Updating Reserving and Premium RBC Charges Tony Phillips, FCAS, MAAA Vice President Accident Fund Insurance Company of America AAA Updated Research on.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Actuarial Management Resources, Inc SEAC Spring Meeting Miami Beach, Florida Individual Health Topics Exploring Methods for Premium Deficiency.
Advertisements

Insurance Premium Risk, Competition and the Insurance Cycle George Maher.
Standardized Performance (%) Goldman Sachs Financial Square Money Market Fund Administration Shares—Data as of Portfolio Composition (%) Fund FactsCurrent.
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 7 Financial Operations of Insurers.
Macroprudential Surveillance in Practice ASSAL – July 2011 Susan Voss Iowa Insurance Commissioner NAIC President Todd Sells Director—Financial Regulatory.
A Comparison of Property-Liability Insurance Financial Pricing Models Stephen P. D’Arcy, FCAS, MAAA, Ph.D. Richard W. Gorvett, FCAS, MAAA, Ph.D. Department.
A Carvill service Operational Risk Management in a Property/Casualty Insurance Company Mark Verheyen, FCAS, MAAA CAS Spring Meeting May 2005.
Health Annual statements: A way to assess insurers’ financial health May 20, 2015 Cheryl Fish-Parcham.
Permission to reprint or distribute any content from this presentation requires the prior written approval of Standard & Poor’s. Copyright (c) 2006 Standard.
New Products – The Intersection of Pricing, Reserving, Planning Betsy DePaolo Vice President & Actuary, Personal Insurance Travelers Insurance Casualty.
FINANCIAL CONDITION REPORTING Ioana Abrahams 13 November 2009.
1 Actuarial Evaluation of Premium Liabilities By:Claudette Cantin, FCIA, FCAS, MAAA Partner – KPMG LLP CLRS - Minneapolis September 19th, 2000.
Solvency Update2008 CAS Spring Meeting – Quebec City 1 U.S. Insurance Solvency Today & Future Kris DeFrain, FCAS, MAAA, CPCU Senior Financial Regulatory.
AEG recommendations on Non-life insurance services (Issue 5) Workshop on National Accounts December 2006, Cairo 1 Gulab Singh UN STATISTICS DIVISION.
Estimating the Predictive Distribution for Loss Reserve Models Glenn Meyers Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar September 12, 2006.
© 2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners NAIC Risk-Based Capital (RBC) HISTORY.
Kpmg Research on the Effectiveness of a Trend Test in the Property/Casualty RBC Formula Chris Nyce KPMG Senior Manager.
Spring 2002 CAS Meeting Modeling Capital Adequacy Matthew C. Mosher, FCAS Group Vice President Property/Casualty Ratings May 21, 2002.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2004 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 7 Insolvencies, Solvency Ratings, and Solvency Regulation.
Risk-Based Capital: So Many Models CAS Annual Meeting 2007 Matthew Carrier, Principal Deloitte Consulting LLP November 12, 2007.
Financial Risk Management of Insurance Enterprises Use of Financial Derivatives by US Insurers.
1 RISK AND RETURN: ACTUARIAL CONSIDERATIONS (FIN - 10) FINANCIAL MODELS and RATE OF RETURN PERSPECTIVES Russ Bingham Vice President and Director of Corporate.
Opinion Writers Symposium Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar September 10-11, 2007 Moderator: Mary D Miller, Ohio Dept of Insurance Panelists: Nicole Elliott,
Loss Reserving Approaches for Mortgage Guaranty Insurance 2003 CAS Annual Meeting New Orleans Marriott John F. Gibson, FCAS, MAAA Principal PricewaterhouseCoopers,
Spring 2004 CAGNY Meeting How do Rating Agencies Determine Insurance Company Ratings John Andre Vice President Property/Casualty Ratings June 3, 2004.
1 Casualty Actuarial Society Loss Reserve Seminar Thomas G. Moylan, FCAS, MAAA September 8th, 2003 Closing the Books.
Premium Deficiency Reserves - GAAP CLRS - September 24th Premium Deficiency Reserves under U.S. GAAP John G. Aquino FCAS MAAA Executive Vice President.
Chapter 7 Financial Operations of Insurers. Copyright ©2014 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.7-2 Agenda Property and Casualty Insurers Life.
CAS Annual Meeting EMERGING ISSUES IN MEDICAL MALPRACTICE THE ROLE OF THE ACTUARY IN ALTERNATIVE INSURANCE MARKETS November 16, 2004 Richard B. Lord, FCAS.
2002 CLRS - Arlington, VA Reserve/Opinion Issues from a Regulatory Perspective Proposed Revision to the NAIC Annual Statement Instructions Richard Marcks,
 2002 NCCI Holdings, Inc. Workers Compensation: Emerging Issues WC Industry Reserve Adequacy Karen Ayres, FCAS, MAAA Casualty Loss.
IRS/Actuary Actuary’s Perspective by Alan E. Kaliski, FCAS, MAAA.
©Towers Perrin Loss Reserve Adequacy and the Underwriting Cycle Casualty Actuarial Society General Meeting Montreal, Canada November 16, 2004 Michael E.
Paul Budde, Ph. D., ACAS, MAAA Senior Vice President Using Catastrophe Models for Pricing: The Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund CAS Special Interest.
Homeowners Insurance Profitability- Is the P&C industry taking the right actions and have we learned anything? Randall E. Brubaker, FCAS Aon Re Services,
1 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar Claudette Cantin, FCIA, FCAS, MAAA Munich Reinsurance Company of Canada September 14, 2004 Las Vegas Session 7 Loss Reserve.
CIA Annual Meeting LOOKING BACK…focused on the future.
0 Allocating the Cost of Capital Practical Examples Daniel Isaac CAS Spring Meeting May 19-22, 2002.
Basic Track II 2004 CLRS September 2004 Las Vegas, Nevada.
1 PROFIT AND CONTINGENCIES IN RATEMAKING (FIN - 12) Russ Bingham Vice President and Director of Corporate Research Hartford Financial Services Seminar.
19 May 2004 The NAIC Risk-Based-Capital Formula Revisited Robert F. Wolf, FCAS, MAAA Principal, Mercer Oliver Wyman G. Chris Nyce, FCAS, MAAA Manager,
CONTROLLING COSTS Choosing the Right Insurance Program Kevin D. Smith, CPCU, ARM Vice President Workers’ Compensation.
Capital Modeling for Benefit Pools: A Case Study How Much is Enough (for us)?
Insurance Companies. Chapter Outline Two Categories of Insurance Companies: Chapter Overview Life Insurance Companies Property-Casualty Insurance Companies.
1 RISK AND RETURN: DEBATING ALTERNATIVE MODELING “APPROACHES” (FIN - 10) Russ Bingham Vice President and Director of Corporate Research Hartford Financial.
PBR for life products IABA Annual Meeting James Collingwood, ASA, MAAA August 1, 2014.
Financial Risk Management of Insurance Enterprises Use of Financial Derivatives by US Insurers.
2005 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar Loss Reserve Analysis and Statements of Actuarial Opinion Robert E. Farnam Senior Financial Analyst and Actuary A.M.
Things That Make You More Likely to Be in an Accident Nevada Traffic Summit Las Vegas – May 25, 2016 James Lynch, FCAS MAAA, Chief Actuary Insurance Information.
1 ASB Constituent Roundtable Financial Instruments: Amortised Cost and Impairment 6 May 2010.
2-1 Financial Institutions other than Depository Financial Institutions.
FNCE 4000 Financial Institutions Management Chapter 2 Part 2 Institutions Other Than Depository Institutions.
Insurance Accounting Overview
Negative underwriting loss turning into positive profit — Explore the role of investment income for U.S. Property and Casualty insurers Shuang Yang Department.
Ratemaking Actuarial functions Ratemaking Loss reserving
1999 CLRS September 1999 Scottsdale, Arizona
Casualty Actuarial Society Practical discounting and risk adjustment issues relating to property/casualty claim liabilities Research conducted.
Mary D. Miller FCAS, MAAA Ohio Department of Insurance March 23, 2004
Mary Gaillard AIG March 11, 2004
Macroprudential Surveillance in Practice
Cost of Capital Issues April 16, 2002 John J. Kollar.
ASU Short Duration Contracts – New GAAP Disclosures
Session 3 – Risk Management and Internal Controls: Actuary Function ICP 8: Risk Management and Internal Controls 2017 ASSAL Regional Seminar on Training.
BUS 401 Possible Is Everything/snaptutorial.com
FIN 420 TUTORIALS Education for Service--fin420tutorials.com.
Rethinking Portfolio Management Based on New Regulation
Non-Life Loss Reserving Practices and Documentation
PBR – It’s not just Life Insurance
Longevity Risk Task Force Update (LRTF) Longevity risk task force April 2019 DRAFT.
Presentation transcript:

Updating Reserving and Premium RBC Charges Tony Phillips, FCAS, MAAA Vice President Accident Fund Insurance Company of America AAA Updated Research on the NAIC Risk Based Capital (RBC) Formula

Disclaimer These results are based on research conducted by a subgroup of the American Academy P/C RBC Committee Views expressed today are based on the research, but do not necessarily reflect the views of the Academy, CAS, Accident Fund, or the NAIC who of course makes all decisions about changes to the RBC formula Examples used are illustrative, and not a reference to any specific company

Mission of the AAA RBC Committee Reserving and Premium RBC factors have not changed in over 10+ years Without “reinventing the wheel” reproduce these factors with updated industry information –Limited documentation –Had to put the pieces of the puzzle together Present results to NAIC –Explain shortcomings in the methodology –Explain the impact of the “underwriting” cycle on the data

History From available records, it appears that the RBC charges were last updated in 1993 with the short tail lines updated in 1999 Methodology used to update the charges derived mainly from –Feldblum’s paper on RBC (NAIC Property/Casualty Insurance Company Risk-Based Capital Requirements) –NY Insurance Department –NAIC –Still, no one complete documentation exists that takes one from start to finish (data to actual factor selections)

Status of project Collected data from the NAIC (1992 Annual Statement Data) –For the reserving charges 10 AY’s and prior years –For the premium charges only 10 AY’s Massaged the data –Some companies reported paid losses but no incurred losses, or had missing data Using the methodology in Feldblum’s paper calculated the premium and reserving RBC charges (as well as the Investment Income Offset) –Applied various filtering criteria –Simple average used Results were then put through a “Reallocation” method that was used last time –Not in Feldblum’s paper

Current Factors (At this point no judgement used)

Next Steps Review the factors and if warranted recommend changes –Do these factors make sense? –Are the last 10 years indicative of future events? –Do these factors truly measure the volatility in a line? –More in-depth review of the data to see if any anomalies are driving some factors –Understand the “NAIC” political environment Working with an NAIC subgroup to understand their concerns

Closing Remarks The current methodology is simple to understand, but (in our opinion)…. –Does it really address risk? Simple average vs. 75% confidence level –Enhanced “Risk Theory” exists today then in the early 1990’s Could it help in making the final selections? –This AAA RBC Subgroup believes there are better approaches that should be explored Overhaul? Adjustments to key assumptions –Judgement still has an impact on the final results