Talent Ready Utah Preparing The Next Generation of Workers From High School and Beyond June 7, 2017 Blair Carruth Assistant Commissioner for Academic Affairs Cyd Grua Director for Instructional Technology

Typical CTE Credentials Awarded by USHE Institutions Certificates of Proficiency – less than one year to complete/16 to 29 semester credit hours Certificates of Completion – one year to complete/ at least 30 semester credit hours Associate of Applied Science Degrees – two years to complete/63 to 69 semester credit hours

Carnevale’s Report on Certificates Carefully targeted certificates of less than one year can have economic value Certificates can make people more employable Certificates add value to degrees: 6% wage premium for associate’s degree, 3% wage premium for bachelor’s degrees Information taken from Certificates: Gateway to Gainful Employment and College Degrees, Carnevale, Rose, and Hansen, Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce, July 2012.

CTE Prepares People for Middle Jobs Taken from Career and Technical Education: Five Ways That Pay Along the Way to the B.A., Carnevale, Jayasundera, & Hanson, Georgetown University Public Policy Institute, September 2012

Educational Attainment for Workforce Preparation is Shifting Taken from Career and Technical Education: Five Ways That Pay Along the Way to the B.A., Carnevale, Jayasundera, & Hanson, Georgetown University Public Policy Institute, September 2012

Utah Median Incomes by Select Education Attainment and Age for Full-time Workers

USHE Utah Wages Information Dashboard http://higheredutah.org/data/utah-wage-information Uses DWS, USHE and UDA Data Has some limitations but is a good indicator of wage data for USHE graduates Example shows wages 5th year following graduation for graduates from all USHE institutions Credential 75th Percentile Median 25th Percentile Cert 1-2 yrs $ 46,027 $ 32,968 $ 25,219 Associate Degree $ 59,736 $ 42,453 $ 28,985

EMERGING INDUSTRIES Major Industry Specific Industry NAICS   Major Industry Specific Industry NAICS Healthcare Other ambulatory health care services 621900 Education Educational support services 611700 Business Services Office administrative services 561100 Home health care services 621600 Professional and Technical Management and technical consulting services 541600 Finance Securities, commodity contracts, investments 523000 Individual and family services 624100 Community care facilities for the elderly 623300 Specialized design services 541400 Computer systems design and related services 541500 Construction Building foundation and exterior contractors 238100 Transportation Support activities for transportation 488000 Warehousing Warehousing and storage 493000 Recreation Museums, historical sites, zoos, and parks 712000 Building finishing contractors 238300 Residential building construction 236100 Other schools and instruction 611600 Other professional and technical services 541900 Offices of physicians 621100 Outpatient care centers 621400 Business support services 561400 Facilities support services 561200 Information Other information services 519000 Offices of other health practitioners 621300 Other residential care facilities 623900 Architectural and engineering services 541300 Retail Trade Nonstore retailers 454000 Emergency and other relief services 624200 Scientific research and development services 541700 Source: DWS Utah WIOA Unified State Plan 2016 available on-line at https://jobs.utah.gov/wioa/wioastateplan.pdf

USHE Institutions have Developed more than 100 New CTE Certificates Over the last several years, USHE CTE directors and others have: Assessed current CTE offerings in the region Submitted a regional plan to the state offices at the USHE, the Utah State Office of Education, and the Utah College of Applied Technology Identified certificates and other programs that could be offered in high‐demand, high wage occupations and that are important to the region Identified how these credentials will stack to additional certificates, associate’s degrees, or other programs Identified ways these programs, or portions thereof, might be provided for delivery in high schools through concurrent enrollment Developed an implementation plan Created more than 100 new CTE certificates

Current Carnavale Studies https://cew.georgetown.edu/publications/reports/ Six Million Missing Jobs Learning While Earning: The New Normal Good Jobs are Back The Economic Value of College Majors The Economy Goes to College

Tools to Guide Students toward Career Preparation Utah Occupational Explorer https://jobs.utah.gov/wi/uocd/dashboard.html Utah Economic Data Viewer https://jobs.utah.gov/jsp/utalmis/#/ UtahMajors.org http://www.utahmajors.org/

Concurrent Enrollment as a Gateway to Career Preparation Utah launched its concurrent enrollment (CE) program in 1987 State-wide program involving USHE institutions and all 41 public ed districts, several dozen charters FY16, 29,750 Utah high school students earned 204,400 semester credits 1/3 of HS juniors and seniors – 52% of the HS graduating class – took at least one CE class

