Legal Framework: International Philanthropy Betsy Buchalter Adler Silk, Adler & Colvin San Francisco, California Symposium: March 11, 2004 University of.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
© 2007 Dechert LLP Anti-Money Laundering Responsibilities of Transfer Agents Securities Transfer Association Annual Conference Naples, Florida October.
Advertisements

Managed Funds Association’s Sound Practices for Hedge Fund Managers 2009 Edition.
Presented by: Janet Wong KPMG LLP 6 November 2007 G L O B A L G R A N T S P R O G R A M T A X Annual High Tech Tax Institute International Corporate Grantmaking.
Anti-Money Laundering and OFAC Compliance for Transfer Agents SSA Annual Conference July 25, 2008.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 6 The Role of Government.
Environmental Management Systems An Overview With Practical Applications.
WELCOME Annual Meeting & Compliance Seminar. Code of Conduct - Impact on Corporate Culture by Andy Greenstein Knight Capital Group, Inc.
This tool can be found in the Banker Tools section of BankersOnline.com. 1 Bank Secrecy, Anti-Money Laundering & OFAC Director Education.
3rd session: Corporate Governance
Supplier Ethics: Program Checklist
Foreign Funding, Accountability and Transparency Dima Jweihan, Legal Consultant - Middle East / North Africa. The International Center for Not-for-Profit.
Discussion Forum Bridge Consulting 9 November 2012.
Governing a Tax-Exempt Nonprofit Corporation The Basics MPCC December 16, 2010.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com Anne Davis Head of Charity and Voluntary Sector Law and Ethics: key developments.
Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) Component Three US Department of Justice/OPDAT (Office of Overseas Prosecutorial Development, Assistance and Training)
The Institutionalization of Business Ethics
Christie Stelling, CPA, CIA Assoc. Director, Finance Financial Controls.
© Adler & Colvin Fiscal Sponsorship Doing it Right! October 8, 2013 Stephanie L. Petit Adler & Colvin
Chapter 3 Internal Controls.
Risk Management Reconstructed Implementing fraud risk intelligence practices July 2011 KPMG FORENSIC SM.
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING TRAINING FOR LENDERS Bill Heyman Offit Kurman
Passing the Hat 2.0: Charitable Giving Goes Low Maintenance Passing the Hat 2.0: Charitable Giving Goes Low Maintenance Presentation by Regina Q. Jahr,
CORPORATE COMPLIANCE Tim Timmons Vice President Compliance and Regulatory Services Health Future, LLC.
Corporate Responsibility and Compliance A Resource for Health Care Boards of Directors By Debbie Troklus, CHC and Michael C. Hemsley, Esq.
Professional Values and Basic Business Legislation.
Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) Institute of International Bankers Annual Seminar on Regulatory Examination, Risk Management and Compliance.
© Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton LLP 2007 FOREIGN CORRUPT PRACTICES ACT.
Preparing Russian Companies for UK Bribery Act Enforcement - The Defence of “Adequate Procedures” Nicholas Munday 14 December 2010 Moscow.
Roadmap For An Effective Compliance And Ethics Program The Top Ten Things the Board Must Know [Name of Presenter] [Title] [Date]
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING COMPLIANCE PROGRAM FCM TRAINING
1 Harvard University Cambridge, MA March 29, 2007 Medical Device Congress AdvaMed’s Efforts to Promote Compliance Christopher L. White, Esq. Executive.
Indiana Regional Sewer District Association October 26, 2015.
US Federal Income Tax Law and Donations to International Charities A Discussion of Issues in an Age of Terrorism Related Restrictions.
© 2011 Leaffer Law Donor-Advised Scholarship Funds: The Rhythm and Harmony of Donor Participation Karen Leaffer Becky Farr Seidel National Scholarship.
 Health Insurance and Accountability Act Cornelius Villalon Jr.
Presentation on Mechanisms for Reducing Corruption through Private Sector Monitoring and Enforcement by Essa Faal / Thomas F. McInerney General Counsel.
Jessie Krafft, Senior Director of Donor Advised and Grant Services
Roadmap For An Effective Compliance And Ethics Program
The CPA Profession Chapter 2.
Private Foundation Grant Agreements: Basics and Beyond
Bank Secrecy Act SCEFCU June 21, 2005.
Anti Money Laundering (AML)
MGMT 452 Corporate Social Responsibility
The Institutionalization of Business Ethics
Lobbying for Your Chamber: Legal and Tax Pitfalls
4 Social Responsibility of Business and Government
4 Social Responsibility of Business and Government
Program Sponsorship You and Your Non-Profit
USA PATRIOT ACT WHAT DOES IT STAND FOR?.
Whistleblower Program
Data protection issues in regulatory investigations
Построение культуры integrity в компании Aнар Каримов партнёр «ЭКВИТА»
Chapter 4 Probation: How Most Offenders Are Punished
East End Chamber of Commerce
Red Flags Rule An Introduction County College of Morris
FATF and MONEYVAL The soft law approach.
Environmental Management Systems The ISO Approach Initial Environmental Review & Gap Analysis Presented by: NC Division of Pollution Prevention.
General tripartite board composition and selection information
4 Social Responsibility of Business and Government
Chapter 8 Developing an Effective Ethics Program
Defining An Effectiveness Standard
ASHRAE Chapter Best Practices
The European Anti-Corruption Report
Protecting Your Voluntary Organisation from Abuse
Establishing Oversight Mechanisms
Compliance and Enforcement of the Privacy Rule
Protecting Your Voluntary Organisation from Abuse
The Regulatory Role of the Charity Commission
Governance Issues Learning Objectives
CF Canada Financial Group
Presentation transcript:

