Obstacles to Peace? Israeli Settlements and BDS

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
186 National Socities.
Advertisements

Born of War, or Design? D ebating the Palestinian Exodus of 1948.
Jewish Settlements… An illegal obstacle to peace? CLICK ON MOUSE TO ADVANCE SLIDES ijm An ICIC QuickFacts Presentation.
The Palestinian-Israeli Conflict. 1947: U.N. Partition of Palestine The UN proposed an Arab state and a Jewish state. The UN proposed an Arab state and.
I- Full Israeli withdrawal from all the territories occupied since II- Achievement of a just solution to the Palestinian refugee problem to be agreed.
An Introduction What about Justice? Rob Dalrymple PhD.
The Arab-Israeli Conflict Part 2 CFR Crisis Guide: The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict –
Two States for Two People? One bi-national State for all? Can the Conflict Come to an End?
July Threats facing Israel: 1. Demographic issues 2. Security: conventional, terrorism, long-range missiles 3. Delegitimization.
Settling the West Bank and Gaza Or is it Gaza, Judea and Samaria?
1 Historical Background to the Palestine-Israel Conflict Prepared for the Forum on the Palestine-Israel Conflict 09 May 2002 at the UP PCED Hostel By Rey.
Palestinian Refugees and IDPs Al Nakba and Ongoing Nakba.
UNISON: Is our pension scheme investing in the occupation? Palestine Is our pension scheme investing in the occupation?
I Care About Peace, I care about Susya How to ask your Senators and Representatives for help to stop the demolition of the Palestinian Village of Susya!
The Holy Land My Land, Your Land My House, Your House.
RE-FRAMING The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. Why Should This Conflict Matter To Us? The conflict is emblematic -- In the Muslim world -- In the global.
Arab-Israeli Conflict. Ongoing Occupation Issues.
IssueIsraeli PositionPalestinian Position Final Status of Jerusalem Jerusalem will be the capital of Israel. Israel will have sovereignty over Jerusalem,
+ Arab Israeli Conflict What is the perspective of the cartoonist?
New Borders and the Arab- Refugee Problem War of Independence  Naqba.
The Region in Question A Brief Background Diaspora – Jews scattered from the region by the Romans (Romans name the area “Syria Palaestina”) Byzantine.
Israeli Palestinian Conflict. Jerusalem: Holy City to Jews, Muslims, and Christians.
Palestinian-Israeli Conflict. The Founding of Israel In the late 1800’s Jews in Europe sought to create a homeland for the Jewish people. Jews were subjected.
Wither the Peace Process?. UN Resolution 242 (November 2, 1967) The Security Council, Expressing its continuing concern with the grave situation in the.
Palestine & Israel at cross roads by Fariz N. Mehdawi IAPC 40 th World Conference Bali – Indonesia 13 th November 2007.
Things I am Going to Talk About  History of Palestine  The Jewish People’s Connection to Palestine  Zionism  The Birth of the State of Israel  The.
Arab-Israeli Conflict
Attempts at Peace. Arafat accepts 242 & 338 (1988) Condemns violence Recognizes Israel Accepts UN Security Council Resolutions 242 (Israel withdraw from.
Objective: To take a position about the Israeli occupation of territories after the Six Day War in Do Now: With your table! Go through the VOCABULARY.
{ Born of War, or Premeditation? Benny Morris and Nur Masalha debate the Palestinian Refugee Problem.
Institutional and Legal Issues in Managing shared Water Resources The Arab Region's Experience Chara Ksia League of Arab States.
The Israeli- Palestinian Conflict. The Ottoman Empire Lost in WWI From the Palestinian perspective: The Ottomans were Turks but at least they were Muslims.
Conflicts in the Middle East the Holy Land Conflicts in the Middle East aka the Holy Land Former territory of Ottoman Empire, becomes British Mandate of.
Two State Idea: Israel – Palestine Shaul Arieli 2014.
Top 10 Things to Know About the Israeli—Palestinian Conflict
Occupation and its Impact on Identities and Self-Determination.
Conflict in the Middle East Israel & Palestine. History of the conflict Jews, Christians, and Muslims trace their histories to Palestine Most Jews left.
The Palestine Center Annual Conference 2004 Implementing the International Court of Justice Ruling on the Wall: The Role of States and Civil Society The.
About BADIL  Established 1998; not-for-profit, Palestinian human rights organization;  Advancing a Rights-Based Solution: Empowering.
About BADIL  Established 1998; not-for-profit, Palestinian human rights organization;  Advancing a Rights-Based Solution: Empowering.
ISRAELI- PALESTINIAN CONFLICT: PRESENT PRESENT.
Born of War, or Design? Reading Benny Morris and Debating the Palestinian ‘Exodus’ of 1948.
Arab-Israeli Conflict. WHO? Arabs- any member or close relative of any Arabic speaking people (Islam) Palestinians- An Arab living in Palestine (Israel)
+ Arab Israeli Conflict What did the British do to help to create the Arab-Israeli?
A Historical Summary of the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict.
Occupation and its Impact on Identities and Self-Determination.
ARAB ISRAELI CONFLICT PART II
Religion Peace and Conflict
Refugee Crisis During the 1948 War, at least 726,000 Palestinians fled the country during the war, leaving behind their homes, property and in many cases.
What do Americans want Trump to do in the Middle East?
Significance: UN and the Origins of the Cold War
The Conflict:
ARAB-ISRAELI CONFLICT
GCSE Knowledge organiser Arab Israeli Conflict
The 1967 War The Israeli army captured all of Jerusalem, the West Bank, the Sinai peninsula, the Gaza Strip, and part of Syria (the Golan Heights).
Arab-Israeli conflict
Significance: UN and the Origins of the Cold War
IS THERE A PATHWAY TO PEACE?
Roles for Palestinian Israeli Conflict
Israel and Palestine.
The Arab-Israeli Conflict
Palestinian Refugees and IDPs
Roles for Palestinian Israeli Conflict
Israel and Palestine.
Palestinian Israeli issues
Palestinian Israeli issues
The Developing World Final Project Model Presentation
Arab-Israeli Conflict
Tuesday, May 21st HW: Aim: What efforts have been made to achieve peace between the Arabs and Israelis? Do Now: Why is the historic region of Palestine.
Module 2: Jerusalem March, 2018.
Presentation transcript:

