PRESENTED BY: JUDGE MARK A. SPEISER

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter Eight: JUDGES.
Advertisements

Practicing With Professionalism.  The Florida Bar spotlight  Resources available to Florida Bar members  Disciplinary process  Avoiding/Limiting Bar.
2007 Annual Conference Professional Discipline Ruby E. Brice, J.D. S.C. Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation.
Judicial Selection in Missouri Merit Selection and Retention through the The Missouri Nonpartisan Court Plan.
Dheeraj Agarwal Ethics Advisor Health Resources and Services Administration U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services.
The Court System.
© 2007 itSMF USA. All rights reserved. itSMF USA Code of Ethics Overview October 2007.
Ethics and Disclosure Act W.S et. seq. Who does the act apply to All public officials, public members and public employees which includes District.
Ethical and Moral Issues in Counseling
Mid-America Regulatory Conference Kansas City, Missouri June 8, 2010.
The Judicial Branch. Court Systems & Jurisdictions.
1 Overview of Ethics Requirements for Employees of Montgomery County This is a summary to help identify issues; it is not the law. Please address ethics.
THE TENNESSEE BOARD OF JUDICIAL CONDUCT Presented to the Tennessee Judicial Conference March 21, 2014 by Tim Discenza, Disciplinary Counsel Judge Chris.
1 State Courts Serving Colorado Our Courts. 2 Our State Courts are Busy Cases Filed—FY ,197 in County Courts 189,235 in District Courts 2,548.
Matthew L. Harvey Office of General Counsel Illinois Commerce Commission.
 Trial Courts : listen to testimony, consider evidence, and decide the facts in disputed situations.
© 2004 by Prentice Hall Terrie Nolinske, Ph.D Respecting Employee Rights and Managing Discipline 14.
FAIR COURTS = JUSTICE CELEBRATING THE 800 TH ANNIVERSARY OF MAGNA CARTA.
A public education program of The Florida Bar Developed by The Florida Law Related Education Association, Inc. What Judges Do An Introduction.
Navigating Your Way Through the Judicial Code of Conduct.
FAIR COURTS = JUSTICE. THE JUDICIAL BRANCH “The founders realized that there has to be some place where being right is more important than being popular.
Sunshine Law, Public Records and Ethics. Discussion Topics Government in the Sunshine Public Records Code of Ethics The Bluewater Bay MSBU Board has a.
Student Rights and Responsibilities Student Conduct and The University of Wyoming Regulations.
CODE OF JUDICIAL CONDUCT Policy & legislative Background.
Missouri Judicial Discipline System Mo Const. Art. 5 s. 24: Commission on Retirement, Removal and Discipline  6 Members  2 laypersons appointed by Gove.
Chapter 1 What is Law?. Laws and Values Our current legal system is based on values that our government and society believe are most important to keep.
THE TENNESSEE BOARD OF JUDICIAL CONDUCT Presented to the Tennessee Municipal Judges Conference April, 2014 by Tim Discenza, Disciplinary Counsel Tennessee.
Unit 5 Midterm Review. What are some of the components of the ABA?
STANDARDS OF CONDUCT AND GOVERNMENT ETHICS
CALIFORNIA CODE OF JUDICIAL ETHICS Hon. Tom Hollenhorst Hon. Julie Conger Hon. Dodie Harman.
The U.S. Constitution & the Bill of Rights
Why is the power of judicial review key to the system of checks and balances? Because the power of judicial review can declare that laws and actions of.
TOPIC K: JUDICIAL ETHICS P.R Prof. Janicke.
1 Judges Chapter Eight 2 Position of the Judge Seen as the symbol of justice. Set bail and revoke it. Determine whether there is sufficient probable.
Open Meetings Open Records and Ethics Training Member Training.
Judicial Branch Basics and “Due Process”. Basic Structure of the Judicial Branch Supreme Court (original and appellate jurisdiction) 13 Circuit Courts.
Article III: The Judicial Branch Chapters: 11,12
Honorable Anne E. LazarusHonorable Robert A. Graci Superior Court of PennsylvaniaChief Counsel Chair, Judicial Conduct BoardJudicial Conduct Board Honorable.
The Ontario Human Rights Commission Complaints Process CLN4U.
Regulation and Discipline. LAWYER’S ROLES Representative of the client Officer of the court Public citizen.
C itizenship 2016 Constitution Day & Citizenship Day C onstitution C ourts &
Judicial Campaign Ethics for Magistrates The Rules Governing Judicial Conduct (22 NYCRR part 100) Laura L. Smith, Esq., Chief Counsel of the ACJE Sandra.
The Finnish Legal Profession of Attorneys-at-law
Judges GOVT 2306, Module 9.
Fair Courts = justice Introduce self and NAWJ Informed Voters Project.  
Courtroom Decorum and Professionalism in the Courts
The Bill of Rights: Amendments I - X
Bullying & Harassment Policy
Chapter Eight: Judges.
GUKEYEH GUK’EH GU’SANI Kaska Dena Good Governance Act
ENSURING ACCESS TO JUSTICE IN A NEUTRAL COURT
JUDICIAL ETHICS by Dame Linda Dobbs
The Courts and the Constitution
The Bill of Rights The first 10 amendments to the Constitution
Entry Into the System Arrests and Miranda.
NEW YORK STATE ETHICS LAW
Missouri Association of Rural Education
General Overview of the Washington State System of Judicial Discipline
The City of East Lansing Board & Commission Training Seminar
Citizenship of the United States
WORKSHOP DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS AGAINST JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS IN UKRAINE GROUNDS FOR DISCIPLINARY LIABILITY AND SANCTIONS AGAINST JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS:
Complaints Admissibility and Screening
WORKSHOP DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS AGAINST JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS IN UKRAINE JUDICIAL DISCIPLINARY PRACTICE: ANALYSIS OF COMPLAINTS ADMISSIBILITY AND OPINIONS.
Chapter 5: The Court System
PROMOTING JUDICIAL ETHICS IN THE COURT OF JUSTICE OF SURINAME
Solving the Ethics Puzzle: An Overview of the Code of Ethics
Nebraska Supreme Court rules on interpreters Additions & Amendments
ETHICS IN PUBLIC SERVICE
Florida Courts Scavenger Hunt
Presentation transcript:

