Doc.: IEEE 802.11-08/1101r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 1 Additional 40 MHz Scanning Proposal Date: 2008-09-09 Authors:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Doc.: IEEE /0049r0 Submission January 2007 Matthew Fischer, BroadcomSlide 1 Signaling of intolerance for 40 MHz transmissions Notice: This document.
Advertisements

Doc.: IEEE /0984r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 1 Bluetooth test cases with n 40 MHz Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /441r0 Submission September 2001 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies Slide 1 IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area.
Doc.: IEEE /1238r4 Submission November 2008 Peter Loc & KiranSlide 1 Proposal to Add Optional non n Radio Scans for 40 MHz Operation in.
Doc.: IEEE /1101r3 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 1 Additional 40 MHz Scanning Proposal Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0231r3 Submission March 2010 John R. Barr, JRBarr, Ltd. & NiCTSlide 1 Efficient Methods for Coexistence with Other 60GHz Systems Date:
Doc.: IEEE /0127r0 Submission January 2009 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 1 Bluetooth AFH and IEEE Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /0576r3 Submission May 2009 George Vlantis (STMicroelectronics) et aliiSlide 1 TGn SB2: Presentation for 40MHz Coexistence CIDs Notice:
Doc.: IEEE /482r0 Submission October 2001 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies Slide 1 IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area.
Doc.: IEEE /2446r0 Submission September 2007 Eldad Perahia, Intel CorporationSlide 1 MIB Attributes for 40 MHz Scanning in 2.4 GHz Date:
Doc.: IEEE /1468r1 Submission Jan 09 Ashish Shukla, Marvell SemiconductorSlide 1 ERP Protection in IEEE s Mesh Network Date:
Doc.: IEEE /0992r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola Inc.Slide 1 20/40 MHz 11n Interference on Bluetooth Date: Authors:
Doc.: IEEE /462r0 Submission July 2002 Bill McFarland, Atheros CommunicationsSlide 1 Backwards/Forwards Compatibility for 11h There will exist.
Doc.: IEEE /0623r0 Submission May 2007 Eldad Perahia, Intel CorporationSlide 1 Resolutions to 20/40 MHz Coexistence in 2.4 GHz Issues Notice:
Doc.: IEEE /1291r0 SubmissionSlide 1 Date: Presenter: Dynamic Bandwidth Control for aj (60GHz New Technique Proposal) KB Png.
Secondary Channel CCA of HE STA
FILS Reduced Neighbor Report
Response to Official Comments
40 MHz Coexistence in 2.4 GHz Tutorial
LB97 20/40 BSS Coexistence Date: Authors: July 2007
P802.11aq Waiver request regarding IEEE RAC comments
July 2008 doc.: IEEE /1021r0 November 2008
Proposed Evaluation Methodology Additions
LB97 CID Coex Date: Authors: May 2007 May 2007
November 2008 doc.: IEEE November 2008
Wake Up Frame to Indicate Group Addressed Frames Transmission
Proposed Evaluation Methodology Additions
Below 6GHz 11vht PAR scope and purpose discussion
120MHz channelization solution
FILS Reduced Neighbor Report
Submission Title: [Bluetooth SIG Liaison Report Nov08]
LB97 20/40 BSS Coexistence Date: Authors: July 2007
CID#102 - Channel Allocation
Bluetooth Liaison Report
Fair Quiet for DFS Date: Authors: February 2008
CR for CID 1105 Date: Authors: January 2019 Month Year
Functional Requirements for EHT Specification Framework
Greenfield VoIP Transmissions Cause False RADAR Triggers
Submission Title: [WG n Liaison Report, March09]
Channel Allocation March 2008 Authors: Date: Month Year
July 2008 doc.: IEEE /1021r0 November 2008
Additional 40 MHz Scanning Proposal
Overlapping BSS Co-Existence
Submission Title: [TGn Report Nov08] Date Submitted: [13Nov08]
Greenfield VoIP Transmissions Cause False RADAR Triggers
Signaling of intolerance for 40 MHz transmissions
MAC Protocol to Support Dynamic Bandwidth for aj (60GHz)
Additional 40 MHz Scanning Proposal
doc.: IEEE <doc#1>
Extended Channel Switch Announcement for TGn
Signaling of intolerance for 40 MHz transmissions
LB97 Coex: Duplicate DSSS
April 2009 doc.: IEEE /xxxxr0 July 2010
P802.11aq Waiver request regarding IEEE RAC comments
P802.11aq Waiver request regarding IEEE RAC comments
Synchronization of Quiet Periods for Incumbent User Detection
Month Year doc.: IEEE /xxxxr0
Month Year doc.: IEEE /xxxxr0
Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [LECIM Coexistence Considerations] Date Submitted:
MBCA and Beacon Timing element clean up
July 2008 doc.: IEEE /1021r0 November 2008
Additional 40 MHz Scanning Proposal
Month Year doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0 November 2013
TGn-LB115-CID 5097 Date: Authors:.
Functional Requirements for EHT Specification Framework
Response to Official Comments
Greenfield protection mechanism
Month Year doc.: IEEE yy/xxxxr0 August 2019
Proposed Evaluation Methodology Additions
Date: Authors: February 2010 Month Year
Presentation transcript:

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 1 Additional 40 MHz Scanning Proposal Date: Authors:

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 2 Abstract Due to the number of negative comments that have been cast in the recent letter ballot regarding use of 40 MHz channels in 2.4 GHz spectrum, it is proposed to add scanning requirements to clause for FC HT AP 19 and FC HT ATA 19 devices to detect presence of non radios operating in 2.4 GHz spectrum and set the Forty MHz Intolerant field to 1 in transmitted HT Capabilities elements if detection is positive. This should be sufficient to resolve all of the latest negative comments (9304, 9044, 9041, 9009, and unresolved comments from earlier ballots).

