Systematic literature searching in social work: Case study on intimate partner violence. Tony McGinn, PhD Candidate, University of Ulster, Northern Ireland,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Electronic literature searching for qualitative research Rachel L Shaw with Andrew Booth, Alex J Sutton, Mary Dixon-Woods, David R Jones, Tina Miller,
Advertisements

Commissioning rapid responsive research reviews to inform health workforce policy Dr John Wilkinson Department of Health Doing the reviews in practice.
Developing a Systematic Review Fiona Morgan. STEP 1 Develop a protocol.
Searching for systematic reviews: a comparison of methods by Diana Papaioannou, Anthea Sutton, Chris Carroll, Ruth Wong & Andrew Booth ScHARR, University.
A three-phase evaluation study to explore nursing students’ assessment skills. Deborah Coleman.
Conducting a Literature Search and Writing a Literature Review Lisa Eblen, MLIS, AHIP Research Symposium 16 November 2011.
Searching for Medicines Information New Zealand College of Pharmacists.
 Finding the right information to answer a given question often depends on the source of the information  Searching for evidence that has already been.
Databases The NSU HPD Library offers many Database Indexes to search for Journal Articles. Each one is different. This presentation is an attempt to highlight.
Accessing Sources Of Evidence For Practice Introduction To Databases Karen Smith Department of Health Sciences University of York.
Databases Searching for scholarly articles. How is Information Stored Why need to know? Method Tables, records, fields Examples What does searching do?
NURS 505B Library Session Rachael Clemens Spring 2007.
Providing Evidence-Based Public Health Resources: The Librarian's Role Elaine Martin Hathy Simpson Nancy Peterson NAHSL September 27, 2005.
Using ProQuest Databases Jackson Community College Atkinson Library.
ISYS3015 Analytical Methods for Information systems professionals Week 3 Lecture 1: Finding the literature.
Finding Scholarly Articles and Research Data in Education Kathleen Carter Arnulfo L. Oliveira Memorial Library
MS 640: Introduction to Biomedical Information Medical Professionalism Finding Information Using Alumni Medical Library Resources.
LIBRARY SERVICES Internet sources of information Paula Funnell Senior Academic Liaison Librarian (Medicine and Dentistry)
Starting your Research by Choosing Databases. Which databases to use depends on: What’s available that’s relevant Where you are and what resources are.
An Introduction to Systematic Reviews Shakila Thangaratinam Professor of Maternal and Perinatal Health Women’s Health Research Unit R & D Director of Women’s.
The following slides were presented at a meeting of potential editors and methods advisors for the proposed Cochrane review group in February The.
PICOT (PATIENT-INTERVENTION- COMPARISON-OUTCOME-TIME) EBP-----FNP Tips for Literature Review and Research Proposal.
Biological Science Database Proquest WEDAD AL-HUSAINAN ISD/NSTIC Kuwait Institute for Scientific Research November/2012.
Literature Review Major(Retd) Mrunalini Lecturer RAKMHSU
WHERE TO START © 2012 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
AND EVIDENCED BASED PRACTICE MAY 23, 2014 REBECCA LEE, DNP, CRNA
Searching beyond the RCT - looking for sibling studies on qualitative, economic and process research Faten Hamad and Christine Urquhart.
Evidence Based Medicine Meta-analysis and systematic reviews Ross Lawrenson.
MEDLINE for Medical Research Juliet Ralph and César Pimenta Hilary Term 2007.
Identifying the evidence Laura Macdonald Health Protection Scotland
Occupational Therapy Orientation 2014 Sandra A. Martin, M.L.I.S. Instructor of Library Services Health Sciences Resource Coordinator John Vaughan Library.
Electronic Resources for Psychology Karine Barker and Kate Williams 8 th February 2006.
1 How to find literature - A very short introduction - How to start smart Students IIC/IID Medical Library, August 2013.
Copyright © 2008 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 5 Finding and Critiquing Evidence: Research Literature Reviews.
Collaboration and its outcomes in primary care compared internationally Sanneke Schepman Johan Hansen Ronald Batenburg Dinny de Bakker Netherlands Institute.
Chapter 3 Searching the Literature. Reading the Literature You will need to understand what has already been written about a topic before you can ask.
A framework to improve evidence-informed decision-making in health service management Ph.D Candidate in Health Care Management Tabriz University of Medical.
INTRO TO LIBRARY RESEARCH LITERATURE REVIEWS. RESEARCH IN 5 STEPS 1.Define your topic; brainstorm keywords 2.Choose the right tool 3.Keyword search 4.Cycle.
Sources of systematic reviews Arash Etemadi, MD PhD Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Tehran University of Medical Sciences.