Obstacles to Peace? Israeli Settlements and BDS

BDS / 3 Demands End Israeli Occupation of Palestinian Territory and end Israeli colonization and settlement of Palestinian Land; Recognize the right of Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality; Respect and promote the right of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and property.

John Kerry / Speech on Israeli Settlements We have to be clear about what is happening in the [Palestinian] West Bank. The Israeli prime minister publicly supports a 2-state solution to the conflict. But his coalition is more committed to settlements than any in Israel's history…. In 1978 the State Department legal advisor advised Congress that Israel's government program establishing civilian settlements in the occupied territory is inconsistent with international law. We see no change since then to affect that fundamental conclusion. December 23, 2017

Barak Obama / Cairo Speech “The United States does not accept the legitimacy of continued Israeli settlements. This construction violates previous agreements and undermines efforts to achieve peace. It is time for these settlements to stop” June 4, 2009

Settlements / Unabated Expansion 2008-17

Israel Approves Wave of West Bank Settlement Expansion Emboldened by Trump Israel Approves Wave of West Bank Settlement Expansion By Isabel Kershner Jan. 24, 2017 JERUSALEM — In a pointed act of defiance, Israel on Tuesday approved a huge new wave of settlement construction in the occupied West Bank. The announcement made clear that just days into the Trump presidency, the Israeli government feels emboldened to shake off the constraints imposed by the Obama administration and more willing to disregard international condemnation.

In Historic First, Israeli Settler Politicians Invited to Attend Trump Inauguration Yesha Council hails “different attitude” of new administration, weeks after Obama failed to veto UN resolution condemning settlements Jeremy Gimpel Yehuda Glick

Questions What are the origins and legal standing of Israeli settlements in the Palestinian Territories? Do Israeli settlements pose an intractable obstacle to resolving the conflict? Why have settlements emerged as a primary target of the BDS Movement?

Argument Israeli settlements in the Palestinian West Bank (and Gaza) have always been, and continue to be violations of international law. Israeli settlements, in their cartographic configuration, constitute the most intractable impediment to peace between Israelis and Palestinians. The settlement problem under the Trump Administration is likely to become more pronounced, and is likely to exacerbate the conflict.

Partition, War and 1949 Borders

Birth of the Palestinian 1947-48 Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem

Palestinian Refugees (1947-49) “There are circumstances that justify ethnic cleansing. A Jewish state would not have come into being without the uprooting of 700,000 Palestinians. Therefore it was necessary to uproot them…. It was necessary to cleanse the border areas and main roads…to cleanse the villages…I know it doesn’t sound nice, but that’s the term we used at the time.” Benny Morris Ha’aretz Interview (2004)

Where Did Refugees Go? Place # (est) Jordan/W. Bank 400,000 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Jordan/W. Bank 400,000 Gaza 220,000 Lebanon 120,000 Syria 75,000

Victors and Vanquished (1947-49)

1947-49 Dilemma of Victory What to do with the Abandoned Palestinian Towns and Property?

