South Italian “Phlyax” Plays Sean McGrath
Tarentum Paestum Magna Graecia Syracuse
The Phlyakes Plays: hilarotragoedia: “exhibition of the subjects of tragedy, in the spirit and style of comedy” tradition among the Greeks of Southern Italy also known as φλυακογραφία, (Smith) 5th-3rd centuries, especially 425-325 B.C. (Taplin 1) φλύαξ, ακος, ο. = jester; tragic burlesque. “φλυακές τραγικοί” (φλυαρέω = to talk nonsense, play the fool) (LSJ)
Aspects and Themes comic effect, parody of tragedy, traditional myths, & daily life gods and heroes (e.g. Hercules), tragic characters (e.g. Aegisthus, Antigones) the Trojan cycle, thieves, boxers, lovers, stock characters: greedy old miser, mischievous slaves, etc.
Issues of Interpretation Were these simply improvisations containing themes and characters from history and mythology, or actual scenes from specific Attic comedies? Or a mixture of both? The Phlyakes Vases: several hundred found in Southern Italy depicting memorable theatrical scenes with absurdly grotesque costumes on simple wooden stages A.D. Trendall, Margarete Bieber, and other scholars traditionally interpreted these as a totally native Italian tradition; recently, Oliver Taplin has connected them with Greek Old Comedy; in turn, H.A. Shapiro and Dwora Gilula have challenged Taplin’s analyses
Choregos Vase, Apulian Bell Krater, 400-380 B.C.
Hercules angers Apollo, 400-325 B.C.
Hercules abducts a woman from a shrine
Zeus visits Alcmene
Servants helping Cheiron up steps
Priam and Neoptolemus
Rape of Cassandra (not a phlyax vase)
Rape by Cassandra
Old miser Charinus with thieves and slave
Father and son fight over a woman -theme of old father competing with young son for a woman—precursor to Plautus Father and son fight over a woman
Dionysus and phlyakes watching a female tumbler Dionysus and phlyakes watching a female tumbler. Paestan vase attributed to Assteas
Slave Xanthias stealing pastries -Xanthias is the typical slave name Slave Xanthias stealing pastries
Taras/Tarentum
Phlyax vase with farmer, clerk, and learned lady
Phlyax vase with farmer, clerk, and learned lady, c. 400-325 B.C. “Sappho” fresco, Pompeii, c. 50 A.D.
Caricature of two boxers Costumes Caricature of two boxers
Masks Cup in the shape of a comic mask Terracotta representing an actor seated on an altar
Temporary stage buildings Digital Visualization of Phlyax stage, King’s Visualization Lab, Kings College, London
Digital Visualization of Phlyax stage, King’s Visualization Lab, Kings College, London
Influence on the Development of Roman Drama: Rhinthon of Syracuse (c. 323-285 B.C.): first to put phlyax plays/hilarotragoedia into written form followed by Sopater, Sciras, Blaesus (Smith) As the phlyakes died out in the late 4th century, the Oscans developed a form of satire and parody that came to be known as Atellan farce. This was brought to Rome, and played a part in the beginning of Roman comedy (i.e. Plautus)
Influence on the Development of Roman Drama (cont.): According to Richard Beacham, the “early Roman entertainments were characterized by satirical abuse, expressed in uninhibited jesting and crude verse… The performances were essentially plotless, comic ‘turns,’ which probably took shape in response to a good deal of audience comment and encouragement.” (Beacham 13) No evidence suggests that the phlyakes had a direct impact on the early Roman entertainments, but considering the shared themes and comic elements (slave beatings, shrewish old women, father and son fighting over a woman, greedy slaves, greedy old men, etc.) a connection is entirely plausible (Beacham 9)
Bibliography Beacham, Richard. The Roman Theatre and its Audience. London: Routledge, 1991. Bieber, Margarete. The History of the Greek and Roman Theater. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1961. Liddell, Henry George, Robert Scott, Henry Stuart Jones, and Roderick McKenzie, eds. A Greek-English Lexicon. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996. McDonald, Marianne and J. Michael Walton, eds. The Cambridge Companion to Greek and Roman Theatre. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. Smith, William. A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology. London: John Murray, 1873. Taplin, Oliver. Comic Angels and Other Approaches to Greek Drama through Vase-Paintings. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993. Trendall, A.D. Phlyax Vases. London: Institute of Classical Studies, 1967.
Images Beacham, Richard. The Roman Theatre and its Audience. London: Routledge, 1991. Bieber, Margarete. The History of the Greek and Roman Theater. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1961. http://posting-thoughts.blogspot.com/2011/09/greenes-thesis-in-poetry-as- inovcation.html http://uga-thea4200.wikispaces.com/Required+reading+groups http://www.didaskalia.net/studyarea/visual_resources/greektemp3d.html http://ancienthistory.about.com/od/romeancientrome/ig/Maps-of-Rome-and-the- Empire/Southern-Italy.htm http://library.calvin.edu/hda/node/1101 http://library.calvin.edu/hda/node/1124 http://library.calvin.edu/hda/node/1128 http://www.artstor.com Trendall, A.D. Phlyax Vases. London: Institute of Classical Studies, 1967.