Students’ Rights: The CMA and beyond

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CMA approach to consumer enforcement: challenges and opportunities Presentation to the CMA Board 19 March
Advertisements

Complaints An Overview for Staff Prepared by MSM Compliance Services Pty Ltd.
Student Integrity and Misconduct Training and support for decision makers and Academic Integrity Officers.
Consumer Code for Home Builders Noel Hunter Chairman 1.
Complaints by Older Adults against Financial Institutions Examples and Possible solutions By Conor Cashman Senior Investigator.
ADVICE AND REPRESENTATION CENTRE = The ARC. What is the ARC Student Union department Independent Free Confidential Non-Judgmental Professional Experienced.
Tier 4 Visa Maintenance Requirements
FAQs about the new regulatory framework Lucy Rhodes
1 Satisfying Student Demand Conference London– 10 June 2008 Managing student complaints – ensuring transparency and fairness Robert Behrens The Independent.
Session 7 Compliance failure policy. 1 Contents Part 1: COLP and COFA duties Part 2: What do we have to comply with and why does it matter? Part 3: Compliance.
Competition and Markets Authority, consumer protection and HE admissions 12 October 2015 Dan Shaffer, Head of Professionalism in Admissions.
Legal Risk Assessment and contacts
Consumer protection one year on: reflections from the sector UCAS Admissions Conference, 21 March 2016 Janet Graham, Director of SPA Carys Fisher, Policy.
Complaint Handling What is a complaint ‘ Any expression of dissatisfaction, whether oral or written, and whether justified or not, from or on behalf.
January 2009: PRS Template Presentation PRS for Music Code of Conduct.
Consumer Protection Law and the Applicant Experience SPA Event Wales- Cardiff University, 2 December 2015 Janet Graham, Director of SPA.
External Examining Induction Event for new Examiners February 2017
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA (with notes)
SPA Programme outline 26/04/2018
Improving customer service
Communications and Marketing February 2017
An Overview for Staff Prepared by MSM Compliance Services Pty Ltd
Equality and Human Rights Exchange Network
CISI – Financial Products, Markets & Services
Investment Forum Regulatory Update Round
Fair Go Rates System Dr Ron Ben-David Chairperson
Privacy principles Individual written policies
HIPAA Administrative Simplification
Content of Tender Dossier Instructions to Tenderers
Good practice in entry requirements
The Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) & Integration Joint Boards
Lesson Objectives All students will understand the importance of regulation in some markets Most students will be able to assess the why the regulation.
EMPLOYMENT EQUITY ACT, No 55, 1998 (EEA)
NUS Charter on Complaints & Appeals
General Data Protection Regulations: what you really need to know
The UK Quality Code and Chapter B9
Marcus Claridge Director Energy and Water October 2017
Communications and Marketing November 2017
Managing Privacy in a Global Organization
ScHARR Bite Size Research Ethics and GDPR: legal requirements for research - what you need to know.
Data Protection and GDPR – An introduction for Baptist Churches
Consumer Protection Law (Application Stage)
Data Protection What’s new about The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) May 2018? Call Kerry on Or .
Fair Go Rates System Dr Ron Ben-David Chairperson
Red Meats Prospects Conference
Training for Local Authorities
General Data Protection Regulations 2018
Complaints Investigation Presenter: Ms H Phetoane Senior Investigator :HealthCare Cases Prepared for OHSC Consultative Workshops.
Complaints Investigation Presenter: Ms H Phetoane Senior Investigator :HealthCare Cases Prepared for OHSC Consultative Workshops.
Complaints Investigation Presenter: Ms H Phetoane Senior Investigator :HealthCare Cases Prepared for OHSC Consultative Workshops.
Complaints Investigation Presenter: Ms H Phetoane Senior Investigator :HealthCare Cases Prepared for OHSC Consultative Workshops.
Training for Local Authorities
Consumer Protection Law: HE Admissions
Training for Care Providers
Complaints Investigation Presenter: Ms H Phetoane Senior Investigator :HealthCare Cases Prepared for OHSC Consultative Workshops.
Academy Medical Centre
GDPR – General Data Protection Regulation
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR FULL-TIME UNDERGRADUATE AND PGCE STUDENTS (with notes) Student Finance is available so that students can make the most of their.
Complaints Investigation Presenter: Ms H Phetoane Senior Investigator :HealthCare Cases Prepared for OHSC Consultative Workshops.
A Review of Board of Health Liability
Training for Local Authorities
University of Brighton
An Overview for Staff Prepared by MSM Compliance Services Pty Ltd
ScHARR Bite Size Research Ethics and GDPR: legal requirements for research - what you need to know.
University of Brighton
Our transparency rules: update on implementation
National data opt-out - Preparing for implementation
University of Brighton
Student complaints and consumer rights issues
Presentation transcript:

Students’ Rights: The CMA and beyond Dr. Adam Wright, Research and Policy Officer (HE)

Why consumer rights matter It is often uncomfortable to talk about students as consumers. But consumer legislation provides protections to students that otherwise would not have been legally enforceable. You CAN argue against markets and consumerism in education and still use the laws available to uphold students’ rights. You do not need to pay a fee to be protected by consumer law. It is the provision of a service which matters, not cost of the service.

The OFT investigation OFT call for information on undergraduate provision in England in 2013. OFT were looking at potential issues relating to competition law and consumer protections. NUS submitted evidence to CfI on a number of areas: hidden costs, course closures, mis-selling of courses, variation of fees etc. OFT published report in March 2014, stating a number of areas which required further investigation. Further work taken up by CMA.

The CMA and guidance to HEIs The CMA was created when OFT and Competition Commission merged. CMA began investigating issues of consumer protection in HE and consulted NUS and students’ unions. Draft guidance was published in October 2014. The guidance was subject to a consultation, which NUS and some SUs fed into Nov-Dec ‘14. CMA will be releasing final guidance in February 2015 to HE providers, and will begin a monitoring phase to check compliance.

Key points for students and advisers Information Provision HEIs are required by law to ensure that the information they provide to applicants is accurate, easily accessible and covers what is necessary for student to make informed choice. Information on courses, their structure, and fees and costs, must be given before a student makes their application. Students must be made aware of additional course costs in pre-contract information. Students should be advised of any changes to course information as early as possible.

Key points for students and advisers Fair contract terms Contract terms must be easily located and accessed and available before student takes up offer. Terms should be written in plain language and not drafted in a way that could be unfair. A number of “blanket terms” used by HEIs are deemed unlawful and must be changed, including: Terms allowing university to massively vary course content and structure or increase fees (above inflation). Terms which limit liability of HEI for non-performance or sub-standard performance of educational service. (We have asked for clarification on what would be considered non-performance or sub-standard performance in law) Terms allowing HEI to impose academic sanctions for non payment of non-tuition debt (e.g. rent)

Key points for students and advisers Complaints Handling Students must have info about complaints procedures prior to accepting an offer. Complaints processes should be accessible to students (e.g. forms available on website). Students should be informed of external, independent redress (e.g. OIA), and follow external guidelines where HEI is a member. If a complaint is not resolved, students must be given the opportunity and info to escalate. Complaints must be handled within clear and reasonable timescales.

Key points for students and advisers Which students are covered? The CMA guidance discussed will apply to the whole of the UK, as consumer protection legislation is not devolved. While the original focus was on undergraduate, consumer law also applies to most postgraduate students (and potentially to FE as well). A student does not need to pay a tuition fee to be covered by consumer law (e.g. Scottish UGs)

What do you think? In groups, take a few minutes to discuss the following questions: What are the most prevalent (non-academic) issues/complaints for students? Is the CMA guidance just discussed useful in dealing with these issues/complaints? How difficult do you think it will be for your institution to comply with this guidance?

What happens now – compliance CMA will publish final guidance to HEIs and state a time period during which HEIs are expected to comply. CMA will monitor the progress of HEIs. If HEIs do not comply within the time period, they may be subject to sanctions. Students, advisers and unions can complain about practice at their HEI during the compliance period. CMA will not investigate individual cases but will log complaints as part of their monitoring of compliance.

Guidance for students and advisers The CMA are putting together resources for students and for student advisers to help explain the law and students’ rights. There will be posters and fact-sheets on students’ rights and more detailed guidance for student advisers. NUS is working with CMA to help disseminate these resources and better inform students of their rights. There will likely be a roundtable for advisers to discuss these materials with the CMA in February. More on this soon.

How best to inform students In groups, please discuss the following questions about how best to inform students about their rights: What do you think are the most important points to get across to students? What kind of guidance would be helpful to student advisers, and in what format would be best? When would be best opportunities to inform students?

For more information To speak to CMA about their guidance, you can email Oscar Plummer Oscar.Plummer@cma.gsi.gov.uk The NUS staff contact for this is Adam Wright adam.wright@nus.org.uk You can download the CMA guidance documents at https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/competition-and-regulation-in-higher-education-in-england