HUMR5140 Introduction to Human Rights Law Autumn 2013

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS MECHANISMS
Advertisements

Poland Basel Protocol on Liability and Compensation Financial Limits And Insurance Questionnaire 2 Ratification Krystyna Panek - Gondek Chief Inspectorate.
European Enforcement Order for uncontested claims
SOURCES OF EU RIGHTS LAW Article 6 TEU indicates three sources for EE Human rights law. 1) EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, Which was proclaimed in Nice.
Den Europæiske Ombudsmand Der Europäische Bürgerbeauftragte Ο Ευρωπαίος Διαμεσολαβητής The European Ombudsman Il Mediatore Europeo Le Médiateur Européen.
The Court of Justice European Law in the Making. Terminology Jurisdiction Jurisdiction Venue Venue Standing Standing Chambers Chambers Plenary Session.
1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention and Brussels II bis Interaction within the EU and beyond Prof. Dr. Marta Pertegás First Secretary Hague Conference.
Data protection at Eurojust: a robust, effective and tailor-made regime Diana ALONSO BLAS, LL.M. Head of the DP Service/Data Protection Officer.
EU joining the ECHR New opportunities under two legal systems EQUINET HIGH-LEVEL LEGAL SEMINAR Brussels, 1 – 2 July 2010 Dr. Mario OETHEIMER EU Agency.
Introduction to EU Law Cont.d. ECJ – TFI (Arts ) “The Court of Justice and the Court of First Instance, each within its jurisdiction, shall ensure.
1 African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. 2 African Charter One of four regional human rights agreements Adopted 1981; entered into force 1986 All.
The Human Rights Act 1998 Mechanism Sections 1 and 2 of the HRA 1998.
History and Functions of the United Nations
Human Rights Act 1998 The European convention on human rights The European convention on human rights The Convention rights The Convention rights How does.
Course: European Criminal Law SS 2009 Hubert Hinterhofer.
Conference for LGBT families in Europe Overview of the work of the Council of Europe in the field of family law Sabrina Cajoly - Council of Europe Directorate.
Judith A. Oder Interights. Normative Framework OAU Refugee Convention 1969 African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights 1981 African Children’s Charter.
Announcements -Final Study Guide will be posted the beginning of next week. -Thursday, May 31 class will be a review session.
17 September 2008Maria Lundberg, NCHR1 JUR 5710 Institutions and Procedures Regional protection Europe.
European Court of Human Rights ZS a , Praha.
CHARTER OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS General overview, history and evolution.
INT 3131 INT 313: INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION Fall November 2002 The United Nations I: An Introduction.
HUMR5140 Introduction to Human Rights Law Autumn 2014 Lecture 8: Regional Human Rights Systems: Europe.
Jerzy Jendrośka Energy security and legal requirements for environmental protection, public involvement and transboundary co-operation Scientific support.
Acquis communautaire Community Acquis DEFINITION.
1 EU LAW WEEK 3 INSTITUTIONS OF THE EU. 2 INSTITUTIONS Institutions of the EU Principal Institutions Advisory Institutions 1.European Parliament 2.The.
The Brussels II Regulation The Council Regulation no 2201/2003 concerning the jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgment in matrimonial.
Enforcing Civil and Political Rights: Lessons from Europe Basak Cali and Anne Koch, The European Court of Human Rights Project, Department of Political.
Court of Justice of the European Union
Non-implementation of ECtHR rulings. Judgements of the ECtHR Article 46 ECHR – Binding force and execution of judgements Obligation to abide by the final.
European Committe for Social Rights. The Council of Europe was established in 1949 by 10 Countries. It has now 47 member States. The European Convention.
Execution of the ECHR judgments in Croatia Štefica Stažnik Croatian Agent before the ECHR Zagreb, November 2015.
European Labour Law Institutions and their Competencies JUDr. Jana Komendová, Ph.D.
Introduction to International and East African Human Rights Mechanisms Solomon Sacco.
HUMR5140 Introduction to Human Rights Law Autumn 2015 Lecture 7: Regional Human Rights Systems: Europe.
EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS Regional protection of human rights.
European Committe for Social Rights. The Council of Europe was established in 1949 by 10 Countries. It has now 47 member States. The European Convention.
The UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: 25 Years 4 June 2010 “The Influence of the UNCITRAL Model Law in Hong Kong and China”
The European Convention of Human Right Corso di inglese giuridico (M-Z) Prof.ssa C. M. Cascione Università degli Studi di Bari ‘Aldo Moro’ Lezione n. 10.
European Law in the Case- law of the Constitutional Court of Latvia Kristine Kruma.
LECTURE 11 ICJ INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE The statute of the ICJ consists of 70 articles and is annexed to the UN Charter. A UN member is an automatic.
HUMAN RIGHTS LAW. Ahmed T. Ghandour.. HUMAN RIGHTS IN EUROPE I.
HUMAN RIGHTS LAW. Ahmed T. Ghandour.. HUMAN RIGHTS IN EUROPE I.
Introduction to the UN human rights system UN TRAINING FOR TRANS ACTIVISTS SEPTEMBER 2015.
The EU Accession to the ECHR after Opinion 2/13: Reflections, Solutions and the Way Forward Dr Sonia Morano – Foadi and Dr Stelios Andreadakis European.
International Human Rights Law (LG 332) Topic 8: Regional Systems 1- Europe.
The European Court of Justice EU Institutions The European Commission The European Parliament The Council of the European Union The European Court of.
HUMR5140 Introduction to Human Rights Law Autumn 2011 Lecture 3: International Bill of Rights.
Seminar on EU Service Directive Budapest, 3 May 2007 Thibaut Partsch
Institutions Acting in the Social Policy and their Competencies
European Union Institutions Law Making
The Protection of Human Rights in Europe
HUMR5140 Human Rights in International and National Law Autumn 2016
European Labour Law Institutions Acting in the Social Policy and their Competencies JUDr. Jana Komendová, Ph.D.
Parliamentary and European Law Making Institutions of the European Union Notes:
THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE
Regional Systems of Human Rights Protection
English for Lawyers 4 Lecturer: Miljen Matijašević Session 6
THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE
European actions.
The European Convention of Human Rights
Fundamental rights.
Legal Environment for Business in Nepal 26 February 2017
Constitution and I’ll Law
European Committe for Social Rights
Introduction to protection of human rights under the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms Lucia Berdisová Department.
UNIT 23: . THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN EUROPE
Fundamental rights.
International Training Centre of the ILO
Making and Applying EU Legislation
Presentation transcript:

