MAGAZINES MAKE A DIFFERENCE

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Market Analysis Learning Unit 3.
Advertisements

Multichannel Personalization At Scale: Building Incremental Value With #dunnhumby.
The Proof 1 Newspapers reveal their unrivalled ability to increase the numbers of buyers who would ‘definitely consider’ a ford.
The Power of Magazine Advertising for brand building 1.
Newspaper Creative Benchmark Report Medibank Private Pet Insurance June 2011.
It’s a component of the Newspaper Effectiveness Metric which is run by the newspaper industry marketing body, The Newspaper Works. A monthly study designed;
Newspaper ads that demonstrate the strategic role of Extension.
It’s a component of the Newspaper Effectiveness Metric which is run by the newspaper industry marketing body, The Newspaper Works. A monthly study designed;
The Newspaper Effectiveness Metric. Content Why create a Newspaper Effectiveness Metric? The Newspaper Effectiveness Metric in summary Validation of the.
Media Neutral Cross Media Analysis Charlies Angels 2 Trailer.
Promotion – 1 Integrated Marketing Communications Professor Carl Mela BA 460 Product Management Fuqua School of Business Brand Management System On Building.
The Proof The business case for newspaper advertising as part of the media mix.
Commissioning Self Analysis and Planning Exercise activity sheets.
Newspaper Creative Benchmark Report Whiskas May 2011.
Newspaper Creative Benchmark Report ING Direct November 2010.
The Proof 1 The business case for newspaper advertising as part of the media mix.
YuMe Online Video Analysis CREATIVE BEST PRACTICES AND MEDIA TACTICS FOR ONLINE VIDEO.
Snapshot of Moments That Matter Data January 2016 For more information please contact:
Brand impact.
Newspaper Creative Benchmark Report Dan Murphy’s February 2011.
Chapter 8 Marketing the Facility and Events. Chapter Objectives 1.Clearly understand the elements of a marketing plan 2.Recognize the importance of a.
A Snapshot Review of Long Copy Ads 27 th April 2011 (Revised July 13 th 2011)
AN EFFECTIVE MEDIUM. MAGAZINES ARE A HIGHLY EFFECTIVE MEDIUM The ultimate benchmark of success for any advertising campaign, is whether it can change.
Graham Page, EVP Head of Global Solutions. MULTIPLE AND CONFLICTING PERSPECTIVES ON WHAT THE MARKETING IMPERATIVE TO MAXIMISE GROWTH SHOULD BE.
Delivering A Lasting Impression The Power of Promotional Products #PromotionalProductsWork.
The ROI study Methodology. Analysis conducted by Sally Dickerson, managing director of effectiveness consultancy The ROI study Part of the Omnicom Media.
Promotion.
Media Growth Summit, April 6, 2017
Effective Marketing.
The new influencer ecosystem FASHION BEAUTY AUTOMOTIVE
Frequency Works in Newspapers
Promotion.
Lesson 2: The role of marketing Marketing Objectives
Wake up and smell the bacon
Chapter 10 Media Planning and Strategy
BUSTING MAGAZINE MEDIA
Chapter 3.
BUSTING MAGAZINE MEDIA
Frequency Works in Newspapers
MULTIPLE AND CONFLICTING PERSPECTIVES ON WHAT THE MARKETING IMPERATIVE TO MAXIMISE GROWTH SHOULD BE
The multi-platform study
Promotion.
For Prospects, Profits and Prosperity
What will you receive today?
4 How Brand Advertising in Newspapers works best   AAMI   June 2009.
Chapter 6 Consumers and Competition
Why digital newsbrands deserve their premium
Investing In A Great Wedding Photographer Is Important
Tourism Marketing for small businesses
The L&D Portfolio Evaluation Model:
BUSTING MAGAZINE MEDIA
The multi-platform study
Amplify, Connect, Activate
Unit 5: Marketing Knowledge Organiser 5 The Role of Marketing
Supporting an omnichannel strategy Enabling an omnichannel strategy
Chart selection webinar
OutPerform How Out of Home is a gateway to personal time with brands
STRATEGIES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR COMPETITION
Why listen to me? Sr. Digital Marketing Specialist for Fastline Media Group Social media is my world Fastline has seen a… 1,044% growth in Facebook audience.
Kantar’s perspective on Brand Guidance Tracking Systems
SOCIAL MEDIA STRATEGY.
Cengage Learning Australia hereby permits the usage and posting of our copyright controlled PowerPoint slide content for all courses wherein the associated.
DON’T READ MAGAZINES IN PRINT
Workforce Engagement Survey
Chapter 9: Setting the list or quoted price
We put students first..
Category management capability and partnerships in 2014
Presented By:- Abhinav Shashtri. Index SR.NOTitleSlide No 1Introduction: Build Awareness: Buildup Brand Image: Content Improves Website.
Digital. Engaged. Our network is more engaging than social media.
Digital Marketing. What is Digital Marketing?  Digital marketing is the marketing of products or services using digital technologies, mainly on the Internet.
Presentation transcript:

