Introduction The importance of shared decision-making (SDM) in medical care is the hallmark of providing individualized, patient-centered care SDM is taught.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Information literacy Curriculum integration – an investment in lifelong learning Anne-Marie Haraldstad Library of Medicine and Health Sciences The University.
Advertisements

Evidence-Based Medicine
Simulation in the Undergraduate Nursing Curriculum at Queen’s University Belfast: Clinical Skills, OSCE, ILS, High Fidelity Simulation.
1 Interprofessional Education (IPE) “.. Occurs when two or more professions learn with, from, and about each other to improve collaboration and the quality.
Teaching/Learning Strategies to Support Evidence-Based Practice Asoc. prof. Vida Staniuliene Klaipeda State College Dean of Faculty of Health Sciences.
Using the Biomedical Library & Its Resources: Becoming Efficient Information Managers Public Health & Epidemiology PHE 131 Winter 2010.
Joanne Muellenbach, MLS, AHIP The Commonwealth Medical College Scranton, Pennsylvania June 26, 2012.
Family Medicine Program By the end of this session, faculty will 1.Understand what is meant by competence and the competence trajectory expected during.
Debriefing in Medical Simulation Manu Madhok, MD, MPH Emergency Department Children’s Hospital and Clinics of Minnesota.
What Health-Professionals Should Know About Research and Why They Should Know It Bill Galey Director of Graduate and Medical Education Programs Howard.
ACGME OUTCOME PROJECT : THE PROGRAM COORDINATOR’S ROLE Jim Kerwin, MD University of Arizona.
Dual interviews: Moving Beyond Didactics to Train Primary Care Providers in the Biopsychosocial Model James Anderson, PhD Fellow in Primary Care Psychology.
Kazakhstan Health Technology Transfer and Institutional Reform Project Clinical Teaching Post Graduate Medicine A Workshop Drs. Henry Averns and Lewis.
Copyright  West Institute Evidence-Based Practices ILLNESS MANAGEMENT AND RECOVERY EVIDENCE-BASEDPRACTICE An Introduction.
The Teaching Physician: How to Become a More Effective Medical Educator The Teaching Center UNC Department of Pediatrics The Teaching Center.
Educating Medical Students about the Care of Patients with Disabilities Kira Zwygart, MD Laurie Woodard, MD University of South Florida College of Medicine.
Teaching EBM Natapong Kosachunhanun, M.D.. Why Teach and Practice EBM?  It is required to be taught by TMC.  Outcomes research has documented that patients.
The New ACGME Competencies for Internal Medicine.
Training for Tomorrow: The Simulated Interprofessional Rounding Experience at MUSC Donna Kern, MD Associate Dean for Curriculum- Clinical Sciences, COM.
Using the Biomedical Library and its Resources Public Health & Epidemiology PHE 131 Winter 2011 Becoming Efficient Information Managers.
Writing Narratives Based on ACGME Competencies. Narratives What Are They?  Written Evaluation of Student Performance Formative  Mid-Course Evaluation.
This material was developed by Oregon Health & Science University, funded by the Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the National Coordinator.
Cultural Competency in End-of-Life Communication Kamal Masaki, M.D. Department of Geriatric Medicine John A. Burns School of Medicine University of Hawaii.
What is “Competency” in the New Millennium? Shirley Schlessinger, MD, FACP Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education University of Mississippi Medical.
Evidence-Based Medicine – Definitions and Applications 1 Component 2 / Unit 5 Health IT Workforce Curriculum Version 1.0 /Fall 2010.
Copyright restrictions may apply Randomized Trial of Teaching Brief Motivational Interviewing to Pediatric Trainees to Promote Healthy Behaviors in Families.
What is a Planned Curriculum?
Improving Medical Education Skills. Many Family Medicine graduates teach… D6 students New doctors who do not have post-graduate training Other healthcare.
Is the conscientious explicit and judicious use of current best evidence in making decision about the care of the individual patient (Dr. David Sackett)
Component 1: Introduction to Health Care and Public Health in the U.S. 1.9: Unit 9: The evolution and reform of healthcare in the US 1.9a: Evidence Based.