Legal Framework: International Philanthropy Betsy Buchalter Adler Silk, Adler & Colvin San Francisco, California Symposium: March 11, 2004 University of Southern California

Silk, Adler & Colvin Where’s The Map? Before 9/11, the law on international giving was familiar Before 9/11, the law on international giving was familiar –Private foundations: expenditure responsibility or equivalency determination –Public charities: discretion and control Now we have multiple lists to check without guidance on what to do with a match, scary guidelines without safe harbors, and no sense of whether obeying existing law is enough Now we have multiple lists to check without guidance on what to do with a match, scary guidelines without safe harbors, and no sense of whether obeying existing law is enough

Silk, Adler & Colvin Today’s Agenda What we know What we know –Laws governing charities specifically –Laws of general application, including federal sentencing guidelines –Treasury’s Voluntary Guidelines What we don’t know What we don’t know –Plenty! What might be coming our way What might be coming our way

Silk, Adler & Colvin What We Know: Charity Law US law divides charities into public charities and private foundations for tax purposes US law divides charities into public charities and private foundations for tax purposes Public charities generally have more flexibility in their international activity Public charities generally have more flexibility in their international activity Private foundations must exercise expenditure responsibility or make a public charity equivalence determination Private foundations must exercise expenditure responsibility or make a public charity equivalence determination

Silk, Adler & Colvin Public charities and international philanthropy Most recent IRS advice is 40 years old Most recent IRS advice is 40 years old Guidance focuses on whether US individuals can take a charitable deduction for gifts to a US charity for use abroad Guidance focuses on whether US individuals can take a charitable deduction for gifts to a US charity for use abroad IRS emphasizes need for US charity to have discretion & control over assets IRS emphasizes need for US charity to have discretion & control over assets

Silk, Adler & Colvin Expenditure Responsibility (PFs) Pre-grant inquiry, documented in writing Pre-grant inquiry, documented in writing Written grant agreement signed by funder and grantee, with specific required limits on how grantee may use funds Written grant agreement signed by funder and grantee, with specific required limits on how grantee may use funds Separate tracking of grant funds Separate tracking of grant funds Written reports from grantee to funder, at least annually Written reports from grantee to funder, at least annually Funder reports ER grants on Form 990-PF Funder reports ER grants on Form 990-PF

Silk, Adler & Colvin Public Charity Equivalence (PFs) If foreign entity is equivalent of US public charity, private foundation funder does not have to exercise expenditure responsibility If foreign entity is equivalent of US public charity, private foundation funder does not have to exercise expenditure responsibility 2 common paths to public charity status: 2 common paths to public charity status: –Nature of grantee - “church,” school, hospital –Finances of grantee – data shows grantee receives financial support from a sufficiently broad donor/consumer base, plus governing documents satisfy technical US standards

Silk, Adler & Colvin What We Know: General Law Executive Order Executive Order USA Patriot Act USA Patriot Act Treasury Office of Foreign Asset Control (OFAC) Treasury Office of Foreign Asset Control (OFAC) US Sentencing Commission’s guidelines for organizations convicted of violating federal law US Sentencing Commission’s guidelines for organizations convicted of violating federal law

