Trends in Financing Reforms Regional Higher Education Seminar

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Competitive Market in Public / Private Education.
Advertisements

Stability Pact for South Eastern Europe Task Force Education and Youth South Eastern European Education Reform Implementation Initiative Good Practice.
EAC HIGHER EDUCATION POLICY
Funding Mechanisms to Ensure Stability, Innovation and Sustainability in Higher Education Arthur M. Hauptman IUA Symposium-21 st Century Universities Dublin,
1 PRESENTATION TO OHIO SSI STUDY GROUP OVERVIEW OF FUNDING PRACTICES AND STATE EXAMPLES Brenda N. Albright September 29, 2005.
Performance-Based Funding in Higher Education Presentation by Arthur M. Hauptman Financing Reforms for Tertiary Education in the Knowledge Economy Seoul,
Tuition & Aid Advisory Board A Discussion of UCB Priorities and Funding Strategies September 27, 2004.
Report on CCHE Performance Contract Negotiations Jack O. Burns, Ph.D. Vice President for Academic Affairs & Research January 25, 2005.
Worcester Polytechnic Institute Presentation to the Advisory Boards October 13, 2006.
22-23 March 2006Weber, Financing Higher Education1 FINANCING HIGHER EDUCATION: PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SOURCES Conference to launch work on a Master plan for.
Impact of the Financial Crisis on Tertiary Education Jamil Salmi Budva, Montenegro 28 October 2009.
Financing Reforms for Tertiary Education KEDI-World Bank International Forum Seoul April 7, 2005.
Competitive Funding for Higher Education Richard Hopper Senior Education Specialist The World Bank Baku, Azerbaijan – May 13, 2009.
Transition from Regulatory to Market-Based Systems of Higher Education Maureen McLaughlin World Bank June 6, 2006.
The Financing of Higher Education EPPL 676 Dr. Pamela Eddy.
A review of innovative allocation mechanisms Jamil Salmi and Art Hauptman international forum on tertiary education financing Barcelona, 30 Nov-2 Dec 2005.
Major Dimensions of Financing Reforms Financing Reforms for Tertiary Education in the Knowledge Economy Seoul, 6-8 April 2005 n.
Addressing the challenges of Latvia’s Current Financing Model Adjunct Prof. Dr. Jussi Kivistö, World Bank Team September 24, 2014 Riga, Latvia.
Design and Implementation of Student Loan Schemes: Lessons from International Experience Forum on Financing of Post-Compulsory Education in China Beijing,
The Challenge of Establishing World-Class Universities Jamil Salmi Fontainebleau 30 April 2009.
Income Generation Strategies Income Generation Strategies Financing Reforms for Tertiary Education in the Knowledge Economy Seoul, 6-8 April 2005.
College Update Fall 2013 Sarah A. Rajala Dean James & Katherine Melsa Professor of Engineering.
Higher Education Policy in the U.S. Case Study for International Conference on Higher Education Maureen McLaughlin World Bank November 2005 Ankara, Turkey.
Possible Uses of Vouchers in Higher Education Presentation by Arthur M. Hauptman Financing Reforms for Tertiary Education in the Knowledge Economy Seoul,
Funding of Higher Education September 2011, Yerevan1 Performance Based Financing in Higher Education: Slovak Experience Peter Mederly Ministry of Education,
5/ WEM 2003, Lisbon, Portugal1 Student Loan Schemes: Lessons from International Experience HDNED World Bank.
Policy Workshop on Private Higher Education Damascus 8 December 2004.
New Governance Models: an international perspective Jamil Salmi London, 10 March 2008.
Governance and Financing Reforms: Latest Trends Jamil Salmi WBI Course 27 February 2008.
Improving Graduate Education in Developing Countries Jamil Salmi Dublin, 5-7 March 2008.
The Challenge of Establishing World-Class Universities in Developing Countries Jamil Salmi Glion Colloquium 22 June 2009.
The Equity Challenge in Tertiary Education Jamil Salmi Tertiary Education Coordinator WCHE Paris, 7 July 2009.
The Impact of the Financial Crisis on Tertiary Education Institutions Jamil Salmi OECD Conference June 2009.
Roadmap Project Higher Education Progress and Issues Astana June 2014 Dr. Mary Canning Former Lead Education Specialist World Bank Member: Higher Education.
International Trends in Governance Reforms Jamil Salmi Global Tertiary Education Expert Sofia, 19 March 2012.
1 VIETNAM HIGHER EDUCATION REFORM FOR THE NATION’S DEVELOPMENT Dr. Nguyen Thi Le Huong Deputy Director General, Dept. of Higher Education Ministry of Education.
Tilburg School of Economics and Management the Netherlands
Slovenian HE Challenges – Systemic Perspective
Advantages of Local Borrowing
FINANCING TVET TVET COSTING, DIVERSIFIED FINANCING SYSTEMS AND COST REDUCING STRATEGIES.
Making College Work: Pathways to Success for Disadvantaged Students
The Challenge of Establishing World-Class Universities
LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE PRESENT GENERATION OF HIGHER EDUCATION PROGRAMMES IN EASTERN PARTNERSHIP COUNTRIES Klaus Haupt, Head of Tempus Unit Education,
The Global Marketplace
Financial autonomy and accountability of the Public Higher Education Institutions: Lessons learned from the FAITH project Prof. Ass. Dr. But Dedaj Dean.
Fiscal Management.
CALS Faculty Senate Financial Review – April 2017
a review of innovative allocation mechanisms
Performance-Based Funding in Higher Education
Performance-based funding of higher education
Performance-based funding of higher education
Autonomous University in Thailand: Case Study of Kasetsart University
Financial Statement Analysis
Albanian VET Strategy and Action Plan for the period
The Global Marketplace
ENTREPRENEURIAL FINANCE Fifth Edition
What CPRs show: summary of major issues
Victoria Harker to open meeting. Pat Hogan:
The Growing Accountability Agenda: Progress or Mixed Blessing
Trends in Governance and Financing Reforms
Financing, resources diversification, private funds
Research Issues & Projects Sadiq M. Sait
Developing the power sector in Federal Nepal Main lessons from international experience Kathmandu, November 06, 2018.
Technical and Advisory Meeting
Charter School Funding in Massachusetts Policy and Practice
TRENDS IN EDUCATION Guntars Catlaks Senior research co-ordinator
Governance: Systemic Issues, autonomy and oversight
BOARD of GOVERNORS State University System of Florida
M&E for ACE II May 14, 2019 Saori Imaizumi Education Specialist.
The Impact of the Financial Crisis on Tertiary Education Institutions
Presentation transcript:

Trends in Financing Reforms Regional Higher Education Seminar Jamil Salmi Regional Higher Education Seminar Kuala Lumpur, 4 December 2007

key financing questions how much money is available for tertiary education? (resource mobilization) how are public resources distributed? (resource allocation) how efficiently are available resources used? (resources utilization) how fairly are resources distributed? (equity)

outline of the presentation resource mobilization resource allocation resource utilization

resource mobilization how much should be spent on tertiary education? (macro-level) income generation at institutional level who should pay, and what share? when and how? is it affordable? (student aid)

funding sources (macro) from public funding to cost sharing

fees for everybody / dual track undergraduate / postgraduate national policy / individual institutions special category students (repeaters, mature, part-time, continuing ed, foreign, out of state) one fee or program-linked? ceiling / freedom to set

optimal fees policy universal reasonable level (10 to 30%) associated with student aid adjusted to cost of living index

funding sources (institutional level) from dependence on public funding to diversified funding

main categories of revenues budget tuition fees productive activities donations loans

productive activities services consulting research laboratory tests patent royalties operation of service enterprise (hotel, retirement home, mall, parking) production of goods agricultural products industrial products rental of facilities (land, buildings, laboratories, dorms, driving-through)

donations direct monetary grants equipment land & buildings scholarships indirect (credit card, lottery, % of stock exchange trade) tied (access to patents) concessions

Traveler: $4 million endowment

financial planning capacity fund-raising team funding criteria contingency planning

outline of the presentation resource mobilization resource allocation

allocation mechanisms from untied funding to performance-based funding

innovative allocation mechanisms funding formula - output measures are used to determine all or a portion of funding formula (Netherlands) performance contracts - governments enter into agreements with institutions which set mutual performance-based objectives (France) competitive funds - support peer-reviewed proposals designed to achieve institutional improvement or national policy objectives (Chile) demand-side vouchers - finance the recurrent expenses of institutions indirectly through vouchers provided to students who enroll in the university of their choice

formula funding formula linking amount of financing and some measures of outputs number of graduates research productivity (publications, patents, licences, spinoffs) unit costs per level of studies / discipline (actual, average, normative costs) In Holland, on average students would spend 7.5 years getting their degree

Holland problem: weak internal efficiency (7.5 years to graduate vs. 4 in theory formula based on graduation rates 4,5 x cost of 1 student-year for graduate 1,5 x cost of 1 student-year for dropouts risk: too lenient on grading mitigation: rigorous inspection system In Holland, on average students would spend 7.5 years getting their degree

