Challenge Awards Judging Tuesday 12 May 2015 UNB Fredericton

2 Challenge Award Chair Pierre-Philippe Ouimet Chief Judge 2017 Regina

3 ChallengeCategory DiscoveryJunior EnergyIntermediate EnvironmentSenior Health Information Innovation Resources Challenge Awards Awarded to the best project in each of the seven Challenges in each Category. The three judges for each Challenge select the best: Junior Intermediate Senior

4 Seven Teams of Three Find your Team Mates and Introduce yourselves

5 Judging Process 1 Three judges per team Chair participates in the Challenge judging. List of highest ranked projects will be provided by the Chief Judge Operations at about 2:15 pm Judges have 8 minutes to interview the student, and 2 minutes to record their impressions. Judges work alone. Do not interrupt Special Award judging which is scheduled. You are free to listen in. Chair leads the team through the process

6 Judging Process 2 Keep to time! Meet as a team to decide your final results by consensus. Ensure all team members get a voice Give final results to the Chief Judge Operations. Put all the remaining paperwork into the box on the table of the Chief Judge Operations

7 Timetable From (pm) To (pm) Event 2:302:45Meet at your Challenge Judging Table. Receive the top ranked projects from the morning’s judging from the Chief Judge Operations. Fill in top three projects to interview on your Judging Form, in each of Junior, Intermediate and Senior 2:454:15Interview your projects for 10 minutes 4:154:45Meet at your table. Decide on final ranking by consensus. 5:00Report Final Results to Challenge Award Chair. 5:01Judges’ Reception – voluntary

8 Judging Form Project NumberMeets CriteriaYesNoRank Comment Project NumberMeets CriteriaYesNoRank Comment Project NumberMeets CriteriaYesNoRank Comment 4 more projects Individual Judge 02 Energy

9 Worksheet Team Consensus Enter the Ranking (e.g. 1-3) of each project by each judge on your team. Through reasoned discussion, determine a consensus rank for each project highest (1) to lowest (3) Project Number Judge’s Name Henry Higgins Ian Ibsen Janet James Total ranking score576 Consensus Rank

10 Final Result 02 Intermediate Energy Project #Name(s)Project Title 1 Alt IrelandLiquid Solar Cells Jones Wind Turbines – Friend or Foe?

11 Possible Challenges The Gold medalist is not a good fit for the Challenge. You like a Silver medalist more than the Gold medalist. Solution: Discuss thoroughly Consult the Chief Judge Operations.

12 Questions ?

13 Thank You for your contribution to the Canada Wide Science Fair