PRESENTED BY: JUDGE MARK A. SPEISER XV. WHY BECOME A JUDGE PRESENTED BY: JUDGE MARK A. SPEISER

I. SALARY CONSIDERATIONS II. CIRCLE OF FRIENDS III. ADDRESSING THREATS AND PROTECTION IV. MEDIA AND PUBLICITY V. MEDIA RELATIONS

VII. CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS VI. FAIRNESS VII. CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS MINIMUM OF 30 CREDIT HOURS EVERY 3 YEARS 2 OF THE 30 HOURS MUST BE ON JUDICIAL ETHICS

VIII. INAPPROPRIATE JUDICIAL BEHAVIOR WILL RESULT IN APPEARANCE BEFORE JUDICIAL QUALIFICATIONS COMMISSION (JQC) SANCTIONS PRIVATE REPRIMAND PUBLIC REPRIMAND IN FRONT OF SUPREME COURT AND PUBLISHED IN LEGAL AND PUBLIC PERIODICALS SUSPENSION AND FINE REMOVAL FROM OFFICE

DECISIONS MADE IN GOOD FAITH HOWEVER, NORMALLY NOT GROUNDS FOR DISCIPLINE LEGAL ERROR JUDICIAL MISINTERPRETATION JUDICIAL INVENTIVENESS

EXAMPLES OF JUDICIAL MISCONDUCT PREJUDICE OR BIAS IMPROPER MOTIVES FOR DECISION (RETALIATION, REVENGE, PERSONAL GAIN, GOOD PRESS) BAD TEMPER, VERBAL ABUSE FLAGRANT DISREGARD FOR BASIC RIGHTS COMPLETE LACK OF UNDERSTANDING OF LAW REFUSING TO COMPLY WITH CLEAR LEGAL PRECEDENT RUDE, NASTY BEHAVIOR PARTICIPATING IN FUNDRAISING

INVOLVEMENT WITH PARTISAN POLITICS PROVIDING CHARACTER REFERENCES EX-PARTE COMMUNICATIONS ALCOHOL/DRUG PROBLEMS UNDUE DELAYS IN ENTERING RULINGS EMBARRASSING BEHAVIOR OUTSIDE COURTROOM ARREST