Poland problem: low enrollment and lack of qualified faculty formula combining enrollment and proportion of full time professors with a Ph.D In Holland, on average students would spend 7.5 years getting their degree

competitive funds set objectives competition on the basis of projects transparent rules & criteria peer review and selection independent monitoring committee

competitive funds (II) avantages better designed projects transparent process aligned with strategic goals of institution limitations hardware projects without vision how do you support the weaker ones?

performance contracts institutional agreement to achieve certain objectives additional funding based on meeting agreed objectives examples: France, Denmark, Austria, Finland, Colorado & Virginia in US

example of contract: McGill increased number of students (and foreign students) increased number of faculty increased graduation rate with same research productivity renewal of academic programs balanced budget Conseiller d’établissement: médiateur entre Ministère et Université

allocation mechanisms from direct funding to indirect funding

indirect funding grants and scholarships student loans vouchers Ivory Coast

student loans from mortgage loans for students to income-contingent loans for graduates

vouchers: the Dream Policy the economists’ ultimate solution on demand power to the consumer transparency value of the voucher eligibility criteria on supply choice drives competition contains costs drives up quality ultimate form of accountability: the markets rules

Colorado funding model Old Model Direct Government Funding Tuition New Model Indirect Gov’t Funding via Stipends Tuition & Stipends

Colorado experience: the theory voucher for an undergraduate education at eligible universities; no cash in students’ hands $2,400 per year at public institutions $1,200 per year for low-income students attending private institutions degree-seeking, non-degree, and teacher licensure undergraduate students eligible age, income and financial aid eligibility are irrelevant to qualify

Colorado experience: the reality insufficient funding overall $2,400 not enough to influence either demand or supply complementary financial aid did not materialize lack of political support champions “expiring”

Kazakhstan experience 20% best qualified secondary school graduates choose university $1,200 for public university up to $4,000 for private university must maintain top academic grades

Kazakhstan experience (II) increased competition generally some private institutions have been able to attract a growing number of voucher beneficiaries but insufficient resources to finance all students

Brazil ProUni State purchases seats in private universities offered to top students from low-income families who don’t get a seat in a public university no actual payment to the university, but tax exemption

Colombia (Antioquia) “access with equity” partnership among local government, private firms and private universities low-income students who don’t get a seat in a public university get financial aid to enter a private university 75% scholarship and 25% subsidized loan

outline of the presentation resource mobilization resource allocation resource utilization

resource utilization how efficiently are available resources utilized?

resource utilization average duration to complete degree cost of a graduate inter-institutional benchmarking comparisons

resource utilization (II) resource allocation mechanisms and practices composition of expenditures (salary / non-salary, teaching staff / administrative staff, educational inputs, IT expenditures, maintenance) deployment of teachers (actual teaching compared to norms) utilization of facilities

Autres schémas d’incitation liant les revenus et la performance Salaire du recteur (classement de l’université) Salaires des enseignants et chercheurs (Mexique) Etudiants (bourses, frais de scolarité, prêts) Au Mexique, lié à la production totale en recherche, en Norvège et en Australie, prime pour chaque article publié dans une revue qui est compté par le ranking de Shanghai

conclusion

which mechanism is more effective?

Alice in Wonderland Lewis Carroll Alice Would you please tell me which way I ought to go from here? Cheshire Cat That depends on where you want to get to.

policy objectives pursued improving access and equity improving quality and external efficiency improving internal efficiency and sustainability

principles of an appropriate allocation instrument linked to performance / policy objectives transparent (objective criteria, openness) compatibility Expansion, efficiency, quality, relevance, equity? Strengthening the strong or stimulating the weak? combination

link to quality assurance? pro: powerful incentive US student loans Intel Madagascar INSCAE rankings (scholarships overseas) con: punitive, rewards stronger institutions link at the margin? Argentina: voluntary accreditation gives eligibility for competitive fund Madagascar (INSCAE): best student in each course gets his fees reimbursed

country context local circumstances (culture, history) dilemma: rewarding the strong or equalizing the field? time dimension (flexibility) combination

institutional capacity financial analysis specialists integrated database (Ministry/UGC/institutions) clearly defined indicators (enrollment, equity, internal efficiency, costs, labor market outcomes, research productivity, technology transfer) Nicaragua Minister of Education Think of your own situation: in Jordan, dual fee track leads to mediocrity for the majority

political economy dimensions move to cost-sharing and performance-based can be controversial dealing with the politics (winners and losers) consultation and consensus-building decentralization and autonomy not an excuse to avoid reforms Nicaragua Minister of Education Think of your own situation: in Jordan, dual fee track leads to mediocrity for the majority

www.worldbank.org/education/tertiary