VSSC CollabCAD Testing Report - Evaluation of Issues 8th & 9th September 2010

5. SPLIT_PLANE_LONGERON.muz VSSC Test Parts 1.      AFT_END_RING.muz 2.      BULK_HEAD.muz 3.      CONNECTING_PLATE.muz 4.      FORE_END_RING.muz 5.      SPLIT_PLANE_LONGERON.muz 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT PARTS : 1 DETAIL AFT END RING      8th & 9th September 2010

PROCEDURE FOR AFT END RING 1.Draw sketch. 2.Revolve @ Y axis 3.New workspace for side holes(cylindrical slab) 4.Making cylindrical slab for side holes 5.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylindrical slab 6.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 7.Making cylindrical slab for bottom holes 8.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylindrical slab 9.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT PARTS : 2 DETAIL FORE END RING 8th & 9th September 2010

PROCEDURE FOR FORE END RING 1.Draw sketch. 2.Revolve @ Y axis 3.New workspace for upper side holes(cylindrical slab) 4.Making cylindrical slab for upper side holes 5.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylindrical slab 6.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 7.New workspace for lower side holes(cylindrical slab) 8.Making cylindrical slab for lower side holes 9.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylindrical slab 10.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 11.Making cylindrical slab for top holes 12.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylindrical slab 13.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.1.0 Not possible to Offset lines with fillets (curves). Only line entites supported in chain selection 1.Individually line / arc chain selectable. 2.RSE : For chain selection. (PTR 2323,2319) 1.2.1 Solid revolution about local / global axis .Resolved V 1.9.3 1.2.2 Entities not visible in grid. Resolved V 1.9.3 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.3.1 Model axis not available 1.Axis is not visible currently but face is selectable to apply the axial constraint. 2.RSE (Axis of cone/cylinder/revolution selection to be implemented.) Need to create Axis Entity 3.PTR 2165 / 1881 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.3.2 Surface not highlighted in shaded view. 1.Visibility due to opaque color of surface. 2.User can change color setting from Tools ---> Options ---> Part change transparency 3.For individual solid Select solid click right mouse button Select modify Select tab General Change Transparency 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.3.3 Workspace parallel to XY plane in solid revolution, model is not visible. PTR 2265 (Critical) 1.4.1 & 1.4.3 Circular patterning Total angle + angular spacing 1.Total angle by default 360 2.Angular spacing available. 3.RSE : Tree structure Reference solid should come under Pattern as a child node 4.RSE : Delete original reference Solid option to be provided. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.4.2 Clockwise / Anticlockwise direction for circular pattern 1.Available 1.4.4 Patterning on Inclined faces Making holes on inclined faces Test part required Instead above Edit ---> Array Copy ---> Cylindrical option used. 1.Working Fine. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.4.5 i. FBSM ( Feature Based Solid Modeling ) for hole. Hole is not selectable for pattern ii. Boolean Difference to be used for hole creation. 1.FBSM is not selectable for pattern as per basic modeling philosophy. 2.User has to pattern cylinder created on required location and check the box available in pattern dialog“Group All copies“ so that user can do boolean difference at a time. 1.5.1 Grids Disappear Suddenly when try to capture image. Working fine during File ---> Capture Image. 8th & 9th September 2010

1.5.1: Capture image with Grid points CollabCAD Window Captured Image 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.5.2 Documentation Documentation reg base point,center point and head point Resolved V1.9.3 1.5.3 Projection of edges, faces, vertices on current Work Plane IC2120 (GMA) 1.It is available while creating profile on current Work plane. 8th & 9th September 2010

