OCRCC’s experiences in collecting HQoL data & preliminary findings

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Seniors Oral Health. Seniors Oral Health Introduction Maintaining healthy teeth and gums at any age is an important part of preserving your overall good.
Advertisements

Swallowing Outcomes in Head & Neck Cancer
Health-related quality of life in diabetic patients and controls without diabetes in refugee camps in Gaza strip: a cross-sectional study By: Ashraf Eljedi:
Supporting the oral cancer patient – what is the role of the dental team? Karen Matley Catherine Waldon Patient Involvement in Service improvement groups,
The 8th International Congress on AIDS in Asia and the Pacific (8th ICAAP), Colombo, August 2007 “HEALTH TESTING FOR MIGRANT DOMESTIC HELPERS WORKING.
Social Work Curriculum Development for Service Delivery and Collaborative Multidisciplinary Practice Elaine T. Jurkowski, MSW, PhD School of Social Work.
FDA Approach to Review of Outcome Measures for Drug Approval and Labeling: Content Validity Initiative on Methods, Measurement, and Pain Assessment in.
DENTURES AND QUALITY OF LIFE – A LONGITUDINAL ANALYSIS S.A. GRAY, M.R. INGLEHART & D. SARMENT University of Michigan, USA This study was supported by funds.
Louise Murphy PhD Arthritis Program, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta GA National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion.
1 The Patient Perspective: Satisfaction Survey Presented at: Disease Management Colloquium June 22, 2005 Shulamit Bernard, RN, PhD.
“The Effect of Patient Complexity on Treatment Outcomes for Patients Enrolled in an Integrated Depression Treatment Program- a Pilot Study” Ryan Miller,
Results From The 2000 Tri-Service Recruit Oral Health Survey CAPT Andrew K. York, DC, USN CDR Thomas M. Leiendecker, DC,USN Lt Col Gary “Chad” Martin,
QUALITY of LIFE Head & Neck Cancer and Chemotherapy Lisa Licitra Head and Neck Medical Oncology Unit Istituto Nazionale Tumori Milano.
Alcohol Consumption and Diabetes Preventive Practices: Preliminary Findings from the U.S.-Mexico Border Patrice A.C. Vaeth, Dr.P.H. Raul Caetano, M.D.,
Diabetic Youth Care Association (DYCA) Evaluation Study Diabetic Awareness Questionnaire “Bullack District Hospital” “Bullack District Hospital” Dr. Nihad.
Quality of Life and Influencing Factors in Ostomates Less Than 24 Months Post Surgery Thom Nichols Principal Clinical Research Statistician Hollister Incorporated.
1 Impact of Implementing Designed Nursing Intervention Protocol on Clinical Outcome of Patient with Peptic Ulcer By Amal Mohamed Ahmad Assistant Professor,
CoRPS Center of Research on Psychology in Somatic diseases Multiple myeloma survivors experience a low quality of life and many disease-specific complaints:
Psychosocial difficulties in head and neck cancer; the development of an evidence based measurement instrument Lucy Ziegler Rob Newell.
HRQoL workshop/Liverpool/ The extent of use and preference of a suitable HRQoL instrument for routine clinical use in head & neck cancer patients.
The Impact of Swallowing Function Pre- and Post Head & Neck Cancer Treatment Jo Patterson Research Associate / Macmillan SALT University of Newcastle /
The impact of cancer on survivors: data from a large national sample of older adults Don Baken, PhD Massey University Oncology Service.
Chapter 4 Survey Research.
JALILAH AL-HAMMALI ORAL COMMUNICATION
FLUORIDATED COMMUNITY WATER KNOWLEDGE AND OPINION AMONG PARENTS IN SOUTHWEST FLORIDA Courtney Uselton, DDS ; Maria E. Davila, DDS, MPH, DrPH; Scott L.
WHO Surveillance Tools for NCD Risk Factors – Instruments and Data Sources Surveillance and Population-based Prevention Unit Department for Prevention.
Emergency department pediatric psychiatric services
Ololade Olakanmi American Medical Association November 2007
The National Health Interview Survey: Celebrating 50 years of success
Exhibit 1 Poverty and Social Isolation Are More Prevalent Among High-Need Patients Percent reporting experiencing Notes: Social isolation = Reported.
Cardiometabolic Health for Adult Diabetics Living in Beijing China
An investigation of the effect of laryngectomy on swallowing and QOL
Long Term Effects of Surgery and Radiotherapy for Colorectal Cancer on Bowel Function and Quality of Life Gillian Knowles, Rachel Haigh, Catriona McLean,
Julia Searl Rusert, M.S.W., Ph.D. David Martin, M.A.
Brriers to healthy lifestyle
Design of interview schedules, questionnaires and checklist
Quality of Life after Total Laryngectomy Cyprus experience
Presentation by: Huynh Ba Phuong Linh
Swallowing function in people with Friedreich ataxia Megan J Keage a, Louise Corbenb , Martin Delatyckib & Adam P. Vogela Swal-QOL items (total) FRDA.
The association between nurses’ coordination with physicians and clients’ ability to die at home Takashi NARUSE, Natsuki YAMAMOTO, Takashi SUGIMOTO,
Poster Presentation Board Number: 231
Dr. Melba A. Hernandez-Tejada
Estimating need and coverage for chronic conditions through household surveys Ties Boerma, WHO, Geneva.
Veterans with life-limiting illness: Baseline descriptors
Guadalupe X. Ayala, PhD, MPH1 Jose Loredo, MD2 Elva Arredondo, PhD1
Dialysis Patient’s Satisfaction with their Dialysis Therapy
5th Coordination Meeting Agenda University of Donja Gorica
Cervical Cancer prevention among women in Vlora city: the influence of fear-related to possible positive outcomes Authors: 1*Fatjona Kamberi RN, MSN,
A feasibility study of an automated practice-based survey
Recognize and respond to physician distress and suicidal behavior
To use or not to use? An exploration of cannabis use motives and constraints Dr Liz Temple
Dr. Muhammad Ajmal Zahid Chairman, Department of Psychiatry,
Rhematoid Rthritis Respiratory disorders
Recognize and respond to physician distress and suicidal behavior
Clinical Presentation
Mirela Anghelina, M.D., M.P.H.
The Burn Injury Model System National Longitudinal Database A Primer on Using the Database Funded under a grant from the National Institute on Disability,
School Oral Health Program Maine CDC/DHHS
Objectives Oral health is integral to an older adult's general health and quality of life, and basic oral health services are an essential component of.
Presented by Hedayet ullah Roll: , Reg: Department of Microbiology Jessore university of science & technology Disease Prevalence at Jessore.
-2014 Korea National Health & Nutrition Examination Survey-
How the Affordable Care Act Has Improved Americans’ Ability to Buy Health Insurance on Their Own Findings from the Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance.
SPENDING NEEDS A BOOST According to the latest data from the American Dental Association (ADA)/Health Policy Institute (HPI), total dental spending.
In the name of Almighty, Eternal, Just And Merciful GOD
Solving Unknown Primary cancER (SUPER)
Greater Baltimore HIV Heath Services
Amani Abdullah Bahdailah
International Perthes Study Group
Patient-reported Outcome Measures
Teeth are one major part that makes your smile beautiful. If you do not want any issues and problems with your teeth and gums healthy then it is important.
Presentation transcript:

OCRCC’s experiences in collecting HQoL data & preliminary findings Raja Latifah RL, Atiya AS, Zain RB, Razak IA, Doss JG, Ghani WMN, Saub R, Ismail R. QoL in H & N Cancer 5th International Workshop, Liverpool 2-3 November 2006 rlatifah@um.edu.my

Aims of presentation To share OCRCC’s experiences: Challenges faced in collecting HQoL data; Preliminary data of HQoL status upon diagnosis prior to treatment

Selecting the interim instrument Those involved in discussion (14) Dentists/ doctors familiar with social health surveys Medical statistician Oral surgeons ENT surgeons Oncologists Pathologists Scientists Nurses/ research assistants

Criteria for instrument Need for HQoL tool for oral cancer patients in Malaysia in the interim period. Acceptable to clinicians & oral ca patients Short time; not more than 15 minutes Easy to use; not many items Easy to response; not too many responses For face-to-face interview not self administered Easy to understand

Selecting the interim instrument UW-QoL Ver. 4 EORTC General and EORTC H & N FACT

Pre-tested & Modified UW-QoL 12 items + 3 general No Q provided just item 3, 4, 5 possible responses OCRCC modified 11 items + 1 impact Removed anxiety, saliva, general Qs Added “opening mouth” Provided Qs 4 possible responses; no problem, some problem, severe problem, “Others”

11 Domains + 1 Impact

The question UW-QOL Ver. 4 Self administered This questionnaire asks about your health and quality of life over the past 7 days. Please answer all the questions by checking one box for each question. 2. Appearance OCRCC modified Interview I am going to ask you questions in relation to your oral cancer. (Only 1 response to be ticked for each question at each visit) Over the past 7 days did/ do you find any change in your appearance?

