An Abundance Spread in the Bootes I Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy? John E. Norris The Australian National University Gerard Gilmore University of Cambridge R.F.G.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Annalisa Calamida 5 Maggio 2009 Metallicity distribution of red-giants in ω Cen.
Advertisements

Dark Matter in Dwarf Galaxies
Modelling the Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxies and Tidal Streams of the Milky Way M. Fellhauer Universidad de Concepcion in collaboration with N.W. Evans 1,
An Abundance Spread in the Bootes I Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy? John E. Norris The Australian National University Gerard Gilmore University of Cambridge R.F.G.
Carbon Enhanced Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ( SDSS ) T. Sivarani, Young Sun Lee, B. Marsteller & T. C. Beers Michigan State University & Joint.
基于 LAMOST 巡天数据的大样 本 M 巨星搜寻和分类 钟靖 中国科学院上海天文台. M giants Red : surface temperature lower than 4000K Luminous: M J from to mag (Covey et al.2007)
Sagittarius debris in SDSS stripe 82 Zhu Ling ( 朱玲 ) & Martin. C. Smith Center for Astrophysics, Tsinghua university KIAA at Peking University.
Stellar Astrophysics: Things That Are Too Hard for Keck Judy Cohen (Caltech)+ Evan Kirby, the 0Z team and Branimir Sesar Astronomy in the TMT Era Tokyo,
dSph Masses Matthew Walker – IoA, Cambridge with Mario Mateo - U. Michigan Edward Olszewski - U. Arizona Jorge Peñarrubia - IoA Wyn.
Galactic archaeology Rodrigo Ibata Observatoire de Strasbourg.
SLEUTHING MASS OUTFLOW FROM EVOLVED STARS Optical/IR Spectroscopy from the MMT, KECK II, and Magellan Andrea Dupree (SAO/CfA) Sz. Meszaros (SAO), Jay Strader.
Chemical Signatures of the Smallest Galaxies Torgny Karlsson SIfA, School of Physics, The University of Sydney Collaborators: Joss Bland-Hawthorn and Ralph.
Mass Loss from Red Giant Branch (and AGB) Stars in Globular Clusters Andrea Dupree Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics AGB Workshop: 20 May 2010.
Looking for the siblings of the Sun Borja Anguiano & RAVE collaboration.
Stars science questions Origin of the Elements Mass Loss, Enrichment High Mass Stars Binary Stars.
The Search for New “r-process-Enhanced” Metal-Poor Stars Timothy C. Beers Michigan State University.
ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS John Southworth Jens Viggo Clausen Niels Bohr Institute Københavns Universitet.
Dark Matter in Dwarf Galaxies Rosemary Wyse Johns Hopkins University Gerry Gilmore, Mark Wilkinson, Vasily Belokurov, Sergei Koposov, Matt Walker, John.
The Nature of the Least Luminous Galaxies Josh Simon Carnegie Observatories Josh Simon Carnegie Observatories Marla Geha (Yale) Quinn Minor (SUNY Oneonta)
Construction and Evolution of the Galaxy Where do the dwarf galaxies fit in? Matthew Shetrone February 26, 2009.
„We are not talking about cosmology...“ (A. Sozzetti)
Dynamics of the outer parts of  Centauri Gary Da Costa Mt Stromlo Observatory, Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics, Australian National University.
IAU General Assembly 2009 Symposium Daniela Carollo Macquarie University Research Centre in Astronomy, Astrophysics & Astrophotonics Department of Physics.
1 Galactic Science and MOS on the WHT Amina Helmi.
Seattle University and APO Joanne Hughes Department of Physics.
NGC 2419 – the most bizarre Galactic globular cluster Judith Cohen (Caltech) & Evan Kirby (UC Irvine/Caltech) Conference: Small Stellar Systems, Tuscany,
Small-scale heros: massive-star enrichment in ultrafaint dSphs Andreas Koch D. Adén, S. Feltzing (Lund) F. Matteucci (Trieste) A. McWilliam (Carnegie)
Giuseppina Battaglia Chemo-dynamics of galaxies from resolved stellar population studies in the surroundings of the Milky Way and beyond Fellow Symposium.
Variable Stars in the Old Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies, SDSS dSph’s, and Globular Clusters Charles Kuehn Michigan State University.