Silk, Adler & Colvin Executive Order Applies generally, not only to charities Applies generally, not only to charities Prohibits transactions involving Listed Persons or their property Prohibits transactions involving Listed Persons or their property Prohibits transactions with unnamed persons who assist, sponsor, or provide financial support to Listed Persons or are otherwise associated with Listed Persons Prohibits transactions with unnamed persons who assist, sponsor, or provide financial support to Listed Persons or are otherwise associated with Listed Persons Prohibition includes humanitarian aid Prohibition includes humanitarian aid

Silk, Adler & Colvin USA Patriot Act Applies generally, not only to charities Applies generally, not only to charities Imposes criminal penalties for providing material resources or financial support for terrorism, foreign terrorist organizations, or Listed Persons Imposes criminal penalties for providing material resources or financial support for terrorism, foreign terrorist organizations, or Listed Persons Government must prove defendant knew or intended that the support would be used in terrorist acts or used by foreign terrorist organizations Government must prove defendant knew or intended that the support would be used in terrorist acts or used by foreign terrorist organizations Civil liability – those injured by a terrorist act may sue those who funded the group behind the act Civil liability – those injured by a terrorist act may sue those who funded the group behind the act

Silk, Adler & Colvin The Lists “They’re making the lists, we’re checking them twice” – the only way to be sure you are not dealing with listed persons “They’re making the lists, we’re checking them twice” – the only way to be sure you are not dealing with listed persons Lists are not yet consolidated; searching is harder than it needs to be Lists are not yet consolidated; searching is harder than it needs to be Links to all lists are at Links to all lists are at

Silk, Adler & Colvin Treasury’s Voluntary Guidelines Treasury released “Voluntary Best Practice Guidelines” in November 2002 Treasury released “Voluntary Best Practice Guidelines” in November 2002 Treasury General Counsel: guidelines have no legal force and offer no safe harbor; issued to reassure Muslim groups; no longer promoted Treasury General Counsel: guidelines have no legal force and offer no safe harbor; issued to reassure Muslim groups; no longer promoted Chilling effect on charities appears not to trouble Treasury – more focused on deterring financing of terror and violence Chilling effect on charities appears not to trouble Treasury – more focused on deterring financing of terror and violence

Silk, Adler & Colvin Voluntary Guidelines: Details Parts 1-3: governance and accountability, mostly ignored; law already covers it Parts 1-3: governance and accountability, mostly ignored; law already covers it Part 4: preventing use of charities for terrorist finance Part 4: preventing use of charities for terrorist finance Consensus among charities: unworkable, costly, charities aren’t banks or law enforcement agents; local staff would become targets; ineffective in any case Consensus among charities: unworkable, costly, charities aren’t banks or law enforcement agents; local staff would become targets; ineffective in any case

Silk, Adler & Colvin Federal Sentencing Guidelines Details at Details at Currently being updated in response to Sarbanes- Oxley Act Currently being updated in response to Sarbanes- Oxley Act An organization “shall (1) exercise due diligence to prevent and detect violations of law, and (2) otherwise promote an organizational culture that encourages a commitment to compliance with the law.” An organization “shall (1) exercise due diligence to prevent and detect violations of law, and (2) otherwise promote an organizational culture that encourages a commitment to compliance with the law.”

Silk, Adler & Colvin Sentencing Guidelines: Elements of Due Diligence Conduct ongoing risk assessment Conduct ongoing risk assessment Establish compliance standards and procedures Establish compliance standards and procedures Governing body must exercise reasonable oversight of program via reports from compliance officer Governing body must exercise reasonable oversight of program via reports from compliance officer Implement training programs so staff, board, etc. know the rules Implement training programs so staff, board, etc. know the rules

Silk, Adler & Colvin Sentencing Guidelines: More Due Diligence Monitor compliance of staff, board, etc.; evaluate effectiveness of compliance program; make whistle-blowing safe Monitor compliance of staff, board, etc.; evaluate effectiveness of compliance program; make whistle-blowing safe Reward compliance, punish non-compliance Reward compliance, punish non-compliance If violations occur, modify program to prevent recurrences If violations occur, modify program to prevent recurrences

Silk, Adler & Colvin Sentencing Guidelines Don’t Tell Us… How does an unstaffed charity (e.g. a family foundation) design a compliance program? How does an unstaffed charity (e.g. a family foundation) design a compliance program? Does “violations of law” refer only to US law? What if a charity is active overseas? Does “violations of law” refer only to US law? What if a charity is active overseas? What if a rogue employee or grantee of an otherwise legally-compliant charity becomes a “listed person” – do the Sentencing Guidelines affect the charity’s culpability under the strict liability provisions of the Patriot Act? What if a rogue employee or grantee of an otherwise legally-compliant charity becomes a “listed person” – do the Sentencing Guidelines affect the charity’s culpability under the strict liability provisions of the Patriot Act?

