Behavior and acoustic relationships: The significance of shared calls in the southern resident killer whales Juliette Nash, Beam Reach Friday Harbor Laboratories,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Science Research Group 4 Project.
Advertisements

Critical Reading Strategies: Overview of Research Process
What is Primary Research and How do I get Started?
Identifying Individual Variation in the Discrete Calls of the Killer Whale, Orcinus orca Sam Levinson October 27, 2007 Beam Reach Marine Science and Sustainability.
Associations of Discrete Call-Type and Behavioral Events of Southern Resident Killer Whales (Orcinus orca) in the Salish Sea Heather Hooper Beam Reach.
Investigating high frequency underwater vessel noise and potential masking of killer whale echolocation clicks Tim Hunt Beam Reach Marine Science and.
Kathryn Scurci Beam Reach Spring Background 3 pods of Southern resident killer whales (J, K, and L) 3 types of phonations: Clicks Whistles Pulsed.
Economics 105: Statistics Review #1 due next Tuesday in class Go over GH 8 No GH’s due until next Thur! GH 9 and 10 due next Thur. Do go to lab this week.
Residents and Transients and Offshores Oh MY! Killer Whales (Orcinus orca) of the Pacific Northwest Residents and Transients and Offshores Oh MY! Killer.
Val Veirs Colorado College Colorado Springs, CO, Scott Veirs Beam Reach marine science and sustainability school Seattle, WA,
Analysis. Start with describing the features you see in the data.
TigerStat ECOTS Understanding the population of rare and endangered Amur tigers in Siberia. [Gerow et al. (2006)] Estimating the Age distribution.
Spatial confirmation of vocal communication between a killer whale calf and its natal family Val Veirs – Colorado College Scott Veirs – Beam Reach Jason.
GALLERY OF VOCALIZATION BEHAVIORS 90Hz 16Hz RAPID “B” CALLING TYPICAL “A”-”B” CALLING “B” CALLING, THIRD HARMONIC ONLY CCC ABABABABABABABABABABABABABAB.
VESSEL NOISE AND ORCA VOCALIZATION: IMPLICATIONS FOR POLICY ALEXANDRA KOUGENTAKIS BEAM REACH FALL beamreach.org/071.
Beam Reach Marine Science and Sustainability School
© 2008 McGraw-Hill Higher Education The Statistical Imagination Chapter 9. Hypothesis Testing I: The Six Steps of Statistical Inference.
Localizing Vocalizations in fish- eating southern resident killer whales (Orcinus orca) Peggy Foreman Beam Reach 2006 Marine Science and Sustainability.
An Action Learning Approach For Increasing Critical Thinking Skills In An Information Systems Capstone Course Alan Burns School of CTI DePaul University.
William H. Bowers – Modeling Users: Personas and Goals Cooper 5.
Danielle Varda & Carrie Chapman University of Colorado at Denver, School of Public Affairs.
Diurnal Acoustic Activity of Southern Resident Killer Whales in the Salish Sea Looking for daily patterns in vocal activity Laura Christoferson Energy.
Unraveling the Communicative Properties of Surface Active Behaviors in Southern Residents Horace Liang Beam Reach: School of Marine Science and Sustainability.
Chapter 1: Research Methods
By: Courtney Kneipp BeamReach Marine Science and Sustainability School Fall 2005 Hendrix College 06 Conway, AR.
Correlation between vocalization and breaching Nicole Lee Beam Reach Marine science and sustainability school.
Modeling the Effects of Stream Microhabitat on Group Size and Foraging Success of Juvenile Coho Salmon William Hintz, Matthew Faust, and Mitch Banach Dr.
URBDP 591 I Lecture 3: Research Process Objectives What are the major steps in the research process? What is an operational definition of variables? What.
Killer whale (Orcinus orca) echolocation click rates during various behavioral states and ambient noise levels Hana Kazunas Beam Reach School of Marine.
Underwater Vessel Noise in the Haro Strait Lindsay H. Robinson University of Puget Sound Intern with Beam Reach Marine Science and Sustainability School.
The Examination of killer whale (Orcinus orca) call duration due to boat noise and vessel count By: Peter Valenzuela Beam Reach Spring 2009.
Are We Gambling With The Youth In Our Society? Jacob Mulhern University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire Introduction Hypothesis & Results Discussion Method Future.
One-way ANOVA: - Comparing the means IPS chapter 12.2 © 2006 W.H. Freeman and Company.
Sociological Research Methods. The Research Process Sociologists answer questions about society through empirical research (observation and experiments)
Megan Stoltzfus Beam Reach Fall 2010
1 Estimation of Population Mean Dr. T. T. Kachwala.
Introduction  Clicks Echolocation Clicks, Click Trains and Buzzes  Whistles Foraging, Socializing, >10m Reich & Thomson  Discrete Pulsed Calls Maintain.
Does an Increase of Boats Cause Decreased Vocalization Rates in Killer Whales (Orcinus orca)? Matthew J. Williams Beam Reach Marine Science and Sustainability.
Slide 7.1 Saunders, Lewis and Thornhill, Research Methods for Business Students, 5 th Edition, © Mark Saunders, Philip Lewis and Adrian Thornhill 2009.
Assistant Instructor Nian K. Ghafoor Feb Definition of Proposal Proposal is a plan for master’s thesis or doctoral dissertation which provides the.
BIOLOGY: Chapter 1 The Science of Biology. 1.1 The Science of Biology “ Science” is basically two things: – A body of knowledge… an accumulation of things.
Research Proposal Writing Resource Person : Furqan-ul-haq Siddiqui Lecture on; Wednesday, May 13, 2015 Quetta Campus.
Investigating the Effect of Large Vessel Noise on Southern Resident Killer Whales Hilary B. Rollins UC Davis Beam Reach Marine Science and Sustainability.
HOW TO DEVELOPE BETTER LISTENING SKILLS Lorie Terry EDU 671 Dr. Goss July 20, 2016.
Online engagement Techniques
Acknowledgement: Khem Gyawali
Articulating Your Practice C3 - Session #3
Asking Scientific Questions
Practice & Communication of Science From Distributions to Confidence
Testing the Motivation-Structural Rules Hypothesis in Southern Resident Killer Whales Kathryn Scurci Beam Reach Spring 2010.
What is there to discuss in a Statistics course?
Applied Geophysics Fall 2016 Umass Lowell
Megan Stoltzfus Beam Reach Fall 2010
Central Tendency and Variability
Unit 4 Introducing the Study.
Bell-ringer: 7 minutes Choose at least 2 to complete:
From Distributions to Confidence
Killer Whale Vocal Response to Vessel Traffic
Statistical Analysis Error Bars
Mealworm Lab Demonstrates experimental design principles and scientific method Explores a living organism’s.
EECS 373 Advanced Embedded Systems
Language and Communication
Language and Communication
The Scientific Method.
Creating a Community of Inquiry
Crisis Pregnancy Communication Campaign
Instrumental Surface Temperature Record
Analyzing Reliability and Validity in Outcomes Assessment
Managerial Decision Making and Evaluating Research
Language and Communication
Presentation transcript:

Behavior and acoustic relationships: The significance of shared calls in the southern resident killer whales Juliette Nash, Beam Reach Friday Harbor Laboratories, University of Washington, 620 University Road, Friday harbor, WA Phone:

The Basics This study focused on the southern resident killer whales of the Pacific Northwest. The SRKW’s are made up of 3 pods – J, K, & L. They communicate using the same or similar vocalizations.

Literature Review So far, the majority of acoustic studies have focused on the northern resident killer whale community. Studies show that there are two types of pulsed calls – those with a single (low frequency) component and those with two components (high and low frequencies). (Ford 1991) Two component calls may be directional and used to convey an individuals orientation to conspecifics. (Miller 2002)

Other studies have shown that certain pulsed calls are stable, while others change over time (Deecke et al. 2000). Pods have their own dialects, with some shared calls. The SRKW’s share 3 calls. (Ford 1983, 1987) In the northern community, little success has been had finding relationships between specific sounds and particular behaviors.

Relevance of shared calls Shared calls are significant to the SRKW Community. Shared calls are used in conjunction with behaviors or in activities important to the social & survival needs of the SRKW’s.

Problem statement Determine essential needs of SRKW community – social and biological. - Foraging - Reproduction - Social Cohesion - Synchronized behaviors & activites

Determine which calls are shared and generate hypothesis on what roles they might play. It is presumed shared calls are used within each pod on a relatively frequent basis.

The Logic Behind it Understanding what a call is related to has important management implications. Determine where and how often whales forage Day/night activities Changes in behavior or travel patterns over time. Determining critical habitat Estimation of energetic needs in wild vs captivity.

S6 – Social cohesion? Single-component – may not relay orientation information to kin. Frequently repetitious Very similar between pods Could potentially be used to maintain a general sense of cohesiveness while MU or pod members are spread.