Concurrent Enrollment (CE) as a Gateway to Career Preparation FY1516 29,758 high school students participated in CE Earned 200,423 semester credit hours 27% of earned credit was CTE credit Utah launched its concurrent enrollment (CE) program in 1987 State-wide program involving USHE institutions and all 41 public ed districts, several dozen charters FY16, 29,750 Utah high school students earned 204,400 semester credits 1/3 of HS juniors and seniors – 52% of the HS graduating class – took at least one CE class

CE as a Gateway to Career Preparation Utah launched its concurrent enrollment (CE) program in 1987 State-wide program involving USHE institutions and all 41 public ed districts, several dozen charters FY16, 29,750 Utah high school students earned 204,400 semester credits 1/3 of HS juniors and seniors – 52% of the HS graduating class – took at least one CE class In the past 8 years, there has be declines in CE earned credit in Business and Health Science classes; growth in InfoTech.

CTE CE Highlights for FY1718 CTE Area # CTE classes # institutionsoffering NEWS Agriculture 5 2 New class: USU/Intro to Landscape Architecture/aligns to Landscape Mgt CE. USU and Snow offer the Agriculture classes. Business 30 7 Students can choose from Intro to Business, Accounting, Management. Entrepreneurship/Leadership classes are new this year. Even though there are a number of pathways in Business, CE enrollments are mediocre. Family & Consumer Science 29 New classes: USU/FCSE 1140 and 2040/Intro Sewing and Intermed Clothing Construction/align to Sports & Outdoor Product Design I & II CE. Health Science 44 Medical Terminology is the only CTE class in the top 10 high enrolling CE classes. It serves as a gateway to Healthcare pathways. Information Technology 50 Computer Science (CS) 1030, 1400, 1410 are the first three classes CS majors take in college. This year, WSU, DSU, and Snow added CS courses so that the full sequence is available through CE. Marketing 10 USBE revisions to Marketing Strands and Standards resulted in lost of 40% of CE Marketing classes. OK. Take more Business classes. Technology & Engineering 48 Trades 173 New classes: Snow will offer Carpentry/Construction CE classes so student can build a house. Several institutions have added Digital Media courses so there are 3-4 course pathways. Utah launched its concurrent enrollment (CE) program in 1987 State-wide program involving USHE institutions and all 41 public ed districts, several dozen charters FY16, 29,750 Utah high school students earned 204,400 semester credits 1/3 of HS juniors and seniors – 52% of the HS graduating class – took at least one CE class

3 Tools to Help Students Choose CE CTE Classes/Explore a Pathway CE Master List CE Exploratory Majors Pathway doc www.UtahMajors.org #1 Find the CE Master List at www.schools.utah.gov/CURR/earlycollege/Concurrent-Enrollment/Master-Lists.aspx . USBE Core Codes, at left, that start with 30 or a larger number are CTE classes. The Exploratory Majors Pathway encourages selection of the appropriate QL. Started with a rubric familiar to public education students: 8th grade College & Career Readiness class uses Holland Vocational Personalities to explore interest in different career paths. Utah Futures website allows students to save and revisit profiles throughout high school.

#2 CE Exploratory Majors Pathways based on Holland Schema used in 8th grade The Exploratory Majors Pathway encourages selection of the appropriate QL. Started with a rubric familiar to public education students: 8th grade College & Career Readiness class uses Holland Vocational Personalities to explore interest in different career paths. Utah Futures website allows students to save and revisit profiles throughout high school.

#2 CE Exploratory Majors Pathways also based on WWM and Perkins Clusters

#2 Select a CE course in a pathway… • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

#3 Liked that CE course … visit www.utahMajors.org Click on Exploratory Majors in the top navigation bar. • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

#3 Explore college programs in a pathway that interests you… • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

#3 Click on a college program in a pathway that interests you… • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

Click on Degree Map or Program Details … • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

…to learn what classes it takes. • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

Click on a Related Career… • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

…to learn about labor market info for graduates of the program. • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers

Questions? Find CE resources at Utahce.org Email CTE certificate or degree questions to bcarruth@ushe.edu Email concurrent questions to cgrua@ushe.edu • USHE created the same pathway schema for www.UtahMajors.org Students can:explore majors associated with CE courses o access labor market data on associated careers