Calvert City Power I, L.L.C. (“Calvert”) Purpose of Meeting

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Evaluation Independent Monitoring Presented at: LPSC Staffs Technical Conference and ESIs Bidders Conference for the Fall 2006 Limited-Term RFP September.
Advertisements

Industry Brainstorm on increasing Export Capacity From Alberta to B.C. January, 2006.
Project Definition of Bulk Electric System & Bulk Electric System Rules of Procedure Development Presenter: Peter Heidrich, FRCC – BES Drafting.
Goshen Area Bus Reconfiguration
Northwest Quadrant Joint Security Study Southern Company Headquarters Birmingham, Alabama August 12, 2002 Presented by Saeed Arabi.
Houston Import Evaluation Cross Texas Transmission & Garland Power & Light ERCOT RPG Meeting August 27th, 2013.
Houston Region Import Capacity Project August 27, 2013 Regional Planning Group Meeting.
MARCH 31, 2014 Maine 2014 Outage Coordination CONTAINS CRITICAL ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INFORMATION – DO NOT RELEASE.
January 5, 2012 TAC Cross Valley 345 kV Project Jeff Billo Manager, Mid-Term Planning.
Reliability Criteria for Bulk Power System Design Richard V. Kowalski Manager, Transmission Planning ISO New England.
NOVEMBER 11, 2014 PUBLIC VERSION Maine 2014 Outage Coordination CONTAINS CRITICAL ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INFORMATION – DO NOT RELEASE.
AUGUST 19, 2014 PUBLIC VERSION Maine 2014 Outage Coordination CONTAINS CRITICAL ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INFORMATION – DO NOT RELEASE.
DRAFT – FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES ONLY © 2014 New York Independent System Operator, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Emergency Transfer Criteria NYSRC Reliability.
1 Local Area Planning Update to TRANSAC – July 29, 2015 Mitigation Update, Uncertainty Scenarios, and Next Steps.
California Energy Commission Workshop Nuclear Power Plant Issues
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N 1 Network Operating Committee (NOC) June 12 th, 2014.
Houston Area Dynamic Reactive Project March 11,
Applying the Distribution System in Grid Restoration/NERC CIP-014 Risk Assessment Srijib Mukherjee, Ph.D., P.E. UC Synergetic.
Reliable Power Reliable Markets Reliable People Performance Targets for the Customer Interconnection Process January, 2008.
Peak RCCo Performance Metrics Draft –November 2013.
Lyndonville Electric Department Feasibility Analysis Review December 2,
1 TRANSMISSION SYSTEM OVERVIEW NETWORK OPERATING COMMITTEE April 17, 2007 New Mexico Transmission System Overview.
Reliability Requirements Bill Blevins Manager of Operations Support ERCOT.
March 11, 2011 RPG Meeting Lower Rio Grande Valley (LRGV) Import.
June 19, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT System Development Update Jeff Billo.
13 Step Approach to Network Design Steps A Systems Approach 8Conduct a feasibility Study 8Prepare a plan 8Understand the current system 8Design.
ERCOT PUBLIC 4/21/ RTP: Cascade Analysis April 21, 2015.
Local Area Study Local Area Study Mitigation Plan Update and Uncertainty Scenarios
1 Stability Issues in Entergy System Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Planning the CREZ 345 kV System for Multi-contingencies CREZ Technical Conference January 26, 2010 Bernie Pasternack AEP Service Corporation.
14 Jan 2004Market Operations Standing Committee1 Special Protection Systems: Operational and Compensation Issues.
Southern California Edison The San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station April 14, 2011.
NERC Lessons Learned Summary LLs Published in September 2015.
ESI Alternate Economic Study Process E-RSC Meeting October 21, 2010.
Coordinated Planning Concept (For Discussion Only) revised 11/30/04 07/01/04.
September 1, 2011 TAC Lower Rio Grande Valley Regional Planning Group Project Jeff Billo Manager, Mid-Term Planning.
OPSTF – Issue 7 Long-term unavailability of autotransformers.
Update on the North Carolina Transmission Planning Collaborative January 30, 2007 For the North Carolina Utilities Commission and the North Carolina Public.
Reliability Subcommittee Report Vishal C. Patel (RS Chair) PCC Meeting La Jolla, CA- March 22, 2015 W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
RA workshop presentation Karl Meeusen, Ph.D. Senior Advisor – Infrastructure Policy CPUC Resource Adequacy Workshop February 18, 2016.
April 7, 2015 Washington, D.C. Area Low-Voltage Event Operations Training Seminar 2016 Erik Johnson System Operations Training (ERCOT)
1 NPCC – A-2 Dr. Mayer Sasson Transmission Planning Consolidated Edison of New York June 1, 2006 Presented to the NYSRC-RRS.
Northern Tier Transmission Group Report to Columbia Grid Planning Committee February 9, 2012 “To ensure efficient, effective, coordinated use & expansion.
Project WECC-0100 Standards Briefing WECC-0100 SDT April 7, 2016 W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
Reliability Must Run Workshop RMR Study Process May 24, 2016.
Information Systems Security
Chapter 8. Electrical Systems
Freeport Area Master Plan Project -
September 18, 2007 Regional Disturbance
Inverter Disconnects During Transmission Disturbances
Modifications to Planning Charter
NERC Published Lessons Learned Summary
Ensuring Security of Supply in Estonian Transmission Grid
Compliance Report to ERCOT TAC February 2007
Project WECC-0100 Update Load Modeling Task Force
Local Area Planning Update to TRANSAC – March 15, 2017
Mid-Continent Area Power Pool
Presenter: Peter Heidrich, FRCC – BES Drafting Team Chair
Impacts and Actions Resulting from the August 14, 2003 Blackout
G5/4 Sub-group Update.
Special Protection Systems: Operational and Compensation Issues
Palo Verde-COI RAS Retirement
Project WECC-0100 Update Load Modeling Task Force
Palo Verde-COI RAS Retirement
Planning Meeting November 4, 2010 Marv Landauer.
Two-Tier Firm Curtailment Overview
Excelsior Energy’s Mesaba Energy Project
Power system operation and control
M. Kezunovic (P.I.) S. S. Luo D. Ristanovic Texas A&M University
Presentation transcript:

Calvert City Power I, L.L.C. (“Calvert”) Purpose of Meeting Enron desires to review TVA’s earlier double contingency mitigation conclusions regarding Calvert to determine if other solutions exist interconnection procedures and design standards have changed since Enron’s ‘99 Peakers (rather than requiring Network Upgrades, TVA allowed operating procedures to avoid contingency events), and Enron’s ‘00 Peakers (TVA’s current policies would not require the $30 million upgrade at Shelby) additional peaking capacity still needed in the TVA system strong local and state support still exist for the project

Calvert City Power I, L.L.C. Overview of Interconnection Issues Three system stability double contingency scenarios were originally posed to Calvert: single line to ground fault with stuck breaker on the Cumberland - Johnsonville 500-kV transmission line (“Contingency #1”), three phase fault on the Cumberland - Johnsonville 500-kV transmission line while the Cumberland - Davidson line is out of service for maintenance (“Contingency #2”), single line to ground fault on the Cumberland - Johnsonville 500-kV transmission line with a “sympathetic trip” of the Cumberland - Davidson 500-kV transmission line resulting from an equipment malfunction (“Contingency #3”). Enron / TVA have agreed that the first two referenced above have been adequately addressed by (i) Calvert paying for the addition of a breaker at the Cumberland facility, and (ii) the addition of a transfer trip mechanism to immediately take Calvert’s generation off-line during maintenance of the Cumberland - Davidson line, respectively.

Calvert City Power I, L.L.C. Overview of Interconnection Issues (cont.) Enron believes that the remaining Contingency #3 can be addressed by the transfer trip mechanism already proposed to mitigate Contingency #2: Enron’s research of TVA’s interconnection design criteria indicates that transfer trip mechanisms are allowed to mitigate double (but not single) contingency events detailed technical analysis of the transfer trip mechanism indicates that it can operate within 15 cycles of a contingency event, well below the threshold required by Contingency #3 three independent industry recognized companies have analyzed Contingency #3, and have concluded that it can be mitigated by a transfer trip mechanism Depending on cost, Enron would potentially agree to additional measures such as looping in the adjacent 161-kV lines, mitigating reactive power losses (if any), and other reasonable measures

Calvert City Power I, L. L. C Calvert City Power I, L.L.C. (“Calvert”) Overview of Interconnection Issues Other considerations related to Contingency #3: this contingency is an extremely remote and theoretical event that has never occurred on the subject 500-kV lines during their approximate 30 years of operation TVA has dismantled fast-valving capability at Cumberland, which is inconsistent with Contingency #3 being posed to Calvert discussions with NERC indicate that Contingency #3 is a Category D contingency under NERC guidelines, and as such is not required to be mitigated