S10 – Foraging indicator? Two-component call, may relay orientation info to kin Often accompanied by echolocation. Variable within and between pods A distinctive call, that is different from other pulsed calls structurally and acoustically.

S42 – Synchronous cue? Clear two component call Not often associated with quantifiable amounts of echolocation Sounds very similar between pods Appears ‘stable’ which may be useful if associated with a range of behaviors.

Behavioral definitions Foraging- circle swimming, lunging, frequent or sudden direction changes. Often includes percussive behaviors. Milling – no predominant behaviors. Often foraging or social behaviors. Percussive behaviors common. Occasionally resting by individuals or sexual behaviors occur. Synchronous behavior – Behaviors deliberately performed in tandem with at least two whales. Occurs frequently across a wide range of behaviors.

Group Spread –Close – any number of associated whales within 50ft of one another. –Spread – any number of assoc. whales at a distance greater than 50ft to one another. Distance parameter based on average underwater visibility in Haro Strait of ~30ft, and the presumption the whales underwater visual acuity is greater than ours.

Methods Research platform was a 42ft biodiesel-electric sailing catamaran, the Gato Verde. Surface behaviors were recorded onto a PDA, with data collection software from Dr. Jim Ha. Supplemental hand written notes were taken Behaviors recorded when the whales were in visual & acoustic range.

Acoustic range was estimated as the area within 1.5miles of the hydrophone. Acoustic data was recorded using a single towed hydrophone and was recorded onto a Marantz recorder. Effort was made to identify the behaviors of all animals in acoustic range.

Acoustic files were analyzed in Raven ™ After acoustic data had been analyzed individual file times were synchronized with the observation real time. Acoustic data was mapped against PDA data. Keeping the data sets separate after initial collection and keeping acoustic recording times raw until after analysis negated bias.

Results There were 5 encounters that yielded usable data. 4 were with Jpod and 1 was K & some L’s Whales were vocal during all encounters.

S6 Determined this call was not involved with social cohesion in interpod settings Recorded only 3x during Jpod encounters. Recorded 11x while with K&L. Raises possibility that a shared call is used primarily during intrapod settings.

S10 A one-factor ANOVA showed there was not a significant relationship with S10 and foraging (F 1,26 = 0.22, P = 0.64). Frequently heard while whales were visibly observed foraging. Less frequently heard during encounters with less observed foraging activity. Often lots of echolocation.

S42 Call occurred sporadically and was frequently repetitious with evenly spaced intervals. Preliminary analysis does not show signs of a link with particular behaviors. Insufficient sample set of group direction change to analyze.

Discussion The one factor ANOVA results may have been caused by a combination of equipment and methodology error. Due to the high occurance of foraging and S10’s during foraging, this relationship should be researched further.

The presence of S6 during the intrapod encounter suggests that it use may be limited to those multipod gatherings. An alternative hypothesis is that S6 is used during social gatherings for either biological or social purposes.

A note on milling & distance Foraging often occurs during milling, but at a distance it is difficult to identify. Whales are in acoustic range, but poor visual range. Choosing not to include foraging as a observed behavior during distant milling may have biased the foraging event data. S10’s were heard during these times as well as during strong visual range milling

Final thoughts More research is warranted on this topic, particularly regarding a vocalization associated with foraging.

Acknowledgements Thank you to Beam Reach and my instructors – Jason Wood, Donna Hauser, and Scott & Val Veirs. Todd Schuster and the Gato Verde along with our relief captains, Mike Dawson and Glenn ***. Thank you to Dr. Jim Ha for providing me with personalized PDA data collection software. Thank you to all of our guest lecturers for providing your time, knowledge and answering all my questions. Thank you to Friday Harbor Labs and the University of Washington. Thank you to Dori Oringer, Don and Helene Hirschfeld, the Lees, Gordon and Anca Nash, Susan Melnick, Maddie and Tyler Gass, and my parents, Alan and Suzanne Nash for their help and financial support. Thank you to my fellow students for their help, advice, and a great ten weeks. Thank you to my family, L.N, P.K, S.A, A.M, C.I, E.A, P & F M, E.L, K.G, N.H, E.G, C.C, E.F, J.R, C.K, K.L, S.M, M. S, R.L, K.O, D.B, B.H, S.D, L.F, and countless others for their love, friendship, inspiration, and support and for not giving me too hard a time about moving across the country to go study whales. Thank you to my guards, for teaching me about perseverance in the face of enormous and ongoing obstacles, and about the amazing things a small group of dedicated people can accomplish. Thank you to everyone who reviewed and edited this paper and helped me organize my ideas and finalize my methods.

Thank you!