The remote globular cluster system of M31 LAMOST Workshop, 19 th July 2010 Dougal Mackey (RSAA, ANU)1 The Newly-Discovered Remote Globular Cluster System.
Chapter 16 – Chemical Analysis Review of curves of growth –The linear part: The width is set by the thermal width Eqw is proportional to abundance –The.
1 / 17 The Elemental Abundance Distributions of Milky Way Satellite Galaxies Evan Kirby (HF09) Caltech Small Magellanic Cloud, HST/ACS credit: NASA, ESA,
The Chemical Impact of Stellar Mass Loss Rosemary Wyse Johns Hopkins University Gerry Gilmore, John Norris, Mark Wilkinson, Vasily Belokurov, Sergei Koposov,
Revealing Elliptical Galaxy Halos Duncan Forbes, Swinburne University.
Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies Orbiting the Milky Way Edward W Olszewski, Steward Obs.
Selection criteria: 21 < R < 24 (-14 < M R < -11) 0.45 < (B – V) < 1.1 (3 arcsec apertures) Highest priority to sources showing any sign of having profiles.
Globular Cluters in Dwarf Galaxies. But first, a digression regarding tides... Leo I.
The Masses and Metallicities of the Least Luminous Galaxies Josh Simon Carnegie Observatories Josh Simon Carnegie Observatories Marla Geha (Yale) Beth.
25 Years of Globular Clusters with HST
Subaru Wide-Field Survey of M87 Globular Cluster Populations N.Arimoto (NAOJ) N.Tamura, R.Sharples (Durham) M.Onodera (Tokyo, NAOJ), K.Ohta(Kyoto) J.-C.Cuillandre.
Galactic structure and star counts Du cuihua BATC meeting, NAOC.
Dr. Alan Alves-Brito ARC Super Science Fellow Red giant stars as tracers of the chemical evolution of the Galactic bulge.
Globular Cluster - Dwarf Galaxy Connection W1: a case study in our neighborhood Ann Arbor, Aug Beth Willman W1 DEIMOS Observations M.Geha (HIA/Yale)
Cluster & Association Members Ernst Paunzen IfA, Vienna.
The Ultra-Faint Milky Way Satellites
Alan McConnachie Mike Irwin, Annette Ferguson, Nial Tanvir, Rodrigo Ibata, Geraint Lewis, Scott Chapman, Avon Huxor Alan McConnachie Mike Irwin, Annette.
1 The Most Metal-Poor Stars in the Galaxy Timothy C. Beers Department of Physics & Astronomy Michigan State University & JINA: Joint Institute for Nuclear.
Intermediate-mass Black Holes in Star Clusters Holger Baumgardt Astrophysical Computing Laboratory, RIKEN, Tokyo new address:
The Chemo-Dynamical Structure of Galaxies: intermediate resolution spectroscopy of resolved stellar populations out to Virgo Giuseppina Battaglia ESO Simulations.
The vertical structure of the Galactic Halo Carla Cacciari, Angela Bragaglia - INAF OA Bologna Tom Kinman - NOAO Alberto Buzzoni - INAF TNG Alessandro.
ASTR112 The Galaxy Lecture 4 Prof. John Hearnshaw 7. Globular clusters 8. Galactic rotation 8.1 From halo stars 8.2 From disk stars – Oort’s constant,
The High Redshift Universe Next Door
BATC Multi-color Photometry of Open Cluster M48 Zhenyu Wu 8.11, 2005, Weifang.
1 VLT kinematics for Omega Centauri : Further support for a central BH E. Noyola et al. 2010, ApJ, 719, L Jun 30 (Thu) Sang Chul KIM ( 김상철 )
SEGUE Target Selection on-going SEGUE observations.
Χαν ιά, August 9, 2004 Content and structure of galaxy halos Rodrigo Ibata Observatoire de Strasbourg.
Galactic Structure and Near-field Cosmology via Astrometry with ODI Dana Casetti, Terry Girard, Bill van Altena - Yale Orbits of MW: satellites satellites.
Hobby-Eberly Telescope Chemical Abundances of Stars in the Halo (CASH) Project: Spectroscopic Analyses of the First ~80 Stars 5 May 2010 Julie Krugler.
Learning about first galaxies using large surveys
Judy’s contribution to globular cluster science
From: The evolution of star formation activity in galaxy groups
1. The Stellar Populations of NGC5128
Ultra-Faint, Ultra-Dark, and Ultra-Handsome
Peculiar Massive Globular Clusters in the Milky Way
Distribution of Galaxies
Chapter 16 – Chemical Analysis
Boötes III: a Disrupted Dwarf Galaxy?
Henry Ferguson STScI August 28, 2008
Planetary Nebula abundances in NGC 5128 with FORS
Modeling Star Formation and Chemical Evolution in the Local Group dwarfs Oleg Gnedin University of Michigan.
Presentation transcript:

An Abundance Spread in the Bootes I Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy? John E. Norris The Australian National University Gerard Gilmore University of Cambridge R.F.G. Wyse Johns Hopkins University The (together with M. Wilkinson, D. Zucker, V. Belokurov, N. Evans & D. Quinn)

Belokurov et al ApJ, 647, L111; 2007 ApJ, 654, 897 M71  Cen M v = -5.8 r h = 230 pc (13 arcmin) V rad = 100 km/sec Distance = 60 kpc [Fe/H] = -2.5 (Munos 2006, Martin et al 2007)

Mass enclosed within stellar extent ~ 4 x 10 7 M   Globular star clusters, no DM  Gilmore et al 2007 ApJ, 663, 948

Bootes I with AAT/AAOMEGA Blue spectra R=5000 Red spectra R=14000

Bootes I : Radial velocity vs Radial distance Membership criterion: 90 < V r < 115 km/sec (~+/- 2  )

Bootes I : C4150 > 200 cnts/pix, Radial vel. vs Radial dist. rhrh

Spectra of 15 radial velocity members of Bootes I g 0 /(g-r) 0 /[Fe/H] W(CaIIK), B-V Beers et al 1999 calibration [Fe/H] Internal error:  ([Fe/H])= 0.35

Bootes I compared with M15 Bootes IM15 (B-V) 0 /[Fe/H]

Boo-1137 versus extremely metal-poor stars Is Boo-1137 (with r = 24 arcmin) a member? This appears to be very likely, given the rareness of objects with [Fe/H] < From the HK survey for metal-poor stars and for [Fe/H] < -3.0, Beers et al (1992) find 5 stars with V 0.7 over 2300 sq.deg. For the HES, Christlieb (2008, priv. comm.) finds 9 stars with B < 14.5, B-V < 0.7 over 7000 sq.deg. From this, we estimate one should expect only ~0.02 field halo giants having [Fe/H] < -3.0 within the central 30 arcmin of Bootes.

Bootes I: Ca II Triplet vs Ca II K

Helmi et al 2006 ApJ, 651, L121

We have obtained spectra of 16 putative radial velocity RGB members of the low-luminosity Bootes I dSph galaxy (90 < V r < 115 km/s) with sufficient S/N for [Fe/H] determination In this sample there is an abundance range of  [Fe/H] ~ 1.7 dex, with one star having [Fe/H = -3.4 The abundance dispersion is  ([Fe/H]) = 0.4 +/- 0.1, which is of the same order as those of the Galaxy’s more luminous dSph systems, and  Centauri This suggests that the large mass (> 10 7 M o ) normally assumed to foster self-enrichment and the production of abundance spreads of the  - and iron-peak elements was provided by the non-baryonic material in Bootes I. CONCLUSIONS