MAGAZINES MAKE A DIFFERENCE

KEY TAKE-OUTS But salience alone isn’t enough SALIENCE IS UNDENIABLE IMPORTANT Meaningful difference is a brand equity measurement connected to long term financial brand health It super charges your brand growth Connected to repeat purchase and loyalty It’s effective at achieving a price premium MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCE IS A POWERFUL LONG TERM BRAND DRIVER Magazines deliver salience, meaningful and difference combined in the most cost effective way MAGAZINE MEDIA IS THE MOST COST EFFICIENT CHANNEL AT DELIVERING MDI (Meaningful Different Impact) As a targeted and often premium channel with a diverse creative canvas magazine media achieves uniqueness Editors specialist knowledge and trusted voice on trends means successful delivery of dynamism MAGAZINES ARE PARTICULARLY STRONG AT DRIVING BRAND DIFFERENCE

Meaningful Salience Difference VALUABLE BRANDS HAVE FIVE KEY PROPERTIES They are top of mind to consumers Consumers feel an affinity for them Consumers feel they will perform well and meet their needs They are seen as different or unique in the category They are dynamic and set category trends Meaningful Salience Difference Millward Brown has run thousands of brand equity projects, and a multitude of R&D studies to establish to how brand perceptions translate into sales. This demonstrates that successful brands have 5 key characteristics: They come to mind easily at relevant moments (salience) Consumers feel positively about them (affinity) People feel they meet their needs They are perceived to offer something unique Consumers think they are dynamic and leading progress in their category. These five attributes can be simplified in Millward Brown’s Equity framework into 3 dimensions - Salience, Meaningful, and Different. The strongest brands have all three properties, not just salience, and by measuring all three dimensions we can predict critical business outcomes, such as brand share, brand premium, and future brand growth or decline. Millward Brown Meaningfully Different Framework 2013

THE FRAMEWORK CAN PREDICT CRITICAL BEHAVIOURAL OUTCOMES LINKED TO ££££’s Potential Meaningful Difference Salience A summary of predisposition which predicts the probability that brands will grow their value share Premium A summary of willingness to pay more for a brand, which correlates strongly with the price-premium brands can charge A summary of brand strength which relates strongly to market share Millward Brown has run thousands of brand equity projects, and a multitude of R&D studies to establish to how brand perceptions translate into sales. Millward Brown Meaningfully Different Framework 2013

RELEVANT TO PLANNING AS THEY TRANSLATE INTO MEDIA BRIEF OBJECTIVES Meaningful Difference Salience Prominence, awareness, getting noticed, cut though Brand love, relevancy, new product development, change perceptions Brand story, repositioning, stand out, leadership credentials

A ‘MEANINGLESS’ BRAND THAT INCREASES SALIENCY WILL GROW A new analysis based on a comparison of data for 2,301 brands measured in BrandZ over a five year time frame finds that brands that are more meaningfully different than their size alone predicts grow faster when salience increases than those that are not. Methodological detail if you need it Before analysis the data set was cleaned to ensure comparability across time. The dependent variable was our Consumer Loyalty score, a measure highly predictive of behavioral market share. A comparison of cases where independent measures of market share could be obtained found a good correlation between the change reported by BrandZ and the independent source. Only 1 in 5 brands grew their market share significantly across the course of the five years (change is defined by a growth/decline of 4% points). In 4 out of 5 cases the growth was accompanied by an increase in Salience. However, once we allow for the influence of brand size it becomes evident that brands with “excess” meaningful difference in 2007/8 grew faster when salience increased. More meaningfully different brands grew projected market share twice as fast as the less meaningfully different brands. This in spite of the fact that the more meaningfully different brands were perceived to be 6% more expensive than average and the less meaningfully different brands 11% cheaper than average. An important side note is that this analysis suggests it is not easy to grow salience for big, well-known brands. The 1 in 5 brands that did not grow Salience were already more salient than average in 2007/8 and instead appear to have grown by improving meaning, difference or both. It is noteworthy, however, that these brand grew on average half as well as those that did improve Salience. This tends to corroborate the finding from How Brands Grow that loyalty strategies are generally less effective. Source: 2012/3 compared to 2007/8 for 2,301 brands measured in BrandZ