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 3 Coexistence with other IEEE 802 Standards Current draft n provides substantial coexistence language for legacy IEEE devices via mandatory scanning prior to enabling operation of 40 MHz channels. 40MHzIntolerant bit is used to inform other devices in BSS that operation of 40 MHz channels is not allowed. Adding mandatory scanning for non-IEEE devices operating in 2.4 GHz should satisfy negative letter ballot comments and improve the draft.

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 4 Current Coexistence Language Normative: – : “ An FC HT AP 19 that detects either of the BSS channel width trigger events TE-B or TE-C or that determines that the value of its variable 20/40 Operation Permitted has changed from TRUE to FALSE shall set the Secondary Channel Offset field to SCN in transmitted HT Operation elements beginning at the next DTIM or next TBTT if no DTIMs are transmitted to indicate that no secondary channel is present (i.e., that the BSS operating width is 20 MHz). ” Informative: –T.5.2: “ Before starting a 20/40 MHz BSS, an 40 MHz capable HT AP is required by the rules defined in to examine the channels of the current regulatory domain to determine whether the operation of a 20/40 MHz BSS might unfairly interfere with the operation of existing 20 MHz BSSs. The AP (or some of its associated HT STAs) is required to scan all of the channels of the current regulatory domain in order to ascertain the operating channels of any existing 20 MHz BSSs and 20/40 MHz BSSs. ”

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission Current Coexistence Language (2) Informative: –T.5.2: “An additional constraint on establishing a 20/40 MHz BSS includes the allowance for any device to explicitly prohibit the operation of the 20/40 BSS mode due to other considerations. For example, if an WPAN device is operating in the area, that device is likely to be unable to communicate successfully with a paired receiver if the number of available WPAN channels falls below a given threshold. Operation of a 20/40 MHz BSS in the 2.4 GHz band can contribute to the reduction of the number of available WPAN channels, possibly pushing the available channels below that threshold.” September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 5

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission Over the Air Measurements Confirm that operation of 40 MHz n Channels Interferes with typical use cases. Number of retransmissions for A2DP increase by a factor of 15. Number of error free packets reduced by a factor of 2. Results in numerous stereo audio drop outs. Adaptive Frequency Hopping (AFH) enabled, but typical detection algorithms can’t handle 100% larger channels and intermittent use of that channel. September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 6

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission Current Negative Comments Suggest Resolution: –Clause , line 22, replace "When using 40 MHz channels, it can operate in the channels defined in and " to "When using 40 MHz channels, it can operate in the channels defined in " Rationale: –Due to the large number of devices based on IEEE Std ™ (e.g., > TWO Billion Bluetooth wireless devices), the probability of sharing the spectrum with n devices will be high. September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 7

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission Alternative Proposal Add clause to /40 MHz BSS Operation: –FC HT AP 19 and FC HT STA 19 devices shall perform a “non radio scan” (TBD) prior to establishing/joining a 20/40 MHz BSS and at least once per dot11BSSWidthTriggerScanInterval seconds during operation of a 20/40 MHz BSS. A positive scan result shall cause the 20/40 Operation Permitted local variable to be set to FALSE in an FC HT AP 19 and the dot11FortyMHzIntolerant MIB attribute set to TRUE. A negative scan result shall have the opposite effect. –Note that the exact integration of scan event results may be best integrated into clause September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 8

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission “non radio scan” IEEE has investigated radio feature detection methods. IEEE (Bluetooth) wireless devices utilize a low cost scanning mechanism to detect presence of frequency hopping signals with pseudo-random hopping sequences. IEEE (Zigbee) wireless devices use energy detection and an active scan to detect beacons of devices. A combination of these methods can be used to define the “non radio scan” algorithm and detection limits. –Similar to DFS algorithm used for radar detection –Detection limits based on expected signal level of non radio within range of likely interference by 40 MHz n transmissions (e.g., 3m). –Confirmation of algorithm and detection limits from at least Bluetooth SIG and Zigbee Alliance. September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 9

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission Process TGn develops language for insertion of “non radio scan” into clause and other clauses as necessary. Bluetooth SIG and Zigbee Alliance provide details on detection of their radios and recommended detection limits. TGn integrates detection methods into single algorithm for inclusion in n draft. Sponsor Ballot... September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 10

doc.: IEEE /1101r0 Submission September 2008 John R. Barr, Motorola, Inc.Slide 11 References 000n-tgn-lb134-coex-comments.xlshttps://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/file/08/ n-tgn-lb134-coex-comments.xls 000n-coex-40-mhz-comments.dochttps://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/file/08/ n-coex-40-mhz-comments.doc 000n mhz-11n-interference-on-bluetooth.ppthttps://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/file/08/ n mhz-11n-interference-on-bluetooth.ppt