ACGME SIX CORE COMPETENCIES Minimum Program Requirements Language Approved by the ACGME, September 28, 1999 “The residency program must require its residents.
Not Just “MK-1” How learning the skills of EBM relates to the pediatric milestones Martha S Wright, MD, MEd Rainbow Babies and Children’s Hospital.
The Electronic Health Record Lab: A Comprehensive Educational Intervention for Outpatient Electronic Records Bruce Britton M.D. Cy Cedar MS4 Christine.
The use of OSCE to assess Patient Care, Professionalism and Interpersonal Communication Milestones in EM residents Miriam Kulkarni, MD, Harsh Sule, MD,
TEMPLATE AND PRINTING BY: GRMERC Consortium Members: Grand Valley State University, Michigan State University, Saint Mary’s.
Exploring Non-Physician Roles in Competency-Based Resident Education April 1, 2016 Nicole McGuire, Education Coordinator, Union Hospital FMR (Terre Haute,
A Multidisciplinary Leadership Model in a Community Health Center Greg Thesing, MD November 2014.
Drew Keister, MD Kira Zwygart, MD.  Define the audience  The USF primary care clerkship background & structure  The USF-LVH partnership  Addition.
1 Transforming Our Practices Transformed Our Teaching: Meeting ACGME Competencies with New Models of Care Katherine Miller, M.D. John Nagle, MPA U. Of.
Use of Mentored Residency Teams to Enhance Addiction Medicine Education Maureen Strohm, MD, Ken Saffier, MD, Julie Nyquist, PhD, Steve Eickelberg, MD MERF.
CBME in MESAU Institutions, Uganda Sarah Kiguli MakCHS 7 th August 2013.
Information Management and Training Residents for “The Future of Family Medicine” Allen F. Shaughnessy, PharmD.
“Look-up Conference” A Learner-driven Resident Conference Format Timothy N. Stephens, MD Allen F. Shaughnessy, PharmD Tufts University Family Medicine.
Promoting Medical Student Engagement in Patient Self-management: A Multi-modality Longitudinal Curriculum in Motivational Interviewing Dave Richard, MD,
Interpersonal and Communication Skills
Curriculum Development for Outcome Based Learning
Northwestern Family Medicine Residency & Erie Family Health Center
Todd Felix, MD, Sam Faber, MD, Dave Richard, MD
Alice Fornari, Ed.D. Francesco Leanza, M.D. Janet Townsend, M.D.
Introduction Developed in collaboration with: Lead Advisor
Conference on Practice Improvement December 3-5, 2015
Five Microskills of Effective Feedback Focus on SBIRT Maureen Strohm, MD, MSEd with thanks to Julie G Nyquist, Ph.D.
Librarian Led Technology Sessions Participation in EBM Conference
Health Care Interpreting
The Development of a Competency Map for Population Health Education
Development of Inter-Professional Geriatric and Palliative Care Clinic
Can Primary Care Physicians Learn and Adopt Brief Motivational Interviewing Techniques in their Practice? Alan Adelman, MD, MS David Richard, MD Robert.
Development of Inter-Professional Geriatric and Palliative Care Clinic
Jonathan dela Cruz, M.D., Jason A Kegg, M.D.
Background/Introduction Curricular Design Curricular Materials (Cont.)
Development of Inter-Professional Geriatric and Palliative Care Clinic
Strategies and Techniques
UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS MEDICAL BRANCH At GALVESTON
Embedding SBIRT (Screening, Brief Intervention and Referral to Treatment) into Health Professional Trainees’ Curriculum Hartman, Cheri W. 1; Hartman, David.