Responses UW-QOL Ver. 4 There is no change in my appearance The change in my appearance is minor My appearance bothers me but I remain active I feel significantly disfigured and limit my activities due to my appearance I cannot be with people due to my appearnace OCRCC modified Patient feels no change in appearance Patients feels there is a minor change in appearance Patient feels disfigured and avoids meeting people Others (Specify…………)

Data collectors Retired nurses & DSAs Trained data collectors: 2 workshops, on the ground assistance; hotline at HQ Q in simple English Training to understand meaning of Qs and information required How to conduct interview & ask Qs. Provided equivalent words in the national language

Data collection Face-to face interview At 1st visit (within 1-3 weeks patient informed of diagnosis). Other Qs as well. Subsequent interviews: 3, 6, 12 months; 2,3, 4, 5 years after 1st visit. Only HQoL Data collection started in late 2003 Development of software for data capture and computerization of data began in 2005

Workshop: Field problems faced by research clerks. 15 & 16 January, 2005 NGT & FGD used

Preliminary analysis 57 patients with complete data on staging and HQOL Diagnosed between Dec 2003 – Dec 2005

Socio-demographic characteristics 66.7% female; 33.3% male 56.1% Indians, 14% Malays; 14% Chinese; 15.9% Indigenous 14% ≤40 years, 43.9% 41-59, 42.1% ≥60 Mean age 56.74 ±11.84 years; 30-79 yrs 56.1% married; 43.9 single/divorced/widowed Income & Schooling: data poor; 25% NR

Cancer sites Tongue: 35.1% Buccal mucosa: 26.3% Alveolar ridge: 21.1% Palate: 5.3% Retromolar region: 3.5% FOM: 1.8% Uncoded: 7.0%

Histopathological staging Stage 1: 15.8% Stage 2: 28.1% Stage 3: 15.8% Stage 4: 40.4%

Few with problems No problem with shoulder: 86.0% No problem opening mouth: 84.2% Speech is the same as always: 82.5% No change in appearance: 78.9% Taste is unaffected: 78.9% Continues to enjoy recreational activities: 70.2% As active as always: 70.2%

Pain Total with pain: 63.2% Pain but does not require painkillers: 38.6% Requires painkillers, activities disrupted: 24.6% Pain in 100% Chinese, 56.2% Indians; 2/3 of Malays, 2/3 Indigenous Pain in 100% of aged ≤40 years; 60% of ≥41 years

Depressed Total depressed: 47.4% Occasionally depressed but life goes on: 47.4% Feels very depressed by cancer and feels moody: 0%

Chewing Total with problem chewing food: 40.4% Chews only soft food: 35.1% Avoids eating solid & soft food, pain & discomfort when chewing: 5.3%

Swallowing foods Total with problem swallowing: 36.8% Swallows some solids: 12.3% Swallows only liquids: 17.5% Swallows only liquids & sometimes choke: 1.8%

Disruption of daily activities Total with activities disrupted: 24.5% Sometimes: 14.0% Always:10.5%

Conclusions A need for HRQoL instrument relevant for Malaysian patients (short, easily understood, easy to respond) Infra-structural problems in contacting patients Main problems: pain, depressed, chewing & swallowing.

Thank you Raja Latifah RL, Oral Cancer Research & Coordinating Centre Faculty of Dentistry University of Malaya 50603 Kuala Lumpur rlatifah@um.edu.my

Prevalence Source* Country Year Prevalence (%) PreC Cancer# 1 Pen. M’sia 1974/5 1.3 0.02 2 M’sia 1993/4 1.5 0.04 1 Dental Division, MOH (1977). Dental epid survey of adults in Pen. M’sia 1974/75 2 Zain RB et al (1995). Oral mucosal lesions survey of adults in Malaysia. MOH & UM, Malaysia; and Aichigakuin University, Japan. # Adults aged  25 years

Cross cultural comparison ASIR per 105 per year Source Time interval Population ASIR 1 94-98 NS 2.34 1 94-98 T’gganu 0.87 1 94-98 Perak 0.93 1 94-98 S’wak 1.02 2 94-98 Kelantan 1.10 3 2000 <developed (F) 3.72 3 2000 <developed (M) 5.98 Mukhriz H et.al (2003) Ghazali N et al (2001) http://www.whocollab.od.mah.se/expl/worldorcincm.html

Cost to patient & society Impact of Disease itself and treatment Household expenditure OH-QOL Physical limitation Psychosocial impact 16.2 years of life were lost per person dying of oral cancer. (National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention & Health Promotion, USA)

Pain Total with pain: 63.2% Pain but does not require painkillers: 38.6% Requires painkillers, activities disrupted: 24.6%