More Missing: Expanding Content Analysis in Social Work Journals to Include Non-Binary Orientations and Gender Identities Sana Marie K. Wilson Kathleen.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Vision: Dedicated to HealthMission: We Care For You.
Advertisements

LGBTQ Youth in Schools ACSSW Conference January 27, 2015 Elaine M. Maccio, Ph.D., LCSW Louisiana State University School of Social Work.
Research Plan and Curriculum Vitae – What to Take into Account? Prof. Kaisa Miettinen
Dating Violence among Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Adolescents: Results from a Community Survey Naomi Freedner, MPH Lorraine H. Freed, MD MPH S. Bryn Austin,
Chapter 18: Group Work: Gay, Lesbian, and Bisexual Clients Introduction to Group Work, 5th Edition Edited by David Capuzzi, Douglas R. Gross, and Mark.
CHAPTER 23 COUNSELING SEXUAL MINORITIES. Homosexuality  Homosexuality involves the affectional and/or sexual orientation to a person of the same sex.
Using Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Youth Data from the Oregon Healthy Teens Survey to Address Health Inequities Molly Franks, MPH Oregon Public Health Division.
Research Report Chapter 15. Research Report – APA Format Title Page Running head – BRIEF TITLE, positioned in upper left corner of no more than 50 characters.
Unifying science, education and service to transform lives Module 14 Policies and Procedures A Provider’s Introduction to Substance Abuse for Lesbian,
A NNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY W HAT IS A BIBLIOGRAPHY ? A bibliography is a list of sources (books, journals, websites, periodicals, etc.) one has used for.
CHAPTER 15, READING AND WRITING SOCIAL RESEARCH. Chapter Outline  Reading Social Research  Using the Internet Wisely  Writing Social Research  The.
Oregon Healthy Teen Survey Data from Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Youth Molly Franks, MPH Oregon Public Health Division April.
Health Disparities in the LGBTQ Community: Providing Culturally Competent Care Julia M. Applegate, MA Planning and Evaluation Program Manager LGBTQ Health.
Guidelines for Reviewing AHC Forum Posters Department of Research “Research is a vital component of training tomorrow’s healthcare providers and delivering.
Working with Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender & Questioning Youth OSBHC Conference 2009.
Do Now "Now that you have completed two different personality surveys and have seen the results, how accurate do you think they are? Do you think that.
Enhancing Resiliency and Safety for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Questioning (LGBTQ) Youth :
Sexual Identity/Sexual Minority Youth Emily Martin & Allee Olive November 20 th, 2014.
An Evaluation of Pipeline Interventions for Minority Scholars An Evaluation of Pipeline Interventions for Minority Scholars Roberta Spalter-Roth, Jean.
Focusing on Quality in Queer Children’s Literature MOVING BEYOND CONTENT Craig A. Young, PhD Bloomsburg University of PA NCTE Annual Convention Boston,
Results: Objective 2 Nicholas C. Heck 1, Lucas A. Mirabito 1, Kelly LeMaire 1, Nicholas A. Livingston 2, and Annesa Flentje 3 Abstract Objective: The present.
Presenters: Zerr Her Abby Novak Ally Training. Introductions Name Year in school/Age Major/Occupation P.G.P. o Preferred Gender Pronoun  He/she/they/zie.
English for EAP Practice activities Reading more efficiently Lesson 4 Different text types English for Academic Purposes Practice activities Reading more.
Safe Space Training Irvine Valley College. What are you communicating or supporting when displaying Safe Space signage or rainbow flag?  Welcomes people.
HHS 307 Week 5 Final Paper Check this A+ tutorial guideline at Focus of the Final.
Challenges when Working with LGBT Survivors of IPV
SOGI-inclusive Education Implementation
Patterns of Sexual Identity Development Over Time Among Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Youths: Implications for Mental Health Margaret Rosario, Ph.D. Eric.
Creating Supportive Environments for LGBTQ Students
Works in progress The needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans* people (LGBT) who are affected by dementia: A comprehensive scoping review. Joanna Semlyen,
Standardized Patient Modules in Medical School with the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Patient in Mind. Jacob Anderson, OMS-II; Ashley Jackson,
Application of the Health Belief Model
migrants. You’re already working with LGBTI
refugees. You’re already working with LGBTI
A program of family & Children services
A Phenomenological Exploration of Transgender People’s Experiences Within the LGBT Community Kristen Martinez.
LGBT Tobacco Surveillance: the challenge and successes
Recommendations for Schools
SAGA Sexuality and Gender Alliance
Introduction to Trans and Gender Diverse Identities
Graduate College of Social Work
Performance Measurement and Rural Primary Care: A scoping review
PROJECT COMPREHENSIVE DEMOGRAPHIC & HEALTH DATA ON ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORDS (CDHEHR) How Integrating Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Measures.
On Their Level: A Conversation about Youth Recruitment and Engagement
LGBTQ 201 A Product of the 3/40 Blueprint:
Culturally-Competent Helping Requirements for Counselors working with LGBT Clients C. 1. Acknowledge that affectional orientations are unique to individuals.
927: Advocating for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Questioning (LGBTQ) Youth The Pennsylvania Child Welfare Training Program.
Healthy Relationships for Youth Session 7
Healthy Relationships for Youth Session 7
Sexual Orientation Unit 5.
