Alternative Delivery Models – Legal issues Kim Howell, Partner Geldards LLP.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Why and how we became a mutual Graham Barnes MyCSP Ltd.
Advertisements

State Aid Rules Ole Damsgaard.
David Alcock Wednesday 12 th February 2014 Somerleyton Road project Stewardship options.
Judge Business School There is Another Way: The Social Economy Dr Helen Haugh.
Communitymatters.org.uk. Community Asset Transfer (CAT) Richard Bridge Head of Conusltancy,Training and Quality.
Integration, cooperation and partnerships
Smart Service Delivery in Challenging Times Shared services – what does it mean for you? Alan Higgins Chair, CIEH Council Director, Environmental Health.
Exploring Social Enterprise EUROPEAN UNION Investing in Your Future European Regional Development Fund
Social enterprise and public service delivery John Maddocks.
VAS Conference 2012 Company Law and Charity Law. Alastair Keatinge Head of Charities, Lindsays.
Strategic Service Partnerships and UNISON Strategy Colin Meech National Officer.
New Procurement & Delivery Arrangements for the Schools’ Estate Presentation to Strategic Advisory Group 18 April 2005.
Copyright © 2008 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Ltd.1 Chapter Twelve Corporate Governance Canadian Business and Society: Ethics & Responsibilities.
CHAPTER 16 Continuity of employment and transfers of undertakings.
Legal Structures for Social Enterprise Nicola Dickins Make it Happen Consultancy.
Alternative Service Delivery Models October
National Smartcard Project Work Package 8 – Corporate Structures Report.
Making the Right Choice Anja Beriro, Browne Jacobson LLP 10 July 2013.
Assessment 1 Co-operative Enterprise- The Democratic Alternative Exemplar Solution LO1 1Co-operative Enterprise ( level 6)
UK government policy on social enterprise and public procurement Jonathan Bland 1.
A wide range of clients Housing associations 3 rd sector bodies Private companies supplying services to the public sector Colleges and government bodies.
State Aid Rules Ole Damsgaard. What is state aid? “Any aid granted by a Member State…which distorts competition by favouring certain undertakings or the.
OneSource – The Way Forward Caroline Nugent Director of Human Resources and Organisational Development.
Legal Structures for Social Enterprise Nicola Dickins Make it Happen Consultancy.
Commercialisation – Alternative Models of Service Delivery CIPFA in the North East Professional Update Day Gavin Barker, Senior Manager Wednesday 16 March.
Welcome, Introduction and Setting the Scene to the Alternative Delivery Model Challenge in Wales Croeso, Cyflwyniad a Gosod yr Olygfa ar gyfer Her Ffyrdd.
Datewww.local.gov.uk Research Findings Service Delivery Models and their HR Implications Anastasia Simpson & Stephen Cooper 17 th March
By the public sector, for the public sector About LGSS  LGSS established in October 2010 as a joint shared services partnership between Cambridgeshire.
New Models and New Challenges for Public Services – a Legal Perspective Tracy Giles 10 March 2015.
Professional support for the voluntary sector. An Overview Of Legal Status Wednesday 25 November 2009 Amy Richardson, Solicitor Charlie Wright, Solicitor.
Culture, Leisure & Tourism A way forward. Update you on the latest financial position (our key driver for change) Share with you some work we have been.
Decision Tree for Status Decision on New Supplier Engagements
An Introduction to Community Interest Companies (CICs)
Social Enterprise – What does it mean for you ?
Family offices – step 21/11/16
Integration, cooperation and partnerships
Marek Stavinoha Legal officer DG MOVE A4 European Commission
How To Drive A Commercial Approach In The Public Sector
Alternative delivery models in public services
The Community, Voluntary and Charitable Sector
Which is the most appropriate legal structure for the business?
Equality and Human Rights Exchange Network
A key principle of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), is that people with disability are empowered to exercise choice and control and access.
Commercial Organizations
The Application of Legal Principles in Business
Public Private Partnerships (PPP)
What do we need from a legal entity?
Corporations and Trusts Law Chapter 3 Choosing a Business Structure
Cross-Border Pension Plans in Europe Where Do We Go From Here?
Consultation on the Proposed Conversion of Moordown St
Consultation on the Proposed Conversion of Moordown St
State aid rules Ole Damsgaard, Joint Secretariat
Commissioning principles
Public Procurement Overview Clare Winter – Procurement Group Manager
Legal framework for social enterprises
The Public Sector Equality Duty
Tokyo - January 2007 Gerold Schwarz
ICA principles towards EU legislation?
Objectives By the end of this lecture students should be able to:
Certificate in Human Resource Management Employment Law Session Three Change and Reorganisation 1/1/2019.
State Aid Rules Kirsti Mijnhijmer, Joint Secretariat
Legal Issues for Hubs Music Mark Conference 2018
Public Procurement Overview Clare Winter – Procurement Group Manager
Charitable Incorporated Organisation
The Public Sector Equality Duty
Types of Business Organizations
CHAPTER 9 CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND GLOBAL ISSUES IN OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT.
The Role of Private Sector in Capital Budgeting
BASICS OF PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
CEng progression through the IOM3
Presentation transcript:

