Supreme Court of Canada Decisions’ “Half-Life” Daniel Poulin (CRDP/Lexum inc.) & Philippe Grand’Maison (CRDP) Faculté de droit, U. de Montréal.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1. Review- What is Science Explain- What kinds of understandings does science contribute about the natural world Form an Opinion- Do you think that scientists.
Advertisements

Q UINCY COLLEGE Paralegal Studies Program Paralegal Studies Program Legal Research & Writing LAW-215 Use of Digests, Annotated Law Reports, and Words and.
Working with Judicial Decisions Part Two by Annette Demers BA LLB MLIS Judicial Decisions.
Collaboration and open access to Law How can Web 2.0 technologies help us understand the law? Olivier Charbonneau Associate Librarian
The Supreme Court at Work. Basic Facts About the Supreme Court 9 Justices on the Court Each “term” begins first Monday in October and lasts until they.
1 Chapter 6 Copyright ©2006 Thomson South-Western, Mason, Ohio William A. Raabe, Gerald E. Whittenburg, & Debra L. Sanders Tax Services and Periodicals.
YOLANDA KOSCIELSKI, LIBRARIAN FOR CRIMINOLOGY AND PSYCHOLOGY LBST 330: LEGAL RESEARCH.
Vital Statistics Council for Canada The NAPHSIS/NCHS Collaboration Past Successes and Future Challenges Salt Lake City, UT June 3 rd – 7 th, Same-Sex.
YOLANDA KOSCIELSKI, LIBRARIAN FOR CRIMINOLOGY AND PSYCHOLOGY LBST 313: LEGAL RESEARCH.
READING & USING CASE CITATIONS. REVIEW OF PRECEDENT PRECEDENT=Something that has been done that can later serve as an example or rule for how other things.
Provincial Court (Province A) Provincial Court (Province B) Federal Court (Trial Court) Tax Court Supreme Court (Trial Court) Court of Queen’s Bench.
BUS 393 Introduction to Commercial Law Resources at Simon Fraser University Library Yolanda Koscielski, Liaison Librarian for Criminology, Computing Science.
Legal Informatics December 13, 2011 Gulfport, Florida Wilhelmina Randtke
LEGAL ASPECTS OF CONTENT MINING copyright publisher licences country-specific legislation.
October 13, 2009: Mount Royal University Tips & Trips of Research Funding.
Lecture Four: Steps 3 and 4 INST 250/4.  Does one look for facts, or opinions, or both when conducting a literature search?  What is the difference.
Judicial Branch Citizenship: American Government.
POPULATION AND HOUSING CENSUSES IN SLOVAKIA ON THE WEBSITE Miroslav Hudec Pavol Büchler INFOSTAT – Bratislava MSIS Geneva
Chapter 10 Handwriting Analysis, Forgery, and Counterfeiting By the end of this chapter you will be able to: describe 12 types of handwriting characteristics.
Journal Impact Factors: What Are They & How Can They Be Used? Pamela Sherwill, MLS, AHIP April 27, 2004.
Chapter 5 Tax Research McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2014 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The role of the judiciary is to act as an independent third party to resolve disputes Governed under principle of Rule of Law: Government must follow.
Who should judge? Judges and Juries in the Canadian justice system.
Caselex An example of how companies can benefit from the PSI Directive, also in Poland! EPSIplus Polish national meeting Marc de Vries Warsaw, 4 December.
The Living Constitution Article 3 – The Judicial Branch.
Forensic Science: Fundamentals & Investigations, Chapter 10 1 Introduction Document analysts examine and compare questioned documents with known material.
