RIEDP PDG Telecon15 – 28 July 2016 Modèle pour les Présentations Techniques sous PowerPoint 2003 RIEDP PDG Telecon15 – 28 July 2016 RIEDP DM Foundations Document Informal Review n°3 Référence – Date : E2Cxxxx du 10-03-2013 RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data.

Modèle pour les Présentations Techniques sous PowerPoint 2003 Agenda Introduction Members and Quorum Informal Review of RIEDP DM Foundations Document Presentation by DGE Feed back by PDG Members Other issues : Glossary, … Way Forward SIW 16 meeting Towards PDG formal Review Product 2 AOB OGC CDB NATO M&S Standard Profile (NMSSP) Conclusion RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016 Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data.

Introduction Web connection information Modèle pour les Présentations Techniques sous PowerPoint 2003 Introduction Web connection information Web connection information Thursday, 28 July 2016 4:30 PM France, 3:30 PM UK, 10:30 AM ET, 7:30 AM PT https://join.me/835-833-791 Tel Germany: +49.69.3329.6380 France: +33.1 82 88 35 90 Netherlands: +31.20.262.0571 United Kingdom: +44.33.0088.2634 United States: +1.860.970.0010 Connection code: 835-833-791# Phone numbers for other countries are also available https://join.me/intphone/781337013/0 RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016 Ce document est la propriété intellectuelle de Sogitec Industries, il ne peut être utilisé, reproduit, modifié ou communiqué sans son autorisation. SOGITEC Industries Proprietary Data.

PDG Communication Method Please join the RIEDP Community PDG SISO Discussion - Register for Discussion: Logon to SISO Discussions and select SAC-PDG-RIEDP (Don’t forget to select SUBMIT !) PDG SISO Webpage - Complete New Affiliation Form: Standards Activities > Development Groups > Reuse and Interoperation of Environmental Data and Processes (RIEDP) PDG PDG SISO Library File Folder – Access PDG Documents: SISO Digital Library > Development Groups > RIEDP PDG RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Introduction DG2 members - Attendance - Quorum Nom Prénom Organisme SISO Status DG2 Attending Voting BAILEY Grant UK MoD Current SISO Member  Yes CASTANER Gilbert SOGITEC COGMAN Jack DATASIM COX Rob PEO STRI / RDG No ENOCHIAN David USAF Not a SISO Member  TITCOMBE Tracy ? FAULK Mark LEIDOS unclear FOLEY Paul DOD Terrain MSEA NGA Current Member HOPKINSON Bill MSCO HUMPHRIES Roland XPI Simulation Expired Membership 2014  IGARZA Jean-Louis Antycip Simulation France MACCHI Warren ABAMIS MAMAGHANI Farid Self Expired Membership 2013  MARROU Lance MOORE Ronald Expired in 2014 PEELE Greg ARA REIF Andreas BwB ROBBINS Bruce US Army/PEO STRI/OneSAF Expired in 2012 SCRUDDER Roy Univ Texas SIEGFRIED Robert ADITERNA TABOURET Yann TT&S GOUGEAT PDG Chair RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Introduction PDG Affiliation List Members First Name Last Name Affiliation Email Created Paul Foley Consultant pjfoley2@verizon.net 9/24/2015 12:04 PM Arno Gerretsen NLR arno.gerretsen@nlr.nl 9/14/2015 1:54 AM Jean-Louis Gougeat Sogitec Industries jlgougeat@sogitec.fr 9/14/2015 3:57 AM Patrice Le Leydour THALES patrice.leleydour@thalesgroup.com 9/14/2015 4:51 AM Arjan Lemmers Netherlands Aerospace Centre NLR Arjan.Lemmers@nlr.nl 9/14/2015 4:25 AM Lance Marrou SE Core CVEM lance.r.marrou@leidos.com 9/14/2015 5:28 PM Andreas Reif German Armed Forces Andreas1reif@bundeswehr.org 10/15/2015 8:21 AM David Ronnfeldt Australian Defence S&T Centre david.ronnfeldt2@defence.gov.au 9/14/2015 5:55 PM Robert Siegfried aditerna GmbH robert.siegfried@aditerna.de 9/14/2015 4:53 AM Simon Skinner XPI Simulation Ltd - Thales UK simon.skinner@xpisimulation.com 9/14/2015 4:22 AM RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