BUT DRIVING SALIENCY FOR A MEANINGFULLY DIFFERENT BRAND SUPERCHARGES YOUR GROWTH They have the foundation and competitive edge to maximise growth Source: 2012/3 compared to 2007/8 for 2,301 brands measured in BrandZ

MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCE IS LINKED TO REPEAT PURCHASE Brand buyers who go on to repeat purchase are more likely to perceive brands as meaningful and different, but salience makes little difference MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCE IS LINKED TO REPEAT PURCHASE Source: Combined MB & Worldpanel study, actual purchase behaviour and attitudinal data

SALIENCE FAILS TO PREDICT PRICE PREMIUM However, now let’s look at the same set of brands but compare the share of salience to how much was paid for the brand on average. The price data has been indexed relative to the category average. So 1.00 is the average price for the category. As you can see, there is no relationship between the share of salience and the price index. Brands can have the same salience but command hugely different price points. So what drives the ability of a brand to command a price premium? Source: PowerPurchase studies, 42 different brands

BUT MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCE DOES… Average Price Paid Source: PowerPurchase studies, 42 different brands

Media ranking by metric (top 3 shown) MAGAZINES UNIQUELY ARE A TOP 3 PERFORMER ACROSS ALL FIVE OF THE KEY METRICS Media ranking by metric (top 3 shown) Online Display Magazines TV Newspapers Online Video Radio OOH Cinema Salient 1 2 3 Salience Meets Needs Brand affinity 3 2 1 Meaningful 3 2 1 Unique Sets Trends Difference 2 3 1 It won’t have escaped your notice that Magazine advertising has appeared on a lot of the last few charts. And it’s clear from the analysis that we have done that advertising there performs consistently in promoting a side range of positive brand perceptions, among those reached. Magazines are in the top 3 in promoting all 5 of the characteristics of valuable brands. 1 2 3 Source: Magnetic/Millward Brown 2015 See additional slides for samples of individual metrics

WE REFER TO THIS AS MEANINGFULLY DIFFERENT IMPACT A MEANINGFULLY DIFFERENT IMPACT affinity unique WE CREATED A SINGLE METRIC WHICH AGGREGATES CHANNEL PERFORMANCE ACROSS ALL 5 METRICS. WE REFER TO THIS AS MEANINGFULLY DIFFERENT IMPACT top of mind meet their needs dynamic We wanted to turn this into a cost efficiency metric so we created a single metric - the meaningfully different impact that aggregates a channels performs across all 5 metrics and used this to assess the financial value we deliver for brands

+1.77% +1.59% MAGAZINES NO 1 AT DELIVERING MDI FOR BRANDS +0.89% Magazines and Cinema excel at helping brands deliver a meaningfully different impact for consumers TV Cinema +1.77% +0.89% 2% % Uplift in metric post exposure +1.59% Magazines On this basis, magazines came out top, meaning that among people reached by that media, we saw the highest average uplift in brand equity attributable to media exposure. A 1.77% uplift may not sound like a lot, but it is an average across a number of dimensions, and when translated into share shifts would mean a lot of money for brands, For comparison, TV came in in third place at at less than 1%. This clearly doesn’t suggest magazines are the only brand building channel, but it does show it is a consistently strong performing part of the mix. Up to this point, all the analysis has taken reach out of the equation, which is why, for instance the large cinema effects don’t translate into huge shifts across whole populations. We have bene specifically looking at effects among those reach by each media. However, we did also look at the picture when we did allow for reach - -ie the average effects attributable to each media, across the whole target population. Source: Magnetic/Millward Brown 2015 MDI Measure: Magazines n=22, TV = 83, Newspapers n=32, Online Display n=68, Radio n=29, OOH n=59, Cinema n=28, Online video n=9

MAGAZINES DELIVER THE BIGGEST MDI UPLIFT FOR £500K INVESTMENT 0.90% 0.31% 0.15% 0.19% 0.35% 0.13% 0.13% Magazines deliver c.1% MDI uplift for a £500k investment Magazines TV Newspapers Online Display Radio OOH Cinema Source: Magnetic/Millward Brown 2015 MDI Measure: Magazines n=22, TV = 83, Newspapers n=32, Online Display n=68, Radio n=29, OOH n=59, Cinema n=28, Online video n=9 *Low base size

DIFFERENTIATION To achieve a level of separation from other brands in the category due to sense of uniqueness or dynamism Focusing specifically on our area of strength we’d like to unpick this and show you how we deliver this for brands

