Population estimates from administrative data sources 5 th Administrative Data Seminar Dublin Castle 12 th April 2016 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 The 2010 Census Coverage Measurement Survey Patrick J. Cantwell U.S Census Bureau Annual Meeting of the Association of Public Data Users September 25,
Advertisements

Estimating the Immigrant Stock in the United States by Legal Status using Administrative and Census Data United Nations Expert Group Meeting on Measuring.
Population Estimates and Projections in the U. S. John F. Long
UK Official Statistics on Migration: Current Methods & Future Plans Emma Wright Office for National Statistics, UK.
1. 2 Census Scientifically or Politically Correct? Stephen E. Fienberg Department of Statistics Notes for Stat October, 2001.
Academic Viva POWER and ERROR T R Wilson. Impact Factor Measure reflecting the average number of citations to recent articles published in that journal.
National Statistics Quality Review on International Migration Estimates Update on taking forward the recommendations of the review Emma Wright & Giles.
Coverage assessment and adjustment methodology Owen Abbott Methodology Directorate, ONS.
2011 CENSUS Coverage Assessment – What’s new? OWEN ABBOTT.
New Alternatives for Estimating Net Migration to the United States Using the American Community Survey Alexa Kennedy-Puthoff David Dixon Sonya Rastogi.
Person Activity Register - a statistical register of persons Administrative Statistics Seminar Dublin Castle 20 th Feb 2014
Smoothing mortality rates using R Gary Brown & Julie Mills.
Plausibility Ranges for Population Estimates Focusing on ranges for children.
An Introduction to the U.S. Demographic System John F. Long
Demographic Analysis Update This presentation is released to inform interested parties of research and to encourage discussion. Any views expressed.
Estimation of Emigration from the United States using International Data Sources Jason P. Schachter Senior Statistician, Bureau of Statistics, ILO Geneva.
UNIT 2 – LESSON 2 TEXTBOOK CHAPTER 4 PG 56 Population Concepts.
1 Understanding and Measuring Uncertainty Associated with the Mid-Year Population Estimates Joanne Clements Ruth Fulton Alison Whitworth.
UN ECE Seminar on New Frontiers for Statistical Data Collection 31 Oct – 2 Nov 2012 Beyond 2011 The future of population statistics Andy Teague, Office.
Adjusting for coverage error in administrative sources in population estimation Owen Abbott Research, Development and Infrastructure Directorate.
Developments with ONS’s Small Area Population Estimates Project Andy Bates, Office for National Statistics.
Net Investment and Stock of Human Capital in the United States: Michael S. Christian May 23, 2016.
Measuring International Migration: An Example from the U. S
Unconventional Approaches to Mortality Estimation
Methods for Data-Integration
Asymmetries in international migration flow data
Senior Consultant, The Annie E. Casey Foundation
The Undercount of Young Children in the U.S. Census
Developments in the measuring and reporting of international migration statistics Royal Statistical Society Sarah Crofts and Paul Vickers 6 December.
A Multi-State Generalization of the HMD Methodology, Applied to Fertility by Parity in the United States, John R. Wilmoth Department of Demography.
Use of Administrative Data for Census 2021
Use of population registers for vital statistics purposes
Integrating administrative data – the 2021 Census and beyond
Building on the Migration Statistics Improvement Programme
Monitoring international migration flows in Europe Frans Willekens
Population, Family and Community
How demographics and the economic downturn are affecting the way we live LSE Seminar: 1 July 2013 Neil McDonald: Visiting Fellow CCHPR.
Overview of Connecticut Population Projections from 2015 to 2040
Estimating Migration from Census data Issues for consideration
Sources of Data Wednesday, August 27.
Census taking in Ireland
Measuring Census Coverage Post Enumeration Survey
Prague EU-SILC Best Practice Workshop, 14th and 15th September 2017
ESF EVALUATION PARTNERSHIP MEETING Bernhard Boockmann / Helmut Apel
A 2nd generation moment George Gershwin Leonard Berstein Aaron Copeland
Towards a Fully Adjusted Census Database for the 2011 Census
CENSUS MICRODATA : THAILAND
AUSTRALIA (2015) Population: 22,992, ,377 Births 159,052 Deaths
ONS progress update on Transforming Population and Migration Statistics System in England and Wales Pete Jones Admin Data Census Project Office for National.
Demography Statistics - looking to the future
Population Estimation Beyond 2021
Asset-based Reallocations
Measurement errors Marina Signore
Marlar Aung Director Central Statistical Organization
Population Sizes -Changes in the size of a population are often difficult to measure directly but may be estimated by measuring the relative rates of birth,
The European perspective
Salah Merad Methodology Division, ONS
Evaluating the Completeness of the Civil Registration System
Evaluating the Completeness of the Civil Registration System
Tabulations & Dual System of Estimation (DSE)
Demographic Analysis and Evaluation
Beyond 2011 Administrative data sources and low-level aggregate models for producing population estimates.
Eurostat WG on Population and Housing Censuses
Pete Benton , Beyond 2011 Programme Director
Population Statistics without a Census or Register
Tabulation and Dual System of Estimation (DSE) Pres. 9
Tabulations & Dual System of Estimation (DSE)
Quality assurance and assessment in the vital statistics system
Modernization of Social statistics: integrated use of survey and
Kaija Ruotsalainen Statistics Finland
Presentation transcript:

Population estimates from administrative data sources 5 th Administrative Data Seminar Dublin Castle 12 th April

Overview Traditional approach Proposed new approach Extending to migration (in and out) Concluding remarks

Traditional – Component method Quality Profile Time Census years

New approach – data ‘signs of life’ PAR - Person Activity Register (CSOPPSN) 2011 (4.3m) Admin Active Population during year Signs of life Sources (Cradle to Grave) - Births - Child benefit * - Post primary - Higher Ed - Further Ed - Employee - Self Employed - Social Welfare - Drivers *** - Medical ** - Pensions * - Deaths Two datasets PAR (excluding drivers) DL – Driver licence renewals Does PAR have undercount? Does PAR have overcount?

New approach – population concepts U I de facto census night definition U II usually resident population U A hypothetical PAR population U B hypothetical DL population Assume U II = U A = U B

Population (N) PAR (x) DL (n) PAR ∩ DL (m) Dual System Estimation - undercoverage But we can look for signs of overcount by trimming PAR E[N] = x n/m Assumptions -Independence -Matching -Catchability ? -No overcount ? See Wolter (1986)

Looking for overcoverage Remove suspicious records step by step Observe behaviour of population estimate if stable OK drops before stabilising => overcoverage? Suspicious records? Low pay and no other activity Steps of €1k Method is called Trimmed Dual System Estimation

Trimmed Dual System Estimate (TDSE) with 95% CIs

DSE Population Estimates Assuming no overcoverage Adjust for undercoverage using DSE model

Next steps Coverage on PAR to enhance quality – PCRS, Child benefit and State pension payments ….. Robustness - dependency on each data source Bias – further investigate age group Timeliness – strong partnerships with data providers Quality Profile Time Census years

Extension to Migration (In and Out) Good quality net migration from Population estimates Estimating immigration and emigration not so easy We can use DSE model to look at problem a differently

Population 1 Population 2 StayersOutflow = Deaths + Emigration Inflow = Births + Immigration

Population 1 Population 2 PAR1 PAR2 DL1 DL2 PAR1 ∩ PAR2 DL1 ∩ DL2 Estimating a shared population – methodology Chao 2008

Population 1 Population 2 PAR1 PAR2 DL1 DL2 PAR1 ∩ PAR2 DL1 ∩ DL2 is NULL !!!!!

Population 1 Population 2 PAR1 PAR2 DL2 Stayers - Forward estimation

Population 1 Population 2 PAR1 PAR2 DL1 Backward estimation

May still be possible to use DSE to estimate stayers

1.Estimate stayers in PAR1 2.Gross up to Population 1 or 1. Estimate stayers in PAR2 2. Gross up to Population 2 Two methods - DSE - Based on Hypergeometric distribution using Par1, DL2 and Population 2 or PAR2, DL1 and Population 1 Two directions Preference for backwards Direction (DL1) ?

Emerging census opportunity Postcodes and small areas Can other census attributes be derived from admin data sources and existing surveys ……

Concluding remarks Only focussed on one aspect Admin data = Many new possibilities.. strong partnerships.. change the way we look at problems.. new methods, new tools Trust and Responsibility

Background references Chao et al (2008), The Petersen Lincoln estimator and its extension to estimate the size of a shared population, Biometrical Journal 50 (2008) 6, 957– 970 Wolter (1986), Some coverage error models for census data, Journal of the American Statistical Association – 346 Zhang and Dunne (2016), Trimmed Dual System Estimation, in Capture-recapture methods for the Social and Medical Sciences, forthcoming