IX. JUDGES SHOULD NEVER ACCEPT GIFT, COMPENSATION OR BENEFITS THAT COULD BE CONSTRUED TO INFLUENCE OR GAIN UNFAIR ADVANTAGE ANNUAL PUBLIC DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS ARE REQUIRED DETAILING GIFTS, SOURCES OF INCOME, AND ANY BUSINESS INTERESTS

AVOID MEMBERSHIP IN ANY ORGANIZATION THAT DISCRIMINATES BASED UPON RACE, RELIGION, SEX OR CULTURE DO NOT BE INFLUENCED BY PUBLIC OUTRAGE OR FEAR OF CRITICISM MAINTAIN COURT DECORUM BE PATIENT, DIGNIFIED AND COURTEOUS IN OFFICIAL CAPACITY

X. REQUIREMENTS OF JUDICIAL CODE OF CONDUCT MAINTAIN HIGH STANDARD OF INTEGRITY PRESERVE JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE REMAIN IMPARTIAL REFRAIN FROM USING PRESTIGE OF OFFICE IMPROPERLY DO NOT TESTIFY VOLUNTARILY AS A CHARACTER WITNESS

PREVENT LAWYERS FROM USING INAPPROPRIATE WORDS, GESTURES OR CONDUCT DO NOT PUBLICLY COMMENT ON A PENDING CASE THAT MIGHT EFFECT THE OUTCOME NEVER COMMENT ON OR CRITICIZE A JURY VERDICT AVOID NEPOTISM AND FAVORTISM IN JUDICIAL APPOINTMENTS

REPORT ATTORNEYS AND OTHER JUDGES WHO VIOLATE THEIR RESPECTIVE CODES OF CONDUCT GRANT RECUSAL REQUESTS WHEN THERE IS A BASIS TO DO SO IF JUDGE’S IMPARTIALITY, PERCEIVED OR ACTUAL IS AT ISSUE WHEN POSSIBLE, IMPROVE THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE AND LEGAL SYSTEM LIMIT ANY NON-JUDICIAL FINANCIAL OR FIDUCIARY ACTIVITIES

XI. JUDICIAL ELECTIONS AND CAMPAIGN FUNDRAISING FILING FEE 4% OF SALARY (APPROX. $5,700) COST OF CAMPAIGN AND HOW CONDUCTED FUNDRAISING CONSIDERATIONS

PERMISSIBLE CAMPAIGN SPEECH NO PLEDGES OR PROMISES AVOID COMMITTING TO ISSUES, CASES OR CONTROVERSIES DO NOT MISREPRESENT YOUR QUALIFICATIONS OR BACKGROUND NO NEGATIVE CAMPAIGNING TALK ABOUT YOURSELF AND YOUR CREDITIALS ELECTION V. MERIT RETENTION

XII. JUDGE SERVING AS BAR REFEREE APPROX. 87,010 LICENSED LAWYERS IN FLORIDA 66.% MALE 33.5% FEMALE OCCURS AFTER BAR GREIVANCE COMMITTEE FINDS PROBABLE CAUSE TO BELIEVE LAWYER IS GUITLY OF MISCONDUCT JUSTIFYING DISCIPLINARY ACTION FLORIDA BAR BOARD OF GOVERNORS REVIEWS GRIEVANCE COMMITTEE FINDING

IF BOARD OF GOVERNORS AGREES, IT FILES COMPLAINTS AGAINST LAWYER AND SUPREME COURT ASSIGNS A CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE TO SERVE AS REFEREE BAR REPRESENTED BY STAFF COUNSEL AND ACCUSED LAWYER MAY RETAIN COUNSEL OR REPRESENT SELF

NO JURY EVIDENCE IS TESTIMONIAL AND/OR DOCUMENTARY JUDGE ENTERS FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDS DISCIPLINE TO FLORIDA SUPREME COURT WHICH CAN ACCEPT OR REJECT RECOMMENDATIONS

YEAR ENDING 2009 SANCTIONS: ADMONISHMENT OR PRIVATE REPRIMAND PROBATION FROM 6 MONTHS TO 3 YEARS PUBLIC REPRIMAND REPORTED IN JUDICIAL REPORTER, BAR NEWSLETTER AND PUBLIC MEDIA SUSPENSION LESS THAN 90 DAYS MORE THAN 90 DAYS DISBARMENT FOR 5 YEARS PERMANENT DISBARMENT 44 3 34 120 61 24

THE END