HOW TO WRITE A SYSTEMATIC/NARRATIVE REVIEW
Robin P. McHaelen, MSW Executive Director
Creating Safer Spaces for LGBTQ Youth
LGBTQIA Youth healthcare experience
Trans 101 and other LGBTQ+ basics
Supporting LGBT Young People in Education
- Trainer - Educator - Case Manager -
Avoiding heterosexual bias in language
Healthy Relationships for Youth Session 7
Support Gender, Ethnicity and Racial Diversity on your Campus
The Rosabeth Moss Kanter Award Module 2, Class 2 A Teaching Module Developed by the Curriculum Task Force of the Sloan Work and Family Research Network.
Preparing for Resident research day
Attracting and Retaining LGBTQ Employees
Avoiding heterosexual bias in language
refugees. You’re already working with LGBTI
Transgender Economic Empowerment Project Manager (TEEP)
219 Articles Eligible for Review 203 Articles Eligible for Review
Factors Preventing Pregnant Teens from Early and Adequate Prenatal Care: Integrative Literature Review Clare Keffer Research Advisor: Dr. Young-Me Lee,
Avoiding heterosexual bias in language
Presentation transcript:

More Missing: Expanding Content Analysis in Social Work Journals to Include Non-Binary Orientations and Gender Identities Sana Marie K. Wilson Kathleen Darby, LCSW, PhD, Faculty Advisor ResultsConclusionBackgroundProcess Journals In 2002, Van Voorhis and Wagner published “Among the Missing: Content on Lesbian and Gay People in Social Work Journals”. This study was a content analysis of four significant social work journals (1988 – 1997) which identified articles that covered gay and lesbian issues and provided an analysis of the article themes and focuses. Pelts, Rolbiecki, and Albright repeated this study and analyzed the same journals covering the years 1998 – As of 2015, there was no comparable analysis of social work journals that looked at content applicable to individuals with non-binary identities (orientations that are not specifically straight, gay, or lesbian, and gender identities that are not cis male or cis female). The purpose of this project was to look at four significant social work journals (1998 – 2013) to identify articles that pertain to non-binary orientations and gender identities and to compile an overview of population focus, topics, and purpose (i.e. client intervention, practitioner knowledge, or macro/other). Language within the articles was analyzed to determine if it was fluid/closed, current, and inclusive. Each article’s abstract, introduction, and literature review was analyzed to determine its level of inclusivity. The remainder of the article was reviewed to determine if the same level of inclusivity was consistent throughout the article’s study design, methods and discussion. More research involving all marginalized orientations and gender identities is needed, but the lack of content regarding non-binary identities and issues is especially glaring since only 1.08% of 2,496 published articles included material applicable to individuals with non-binary identities. Content that needs to be prioritized includes:  conceptual and descriptive knowledge about non-binary and/or variant aspects of sex identity, gender identity, romantic orientation and sexual orientation;  accurate terminology and language that affirms the experiences of non-binary individuals;  identifying and avoiding heterosexist and cissexist bias in assumptions, attitudes and practice tools; and  working with cultural norms and patterns within various non-binary communities. These study journals listed below were chosen because they “have a national audience; are viewed as major social work journals and reflect current trends; have been used in previous content analyses; are not limited to one area of social work practice; and have established publication records.” 4  Social Work  Child Welfare  Social Service Review  Families in Society Acknowledgements Funding for this study was provided by an Undergraduate Research Experience and Creative Activity (URECA) grant awarded by the Middle Tennessee State University Undergraduate Research Center. Publication Period Analyzed: 1998 – 2013 Inclusion Criteria: Contains material addressing any sexual orientation other than straight, gay, or lesbian and/or any gender identity other than cis male or cis female Exclusions: Short elements such as editorials, book reviews, and letters Total Articles Published: 2,496 All were evaluated by title and abstract Articles Pulled for Full-Text Review: 94 Articles Identified for Inclusion: 27 These articles were coded and analyzed Total Qualifying Content: 1.08% Of the 27 articles, 15 were published in a 2006 special issue of Child Welfare related to lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and questioning (LGBTQ) youth, resulting in a single month having 55% of all included articles. With this special issue excluded, there is an average of less than one article (0.75) per year, with a high of 3 in During 7 of the study years, there were 0 articles published. Language / Inclusion  Most commonly used acronym: LGBTQ  44% of articles used outdated and/or dehumanizing language  The majority of problematic language issues were in reference to non-cis genders (e.g. referring to trans individuals as “it”)  33% of articles had non-binary inclusive acronyms and/or opening language, with main body of material focused on only gay/lesbian individuals or families  70% of articles showed heterosexist or cissexist biases as defined by the APA  Only one article included intersex individuals  The only non-binary orientation that was discussed in any article was bisexuality, with that identity usually being subsumed into gay or lesbian if the individual(s) had a same-sex partner and elided if the individual(s) were not same-sex partnered References 1. Alessi, E. (2013). Acknowledging the impact of social forces on sexual minority clients. Clinical Social Work, 41, Elizabeth. A. (2013). Challenging the binary: Sexual identity that is not duality. Journal of Bisexuality, 13, Pelts, M., Rolbiecki, A., and Albright, D. (2014). An update to “Still among the missing: Lesbian and gay content in social work journals”. Social Work, 59(2), Van Voorhis, R., and Wagner, M. (2002). Among the missing: Content on lesbian and gay people in social work journals. Social Work, 47(4), Results Topics#% Youth in Out-of-Home Care933.4% Administration and Training414.8% Trans - Specific Issues311.1% Health Care and Related Issues311.1% Community Interventions311.1% LGB Parents (Bio, Step, & Foster)27.4% Homeless Youth27.4% Guidelines for Practice13.7% Purpose