Mandatory National Service

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
How to Give an Effective 2ar. 1. Think About the Big Picture  Remember: focus on offense – defend your house  Isolate 1 or 2 Impacts  Decide on impacts.
Advertisements

(Counter) Plans Because they didn’t limit the topic.
The Counterplan. A counterplan is a policy defended by the negative team which competes with the affirmative plan and is, on balance, more beneficial.
2012 GMU Patriot Debate Institute. What is states cp?  Fiats the 50 states governments/Washington D.C./relevant territories to do plan action.  Variations.
Debating Case and Disadvantages CODI 2014 Lecture 1.
 A counterplan is a competitive policy option to the affirmative plan.
SSCG:7 The students will describe how thoughtful and effective participation in Civil life is characterized by obeying the law, paying taxes, serving on.
Counterplan Lecture GDI 2013 Austin Layton Note: This PowerPoint can be accessed on the PaDS website.
By Beth Mendenhall. Introduction Why you should listen Please ask questions.
USII.8a Rebuilding Europe and Japan Emergence of the United States as a Superpower Establishment of the United Nations.
Counterplans Debate Central Workshop August 30, 2008.
Alejandres Gannon UC Berkeley.  The United States federal government should substantially increase its transportation infrastructure investment in the.
National Anthem.  Although America is very diverse, it is united under a common political culture.  A political culture is a common set of beliefs and.
Most important things Keep your personal views outside the room Debaters must adapt to you Be honest about your judging experience.
 CE.C&G.1.1  Why was the Articles of Confederation rejected as the Constitution of the United States? Provide two specific examples in your response.
Advanced Debate Friday, August 21,  Speaking Drills  Counterplans  Work on cases  Exam 1: Next Friday Preview.
Going Negative The Surveillance Topic. Outline for the topic I. Categories of neg ground -Go over the specific arguments we have II. Dealing.
Affirmative Strategy Austin Layton. Overview At least, take two things from this lecture Main Advantage of Being Aff: Familiarity – Preparation Matters.
Citizens  CITIZENS: Members of a country who are protected by the government & involved in society.  They enjoy certain rights, but also have duties.
Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards Baylor University July 2013.
Intro to Counterplans Casey Parsons. Introduction to Counterplans Thus far in debate, we have assumed that the neg defends the status quo In the vast.
POLICY DEBATE. WHAT IS POLICY DEBATE? A structured format for fairly arguing a topic of policy TEAM DEBATE: two teams of two students each 8 speeches.
Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards & Russell Kirkscey June 2015.
REVIEW NEW FRONTIER AND GREAT SOCIETY. ELECTION OF In the election of 1960, what was a major difference between John F. Kennedy’s campaign and.
Duties, Responsibilities, and Rights of Citizens Unit 1.
Hays Watson Head Debate Coach UGA.  It is the counterpoint to the Affirmative – instead of Affirming a particular course of action (i.e. the resolution),
Topicality “That sounds good. That’s a good skill to have.” –Julia Marshall “Naw. Advantages don’t matter when it comes to Topicality.” –Humza Tahir.
Introduction To Debate. What Is Debate? -D-Debate is a formal academic competition in which students argue both sides of a given topic. -T-The foundation.
Basic Strategies Dallas Urban Debate League December, 2007.
Warm-Up For your warm-up today, complete the sheet on the Dream Act. Do not write on the sheet! Answer in the warm-up section of your binder.
C hap t er 1: Why Study IR? Lecturer: Som Savuth MPS and B.Ed. h.
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
Affirmative vs. negative
Political Experience.
Political Parties 101 Quick overview.
Introduction to the Negative
The Politics DA.
Chapter 2 Economic Systems & the American Economy
Lincoln Douglas.
HOW IT IS SUPPOSED TO WORK
The State Unit 1.
With William Kim and Friends
How to be negative Gabi Yamout.
Citizen Participation
Debate Judges Orientation
What is Civics? Mr. Gutierrez.
Modern Political Parties: The Two Party System
Hegemony (Heg) Economic, military, and political influence a nation has. It’s America’s street cred Soft Power + Hard Power= Heg Amount of Soft + Amount.
Debate: The Basics.
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
Vocabulary/Identification
8d: The Changing Patterns of Society
Splash Screen.
American Political Culture and Beliefs
Introduction to Policy Debate
Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
ORDER AND PURPOSE OF POLICY SPEECHES
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizenship
Civic Duties & Responsibilities
Forms of Democracy.
Plans in LD No Limits Debate Camp.
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
Bellringer “It is the State which educates its citizens in civic virtue, gives them a consciousness of their mission and welds them into unity.” In 3 to.
Introduction to the Neg
Democrats vs. Republicans
Introduction to CX Debate: Part II
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
The Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
Presentation transcript:

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Resolved: In the United States, national service ought to be compulsory Version I -- August 14, 2017

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lecture Lecture Key Terms of the Resolution Affirmative Arguments Negative Argument

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Resolved: In the United States, national service ought to be compulsory In –Within/Throughout United States – Country, but doesn’t describe where the service ought to take place – proposals include the peace corps, for example; military service occurs outside the US National Service – service to one’s country – military service, “community service” – Education Corps, Americorps, peace corps, legal aid Compulsory – Word in the literature is mandatory (a) Law, get arrested (b) Condition financial incentives Compulsory probably eliminates financial incentives

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Core Topic Debates Should we invest in national service? Values of it vs. the costs Should it be mandatory/compulsory? Many advocates for mandatory, but in order to win on the Aff you have to structure your case properly and defend mandatory in 1AC. Only two mandatory cases – draft (very hard to defend), mandatory with options (really once case) Negatives should be well-prepared to debate mandatory Lecture – Benefits, including which are easiest to defend with mandatory Voluntary CPs and CP mechanisms Disadvantages/Ks – go with Mandatory That’s just the CP – modern LD is very critical – anti-government, anti restrictions on liberty, plus national service in the age of Trump?

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Affirmative -- Arguments in Favor of Service *Share the burden of war – costs of war disproportionately impact minorities and the least well off (compulsory) *National unity – different classes and races not interacting now, US polarized (compulsory) *Citizens would become more engaged in politics, especially on issues related to foreign policy; Sense of shared civic responsibility *Social problems – education, poverty *Benefits participants – maturity, life skills, career skills *Benefits military – enough troops, different roles, reduces costs *Civil-military relations

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Arguments Against Service General *It’s expensive – general costs, veteran expenses *Economy – reduces the active labor force *Hurts individuals – education, other obligations to family, some service is provided by low paying jobs *Triggers more early marriages *Hurts the military – reduces the effectiveness of the fighting force, bad attitudes (compulsory) *North Korea perception (compulsory) *Politics (compulsory) *Wars of aggression (enhanced by compulsory?)

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Arguments Against Service Critical *Capitalist – trains people for success in a capitalist economy, programs will be designed that way, *Coercive – requirement to serve the state is a violation of freedom, freedom absolute (coercion); taxation links (not net-beneficial) *General Ks of the liberal, government-based order –Agamben, Foucault, *Race Ks – The whole point of national service is to support civil society…

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Counterplans Voluntary -- Expand the number of programs, encourage people -- Expand the number of programs, financial incentives -- Expand the number of programs, condition financial opportunities (compulsory)? Net-Benefits -- Coercion Kritik -- Court Clog (+ State power precedent?) -- Miltary readiness OR Wars of aggression? (Or both?) -- Politics -- Korea DA?

----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Lincoln-Douglas ----------------------------- Mandatory National Service Strategic Thoughts Affirmative -- Must have compulsory/mandatory defense in 1AC -- Must choose advantages that are needed to defend compulsory (national unity, equality, racism) -- Must have angle on these Ks – defense of state, defense of civil society – There is no fighting the link -- There is probably only one Aff not beatable by voluntary CP (legal aid is a good aff, probalby can’t beat voluntary CP) Negative -- Voluntary CP is very good -- Ks are very good, especially with a Trump angle..