HUMR5140 Introduction to Human Rights Law Autumn 2013 Please note: Hyperlinks exist in slides 11 and 16 Lecture 8: Regional Human Rights Systems: Europe

Three prepared cases

Filling in some of the blanks

The European Convention on Human Rights The European Social Charter Many different European regimes EU’s Charter of Fundamental Rights OSCE Other CoE treaties Mainly civil and political rights Some absolute rights, but mainly relative rights Positive and negative obligations The European Convention on Human Rights An impact of ESC rights Integrated interpretation

Three threads in the creation and development of the ECHR European integration not only a matter of technical needs and economic interests; the ECHR embodies a system of liberal values The continuing concern for the protection of human rights Human rights as a tool to spread democracy to Central and Eastern European states

A quick history: The original control mechanisms – until 1998 A tripartite system The European Commission on Human Rights The European Court of Human Rights The Committee of Ministers Consider the admissibility of petitions Establish the facts Promote friendly settlements Give opinions of violations A judicial body Give final and binding judgments in cases referred to it A political body Give final and binding decisions in cases not referred to the Court

The revised control mechanisms Protocol No. 11, restructuring the control machinery, adopted on 11 May 1994, entry into force on 1 November 1998 A sidestep: Additional protocols: Do not amend the original text, but introduces additional rights. Do not require consensus; become binding for States that ratify Amending protocols: Amend the original text (“Since its entry into force on 1 November 1998, this Protocol forms an integral part of the Convention”). Require consensus, do not enter into force until all Contracting States have consented

Protocol no. 11 A tripartite system The European Commission on Human Rights Now established as a permanent body The European Court of Human Rights New, reduced role: To supervise compliance with decisions by the Court The Committee of Ministers Assumed (most of) the responsibilities of the Commission The competence of the Court became compulsory

A dramatic increase in cases A victim of its own success? Attempt at improvement: Protocol No. 14, entry into force 1 June 2010. Aims to guarantee the long-term efficiency of the Court by optimising the filtering and processing of applications New judicial formations to deal with the simplest cases A new admissibility criterion (“significant disadvantage”) Judges’ terms of office to be extended to nine years without the possibility of re-election. 2010 2011 Applications received 61,300 64,500 Applications disposed of 41,183 52,188 Annual deficit 20,100 12,300 Backlog 31 December 139,650 151,600 2010: 38,576 More than 90 % of cases are declared inadmissible 2011: 50,677

More than 90 % of cases are declared inadmissible 2010 2011 2012 Applications received 61,300 64,500 65,150 Applications disposed of 41,183 52,188 87,879 Annual deficit 20,100 12,300 + 22,700 Backlog 31 December 139,650 151,600 128,100 2010: 38,576 More than 90 % of cases are declared inadmissible 2012: 86,201 2011: 50,677

The life of an application Grand Chamber Admissibility Jurisdiction Relinquishment Procedural requirements Referral (appeal) Substantive requirements

Fundamental principles of interpretation The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties A strong principle of effectiveness A clear evolutive interpretation The European Court of Human Rights Fundamental principles of interpretation National courts For national law to decide «No less, but certainly no more» «No more, but certainly no less» A tendency to apply the same method as the ECtHR Challenge: The evolutive interpretation

Pilot-judgment procedure Introduced in 2004 as a means of addressing systemic problems in Contracting States which result in multiple applications to the Court One (or a few) case is given priority treatment, while other applications are adjourned until the pilot case is decided Justification: Speedier redress for victims The systemic problem is redressed within the national legal order under guidance from the Court A large number of repetitive cases may be removed from the Court’s docket Legal basis: Now «rule 61»

Examples of pilot-judgments Broniowski v. Poland (2004): Failure to compensate loss of property See paras. 189-194: The pilot-judgment procedure explained Burdov v. Russia (2009): Failure to enforce domestic court decisions Rumpf v. Germany (2010): Length of proceedings

Enforcement Art. 46 Binding force «undertake to abide by the final judgment» Execution of judgments Committee of Ministers Link to the video of David Cameron’s refusal to comply with the court: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-20053244 Referral to Court Interpretation procedure Infringement procedure

If time allows…: Reform issues Interlaken Izmir Brighton Protocol no. 15 Protocol no. 16