Silk, Adler & Colvin What Else We Don’t Know How much due diligence and oversight is enough to protect a donor from civil or criminal liability for a charity’s acts? How much due diligence and oversight is enough to protect a donor from civil or criminal liability for a charity’s acts? How much due diligence and oversight is enough to protect a grantmaker or an operating charity from civil or criminal liability? How much due diligence and oversight is enough to protect a grantmaker or an operating charity from civil or criminal liability? How will the government use its prosecutorial discretion where a charity has acted in good faith? How will the government use its prosecutorial discretion where a charity has acted in good faith?

Silk, Adler & Colvin More Unknowns Charities are used to answering to the IRS and state charity regulators; what other government agencies will we hear from, what will they want to know, and what must we tell them? Charities are used to answering to the IRS and state charity regulators; what other government agencies will we hear from, what will they want to know, and what must we tell them? Will the governmental attention to terrorist financing and money laundering affect the traditional practice of informal cash gifts to, and through, religious institutions? Will the governmental attention to terrorist financing and money laundering affect the traditional practice of informal cash gifts to, and through, religious institutions?

Silk, Adler & Colvin IRS Information Request IRS asked how charities protect their assets from diversion to non-charitable ends overseas IRS asked how charities protect their assets from diversion to non-charitable ends overseas Consensus of responders: charities exercise great care in their international operations, Treasury Voluntary Guidelines should be withdrawn, and list-checking is severely burdensome Consensus of responders: charities exercise great care in their international operations, Treasury Voluntary Guidelines should be withdrawn, and list-checking is severely burdensome No consensus on whether we need more guidance or whether IRS should just enforce current law more vigorously No consensus on whether we need more guidance or whether IRS should just enforce current law more vigorously

Silk, Adler & Colvin Enforcement: Not Just IRS IRS Small Business/Self Employed group asked a charity about payments to its overseas aid workers, alleging the charity is a “financial institution” under the Bank Secrecy Act IRS Small Business/Self Employed group asked a charity about payments to its overseas aid workers, alleging the charity is a “financial institution” under the Bank Secrecy Act The FBI questioned various donors and funders of charities whose assets were frozen The FBI questioned various donors and funders of charities whose assets were frozen Media coverage of charities as terrorist finance tools may influence local government agencies Media coverage of charities as terrorist finance tools may influence local government agencies

Silk, Adler & Colvin What Should Charities Do? 1. Assess the risk: how likely is it, in the circumstances, that your money will be diverted to non-charitable ends? 2. Manage/prevent the risk: based on your assessment, do what’s reasonably necessary in the circumstances to reduce chance of asset diversion

Silk, Adler & Colvin Managing the Risk Adopt and implement a compliance program as described in the Sentencing Guidelines Adopt and implement a compliance program as described in the Sentencing Guidelines Know your grantees/vendors; check the lists Know your grantees/vendors; check the lists Have a clearly written grant agreement Have a clearly written grant agreement Obtain and review reports from your grantees on how they used the funds Obtain and review reports from your grantees on how they used the funds Follow up if you see potential problems Follow up if you see potential problems

Silk, Adler & Colvin Working with Intermediaries: Another Way to Manage Risk U.S. charities and donors can work with charitable intermediaries that have staff or volunteers in the region and are better placed to assess and manage any risk of diversion U.S. charities and donors can work with charitable intermediaries that have staff or volunteers in the region and are better placed to assess and manage any risk of diversion Some operate programs directly in particular areas of interest or need Some operate programs directly in particular areas of interest or need Others have active re-granting or donor-advised programs based on local due diligence and oversight Others have active re-granting or donor-advised programs based on local due diligence and oversight

Silk, Adler & Colvin Don’t Give Up! U.S. charities have an essential role in cross- border giving, especially in communities with strong ties to countries of origin – and especially in times of international turmoil U.S. charities have an essential role in cross- border giving, especially in communities with strong ties to countries of origin – and especially in times of international turmoil Governmental “donor deterrence” efforts were not meant to deter the responsible philanthropist Governmental “donor deterrence” efforts were not meant to deter the responsible philanthropist