Depopulation and Settlement

Lifta

June, 1967 -- Dilemma of Victory? What to do with West Bank / Gaza?

The ‘Allon’ Plan (July, 1967) “Settlement” “We have never held territory without settling it.”

Fourth Geneva Convention (1949) Article 49 “Individual or mass forcible transfers, as well as deportations of protected persons from occupied territory to the territory of the Occupying Power or to that of any other country, occupied or not, are prohibited…. The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.”

The Meron Memorandum Jerusalem, 13 Elul 5727 18 September 1967 TOP SECRET To: Mr Adi Yafeh, Political Secretary to the Prime Minister From: Legal Counsel, Ministry of Foreign Affairs Subject: Settlement in the Administered Territories At your and Mr Raviv’s request, I am enclosing a copy of my memorandum on the above subject, which I submitted to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. My conclusion is that civilian settlement in the administered territories contravenes explicit provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention. Regards, Theodor Meron

Creating a Legal Basis for Settlement Law of War / Law of Belligerent Occupation “It is especially forbidden ... to destroy or seize the enemy's property, unless such destruction or seizure be imperatively demanded by the necessities of war.” Hague Regulations (1907), Article 23, paragraph g “Any destruction by the Occupying Power of real or personal property belonging individually or collectively to private persons, or to cooperative organizations, is prohibited, except where such destruction is rendered absolutely necessary by military operations.” Geneva Convention (1949), Article 53

The Nexus of Settlement and Security From 1967–79 the state of Israel used military orders to confiscate 61,000 dunums of land (15,000 acres) for 19 settlements, primarily in the Jordan Valley in accordance with the Allon Plan, ostensibly for reasons of security. “We here in the Jordan Valley cultivate thousands of dunums of land. These lands are – let us tell the truth – the lands of Arabs.” Jewish Settler, Jordan Valley (1978)

The Legality of Israeli Settlements UN Security Council Resolution 446 (1979) “determines that the policy and practices of Israel in establishing settlements in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967 have no legal validity…”

The Israeli Legal Position * Palestinian Territories are not occupied but “disputed.” * Geneva Convention (GC) covers only forcible transfers; Israelis have settled voluntarily. Article 49 was intended to prevent transfers of population of the type carried out by the Nazis. * Israeli settlers returning to areas of Jewish settlement prior to 1948. * Legality of settlements was resolved by Oslo Agreement which holds that the fate of settlements is to be determined by future negotiations. After Oslo (1993), Israel was no longer an occupier. http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/business/legality-is-in-the-eye-of-the-beholder-1.101181

Letter of the State Department Legal Advisor Concerning the Legality of Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Territories Washington DC April 21, 1978 To: Reps. Donald Fraser and Lee Hamilton / Committee on International Relations From: Herbert J. Hansell, Legal Counsel, Department of State Subject: Israeli Settlement in the Occupied Territories Secretary Vance asked me to reply to your request for a statement on the legal considerations regarding the Israeli civilian settlements in the territories occupied by Israel. I am providing the following response to that request. While Israel may undertake actions necessary in the occupied territories to meet its military needs and to provide for orderly government during the occupation, the establishment of the civilian settlements in those territories is inconsistent with international law. Very Truly Yours, Herbert J. Hansell https://www.jstor.org/stable/20691910?seq=3#page_scan_tab_contents

‘The Bloc of the Faithful’ Gush Emunim

The ‘Allon’ Plan (July, 1967) “Settlement” “We have never held territory without settling it.”

Gush Emunim /Elon Moreh Ascent (1975-78)

Elon Moreh Decision (1979) On behalf of the village of Rujeib and its residents, we ask the high court to nullify the order for the requisition of 800 dunums of land belong to village residents. We contend that the order has no military purpose. Its sole purpose is to take land for permanent civilian settlement. This is illegal and contravenes Israeli law. Izzat Muhammed Mustafa Dweikat “Our concern is not security but the commandment to settle the Land of Israel. Basing the land requisition orders on security …can only be construed in one way. The settlement is temporary and replaceable. We reject this conclusion outright. Our settlement is a permanent Jewish settlement, no less than Degania or Netanya.” Menahem Felix, Gush Emunim “It is not possible to seize private land in order to hand it over to Israeli civilians,… In this petition, there is a definitive response to those who seek to interpret the historical right promised to the nation of Israel in the Book of Books, as running contrary to property rights according to private ownership laws.” Moshe Landau, Chief Justice

Declarations of State Land Unregistered Land, Hilltops and the 50% Rule (Sinjil)