Deep Indexing in ProQuest Health and Medical Databases.
Searching for Grey Literature Farhad Shokraneh Medical Information Specialist Cochrane Schizophrenia Group Presentation at: Information Retrieval Topics:
Elsevier Science (USA) items and derived items copyright © 2003, Elsevier Science (USA). All rights reserved. Reviewing the Literature Prepare by :Dr/Amira.
Data Mining for Expertise: Using Scopus to Create Lists of Experts for U.S. Department of Education Discretionary Grant Programs Good afternoon, my name.
BME1450: Biomaterials and Biomedical Research
Institute of Health and Society, Newcastle University
Presented by Renee Harrison, MSW University of Utah 2012
TJTS505: Master's Thesis Seminar
Your Librarians Clare, Elen, Izzy, Katrina, Stephen.
The How and Where of Finding Information
Citation Analysis Your article Jill Otto InCites Other?
Welcome to the Bio-Medical Library
a review of outcome measures
The Basics of Literature Reviews
Review of the Literature
مرور متون به روش ماتریس علي شيخيان دكتراي ايمونولوژي و سرولوژي
ONLINE LITERATURE SEARCH By Using MEDLINE PUBMED HINARI
Figure 1.Flowchart of the article-selection process.
Chapter Two: Review of the Literature
Bibliometrics: the black art of citation rankings
WISER: Citiation searching
Google Scholar: 8,554 publications Systematic search:
Drug Information Resources
Evidence-Based Research
Chapter Two: Review of the Literature
Chapter 3 Finding Relevant Evidence to Answer Clinical Questions
Supporting Priority Setting Partnerships
Literature Searching Using MEDLINE
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
How to research in Social Work
Presentation transcript:

Systematic literature searching in social work: Case study on intimate partner violence. Tony McGinn, PhD Candidate, University of Ulster, Northern Ireland, mcginn-a1@email.ulster.ac.uk Brian J Taylor, PhD, Professor of Social Work, University of Ulster, Northern Ireland, bj.taylor@ulster.ac.uk Mary McColgan, Professor of Social Work, University of Ulster, Northern Ireland, m.mccolgan@ulster.ac.uk Janice McQuilkan, Subject Assistant Librarian, University Of Ulster, j.mcquilkan@ulster.ac.uk CONTEXT Literature searching in the social work field is often more difficult than in other disciplines because of the range of terminology used for key concepts, and because relevant evidence is found in databases designed for a range of other disciplines. Developments in literature search methods and comparisons of search facilities help facilitate access to the best available evidence for social workers. RESULTS:Comparison of database sensitivity, precision and total relevant hits. Database Total hits retrieved Unique hits Sensitivity Precision Average ranking No. Rank % SSA (Social Services Abstracts) 373 9 2 39 8 2.0 PsycINFO 912 11 1 40 3 5 2.3 ASSIA (Applied Social Science Index and Abstracts) 335 4 27 6 3.3 Sociological Abstracts 481 22 3.7 CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Applied Health 749 7 23 4.3 National Criminal Justice Research Service 299 16 4.7 SCOPUS 17 5.3 Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) via Web of Knowledge 28 6.3 EMBASE 918 14 6.7 International Bibliography of the Social Sciences (IBSS) 297 10 7.3 Proquest Health and Medical Complete 383 Social Care Online, previously CareData 385 7.7 Google Scholar (Advanced function) 100 12 8.3 MEDLINE 13 9.3 Total 5581 52    RESULTS: The top ranking six databases provided 94% of relevant articles found. The figure represents the relative strengths of these databases in terms of precision, sensitivity and total number of relevant hits . METHOD The performance of 14 databases and web search engines were appraised by applying a search formula for articles related to the process of change for perpetrators of intimate partner violence. The search process consisted of a series of steps: Establishing criteria for article relevance Compiling list of potentially relevant bibliographic databases & web-search engines Performing a pilot test-search on potential databases and web search engines Establishing concept groups for the generic search formula Selecting search terms for each concept group Running the searches Screening hits for relevant articles Identifying unique hits (relevant articles found on one database only) Calculating sensitivity (the degree to which relevant articles are found) Calculating precision (the degree to which irrelevant articles are excluded) Discussion and Conclusion Systematic reviews of previous research are a vital part of professional social work practice. Searching for studies of diverse designs is complex and the process required for a thorough search may hinder busy practitioners. Senior practitioners who specialise in retrieving (rather than undertaking) research are required as well as collaborative arrangements with librarians and information specialists. Decisions about ‘reasonable’ rather than ‘as good as possible’ searches may have to be made in view of time constraints. For example the majority of relevant hits on this topic could have been found with just four searches if the most relevant databases were known.