1.5.3: Projection on current work plane PREVIOUS SKETCH AT DEPTH “0” NEW PROFILE AT DEPTH “100” 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.5.4 Face Extraction not available 1.Available. Surface-Explore-Selected Face. 2.If anything further required Please give details. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment IC2263 1.5.5 Measurement Tools a. Point to surface b. surface to surface c. radial parameters. Feature parameter like depth, diameter etc. IC2263 Available under Tools ---> Analysis. 1.RSE surface to surface. 2.RSE:Measure items for curve , edge, length, depth , radius. 3.Available for other issues like Point to surface, edges. 4.If anything further required please give details. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1.Not an issue. 1.5.6 Runtime Exception during Dynamics 1.Not an issue. 2.Check console for error if able to duplicate. 1.5.7 Fit in feature in shaded mode with all basic entities 1.Fixed in 1.9.2 2.IC2267 1.5.8 After making 105 holes, last operation for next 29 holes took long 1.Which operation was used? 2.What about the 105 holes? 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT PARTS : 2 DETAIL BULK HEAD 8th & 9th September 2010

PROCEDURE FOR BULK HEAD 1.Draw sketch. 2.Revolve @ Y axis 3.New workspace for holes 4.Making cylinder for upper holes 4.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylinder 5.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylinders 6.Making cylinder for lower holes 7.Array copy ---> cylindrical for cylinder 8.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylinders 9.Making cylinder for holes (4 nos X 2 times) 10.Taking difference of parent & cylinders 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 2.1.1 Surface Extrusion a. Linear extrusion direction not normal to Work plane Test part is required from TEST REPORT to duplicate. 1.PTR IC2336 ( Chenthil ) 2.Test part required. b.Bidirectional extrusion not possible 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 2.1.1 Linear extrusion : default extrusion is not normal to current work plane B. Biderctional extrusion Surface extrusion multiple entities 1.RSE a.Extrusion of profile to get - Free form surface - N no. of surface b.Solid trimming with free form surface. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES Observation # NIC Comment 2.1.2 Plane Cut Surface has to be created for defining split plane. RSE: Solid trimming issue and Test part is required from TEST REPORT to duplicate. 2.2.1 Systems Performance very poor. 1.Need to be supported with examples / parts , exact steps. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES Observation # NIC Comment 2.2.2 Hide elements are converted into Unhide elements vice versa if all curves selected from tree. This implementation as per design. For blanking / unblanking, enough options are available to user like individual selection and selection at tree level using shift + Arrow and CTRL key too. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES Observation # NIC Comment 2.2.3 Boolean Operation For making holes gives Null pointer exception Not able to duplicate. 1.Is it same as 1.4.4? 2.Please indicate operation 3.Test part required. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 2.2.4 Entity Selection via Tree Regarding selection of “n” no. of cylinders to cut from parent. Selection from canvas and tree are two separate operations Selection from tree is for edit This operation is not for modeling. It is allowed for certain operations like blanking/ unblanking , making analysis,modify,translate,delete and delete constraints. While array copy select the checkbox for group all entities so that while boolean cut all entities are selected at a time. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 2.2.5 Circular pattern Crash Pattern not allowed for curved surface (Refer 1.4.4). IF crashing, check will be added RSE: Cylindrical Pattern 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT PARTS : 3 DETAIL CONNECTING PLATE 8th & 9th September 2010