TARGETED, PREMIUM CHANNELS CONTRIBUTE TO UNIQUENESS Magazine media has a diverse creative canvas that allows successful delivery of differentiation 3.6% Cinema % Uplift in metric post exposure Magazines +3.50% Radio +2.49% +0.71% To achieve a sense of uniqueness is best achieved by channels which are targeted in their nature so the product of service feels like something that is aimed at you, however uniqueness also needs to feel special and premium so the message is best conveyed in channels with high creative values and a diverse creative canvas Magazines – the information/detail provided in magazine ads might give brands more space to express their difference. For example mascara brands advertising 8x longer lashes etc. This messaging reaching a relevant audience, often with editorial and reviews proving or disproving the product could be amplifying this. Magnetic are building case studies to supplement this but you may want to add your own here

+2.86% +1.45% +0.83% SPECIALIST CHANNELS ACHIEVE DYNAMISM Specialist knowledge of magazine editors and their trusted voice on next new trend means they successfully deliver differentiation 3.6% Magazines % Uplift in metric post exposure Radio +2.86% Cinema +1.45% +0.83% Magazine editors and writers offer unrivalled expertise and specialist knowledge about their sectors and they are skilled and crafted writers in their subject areas, so people trust their point of view and they are able to curate / drive conversations about what’s next/ what’s a hot topic. While belonging and trust might be underlying factors it could also be down to the new news factor.  Often the first time we hear about a new products is through an ad or a review in a magazine, I’m thinking mainly about the health & beauty category but it could also work for food or tech. Magnetic are building case studies to supplement this but you may want to add your own here

CONCLUSIONS > SALIENCE IS UNDENIABLY IMPORTANT AS A GROWTH LEVER > MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCE IS A POWERFUL LONG-TERM BRAND DRIVER > MAGAZINE MEDIA IS A CONSISTENT ALL ROUNDER IN DELIVERING BRAND EQUITY > MAGAZINES ARE THE MOST COST-EFFICIENT CHANNEL IN THE MIX, AND PARTICULARLY STRONG AT DRIVING DIFFERENCE FOR A BRAND So – in conclusion…While marketing is changing, and marketing models are shifting, some truisms remain. Brand salience is a critical growth lever, but building a brand that is meaningfully different is also a critical goal, which should be a key brand KPI alongside salience, when planning and assessing campaign effectiveness. Different media channels have different strengths in influencing brand perceptions – and while a mix is always the best route for a campaign, magazine advertising is a consistent all-rounder. Magazines are a cost-effective way of promoting brand equity, and should be considered especially when brands are seeking to promote differentiation and dynamism. While digital channels may be instinctively considered more dynamic by the marketing industry, magazines’ impact on the dynamism of the brands that advertise in them belies that view.

MAKE DIFFERENTIATION A KPI

Appendix – notes on the methodology all three of these pieces of information for the same individual respondent that they have been able to understand how intuitive brand responses (or system 1 thinking) influence reflective thought about the brands (system 2) and how these ultimately combine to explain purchase behaviour. To read full paper about the Meaningfully Different Framework, click here Channel Analysis In order to assess the contribution that different channels make within the context of the Meaningfully Different framework, we analysed 88 FMCG campaigns from the Millward Brown CrossMedia database. Each channel’s performance was measured against the 5 key MDF metrics on an impact per person basis. Sample sizes for each channel are as follows: TV n=83, Newspapers n=32, Online Display n=68, Radio n=29, OOH n=59, Cinema n=28, Online video n=9, Magazines n=22. Cost efficiency calculations included reach of each channel, to ensure cost data reflected the contribution each channel made at campaign level. As the total number of campaigns in which online video was measured in less than 10 campaigns, the base was too small to include the channel in the final cost analysis. Who are Millward Brown Millward Brown is part of Kantar, WPPs data investment division. They have access to a large network of advertising, research and media agency experts around the world which strengthens their ability to help clients thrive and grow. They work with 90% of the world leading brands. They are industry leaders and innovators with over 40 years of experience in advertising, media and brand equity research. Meaningful Different Framework The analysis of historical Millward Brown (MB) data and a review of academic understanding of consumer decision making, suggested the hypothesis that Meaning, Difference and Salience are important influences on consumer purchase behaviour. To test this hypothesis thoroughly, MB setup a study across five countries (U.S., UK, France, India and Mexico), covering 12 categories, over 400 brands and more than 8,000 consumers. Furthermore, it was the first study to put together the following three elements on such a scale: Implicit measures of the fast, automatic, emotional, instinctive and subconscious thought process and heuristics, such as intuitive emotion – system 1. Survey-based measures of brand associations and equity – a combination of systems 1 and 2. Actual purchase data recorded through SMS diary and shopper panel – behaviour. It is only by holding.