Explain why the Liberals introduced their reforms (1906-1914) Quick revision guide.

Background In the nineteenth century, if one fell into poverty it was seen as your own fault. The government at this time pursued a “laissez-faire” policy towards social issues. To improve one’s situation, many people believed in the idea of “self help”, advocated by Samuel Smiles’ book of that name. Poor people relied on charity or the workhouse if they fell into poverty.

Why did the Liberals pass their reforms? 5 reasons 1. Booth and Rowntree’s reports. 2. Self interest. 3. Genuine motives to improve welfare. 4. National efficiency. 5. National security

The first reason… Charles Booth investigated poverty in London (1889) 35% of people lived in extreme poverty Produced by a sceptic… Well researched. Seebohm Rowntree investigated poverty in York (1891, 1903) 25% of the population in poverty. Defined a poverty line. Defined “primary” and “secondary” poverty. Impacts of these reports: The first time scientific studies had been done. Proved falling into poverty was often out of people’s control. Limits of the reports: Attitudes among the upper classes (in power) were slow to change The Liberal Reforms happened well after 1889. Evaluation: These reports were very important as their evidence showed that individuals or charities were not adequate to support a “deserving poor”.

The second reason… Self interest – the Liberals wanted to appeal to the working classes who now had the vote. The ILP (Independent Labour Party) or Labour Party (formed 1906) was growing in popularity. Impacts- this made many “New Liberals” (Lloyd George, Winston Churchill) push for the government to intervene much more in social welfare. Limits- no new reforms were in the Liberal manifesto and Campbell Bannerman was leader (he was not in favour of state intervention) Evaluation- political self interest was of limited importance as when the Liberals first took power in 1906, only limited reforms were introduced.

The third reason… Genuine concern for the poor: New liberals like Churchill and Lloyd George supported welfare reforms. There was a realisation that old “laissez faire” attitudes had allowed many to sink into poverty in the world’s richest nation. Impacts: Lloyd George and Churchill pushed for new welfare reforms and help for the poor. Limits: again, the Liberal leadership was controlled by an “old” liberal who did not want to intervene. There were no reforms in the Liberal manifesto. Evaluation: Genuine concern for the poor was somewhat of a motivation for the Liberal Reforms as attitudes towards poverty had been changing for some time, partially due to the reports of Booth and Rowntree, which were widely read and reported on among educated people.

The fourth reason… National efficiency: Concern that Britain was falling behind its competitors. Germany (and the USA) were overtaking Britain People were unemployed in some industries and there was demand for workers in others. Impacts: the Liberals wanted to improve education, health and set up Labour Exchanges to make Britain more competitive. Limits: the reforms introduced were far more limited than the Labour Reforms of post WWII and had limited aims, therefore this may not have been a top priority. Evaluation: This was an important motivation for the reforms because Germany was threatening Britain’s position in the world both militarily and economically.

The fifth reason… National security Britain went to war with the Boers in South Africa (1899). Britain almost lost. 25% of volunteers rejected due to failed medicals. Britain was now under increasing threat – could the Empire survive? Impacts: the Liberals introduced reforms to prevent children becoming malnourished (free school meals)and help people have enough to eat in case of war. Limits: the measures the Liberals brought in were quite limited and not that effective, so may not have been a high priority for the Liberals. Evaluation: Concerns for national security were a major reason the Liberals brought in reforms. Though their reforms were limited they were the first steps in improving a nation under increasing threat from a war with Germany.