Adel AlAdlani. , Daniela C. Schroeter, Ruth M

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Utilization-focused Assessment in Foundations Curriculum: Examining RCLS 2601: Leisure in Society Clifton E. Watts, PhD Dept. of Recreation & Leisure Studies.
Advertisements

Improving Learning, Persistence, and Transparency by Writing for the NASPA Journal Dr. Cary Anderson, Editor, NASPA Journal Kiersten Feeney, Editorial.
Creating Research proposal. What is a Marketing or Business Research Proposal? “A plan that offers ideas for conducting research”. “A marketing research.
Reporting & Ethical Standards EPSY 5245 Michael C. Rodriguez.
Literature Review and Parts of Proposal
Chapter 21 Preparing a Research Report Gay, Mills, and Airasian
HECSE Quality Indicators for Leadership Preparation.
Is research in education important?. What is the difference between Qualitative and Quantitative Research Methods?
Elke Johanna de Buhr, PhD Tulane University
Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Application, 9 th edition. Gay, Mills, & Airasian © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
Opening Scenario Two research I universities A & B Same requirements for admission of doctoral students into Ph.D. Science Education program. Upon graduation,
Forms Compliance Correction Action Plan Instructions for completing the Compliance Corrective Action Plan.
LITERATURE REVIEW  A GENERAL GUIDE  MAIN SOURCE  HART, C. (1998), DOING A LITERATURE REVIEW: RELEASING THE SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH IMAGINATION.
Anatomy of a Research Article Five (or six) major sections Abstract Introduction (without a heading!) Method (and procedures) Results Discussion and conclusions.
NSC 440 RESEARCH IN NURSING 4 UNITS DEPARTMENT OF NURSING SCIENCE FACULTY OF BASIC MEDICAL SCIENCES 1.
Instructors’ General Perceptions on Students’ Self-Awareness Frances Feng-Mei Choi HUNGKUANG UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH.
Principals of Research Writing. What is Research Writing? Process of communicating your research  Before the fact  Research proposal  After the fact.
Publishing Educational Research Articles Dr. David Kaufman Faculty of Education Simon Fraser University Presented at Universitas Terbuka March 4, 2011.
PSYA4- research methods Section C. Validating new knowledge The role of peer review the assessment of scientific work by others who are experts in the.
PSYCH 610 Entire Course (UOP) For more course tutorials visit  PSYCH 610 Week 1 Individual Assignment Research Studies Questionnaire.
MScSED THESIS WORKSHOP: 1 ST STEPS NUI Galway May 16 th, 2014.
PSYCH 610 guide / psych610guidedotcom.  PSYCH 610 Week 1 Individual Assignment Research Studies Questionnaire  PSYCH 610 Week 2 Individual Assignment.
Course title: RESEARCH PLANNING AND REPORT WRITING Lecture 1 Introduction to postgraduate research.
4/16/07 Assessment of the Core – Humanities with Writing Charlyne L. Walker Director of Educational Research and Evaluation, Arts and Sciences.
Writing for Healthcare Professionals The Outline
Introduction to Marketing Research
DIRECTED ADMINISTRATIVE PORTFOLIO
COM 295 STUDY Inspiring Minds/com295study.com
Assessment and Reporting
This Week’s Agenda Types of Research Papers Types of Research studies
Requirements for the Course
Understanding Standards: Higher Course Event
Part Two.
CRITICAL CORE: Straight Talk.
This Week’s Agenda Types of Research Papers Types of Research studies
The majority of players were born in January, February, and March
Data Driven Decision Making: Utilizing Alumni Perspectives In Strategic Management School of Public Affairs and Administration (SPAA) Student Researcher:
PSY 325 aid Something Great/psy325aid.com
3 Research Design Formulation
Searching the Literature
MGT-491 QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS AND RESEARCH FOR MANAGEMENT
The Literature Search and Background of the Problem
Literature Review: Conception to Completion
This Week’s Agenda Types of Research Papers Types of Research studies
TYPES OF RESEARCH.
Parts of an Academic Paper
CHAPTER 2 Research Methods in Industrial/Organizational Psychology
Theoretical Framework
HCS 542 Competitive Success/snaptutorial.com
PSYCH 610 Competitive Success/snaptutorial.com
PSYCH 610 GUIDE Experience Tradition / psych610guide.com.
HCS 542 Education for Service/snaptutorial.com
PSYCH 610 Education for Service/snaptutorial.com.
PSYCH 610 GUIDE Perfect Education/ psych610guide.com.
Business and Management Research
The Marketing Research Process
Lecture Slides Elementary Statistics Eleventh Edition
Design Project Article Title Results and Discussion
Preparing Informative and Influential Business Reports
Welcome.
Mapping the ACRL Framework and Nursing Professional
Business and Management Research
The Rosabeth Moss Kanter Award Module 2, Class 2 A Teaching Module Developed by the Curriculum Task Force of the Sloan Work and Family Research Network.
Techniques to Engage Students in Research Methods Courses
Research Problem: The research problem starts with clearly identifying the problem you want to study and considering what possible methods will affect.
Independent Study Supervision Workshop
Student Research Conference 2019
Ass. Prof. Dr. Mogeeb Mosleh
Finalization of the Action Plans and Development of Syllabus
Research design and techniques Workshop ICBEDC 2010
Presentation transcript:

Research Methods in Public Administration Journals: A Systematic Review Adel AlAdlani*, Daniela C. Schroeter, Ruth M. Bates-Hill, Hussein Chalabi, Gregory D. Greenman II, Mike Mendenhall, and Diane Thompson Population and Sample Purposeful selection of primary journals of four public administration membership associations, including: the American Society for Public Administration’s (ASPA) Public Administration Review (PAR), the Association for Public Policy and Management’s (APPAM) Journal of Policy Analysis and Management (JPAM), the Public Management Research Association’s (PMRA) Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory (JPART), the Association for Research on Nonprofit Organizations and Voluntary Action’s (ARNOVA) Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly (NVSQ). Findings Findings, continued Conclusions Overall, 79% of articles published in the public administration journals studied have clear method section. The 21% of articles with no method explained are identified as general articles describing specific theories in the field or commentaries providing instructions about certain themes. 45% of the articles published do not have question stated clearly. This does not mean that articles do not have questions at all; it means articles do not tend to mention the questions identified with a question mark (?). Most of the published research articles studied use a nonprobability sampling technique. This may be correlated with the type of data used, as 53% of articles use secondary data for certain purposes relevant to the study or easy access to data. There is a high frequency in the use of quantitative methods in public administration (80%). Small percentages of articles use qualitative and mixed methods in all the four journals except JPAM, which published no articles using qualitative or mixed methods in 2015 or 2016. Next Steps Complete coding of years 2007 to 2014 Refine analytical procedures Analyze complete dataset and formulate conclusions and implications Draft and submit manuscript Contacts *Adel AlAdlani, Doctoral Student, Western Michigan University Dept. of Public Affairs and Administration, a.aladlani@wmich.edu Acknowledgements Faculty mentor Dr. Daniela C. Schroeter, Assistant Professor of Public Administration, School of Public Affairs and Administration; daniela.schroeter@wmich.edu, for her efforts in providing a high-value learning experience. Gregory Greenman, II, Doctoral Research Assistant, for developing the Qualtrics database, expert management of data cleaning efforts, and providing final data for analysis. Abstract This poster includes findings from a systematic review conducted during a doctoral methods course at Western Michigan University. The systematic mixed methods review covered key public administration membership association journals. The review indicated differences in the research methods and types used with a strong preference for using quantitative research. Problem Statement Research methods are widely taught in social science graduate programs. Knowing the research designs that are employed or underutilized by researchers provides information for curriculum development in public administration. Research Questions What proportion of articles published in public administration journals have clearly identifiable method sections, stated questions, sampling approach, data type, and method? How does research published in these journals differ? Research Design A systematic mixed methods review was conducted to examine the research questions. Methods A total of 425 articles were randomly assigned to 21 coder pairs for review. Data elements were entered into a Qualtrics database. Interrater agreement was assessed and discrepancies corrected during several agreement workshops. Data from Qualtrics were provided to students in an MS Excel spreadsheet. Students devised their own analytical plans, which were approved by the instructor, and carried out individual analyses. Data were examined via descriptive statistics.