The Political Salience of Cultural Difference: Why Chewas and Tumbukas Are Allies in Zambia and Adversaries in Malawi Zsolt Szabó.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Institutions Want stable democracy? Get the institutions right!
Advertisements

Ethnicity? Tribe? Ethnic Conflict? Tribalism? What word to use? Does it matter? In colonial and postcolonial Africa.
Building Blocks of Research Process
Theories of Development
The Comparison Essay in World History Writing Workshop #1 Sit next to someone with whom you can cooperate! Step 1: Read the question Compare the current.
Ethnicity? Tribe? Ethnic Conflict? Tribalism? What word to use? Does it matter? In colonial and postcolonial Africa.
Are new political cleavages opening up between globalization’s (perceived) ‘winners’ and ‘losers’? Edgar Grande University of Munich Chair in Comparative.
Colonialism in Nigeria Jenna Ward. Nigeria in the 1900s.
* When conducting qualitative research one is faced with the difficult task of interpreting the data. The following has been created to help make sense.
Chapter 1 Section 5 Outline Geopolitical Framework: Fragmentation & Unity.
Kinship and Society. “Non-Kin” Organizing Principles  Age Sets  Special Interest Groups  Ethnicity.
APUSH ‘themes’ (B.A.G.P.I.P.E.)
© The McGraw-Hill Companies, 2005 TECHNOLOGICAL PROGRESS AND GROWTH: THE GENERAL SOLOW MODEL Chapter 5 – second lecture Introducing Advanced Macroeconomics:
Unit 2 Vocabulary Review for Test Chapter 4 Political Culture and Ideology Vocabulary.
Bell-Ringer Identify the major differences between presidential and congressional campaigns (232) What are the 2 kinds of campaign issues and.
Society views on interracial couples..  Summaries of Journals  Charts and tables  Book summary  Work cited.
Today’s theme is Power / Conflict 1. Native Am.s got along better with the French ( than the British ) in the 1760s because... Closure: When the British.
Ethnic Conflict and Political Instability in Sub-Saharan Africa MAIN IDEA: Many countries in sub-Saharan Africa are constantly plagued by ethnic conflict.
Identify the major differences between presidential and congressional campaigns (232) What are the 2 kinds of campaign issues and give an example of each.
WHY DO SOME SOCIETIES/ STATES/CULTURES FIGHT MORE THAN OTHERS?
Political Parties 4/17/2012. Clearly Communicated Learning Objectives in Written Form Upon completion of this course, students will be able to: – discuss.
By Nat Murphy.  Involves drawing conclusions about something based on a physical sign  Mystery Novels  Conclusions based on such reasoning are based.
How far do the unemployment statistics in the Weimar Republic help to explain the rise of the Nazis? By Mr S. DrewDownloaded from
Theme: electoral competition and manipulation of ethnic identity Politicians’ desire to win in political competition drives them to mobilize ethnic identity.
Identify the major differences between presidential and congressional campaigns (232) What are the 2 kinds of campaign issues and give an example of each.
Electoral Mobilization Turnout has declined in U.S..
Worldviews Perspective on historic treaties Treaties to the Europeans were originally land use agreements which were used to keep the peace and gain.
C HAPTER 10. Politics Without Parties: What Are the Consequences?  How do we know what parties contribute if we have never experienced politics without.
The Fall of the Ottoman Empire and Conflict in SW Asia
SOC 308 TUTORIALS Real Success SOC 308 Entire Course (Ash) FOR MORE CLASSES VISIT SOC 308 Week 1 DQ 1 Constructing Race SOC 308.
Vice Nigeria video Why do you think the Niger Delta region is so poor, even if they have huge oil reserves? What steps should Nigeria take to address.
Bell Work #7 What is the difference between: Nationality Ethnicity
Building Blocks of Research Process
Gender and Politics in Finland
2000 AP® UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS FREE-RESPONSE QUESTIONS The Constitution was an attempt to address problems of decentralization that.
Why has Kenya not Experienced a Full-blown Civil War?
Writing the Long Essay Question
AMERICAN GOVERNMENT. POWER AND PURPOSE, 8th Edition. by Theodore J
African Nationalist Movements
Globalization and National Cultures.
Unemployment and the Nazis: A fatal combination?
Political, Economic, & Social
“Non-Kin” Organizing Principles
Claims and Counterclaims
Lessons for the 21st Century
Sectarian VIolence in the Middle East: Myths and Realities
Literature review (a synthesis paper)
The Heat Equation for Two-Dimensional Objects
THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE.
AP World History Riverside High School Mr. Sakole
Do Now Journal #9 According to the Nacirema article, define these words: Shrines Charms & magical potions Medicine Men Ingredients written in ancient secret.
Interaction of politics and place
Are you sure we learned that?
2nd 9 Weeks Test Study Guide Answers
2nd 9 Weeks Test Study Guide Answers
Interaction of politics and place
& Political Socialization
The Determinants of Local and National Vote Choice:
Connecting words Vocabulary And But So Voting Then Election Because
Connecting words Vocabulary And But So Then Because When However
Political Geography of Africa
“Show Me” Standards (page 49)
Electoral College.
Chapter 3 The Idea Of Causation on Social Research
Make a list of 5 things that you would say might be wrong in certain situations Compare your list with the person next to you and come up with a common.
Make a list of 5 things that you would say might be wrong in certain situations 5 mins Bottom of test yourself page in booklet.
Political Geography SSWG3. Evaluate how cooperation and conflict among people influence the division and control of the earth’s surface.
Political Boundaries.
Identity and Diversity: Who are we? World Issues 120 Saunders
Lecture 24: Indecency of central bank
Presentation transcript:

The Political Salience of Cultural Difference: Why Chewas and Tumbukas Are Allies in Zambia and Adversaries in Malawi Zsolt Szabó

The Chewas and Tumbukas Both groups divided by the Zambia-Malawi border Border exists since the British conquest, set arbitrarily In Malawi relations between these groups are largely hostile, in Zambia friendly

Cultural differences as sources of conflict cultural differences often evoked when conflicts are analyzed, yet they cannot fully explain the emergence of conflicts Why some cleavages matter more? Suggested explanations: - Degree of cultural differences, progress in society The Malawi-Zambia situation seems to contradict the „Culturalistic” approach

Research setup Members of both groups were interviewed on both sides of the border Villages were similar: homogenous, no variation in geography and economy Questions: 5 questions: what makes Chewas different from Tumbukas? Would a member of your tribe vote for a member of the other tribe in the case this person stood for president? Would you personally? Are you married to a member of the other group? Would you consider it?

Findings small differences in language and culture 61 % in Malawi thought their group would not support a presidential candidate from the other group, just 21 % in Zambia, similar pattern by the marriage question

How to explain this discrepancy? Political system Electoral cycle Different experience during colonialism Higher relevancy of ethnicity in Malawi None of the approaches above is satisfactory

Relative size of the ethnic groups in their countries

Ethnicity as a basis for political mobilization Both countries work on the basis of patronage networks In Zambia, when the „ethnic card” is played, Chewas and Tumbukas are relatively small and are lumped together as „Easterns” In Malawi, they are the biggest ethnic groups and are played out against each other

Other findings Political hostility spills over to social situations An arbitrary drawing of a border just as potent in creating a sense of belonging as cultural differences (the case of the Tongas) – this fits constructivism better than primordialism

Conclusion ethnic diversity is a poor predictor of actual animosity, let alone violent conflict In The Malawi-Zambia example, the real reason of non-violent conflict is access to resources and politicians attempt to mobilize support along cleavages, with ethnic cleavages being the most obvious cleavage to exploit as they already exist, but cleavages can be created artificially (by drawing a border arbitrarily). However, cultural differences alone, without politicians playing the “ethnic cards” are not enough for conflict Conflicts rarely start out as ethnic, but they can become one after politicians instrumentalize cultural differences to mobilize support and thus divide their country along ethnic lines

Critical notes and questions for discussion a well-written article about an often neglected region It shows that the instrumentalization of cleavages by elites is critical for the emergence of animosity It is also a clear example against the essentialist “ancient hatreds” argument It also suggests interesting questions: if identity is seemingly so easily created, why couldn’t other states, that were carved out arbitrarily by colonial masters, ignoring ethnic-cultural realities (Sudan, Iraq) come up with a common identity? Thanks to what factors didn’t the hostilities in Malawi turn violent?