Finance and Development Conference

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Innovative Experiences in Access to Finance: Market Friendly Roles for the Visible Hand? Augusto de la Torre and Sergio Schmukler World Bank UN International.
Advertisements

Comments on What are the constraints on inclusive growth in Zambia? Elena Ianchovichina and Susanna Lundström Arne Bigsten University of Gothenburg.
Should Countries Promote Bank 0r Market Based Financial Systems? Why, When and How? Michael Fuchs, Adviser, Finance & Private Sector Development, Africa.
© International Finance Corporation The Importance of the SME Segment to Banks in Developing Countries A Perspective New Technologies for Small- and Medium-Size.
“HOW CAN FINANCE TRANSFORM ECONOMIES TO HIGHER LEVELS OF DEVELOPMENT AND HOW TO AVOID THE PITFALLS OF EXCESSIVE FINANCIALISATION?” Debate at the World.
SME Finance for Internationalisation Erich Kühnelt Wirtschaftskammer Österreich (WKÖ) Austrian Federal Economic Chamber.
SMEs Financing & Financial Policy SET AUNG 20 th December 2014 Picture sources: blogs.sap.com, pixgood.com.
1 The banking system in Israel in view of the global crisis Herzliya Conference February 4, 2009 Roni Hizkiyahu, Supervisor of Banks.
SMEs: Improving Growth and Containing Unemployment Munther Sharé President of Jordan’s Economic & Social Council JLGC - SME Conference November 24, 2014.
Comments on: Firm Growth and Finance: Are Some Financial Institutions Better Suited to Early Stages of Development than Others? by Robert Cull and L. Colin.
What Works for Financial Sector Development? A review of the evidence DIIS December 2 nd 2014.
APECCAM Cameroon Bankers’ Association Mathieu Mandeng PRESIDENT.
MACROECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS OF FINANCIAL CONSTRAINTS 1. Credit crunch. 9th set of transparencies for ToCF.
1 ARE LOAN GUARANTEE PROGRAMS EFFECTIVE? by Dale W Adams The Ohio State University.
Dubai SMEs Issues & Challenges Essa Al Zaabi, Senior Vice President Dubai Chamber 21 May 2014.
Developing Corporate Debt Market in India The 3 rd Invest India Debt Market Round Table May 6, 2003 Rakesh Mohan Deputy Governor Reserve Bank of India.
1 Focused and Coordinated Development of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs): The Malaysian Experience Conference on SME Financing: Issues and Strategies.
Credit Guarantees-Session III Alain Ize. What justifies public guarantees: Stiglitz-Weiss or Arrow-Lind? Externalities (Public lending benefits > private.
The Economics of Higher Education Presentation by Robin Sherbourne to the Polytechnic of Namibia 22 January 2003.
Eng. Osama Al-Mobarak Director of Kafalah Financing Guarantee Program, SIDF (K.S.A)
OVERVIEW OF CAPITAL MARKET DEVELOPMENT IN THE LAC REGION Carolin A. Crabbe Infrastructure and Financial Markets Division INTER-AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK.
Discussion Monetary Policy and Financial Stability: Is there a conflict? Ami Barnea, Yoram Landskroner and Meir Sokoler Paul Wachtel New York University.
Public-Private-Partnerships and Finance Patrick Legros* ECARES, ULB * Part of work in progress (Dewatripont-Estache-Grout-Legros)
Assessing the effects of collaterals and guarantee on loan pricing under the IRB approach: a comparative-static analysis R. De Lisa*, M. Marchesi**, F.
Actual trends and risks in the Slovak banking sector Štefan Rychtárik National Bank of Slovakia BACEE Country and Bank Conference Budapest, 14 – 16 November.
1 Comments on Hancock, Peek, and Wilcox and Wilcox and Yasuda Sole Martínez Pería (World Bank) Presentation prepared for the World Bank, Rensselaer Polytechnic.
The Global and Regional Outlook Olaf Unteroberdoerster Resident Representative, Hong Kong SAR, International Monetary Fund Task Force on Economic Challenges’
Credit Fluctuations in Latin America: Stylized Facts and Policy Issues XXV Meeting of the Latin American Network of Central Banks and Finance Ministries.
Financial market supervision and stability Seminar to mark the 20th anniversary of the Czech and Slovak Central Banks Marek Ličák.