Oral Exams & Interviews
The Clinical Competency Committee
PCM M1-M3 Mentor Program PCM3 Objectives Structure
Kira Zwygart, MD Laurie Woodard, MD
Presentation transcript:

Introduction The importance of shared decision-making (SDM) in medical care is the hallmark of providing individualized, patient-centered care SDM is taught and referenced throughout the literature yet there is a lack of published data on how to best evaluate such skills We developed an Observed Structured Clinical Exam (OSCE) to evaluate our PGY3 Family Medicine residents in the ability to define a clinical question, research it, and perform SDM in a brief clinical encounter Curriculum Patient-Centered Communication (PCC) Skills: OARS (Open-ended questions, Affirmations, Reflective listening, and Summarization), asking permission, and patient agenda-setting skills Evidence Based Medicine/Information Mastery (EBM/IM) Skills: Searching the literature, statistics for clinical practice, patient-oriented evidence that matters, developing a PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome) clinical question Competencies evaluated included: Patient Care, Communication, Problem Based Learning and Improvement, Professionalism Demonstration of Level 2-4 Milestones Behaviors Methods OSCE scenarios were developed that measured an ability to utilize skills in evaluating information for preventive guidelines including screening as well as common clinical scenarios for treatment in daily practice. Example scenarios include: Osteoporosis screening Hyperlipidemia treatment Lung cancer screening Teaching faculty all have advanced training in communication skills and evidence-based medicine, and are interdepartmental (Family Medicine and Library Science) Standardized Patients (SP) go through a brief training process Evaluators of learners include faculty and SPs to allow for evaluation of competencies in patient-centeredness and EBM Learners must complete two OSCEs, each under 10 minutes duration in the presence of a faculty member, and demonstrate competency in PCC & IM techniques Residents were given brief formative feedback on their performance after each OSCE in the second year OSCEs were revised following each session, increasing the granularity of questions 4 & 5 on Faculty Evaluations Results Residents regularly demonstrated PCC, IM skills by achieving 70% or greater on evaluation questions Residents had the most difficulty with SDM, in ‘teach back’ technique such as Ask-Tell-Ask: 2015: Residents demonstrated 33% for all 3 questions 2016: 18% for all 3, with ≤50% for each sub- question This demonstrates that SDM can be performed in a brief encounter with real world scenarios Limitations/Future Considerations This was not a randomized trial, and we lack a comparison group This OSCE has only been performed at one site Our institution has a dedicated team and financial support for SPs, faculty time and support for our simulation center 4 faculty observers and 4 SPs were required for each 4 hour of direct observation It is uncertain if this translates into real-world data especially given the paucity of trained faculty/community physicians in these skill sets Future OSCEs for training medical students in this field are in development within our institution Long term data on providers could be collected for retention of these skills, but would be difficult to achieve after graduation Continued modification of evaluation are in progress Acknowledgments Nancy Adams, MLIS, Amy Knehans, MLIS, AHIP Observed Structured Clinical Exam in Shared Decision Making Jay Zimmermann, M.D., David Richard, M.D., FAAFP, Todd Felix M.D., F. Samuel Faber M.D., FAAFP Penn State College of Medicine, Hershey, PA Example SP Evaluation Questions: Question 1 Did the resident introduce herself/himself to the patient and approach the encounter professionally? Question 2 Did the resident turn the computer to you to look up information together or show the results of the search to you? Question 3Did the resident discuss the harms of testing/ treatment? Question 4Did the resident discuss the benefits of testing/treatment? Question 5Did you feel you shared the role in decision- making? Question 6 Were you given the opportunity or encouraged to ask questions and discuss the information presented in a shared decision-making format? Question 7 Did the student present the information in a way which was understandable to you as the patient (or did they rely on medical jargon without asking if you understood)? Example Faculty Evaluation Questions: Question 1 Was the resident able to develop a clinical question to search at the time of the SP interview? Question 2 Did the source(s) allow for an up-to-date, best evidence answer to the question (evidence-based source/review versus expert opinion)? Question 3 Was an answer acquired in an efficient manner, (under 3 minutes) ? Question 4 Did the resident present and discuss the findings with the patient in a patient-centered format (Sub- questions: Asking permission, Open-ended questions, Summarization techniques) to allow for shared decision-making? Question 5 Was the patient encouraged to ask questions and discuss the information at hand to assure that shared decision-making occurred? (Did a ‘teach back’ occur?) Discussion Evaluation of competencies expected for future patient care is complex, but an achievable exercise for residency training programs This OSCE maps to higher level ACGME milestones for Family Medicine residents, and was used for CCC reporting To train a future generation of physicians capable of providing true SDM for ideal individualized patient care, we need to interweave clinical expertise with two aspects of care Information Mastery PCC skills This data has correlated with Physician Assistant student OSCEs at our site