PROCEDURE FOR CONNECTING PLATE 1.Draw sketch. 2.Slab along -ve Z axis 3.Making slab for side holes(cylindrical slab) 4.Array copy ---> rectangular for cylindrical slab 5.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 6.Making slab for bottom holes(cylindrical slab) 7.Array copy ---> rectangular for cylindrical slab 8.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 3.1.1 Boolean Union Solid plates should become one solid and should not show intermediate lines. HLR & HLR with Back edges option available to user. 2.Part required. 3.1.2 Curved edge selection crash during solid blend 1.Part required. 3.1.3 Solid Blend crash 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 3.2.1 Solid Pattern (Rectangular) a.Use of Global Axis reg direction 1.Assumed Left to right + ve X Bottom to top + ve Y b.pattern on curve/inclined face 1.Currently pattern supports planar faces only. Alternate exists. 2 Part required. . 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 3.2.1 c.Delta row & Column value User can calculate delta row & column with respect to model size of particular view(Length x Breadth x Height). .RSE : Color coding to be implemented for row / column indication. d.Local Coordinate system for patterning. LCS of selected face Test part required 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 3.2.2 Boolean Cut one hole having extra surface. 1.Appears to be reference solid. Will provide User option to retain/remove reference solid. 3.3.1 Coordinate System & workview same highlights LCS & GCS but if workview changed LCS is not visible. 1.In user defined workspace both the GCS & LCS are available. 2.In the standard view this is not provided as it is felt that it is not required. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 3.3.2 Translate operation Not available w.r.t. LCS Available V1.9.3 ( Was available in development version since June 14th) 3.3.3 Dynamics can not be applied if input dialog active. This implementation as per design. 3.3.4 Refresh tree Provided V1.9.3 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT PARTS : 5 DETAIL SPLIT PLANE LONGERON 8th & 9th September 2010

PROCEDURE FOR SPLIT PLANE LONGERON 1.Draw sketch. 2.Slab along -ve Z axis 3.Making cylinder for side holes (4 nos.) 4.Array copy ---> rectangular for cylinders (4 nos. X 2 times) 5.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylinders (8 nos.) 6.Making cylinder for side upper holes 7.Array copy ---> rectangular for cylinders. 8.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 9.Making cylinder for side lower holes 10.Array copy ---> rectangular for cylinders. 11.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 12.Making cylinder for top holes 13.Array copy ---> rectangular for cylinders. 14.Taking difference of parent & array copy cylindrical slab 15.Drawing lines at an angle 26 & 33 16.Making surface by using lines. 17.Trim solid by using surfaces 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 4.1.1 Offset workplane 1.By changing origin create workspace. (Define workspace – New origin) 2. creation of profile at depth is also possible. V 1.9.3 4.1.2 Selection of origin at reqd depth Origin could be selected using RMB- Enter coordinates at reqd depth. 1.Refer 4.1.1 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 4.1.3 Creation of 2D Profile Available 4.1.4 2D Fillet Filleting & trimming can not be done together. 1.Trim of fillet is available in 1 step. 2.Remaining lines can be deleted. 3.The combined option can be provided to user. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES Observation # NIC Comment 4.1.5 Offset Surface as Workspace Resolved V1.9.3 4.1.6 Extract surface can not be used further Which operation? 4.1.7 Dynamics-rotate failure Test part required. 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 4.1.8 Solid Trim : surface missing Test part required. Such cases can also be supplemented with images 4.1.9 Zoom In or Shift K : surface appearing as open surface. Test part required. 4.2.0 Hole Creation on solid faces a.Solid pattern reference face Issue (For non planer) (Refer 2.2.5 & 1.4.4) b.Array Copy – rectangular w.r.t. LCS not available Resolved V1.9.3 8th & 9th September 2010

ASSEMBLY 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 1 Random Color issue 1.Ongoing work (MPR) 2 Edit-Rotate in Assembly module when 2 same parts available and rotate any one of them, both disappears. Not able to duplicate. Test part required. 3 Changing view software hanged. Increase system resource for heavy parts. 4 Restarted the session 8th & 9th September 2010

Assembly:90 degree rotation of one of the two same entities Inserting same component two times After rotating one of them by 90 degree 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES # Observation NIC Comment 5 a.last used directory to be set while opening file This happens on new CollabCAD session.For same session last used directory is used. b.Number of components loaded Into assembly & performance issue c.Assembly Reopen error Either part was corrupted or user had relocated the part. d.warning message on canvas Test part required. IGCAR 50 components inserted without problem 8th & 9th September 2010

DRAFTING (PLOT CONFIGURATOR) 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

GENERAL OBSERVATION 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010

TEST REPORT ISSUES 8th & 9th September 2010