DG1 DG2 DG3 DG principles Check Consistency Find PDG Consensus Approve within PDG Towards Balloting - Reference Doc - Copyrights Define for Doc1 & 2 : Doc Headlines Sections principles Guidances Wording by DGM Cross Reviews Identify Use Draft Doc1 Draft Doc2 Recommandations V0 Doc1 & 2 for PDG approval V1 Doc1 & 2 for balloting § allocation § wording Flesh out Doc 1 Find DGM consensus Align with Doc 2 Flesh out Doc 2 Align with Doc 1 DG2 DG3 Doc 1 = RIEDP Data Model Foundations (RPM+RADM) Doc 2 = RIEDP Detailled Features Description

Status of the RIEDP DM Foundations Document RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15

New version at a glance The RADM section has been completely revised The RPM section has been updated accordingly New sections on Conformance, Profiles, and Media-based data organization Details for RIEDP-required formats have been included Numerous other changes, including many new diagrams. The content of the document has increased by more than 50 pages. RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

RPM RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

RADM RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

What When Objective Target Informal Review n°3 The RIEDP DM Foundations Document : Version 1.0 When Launched on July 19 Dead Line : July 28 Objective Review of all sections Target Launch formal Review asap. Foundations RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Feedback so far: Expected Informal Review n°3 Paul Foley (USA) David Ronnfeldt (Aus) Expected USA : Greg, Roy, Rob, Lance, Ron, Anthony US Navy ? John Moore ? UK : Simon, Jack NL : Arno, Arjan GER : Andreas FR : Christian, Senior RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Glossary Difficult subject Separated from the main document to avoid disturbance On going action on Lance A proposal was submitted Result ? RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Way Forward RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Extension for additional Feed Back ? Informal Review n°3 Extension for additional Feed Back ? End of August 2016 Activate CTS ? RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Towards Balloting Main steps of the Process PDG Chair sends document to SAC SAC reviews and approves document for Official Review SAC establishes establish de Ballot Group SAC asks for volunteers for Review How ? Volunteers identify themselves How ? SAC check validity of the Group Review Period is launched Reviewers feed the CTS and Vote (Y/N/?) Comments are resolved by DG Resolutions are voted Reviewers reassess their vote Recirculation ??? ????? RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Instanciation to RIEDP ? RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

RIEDP Detailed Features Description RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15

RIEDP Detailed Features Description Approach During Telecon2, it was agreed that it was currently difficult to go into high detail on DG3 (Attribution subject) before the RADM is sufficiently stabilized. However, preliminary discussion was held during Telecon3 to analyze possible approaches. Core Team work current results : DG3 has now an impact on DG2 Attribution RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

RIEDP Detailed Features Description Approach Process Establish outlines based on Product #1 entries and Assess available Dictionaries and select the most suitable as the RIEDP reference dictionary Check what is available and what is missing in these dictionnaries Identify required extensions or additions to the dictionary Identify the required collection of Features (classes) and Attributes needed for RIEDP Define what is mandatory and what is optional Define how this collection can be described with the reference dictionary Identify mappings between RIEDP Attributions and those used by the initiatives/users This process will be incremental (for initialization and as for updates), it is important to define a flexible way of characterizing the underlying “Data model” of the attribution Features and Attributes. RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

RIEDP Detailed Features Description Next step Initialization of the RIEDP DFD Based on ??? Who ? DG 3 Volunteers ? Schedule End of 2014 Status during IITSEC RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Next Events RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15

SISO Fall 2016 SIW Next Events Who plans to attend ? Room Requested Forum West 3 (?) Wednesday 14 September 2016 Agenda Update of the Informal Review – Way forward to Formal Review RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Action Items RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15

Action Items Attendance RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

AOB RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15

OGC CDB CDB was a SISO Shared Specifications when that web capability came on online In 2015 it was withdrawn by CAE (taken off the SPS webpage) CDB is currently being processed by the OGC Open Geospatial Consortium. Initially as a « Best Practice » Lead by David Graham Request For Comments on draft standard : Started 12 April 2016 Closed 27 May 2016 Comment Resolution during June/July 2016 Situation Comments from CAE (!!!!) : approved Comments from Fraunhofer & ARA : Accepted for future work Comments from others (including TTS) : « comment or question with no call for a modification » RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

NMSSP NATO MS3 Group has issued the Nato M&S Standard Profile (NMSSP) The NMSSP contains several standards proposal about Terrain Including : CDB and RIEDP Each Alliance Nation have been invited to cast their vote Situation votes have been received from : CZE, ESP, FRA, GBR, NLD, NOR, ITA, DEU, AUS,TUR Votes are still expected from : BEL, CAN, EST, FIN, PRT, ROU, SWE, USA Summary to be provided by Adrian RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Conclusion RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15

Conclusion During Session RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15 28 July 2016

Backup RIEDP-PDG - Telecon15