Citation... The citation is a valuable and concise source of information which includes: the name of the parties involved in the action; the date the.
Working with Judicial Decisions Part Two by Annette Demers BA LLB MLIS Judicial Decisions.
Case Law: Criminal and Civil Citations Photo: Supreme Court of Canada Library/Archives.
Yolanda Koscielski, Liaison Librarian for Criminology, Philosophy, Psychology and Legal Research Mark Christensen, Reference Librarian.
Prof. Emily Ryan PA 101.  Primary sources are actual statements of the law.  Enormous amounts of primary source materials available are issued chronologically.
Practical Analysis of Obstacles Encountered by Legal Services as Part of Access to Information Requests Presentation to the Canadian Institute at the Conference.
1 Copyright © 2014, 2012, 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 9 Understanding Randomness.
Uncertainty in Measurement How would you measure 9 ml most precisely? What is the volume being measured here? What is the uncertainty measurement? For.
Nature’s Clock.  When sedimentary rock is deposited in layers it is deposited horizontally.  Scientists use this “Principle of Original Horizontality”
CRIMINAL JUSTICE TODAY, 9E PRENTICE HALL By Frank Schmalleger ©2007 Pearson Education, Inc. 1 The Courts: Structure and Participants CHAPTER 9.
What is Citizenship??. What does citizenship mean?
Judicial Archives and Deliberative Secrecy
“Every decision is binding no matter whether it is reported in the regular series of Law Reports, or is unreported. Once you have the transcript, you can.
Universadade de São Paulo Faculdade De Direito São Paulo Faculty Workshop The Socratic Method and Beyond: ‎Reflections on Teaching about the Law 28 March.
Statistics for Managers Using Microsoft® Excel 5th Edition
Old Media v. Social Media: Some Observations
State Court System: Structure & Overview
Sonia Loubier and Frédéric Pelletier LVI 2015
9.2 Legal Reasoning The English ancestry of the American and Canadian legal systems means that many legal arguments are analogical in nature because.
BHS Database Guide How to Find Great Information Quickly
Presented by Elisabeth McKechnie Mabie Law Library
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW.
Chartbook | September 2017 Physicians in Canada, 2016.
Constructing and Deconstructing ‘Constitutional’ European Law
Looking at Data - Relationships Data analysis for two-way tables
5.1 What Makes a Memoir?.
Hypothesis Testing with
Judicial Branch Vocabulary
Chapter 10 Handwriting Analysis, Forgery, and Counterfeiting By the end of this chapter you will be able to: describe 12 types of handwriting characteristics.
READING & USING CASE CITATIONS
Jane Zhang, Catholic University of America
Advanced Legal Analysis and Writing Class 13
What is the Supreme Court’s main job?
The Supreme Court At Work
The Supreme Court at Work
1.3 Reporting with Precision and Accuracy
Chapter 10 Handwriting Analysis, Forgery, and Counterfeiting By the end of this chapter you will be able to: describe 12 types of handwriting characteristics.
CS/INFO 430 Information Retrieval
Use Patterns of Print and Electronic Journals
The Influence of Customs and Conventions
The Constitution.
Judicial Branch Vocabulary
CANADIAN CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
Florida Legal Citation Guide
Presentation transcript:

Supreme Court of Canada Decisions’ “Half-Life” Daniel Poulin (CRDP/Lexum inc.) & Philippe Grand’Maison (CRDP) Faculté de droit, U. de Montréal

Summary Approach: counting citations in case law Objectives: part science, part business Discussion of results Challenges

THE APPROACH

Case life-cycle Awakening: from publication on to the apex Apex: the year when a case is the most cited Death: year of the last known citation Length of life: from the time a decision is rendered until it is cited for the last time Half-life: form the apex to when the number of citations is half the value at apex

Hypothetical life of case ApexHalf life Number of citation per year Time

Long awakening; and local apexes Ithaca Daniel/long réveil

Cases with a “life” Percentage of decisions from 2002 having been cited Ithaca Daniel/Pourcentage cité

Methodology Data was arranged in decision’s vectors, decision-cite-decision, and metadata; For each decision, the following data is retrieved or calculated – Year first time cited – Year of apex – Apex value, the maximum # citations in a year; – Year of half-life (for decisions with over 50 cit.) – Year of last time cited

Challenges The data obtained from Lexum was estimated “messy” by one of the authors – The Reflex database was never thought as a tool for compilation, everything is geared towards adding link as cases get in The heavy calculation for building the life- cycle table fried the computer motherboard of one of the authors

Challenges The first tack was to limit the study to the Supreme Court of Canada – A couple months delay in a scanning project results in having to work with a more limited set of data: from 1949 on … instead of from 1907 With the more general citation data from the whole CanLII Compilation, the scope is even shorter

Did the law changed? In Katsh, M.E., “The new electronic media and the transformation of the law” (1989) Katsh hypothesized that – […] there will be more and more decisions cited on both sides of an issue… […] – [O]pinions are being added to the computerized database more and more quickly. This increase the pressure to use recent cases […] (p. 46)

What citations say about law? Could citations tell us something about the Canadian legal system? Are the changes in the constitutional framework in the case law citation?

How much case law history do lawyers need? CanLII was planned as a professional tool Historical scopes on CanLII today – Supreme Court: 105 years – Courts of appeal: 22 years – Superior courts: 16 years Is it enough? What more is needed from the past? What must be added?

The data Lexum’s SCC collection – 5600 decisions Lexum’s “CanLII compilation” – ~ 1,1 M decisions – 110,000 decisions from courts of appeal – 245,000 decisions from superior courts Reflex database – Millions of records Main limit – 83% of the decisions are from after 2000

CanLII Compilation Ithaca Daniel/Nombre de décisions par an

SOME OF THE RESULTS

Number of citations per decision Philippe /Ok. #cit par jugt parannée

Number of citations per decision Philippe /Ok. #cit par jugt parannée

AS HYPOTHESIZED, THE NUMBER OF CITATIONS AUGMENTED SIGNIFICANTLY WITH THE ADVENT OF NEW DIGITAL MEDIA

Awakening – Time to be known Philippe /Eveil dans le temps

Awakening – Time to be known Philippe /Eveil dans le temps

AWAKENING HAVE SHORTENED THE ACCELERATION STARTED EVEN BEFORE THE ADVENT OF NEW IT

Evolution of the age of citations Philippe / Âge des ref par année

Major legal events shorten lives

WHAT IS CITED – OLD V. RECENT CASES – SEEMS MUCH MORE SENSITIVE TO THE LEGAL CONTEXT THAN TO THE TECHNOLOGICAL CONTEXT

The shortening of half-life Philippe / Ok. demie dans le temps

The shortening of half-life ?! Philippe / Ok. demie dans le temps

FOR LACK OF HISTORICAL SCOPE, THE DATA SET CANNOT LEAD TO ANY CONCLUSION ABOUT THE HALF LIFE OF JUDGMENTS

QCCA citing ROC-CA Philippe / QC CA

ROC-CA citing QCCA Philippe / QC CA

ROC-CA & QCCA Philippe / QC CA

QUEBEC CA IGNORES CANADIAN CA, BUT LESS THAN CANADIAN CA IGNORE QCCA IT MUST BE NOTED THAT QUEBEC PRIVATE LAW IS DISTINCT FROM THE COMMON LAW TRADITION IN THE OTHER CANADIAN JURISDICTIONS

Citations to historic decisions ( ) Ithaca Daniel/07-11 # vers décennie

Citations to historic decisions ( ) Ithaca Daniel/07-11 # vers décennie

Citations to historic decisions ( ) Ithaca Daniel/07-11 # vers décennie

CITATIONS TO OLDER DECISIONS ARE FEW HOWEVER, THE TAIL COULD BE LONG

Summing up As hypothesized with the advent of new IT – The number of citations has augmented – Awakening have shortened Contrary to what was hypothesized – The age of the citations relate much more to the legal context than the technological one Quebec CA ignores Canadian CAs, but less than Canadian CAs ignore QCCA

Summing up This data set cannot lead to any solid conclusions about the half life of judgments However, – 0,5 M recent decisions cite only hundreds of cases from the 50s and the 60s – Almost as many from the 50s than the 60s