ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS The philosophical debate regarding the environment has branched into two: One centers on ethical obligations regarding nature and.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Class 5 Environmental Ethics: Other species and the community of life.
Advertisements

Ethics: The Greeks Plato & Aristotle. Plato ( B.C.E) Discusses Ethics using the doctrine of: Teleology: all things have a distinct purpose:
Environmental Science A Global Perspective Understanding our Environment Section 1.1.
Chapter 2 Environmental Sustainability and Human Values
Deontological & Consequential Ethics
Chapter One of the major concerns in environmental science is how to successfully integrate the natural world and the socio-cultural-technological.
CHAPTER 1 Environmental Science: A Global Perspective
PowerPoint Backgrounds Chapter 2 Students will understand many of the contributing factors involved with environmental science.
A retailer may legally sell fresh or process meat and poultry products beyond the expiration date: A. Only if the food is wholesome B. At no time C. Only.
Maybe there is enough land for landfills for generations to come. Maybe global warming is a simple weather pattern that will reverse in five years. Perhaps.
“Toxic Garbage Island” movie tonight at 5pm in JES A121A.
Different Cultural View of Nature Our view of nature and the environment are culturally bound Western View of the Environment Judeo-Christian tradition.
Definition Environmental studies deals with every issue that affects an organism. It is essentially a multidisciplinary approach that brings about an appreciation.
Copyright © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Ethics: Theory and Practice Jacques P. Thiroux Keith W. Krasemann.
Key Terms  Speciesism  Prejudice for one’s own species and against other species  Sentientism  Theory that only those beings with mental states should.
Chapter 2 Views of Nature Control nature, or we are wasting resources. All living things have value. Problems now arise because of rate, scale and complexity.
DEEP ECOLOGY AN ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICAL POSITION. Human beings are destroying the planet It is a major concern of environmental ethics that human beings.
PHIL 2 Philosophy: Ethics in Contemporary Society Week 6 Topic Outlines.
The Moral Philosophy of Immanuel Kant The Ethics of Duty and Reason
Population and Environment. The Ecological Environment Sociological inquiry and the environment – Social theory – A multi-dimensional solution to a problem.
Unit Eight Seminar Animal Rights. Old Business!  Welcome Back! Only one seminar remaining!  Unit 7 Papers.
Principles of Environmental Management Overview. Environmental Science An interdisciplinary area of study that includes both applied and theoretical aspects.
The Ethics Of Environment Businesses have been ignoring their impact on the natural environment for centuries, largely because the economic costs and harmful.
1 Environmental Science Chapter 2: Environmental Ethics.
Chapter 6 PUTTING PHILOSPHY TO WORK IN CULTURALLY DIVERSE CLASSROOMS.
Ethical Decision Making and Ethical Theory Mgmt 621 Contemporary Ethical Issues in Management Jeffery D. Smith.
Engineering in Environmental and Technological Contexts AKHIL A T.
Sociology and the Environment. What do sociologists have to offer to a discussion about the environment and environmental problems?
Seeing the Father John 14:5-11.
PHI 208 Course Extraordinary Success tutorialrank.com
Environmental Science
The world around us.
POPULATION AND NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
Environmental Ethics.
Human Impact on the Environment
Plato vs Aristotle
The World of Life Science
The environmental problems
Why is everybody fighting?
Karl Marx & Friedrich Engels Sociology 100
Philosophy of Education
Multidisciplinary nature of environmental studies Lecture #1
Absolutism.
Chapter 8 Environmental Ethics
UNIT 1 NATURE OF ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES
Life After Death: The Soul (Lesson 4)
ETHICS BOWL kantian ETHICS.
Environmental Ethics.
Ethics: Theory and Practice
The Foundations of Ethics
Human Caused Hazards and Pollution
Environmental Issues Human Impact on Earth.
“The Tragedy of the Commons”
Aspects of Science 1 The body of all knowledge and understanding of the way the Physical and Natural World work 2 The application of that knowledge - Technology.
Classical political ideologies
The study of the nature of reality
Greek Philosophers Chapter 5-2.
American Transcendentalism
Science and the Environment
Persons, Persistence & Tuvix: What Makes Me “Me” From One Moment to the Next?
Chapter 1 section 4 Earth system science.
Kant Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View
“A land ethic, then, reflects the existence of an ecological conscience, and this in turn reflects a conviction of individual responsibility for the health.
Lesson Overview 6.1 A Changing Landscape.
Religion and the Environment Revision
Religion and the Environment Revision
Greek Philosophy & History
Eco-Feminists’ View Eco-Feminists, a related group of thinkers, see the key form of hierarchy connected to the destruction of the environment as the domination.
The Environment For many thousands of years, Aboriginal people lived in harmony with the unique Australian environment. When Europeans arrived, they had.
Presentation transcript:

ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS The philosophical debate regarding the environment has branched into two: One centers on ethical obligations regarding nature and our responsibilities to future generations. This view has been referred to as Stewardship-anthropocentrism, or simply stewardship. Another view, called “deep ecology”, is more controversial. It holds that we have obligations to nature. Obligations to nature include animals and even trees and mountains, which would be seen as bearers of legal rights. In this view people are seen as a mere part of nature, although with the capacity to disturb it. 2

Few people question the fittingness of living in harmony with nature. However, a deep ecology goes beyond this, diluting humanity with nature. This radically materialistic view contrasts with a more widely accepted outlook: that human, though part of nature, also transcend it because of their inner world, which expresses a significant spiritual dimension. These two anthropological views have important consequences for the environmental ethics. 3

Human beings are the central fact of the earth, and only they possess dignity and authentic rights. Stewardship is a philosophy that holds that development should be, above all, both human and sustainable, which means employing material goods with moderation and a sense of responsibility, as a tool for human flourishing, with concern for future generations. A managerial stewardship of the environment reconciles respect for nature and the attainment of reasonable profits. 4

The immediate consequences of the discussion above highlight the following aspects of environmental ethics: Animal welfare Responsible use of resources Avoid all form of pollution 5

Limitation of earth resources

We live in a world of limits. Population increase, unprecedented consumption, toxic waste, pollution, depletion of resources and species, and climate change have brought humanity face to face with the limits of the natural world and the environment. This realization makes it imperative that we rethink our core values and the way(s) we live. In addition, we must also rethink our relationships to the environment and obligations to one another, including our posterity.

Role of environmental ethics 1. Recognize environmental ethical issues. 2. Understand what lies behind our attitudes toward the natural environment and everything in it (plants, trees, animals). 3. Discern whether we have a moral obligation to preserve and protect nature. 4. Understand and deal with the question "To what extent do animals and plants have rights?" 5. Know and understand the arguments for and against the use and exploitation of the natural environment and everything in it. 6. Recognize the importance of non-Western ethical perspectives for addressing environmental issues.

Environmental ethical issues Waste and Destruction of Natural Resources As I pointed out, we have assumed that our natural resources will last forever, that our water, air, oil, minerals, earth, plants, and trees will always be there for us to use and will never be depleted. However, in recent times we have discovered that there is a limit to everything, including our natural resources.

Exploiting, Misusing, and Polluting the Environment As our industrialization and technology increased, so did the toxicity of the waste, and we found ourselves burying in the land or dumping in bodies of water very dangerous and poisonous materials, such as strong chemicals, atomic waste, and other dangerous materials that seriously affected our whole environment as well as us its inhabitants.

Exploiting, Abusing, and Destroying Animals One of the most controversial ethical issues concerning the environment is the question of animal rights and whether we have moral obligations toward animals. These issues encompass destroying animals for food or for parts of their bodies (e.g., furs, skins, or tusks); hunting them for sport; and using them for scientific and other experimentation. Hunting and Destroying Animals for Food and Body Parts

How did we get here? Attitudes Platonic Dualism: The Beginnings of Western Philosophy Both Socrates and Plato, then, tended to deemphasize the importance of this world as opposed to the world of ideas where they felt that ultimate truths could be found, but only through human reason

This dualism enabled the Greeks to think abstractly for the first time in their history, but it also tended to split them away from nature in that they, as reasoning beings, saw themselves as different from and more important than nature and the external world, because they and no other beings in nature could attain the "real" world of ideas that Plato thought actually existed.

Judeo-Christian Teachings in the Bible Taught that God is a supernatural, spiritual being who shares His spirituality with human beings. No other being in nature, according to the teachings in both traditions, has any spirituality. Makes nature and everything in it subservient to human beings and their wishes, implying that nature exists strictly for their use and has little or no value in itself

The Rise of Science and Scientific Progress As science and technology advanced, nature became more and more subservient to human needs and desires, and the environment and animals were used and exploited without regard to any inherent value they might have. After all, so the attitude went, we are the only beings with intrinsic value.

Industrialization most nations in the West and many in the East have become highly industrialized, requiring a greater use of natural resources and also causing a greater deleterious effect on the environment because of the need for more land, and air, and a greater disposal of waste.

Encroachment of Nature by Civilization As we have moved out of crowded cities into the countryside nearby and created suburbs, we have eliminated more and more of the natural environment and replaced it with our own

some of the arguments which have been advanced to show that it is wrong to justify our concern for future generations by attributing rights to those generations Future generations do not now exist and may never exist. Future people presently exist only in the imagination, and imaginary entities cannot be acted on whatsoever way except in imagination If future generations have rights then the present must be sacrificed for the future Because we don’t know what interests future generations will have, we cannot say what rights they have.

Thank you