Developing an Intellectual Property Strategy Marie Jones Bank of America Asst. General Counsel, SVP CCWC Career Strategies Conference Sept. 21, 2016
Types of Intellectual Property Rights Ensuring Company Owns the Intellectual Property Rights Developing an Intellectual Property Strategy (Patent Emphasis) Overview 21 September 20162Bank of America
Trade Secrets -Information + economic value because it is generally not known (formulas, industrial processes, devices, business information) Patents (most common utility patents) -Inventions (processes, machines, devices, compositions) -Right to exclude others from making, selling, or using the invention Trademarks -Identify the source of products and services (words, phrases, symbols, sounds) -Right to use the mark Copyrights -Works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium (literary works, music, artistic works, software) -Exclusive right to reproduce, adapt, and distribute Types of Intellectual Property Rights 21 September 20163Bank of America
Trade Secrets vs. Patents -Trade Secrets - Economic value because it is kept confidential. -Patents – A quid pro quo. In exchange for the “monopoly,” you will share the information to the public. A product may be covered by multiple intellectual property rights -Copyright -Trade Secret Industrial process, customer list -Patent Processes performed by portions of the software -Trademark Branding 21 September 20164Bank of America
Hiring Process (Employee) -Proprietary Rights Agreement clearly stating Ownership Rights of the Company Contracts (Example, vendors) -Clearly ensure that contract has language indicating ownership of IP as intended. -What deliverables or work products do you envision the vendor will create? Copyrights -Vendor creates software for your company; who owns such software? -Will there be a license to the other party? Patents – Ideas -Brainstorming session; who owns such ideas? Ensuring Company Owns the Intellectual Property Rights 21 September 20165Bank of America
Considerations: Company has a growing portfolio of patents (pending and granted) What do we do now? There must be a strategy rather than growth by accident Determine Business Strategy; Align Patent Strategy to Business Strategy Two Sides of a Coin: -Developing and Protecting Patent Rights Sword - Build a patent portfolio -More patents, more swords, more territories -Avoiding Infringement Suits (Respecting the IP Rights of Others) Shield – Mitigate Risks -How to Avoid Being Sued? Developing an Intellectual Property Strategy (Patent Emphasis) 21 September 20166Bank of America
So how do you develop your patent portfolio? Education -Dispel the “layman’s view” of patents (“flash of genius” not required) -Take the “bad thing” and turn it into a “good thing” (patent suit) -Repetition Helps – presentations, newsletters -Find other champions, e.g., other attorneys and business partners -Educate Sourcing/Contract Management Close and Regular Communication between Business and Patent Team -Important that patent team understands business strategy -Communication -Who in the business side? Business and technology partners -What should be discussed? Current products (protect current products) Future products (file patents now for future protection) Competitors Patent Landscapes (areas where competitors are patenting) Developing and Protecting Patent Rights 21 September 20167Bank of America
So how do you develop your patent portfolio? Find Opportunities to Raise Development of Patent Rights -Product Development Checkpoint or IP Legal Consultation Ask the questions: -Did you take the proper steps to vet if your ideas are suitable for patent protection? -What are your future plans? Suggest forward inventing sessions. Putting your patent stakes into the future. Use this opportunity to ask other IP questions? -Is there a product name? Vetting the trademark for possible registration. Avoids delays in the event of name/mark change. -Are there trade secrets that we need to identify? Make it Easy for Inventors to Submit Ideas or Disclosures -Use outside counsel -Software tools -Process Change Developing and Protecting Patent Rights 21 September 20168Bank of America
Watch out for: Inadvertent licensing or transfer of ownership rights -Have a review process if IP rights are going to be handled differently from your company’s standard IP strategy Educating your sourcing/contract management -Example: A different line of business agreeing to IP not being owned by the company Think about: Acquisition of other Patents -Fill in patent portfolio gaps Monetization -Is this part of the business strategy? Developing and Protecting Patent Rights 21 September 20169Bank of America
So how do you avoid being sued? Proactive Step (Patent Perspective) Establish a Product Development Checkpoint or IP Legal Consultation -Serves dual purpose (Developing IP and Risk Mitigation) Early enough to have sufficient time to -Obtain Product Clearance/Freedom to Operate Opinion -Develop a Design Around -Obtain a License Consider a buy or build situation? -Buy from a vendor, negotiate for IP indemnification Look at financial viability of the vendor Avoiding Patent Infringement Suits (Respecting the Patent Rights of Others) 21 September Bank of America
So how do you avoid being sued? Proactive Step (Other IP Perspective) Establish a Product Development Checkpoint or IP Legal Consultation -Use this opportunity to vet other IP Trademark -Vet to ensure not infringing other trademarks Copyrights -Open Source -Ensure no unauthorized copyrights used (from previous employers or internet) -Provide proper guidance when developing software in-house Particularly when replacing a vendor product Avoiding Patent Infringement Suits (Respecting the Patent Rights of Others) 21 September Bank of America
You received a demand letter. Now what? -Consider: Is the letter from a competitor or a non-practicing entity (NPE)? -Strategy may be different Do you ignore, wait, respond, or take other action? Who is sending the letter? Who have they sued? Quick settlements? Take a license now? Investigate for prior art? Assess non-infringement? Avoiding Patent Infringement Suits (Respecting the Patent Rights of Others) 21 September Bank of America
Now you have been sued for patent infringement. -Approach may be different, if suit is by NPE vs Operating Company -Check if you have indemnification from vendors (note notice requirement). -Consider AIA Reviews: Inter Partes Review Covered Business Method Review -Suit is by operating company or competitor Patent portfolio for cross-licensing purposes? Avoiding Patent Infringement Suits (Respecting the Patent Rights of Others) 21 September Bank of America