해외저널에 논문게재하기 고려대학교 이상민 “scholarly work is rooted in the lively exchange of ideas – conversation at its best” (Huff 1999)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Peer reviewer training part I: What do we know about peer review?
Advertisements

Tips for Publishing Qualitative Research Sandra Mathison University of British Columbia Editor-in-Chief, New Directions for Evaluation.
What happens after submission? Sadeghi Ramin, MD Nuclear Medicine Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences.
Submission Process. Overview Preparing for submission The submission process The review process.
ASV Education and Career Development Workshop Put down the pipette and pick up the pen: Getting your work published The third part of the story... The.
University of Ottawa Medical Journal Workshop Feb 11, 2014 Diane Kelsall MD MEd Deputy Editor, CMAJ and Editor, CMAJ Open.
A quick guide to APA formatting William A. Sodeman, Ph.D. Hawaii Pacific University.
Improving Learning, Persistence, and Transparency by Writing for the NASPA Journal Dr. Cary Anderson, Editor, NASPA Journal Kiersten Feeney, Editorial.
Finding a Journal Article
Library Session NURS 305-L Rachael Clemens. Purpose of this session Teach you how to obtain the scholarly literature you need to support these assignments:
School of something FACULTY OF OTHER Publications Master Class Marge Wilson (Pro-Dean for Research in Environment & Alan Haywood (Postgraduate Research.
Reading the Literature
Literature Review Week 3 Lecture 1. School of Information Technologies Faculty of Science, College of Sciences and Technology The University of Sydney.
Getting Published in Clinical Research Getting Published in Clinical Research (or 101 ways to get really frustrated…)
Manuscript Writing and the Peer-Review Process
Welcome to the CINAHL* tutorial By the end of this tutorial you should be able to: Do a basic search to find references Use search techniques to make your.
LITERATURE REVIEWS. What is a literature review?  “a synthesis of the literature on a topic.”  (Cottrell & McKenzie, 2011, pg 40)
Getting Published (or 101 ways to get really frustrated…)
Research Paper : A Little Resource Help
WRITING FOR PUBLICATION Ghada aboheimed Msc. Writing for publication  Why is it an important lect?
Shobna Bhatia.  Telephone instrument  Computer  Software Instructions nearly always provided However, frequently not read At least, not until things.
Periodical Databases Full-text article – entire textual contents of article in online format Abstract – brief summary of article Citation – basic information.
Dr. Dinesh Kumar Assistant Professor Department of ENT, GMC Amritsar.
Writing a research paper in science/physics education The first episode! Apisit Tongchai.
Literature Review. General Format  Typed, Double Spaced on standard paper  12 point Times New Roman Font  1 inch margin on all sides of the paper 
What is a vita and why do we call it that? Vita, vitae, curriculum vitae??
Submitting Manuscripts to Journals: An Editor’s Perspective Michael K. Lindell Hazard Reduction & Recovery Center Texas A&M University.
Thomson Reuters ISI (Information Sciences Institute) Azam Raoofi, Head of Indexing & Education Departments, Kowsar Editorial Meeting, Sep 19 th 2013.
References Prof. Nikos Siafakas MD,PhD. University of Crete.
Ian White Publisher, Journals (Education) Routledge/Taylor & Francis
Just the Facts: How to Successfully Incorporate Relevant Research into your Academic Writing Writing Specialist Jamie Patterson and Dissertation Editor.
Journal Searching Nancy B. Clark, M.Ed. Director of Medical Informatics Education FSU College of Medicine 1 All recourses are available online in Medical.
Manuscript Review Prepared by Noni MacDonald MD FRCPc Editor-in-Chief Paediatrics and Child Health Former Editor-in -Chief CMAJ
Scope of the Journal The International Journal of Sports Medicine (IJSM) provides a forum for the publication of papers dealing with basic or applied information.
How to publish paper in journal. Step 1.Familiarize yourself with potential publications.
B130P16E: Practical basics of scientific work Department of Plant Physiology FS CU RNDr. Jan Petrášek, Ph.D. 5. Presentation.
Dr. Sundar Christopher Navigating Graduate School and Beyond: Sow Well Now To Reap Big Later Writing Papers.
SCI 论文发表流程 1. 上传或写信或发 投递 Dear Prof. xxx (Editor): Attached (Enclosed) please find the word or PDF version of my paper entitled "xxx" with the kind.
Research Methods in Pscyhology Library Workshop January 2011.
DATABASES. Learning outcomes for today By the end of this session you will be able to: ◦ Use boolean operators ◦ Understand the structure of information.
© 2009 Pearson Prentice Hall, Salkind. Chapter 3A Selecting a Problem and Reviewing the Research.
4 Steps to follow when writing an original research article.
publications in international peer-reviewed journals
Introduction to Human Services
Welcome to your library day!
BIO1130 Lab 2 Scientific literature
Journeys into journals: publishing for the new professional
David Ockert Toyo University
Finding Scholarly Articles in a Library Database
Annotated Bibliography
Reliable and UNRELIABLE Sources
APA Style for Students By Kate Cottle.
Test Review Be prepared to provide an answer.
Locating & Evaluating Sources
Scholarly & Peer Reviewed Sources.
Dealing with reviewer comments
GRADUATION PROJECT DIPLOMA IN PHARMACY
Field Guide to Periodical Types
From EMA assignments to published articles
BIO1130 Lab 2 Scientific literature
Cite it Right How to create a correctly formatted Works Cited paper and matching in-text citations.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم.
APA Research Paper Day 3: Works cited page, Citations, and Outlining
APA style 2018.
Formatting It is a BIG Deal!!!.
5. Presenting a scientific work
Ins and Outs of Publishing:
Dr John Corbett USP-CAPES International Fellow
Presentation transcript:

해외저널에 논문게재하기 고려대학교 이상민 “scholarly work is rooted in the lively exchange of ideas – conversation at its best” (Huff 1999)

논문작성 참고문헌 찾기 – 예시 ( – ERIC (education journals) – Lexis-Nexis Academic Universe (business, government, medical, legal...) – Newspaper Abstracts (25 major newspapers) – PsychINFO (social sciences) – EBSCO database – Web of Science (science, social science, arts and literature citations)

참고문헌의 수준 Primary: Peer Reviewed journal articles Secondary: Not peer reviewed Primary Secondary

Levels of Peer Reviewed Information Primary: original research Secondary: review articles Tertiary: textbooks, summaries Primary Secondary Tertiary

Primary Peer Reviewed Literature Original Research

Secondary Peer Reviewed Sources

EBSCO Fields Author Title Date Type of publication Journal, Volume, Issue Page numbers Abstract Institution A lot of cataloging numbers

Tips Find one good article Look at authors & heading Pick similar articles Search same authors and terms Use Related Articles in EBSCO

좋은 아티클 찾기 Recent Applicable Relevant Good research criteria Not just first full text article you find

아티클 형식 - APA Style Margins 1”, top, bottom, left and right 8 ½ X 11 inch white paper Portrait orientation Font: Times New Roman, 12 point References Alpay, L., & Russell, A. (2002). Information technology training in primary care: the nurses' voice. Comput Inform Nurs, 20(4), Balen, R. M., & Jewesson, P. J. (2004). Pharmacist computer skills and needs assessment survey. J Med Internet Res, 6(1), 11.

출판할 저널 고르기

저널을 고를 때 고려해야 할 점 Is your paper of very general interest/ significance? Or is it of more interest to a specialist group? Is your paper of very general interest/ significance? Or is it of more interest to a specialist group? If the former, your work might be appropriate for a high-impact generalist journal; if the latter, it may be appropriate to target a good quality specialist journal If the former, your work might be appropriate for a high-impact generalist journal; if the latter, it may be appropriate to target a good quality specialist journal

언제 저널을 선정해야 하는가 ? Before you even start the research. It is far more important to ask a good question than exhaustively answer a question nobody cares about. If you are addressing an issue widely perceived as important, your chances of being published in a "high-impact" journal are far greater from the outset.

편집자가 원하는 게 무엇인가 ? They want well-written submissions that: They want well-written submissions that: – Conform to all the journals format requirements. All modern journals have web pages from which you can access/download information ("Instructions for Authors") All modern journals have web pages from which you can access/download information ("Instructions for Authors") Most good journal receive many more submissions that they can publish. Thus, the editors can usually afford to be very choosy. Most good journal receive many more submissions that they can publish. Thus, the editors can usually afford to be very choosy.

게재 절차 All quality journals use a form of the "peer review process"All quality journals use a form of the "peer review process" You submit your manuscript (on-line for many journals) - Example You submit your manuscript (on-line for many journals) - Example The journal sends you an acknowledgement of receipt (often an ) - Example The journal sends you an acknowledgement of receipt (often an ) - Example

제출 후 얼마나 기다려야 하는가 ? Wait 1-2 weeks or wait 2-3 months while the manuscript is reviewed by 2-3 external reviewersWait 1-2 weeks or wait 2-3 months while the manuscript is reviewed by 2-3 external reviewers

The editor and the editorial board consider the reviews and contact you with a decision I’m not sure about this..... Then….

가능한 결과 (i) Rejection first the tears then the anger “the most common cause of outright rejection …. is that the paper is not suited to the journal” (Day 1996)

You will need to work your way past this stage… Around about now this could look attractive…

Rejected? Editors are supposed to act as "informed judges", weighing up the strengths of your arguments against any criticisms raised by the reviewers However, when editors are stretched for time and the reviewers are unpaid "experts" of variable quality, the peer review process may treat your manuscript with "cavalier disregard"

게재불가시 대안은 ? Move on to the next journal (incorporate changes to counter any criticisms encountered) Move on to the next journal (incorporate changes to counter any criticisms encountered) If you have a case, write to the editor with a calm, clear and fact-centered rebuttal of the criticisms (good luck) If you have a case, write to the editor with a calm, clear and fact-centered rebuttal of the criticisms (good luck) If not satisfied with the editor's response to your rebuttal, write to the Managing Editor If not satisfied with the editor's response to your rebuttal, write to the Managing Editor

좋은 결과 You are requested to submit a revised manuscript (this is good!) You are requested to submit a revised manuscript (this is good!) You obtain unqualified acceptance (go buy a lottery ticket!) You obtain unqualified acceptance (go buy a lottery ticket!)