Protection Coordination Draft 2 of TOP Texas Reliability Entity NERC Standards Reliability Subcommittee November 2, 2015.
SAR 001 DT Presentation Texas RE Presentation to SAR-001 Drafting Team Farzaneh Tafreshi Manager, Reliability Standards Texas Regional Entity.
Project Underfrequency Load Shedding PRC-006, 007 and 009 Bob Millard ReliabilityFirst staff Reliability Standards Workshop April 29-30, 2008.
NSRS Update Recent NERC Standards Activities RSC – June 2013 Presented by: Lisa Martin, NSRS Chair.
Reliability Standards Development Plan David Taylor Manager Standards Development Standards Committee Meeting June 12-13, 2008.
RFC Webinar April 24, 2009 and May 1, 2009 Presented By: Mark Kuras Chair, Generator Verification SDT.
1 Compliance Update June Control Performance Highlights  NERC CPS1 Performance April Performance  April performance comparison April 2007:
TPTF Update Trip Doggett TAC March 9, TPTF Update Meetings February 6 & 7, February 20 Attendance approximately 40 Completed review of ERCOT’s clarification.
NERC Transmission System Vegetation Management Standard ERCOT TAC Update Mike Boone – CenterPoint Energy John Schechter – AEP August 4, 2005 Austin, TX.
Reliability Standards Committee 2009 Scope and Plan Judith James Manager, Reliability Standards.
Path Operator Implementation Task Force Vic Howell, Vice Chair Report to OC March 22, 2016.
Top 10 Questions on Regional Reliability Standards Development Judith A. James Manager, Reliability Standards March 5, 2009 June 2008 TAC.
Updated ERO Enterprise Guide for Internal Controls
Rachel Coyne Manager, Reliability Standards Program
Path Operator Implementation Task Force
ERCOT Technical Advisory Committee June 2, 2005
PRC-006-RFC-01 Automatic Under Frequency Load Shedding Requirements
Background (history, process to date) Status of CANs
GMD Data Request NERC Rules of Procedure Section 1600
[INSERT APPLICABLE REGIONAL ENTITY NAME/LOGO]
[INSERT APPLICABLE REGIONAL ENTITY NAME/LOGO]
Reliability Standards Development Plan
Coordinate Operations Standard
NERC Reliability Standards Development Plan
Steve Rueckert – Director of Standards
NERC Reliability Standards Development Plan
Standards Development Process
Presentation transcript:

System Restoration & Blackstart Standards Drafting Team Presentation to Texas RE Reliability Standards Committee March 4, 2009 Rick Terrill Confidential & Proprietary – For Discussion Purposes Only

1 SRBSDT Roster Dick Kafka, PEPCO (Chair) Francis Esselman, ATC (Vice Chair) Mike Adibi, IRD Ed Baznik, First Energy Rod Byrnell, BCTC Gary Campbell, RFC Steve Cooper, IESO Frank Cumpton, CAISO Will Houston, National Grid Mark Kuras, PJM David Mahlman, NYISO Al McMeekin, SCE&G Doug Rempel, Manitoba Hydro Mike Richardson, AEP George Rodriguez, FPL Paul Srogas, US Bureau of Reclamation Mo Tadayon, Georgia Power Rick Terrill, Luminant Power

2 SRBSDT – Project Standards Original set:  EOP-005: System Restoration Plans  EOP-006: Reliability Coordination – System Restoration  EOP-007: Establish, Maintain, and Document a Regional Blackstart Capability Plan  EOP-009: Documentation of Blackstart Generating Unit Test Results Proposed set:  EOP-005: System Restoration from Blackstart Resources  EOP-006: System Restoration Coordination  EOP-007 & EOP-009 will be retired. Requirements have been incorporated into EOP-005 or EOP-006 or are no longer needed.

3 SRBSDT Project Scope This project involves reviewing and revising the four current referenced standards including: Resolving the issue of associating compliance measures with Attachment 1-EOP-005 elements. EOP-005 only requires the TOP and the BA to have a system restoration plan. The role of these and other entities, especially the Reliability Coordinator, needs to be defined. Both EOP-005 and EOP-006 contain a mix of requirements that address advance planning and real-time operations. The Standards Drafting Team (SDT) should consider the need to clearly delineate the two processes within the standards requirements. The elimination of ‘fill-in-the-blank’ components in EOP-007 and EOP-009. Other improvements to the standards deemed appropriate by the drafting team, with the consensus of stakeholders, consistent with establishing high quality, enforceable standards and consistent with establishing technically sufficient bulk power system blackstart and restoration standards. Comments on the appropriate EOP standards in FERC Order #693, issued March 16, 2007 were addressed as well as any comments produced by CESDT, VRF, V0, etc. Throughout the process, the SDT should identify any conflicts that are found with other existing standards and bring them to the attention of the Standards Committee for resolution.

4 Discussion of Key Items and Disclaimer Each NERC Registered Entity has the responsibility to review the draft NERC Standards EOP and EOP and determine the intent of the requirements and the application of those requirements to the Entity. The following discussion of requirements is for general informational purposes only, and is not intended to define specific activities each entity must complete for compliance.

5 SRBSDT: EOP Key requirements of the revised standard are: Most requirements are applicable to the TOP and GOP (ERCOT ISO is the only registered TOP in ERCOT. Some of the EOP TOP requirements may be performed by TO’s in ERCOT). Aligning restoration for TOP with use of Blackstart Resources. Defining the start and end of restoration. Elements required in plan and distribution of plan (May require more specific items to be identified in the plans & may increase documentation of plan distribution). Review and update cycle. Analysis/simulation of plan (Requires TOP to verify validity of plan every 5 years). Blackstart Resource testing requirements (ERCOT addressed 5-year timing with OGRR). Training of System Operators & switching personnel ( 2 hours training of switching personnel on tasks unique to System Restoration). Mandated participation in RC drills (once every 2 years). Mandated Blackstart Resource Agreements. Inclusion of requirements for GOP.

6 SRBSDT: EOP Key requirements of the revised standard are: Defining the role of the RC as coordination (More documentation of activities). Defining the start and end of the RC role. Elements required in plan and distribution of plan (May require more specific details in the ERCOT Plan). Review and update cycle (Document review). Review and approval of TOP plan (Requires formal review, response, and documentation). Training of System Operators. Conducting 2 drills or simulations annually (Training simulation plus the annual drill should meet this requirement).

7 SRBSDT – Draft 4 Standards  Significant Revisions to EOP –Included restoration without Blackstart Resources  Both Standards –Added Compliance section –Added Violation Severity Levels  Included Transition Plan –24 Month Implementation Plan

8 SRBSDT Schedule SAR approved on 4/10/07. First meeting of SDT on 6/6/07. First posting on 9/28/07. Second posting on 1/7/08. Third posting on 4/15/08. Fourth posting 10/21/08. Submit to NERC for review in February Balloting tentative late 1 st quarter 2009.

9 SRBSDT – Draft 4 Standards – ERCOT Regional Variance?  First opinion is that a Regional Variance is not necessary. –Many proposed requirements are currently in place in ERCOT –May need more detail in plans –May need more documentation of items and communications –Some minor additions  Do need to address which entity actually performs specific requirements (TOP or TO).  These are still DRAFT Standards

10 SRBSDT – Information Link

11 SRBSDT Questions?