Comment on “A More Complete Conceptual Framework for SME Finance,” by Berger and Udell Zoltan J. Acs Ph.D University of Baltimore and Max Planck Institute.
Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION EN JEREMIE and economic development based on innovation in Poland? Manfred Beschel Directorate General for Regional.
“SMEs: Improving Growth and Containing Unemployment” JLGC - SME Conference November 24, 2014 Robert Dressen, Senior Banking & Financial Services Advisor,
1 Credit Growth: Enhanced Access or Higher Risk by Giovanni Majnoni IADB “ XXIII Meeting of the Latin American Network of Central Banks and Finance Ministries.
Discussant Comments on “Revisiting Economic Growth in Colombia: A Microeconomic Perspective” Ben Clements International Monetary Fund IADB Project on Competitiveness.
Kevin Chow Senior Manager Research Department Hong Kong Monetary Authority 9 October 2015 F INANCING D IFFICULTY OF S MALL F IRMS IN C HINA.
Should the Government be in the Banking Business? The Role of State-Owned and Development Banks Eduardo Levy-Yeyati (UTDT) Alejandro Micco (IDB) Ugo Panizza.
REPUBLIC OF BELARUS INTERNATIONAL ENTREPRENEUERSHIP FORUM Increasing Competitiveness of the Belarusian Economy - Access to Finance of Households and Firms.
Managing Risk in Financing Agriculture - Expert Meeting Johannesburg 1-3 April 2009 Synthesis of the Expert Meeting “Johannesburg Findings”
Comments on: Public Initiative to Support Entrepreneurs: Credit Guarantees versus Co-Funding by Arping, Loranth and Morrison and Are Loan Guarantees Effective?
RESTARTING EUROPEAN LONG-TERM INVESTMENT FINANCE Andrea Polo (UPF, Barcelona GSE) CEPR Financial Regulation Initiative London, 30 September 2015.
Introduction A central piece of the current reform of the Cuban economic model is the creation of alternative spaces for small-scale private sector and.
Housing Finance in Emerging Markets: Policy and Regulatory Challenges The World Bank Washington, DC March 10-13, 2003 Role of Land and Urban Development.
FINANCIAL DILEMMAS OF SMES IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES YAO WANG.
SME Financing to Promote Innovation in Korea Soon-Yeong Hong.
IMF conference march 2011 Book august leading economists reassess Economic Policy.
Public Sector Partial Credit Guarantee Programs: What, Why, When and a little bit of How? Frank Nieder Lead Financial Markets Specialist Capital Markets.
FINANCIAL LIBERALIZATION, CRISIS, AND RESCUE: Lessons for China from Latin America and East Asia.
TOPIC 1 INTRODUCTION TO MONEY AND THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM.
1 IUHF World Congress June 25, 2004 Lessons from Best International Practices Loïc Chiquier The World Bank Housing Finance Business Group Financial Sector.
Capital Market for raising finance for SMEs
Macro-Financial Review H June 2016
 CIS 7 Poverty and Growth Conference Investment Climate and Financial Sector Reforms EBRD 1.
R. V. Verma National Housing Bank India
THE PEER MONITORING ROLE OF THE INTERBANK MARKET IN KENYA
Rebuilding Lebanon’s Banking Sector – A POST WAR SUCCESS STORY
Corporate Governance in Arab Countries
MGT601 SME MANAGEMENT.
How can Entrepreneurship help create Wealth for Economies, Businesses and Communities Thabo Thamane Chief Executive Officer CEDA Global Expo 24th November.
Public Sector Partial Credit Guarantee Programs: What, Why, When and a little bit of How? Ambitious for 10 minutes. summarize key issues, and allow.
BUSA Presentation to the Portfolio Committee on Economic Development
Development Bank’s Perspective By Dr. Stephen Robert Isabalija
Changes in the Cost of Bank Equity and the Supply of Bank Credit By C
Revisiting the Financial Accelerator Hypothesis
Chairman OECD Working Party on SME and Entrepreneurship
What’s holding back the private sector in MENA?
Hungary: Growth, Competitiveness and Innovation
MICRO: Enhancing Competitiveness of Micro-enterprises in Rural Areas
Improving SME Access to Finance: the Role of Government
Scaling Up SME Access to Finance
by M. Ayhan Kose Research Department International Monetary Fund
Presentation transcript:

Finance and Development Conference Promoting SME Finance: When and How? Comments on How Collateral Laws Shape Lending and Sectoral Activity by Charles Calomiris, Mauricio Larrain, Jose Liberti, Jason Sturgess Discussion by Sergio Schmukler Finance and Development Conference November 2, 2016 World Bank Washington, DC 1

Two difficult tasks Comment on a great paper, already accepted for publication Discuss broad issue of SME finance posed by the session Does fostering SME finance matter for economic growth? What works and what does not work in fostering SME finance? The role of the government in promoting SME finance Do all this in about 10 minutes And provide comments to own co-authors

Calomiris et al. paper Need of collateral for lending Movable vs. immovable collateral Weak laws hamper use of movable collateral & might tilt production toward immovable-intensive sector Contribution Great paper Several pieces of evidence, including financial and real activity Proprietary bank data in 12 emerging economies Case study of Slovakia Sectoral data Innovative and persuasive, tackling main issues Need for this kind of research, which adds to cumulative evidence Still leaves questions for further research

Calomiris et al. paper More obvious points, some already addressed Omitted factors Reverse causality, endogeneity of collateral laws Conclusions: distortions in financial and economic activity? Other effects besides LTV How firms use more finance Effects on immovable collateral Mitigating factors Leasing, technological innovations (blocking devices), financial innovations (bitcoin), formal solutions (NAFIN), informal solutions Might make movable collateral laws less relevant Effects of collateral laws vs. other laws

Does more SME finance matter for economic growth? Would need to answer at least three challenging questions Do SMEs need more financing? If SMEs receive more financing, do they grow more? If SMEs grow more, how much do they matter for overall growth? Difficult to address even the first question Fact: SMEs borrow less and in worse terms than other firms Due to problems in supply- or demand-side of capital? If supply-side problem, which one? Many possible, concurrent answers, with unclear relative importance Better off intervening?

What works and not in fostering SME finance? Big push to provide more financing to SMEs Based on Evidence of SMEs not getting good finance Probable, real problem of access to finance for SMEs But even if there is a problem, of which type of financing is needed? Just more? Lower cost? Equity? Long-term debt? Solution depends on How risks get mitigated How risks get redistributed: creditors vs. debtors Even if more financing pushed, not clear what SMEs would do with it Don’t know this even for large corporations

Role of the government Do more than providing good macro and institutional environment? Even under market failures, can government failures be avoided? General principles Identify binding constraints Crowd in private sector Work closely with private sector Still … Which instruments/policy should be used? Which institutions should conduct interventions?

Role of the government – Policy Type of policy Example Verdict Contractual-based measures Calomiris et al.  Information-based measures Credit bureaus Market infrastructure NAFIN, Mexico Catalytic role FIRA, Mexico Public guarantees FOGAPE, Chile ? Direct lending Public banks: retail and wholesale

Role of the government – Institution Type of institution Example of interventions Verdict Ministry of Finance/Economy Subsidies ? Central bank Regulations, bureaus Superintendencies SME programs Public banks From traditional to innovative International organizations World Bank, IADB, CAF: loans, guarantees, others

Thank you! 10