Alternative Delivery Models – Legal issues Kim Howell, Partner Geldards LLP

Why alternative delivery models? Savings – Pressures on budgets Efficiency savings already made Emergence of private sector provision Reassess the role of the local authority Community engagement How will your chosen model help you achieve these objectives? What are the opportunities and risks

Legal Issues Powers Democratic Control Procurement State Aid Employment

Service Delivery Models In-house Outsourced contract Strategic Partnership Shared Services Corporate Entity Mutual Trading Company Combination

Powers Identify a power s.2 Local Government Act 2000 s.111 Government Act 1972 s.120 Local Government Act 1972 S.123 Local Government Act 1972 s.1 Local Authorities (Goods and Services) Act 1970 Exercise of powers Constraints

Democratic Control Outsourced contract – Limited to control through contract New delivery vehicle May minimise local authority involvement to ensure Charitable status Eligibility for non-domestic rate relief Company not subject to constraints on local authority controlled and influenced companies Is this acceptable to members and public?

Procurement Is there a contract for services where Council buying from provider? If so, competitive procurement required in principle BUT Some potential to avoid competition process through concession contract, provided no realistic prospect of interest from other EU states. Take advice! Concessions Directive to be implemented

Procurement Public Contracts Regulations 2015 “Light touch” regime for some services Removal of distinction between Part A and Part B services “Teckal” exemption for in-house companies Exemption developed from case law included in 2015 Regulations

Procurement Public Contracts Regulations 2015 Reserved right for “mutuals” to participate in award of public contracts for some services Restricts competition to types of organisation that meet set criteria “Criteria includes employee ownership or participatory principles or active participation of employees, users or stakeholders and maximum 3 year term

State Aid – the ingredients Economic advantage out of State resources Provided to an economic undertaking Giving rise to a selective advantage Potential to distort competition Potential to affect trade between Member States

State Aid in outsourcing In the terms of transfer Business and assets transfer Pension arrangements Other deal terms In the ongoing relationship Service contract Back office support Property use

State aid solutions Market terms deal De minimis aid Possible exemptions include: Sports and recreation infrastructure Culture and heritage (including libraries) Services of general economic interest (SGEI) Carry out a State aid analysis when planning the structure

Employment Staff costs account may be a large part of service delivery budget – Is this your motivation for change? If reducing staff costs, how will you ensure the service can be run effectively? How will redundancies be funded? What impact will this have on the savings you are aiming to achieve?

Employment Employment opportunities and obligations Provided Council relinquishes “ control ", should minimise equal pay comparison risks if different terms and conditions emerge Cross employer comparisons where employers are “associated” Glasgow City Council CPG and Coria v Unison and Fox Cross Claimants 2014 Associated where one employer is a company of which the other directly or indirectly has control

Employment TUPE applies but opportunity to restructure provided rely on “ETO reason entailing changes in workforce” Code of Practice on Workforce Matters have regard to it rather than automatically apply it

Example – ML Community Enterprise Limited Spin out from Lambeth – Youth services Company with a representative Partnership Board Members comprise of subscribers and employees of the company One member, one vote

ML Community Enterprise Limited Why this structure? Council required: An employee led asset locked body with no ability to distribute profits to members Body capable of registration as a charity Democratic member voting structure

Example – People 2 People CIC Spin out from Shropshire CC – Social Services Company limited by shares Only founder members and employees can hold voting shares Dividends payable to shareholders One member one vote regardless of shareholding Board composition – Service user, employee, independent directors, managing director

People 2 People Why this structure? Council required: A social enterprise: Employee led Employees have financial dividend and controlling interest subject to statutory cap Democratic voting structure

Leeds Learning Disability Services Spin out from Leeds City Council Community benefit society Why this structure? Employee led Employees able to take a nominal shareholding

In Summary The same model will not suit all circumstances Structures do not deliver transformation Choice of suitable structure Effective implementation Range of factors influence choice of alternative model Financial implications Staffing implications Political acceptability of level of control

In Summary Develop proposals for transformation Identify and analyse the benefits/risks/costs of each model Map out process and implementation programme Implement plans Review Share your experiences with others on the journey!

Kim Howell DD : Mobile:

Thank You