Understanding Satire, Parody, and Humorous Arguments “Dying’s easy, but comedy will kill you.” --Sir Laurence Olivier
First, the Big Picture…Four “Shapes” of Literature Tragedy: shape of Disintegration Main character breaks from society, family, country, etc. Government, society, family breaking down Comedy: shape of Reintegration Restoring family or social order Things start out jumbled but sort out
Four “Shapes” of Literature Romance: shape of Wish-fulfillment Adventure full of excitement and passion Main character desires something (eventually) gets it Satire: shape of Fragmentation Chaos, uncivilized Social fabric threatens to come apart
What is Satire? Humorous, wry, detached Ridicules politics, society, human foibles Makes us examine life & change it Moral outrage is at core, then either: Condemns Warns/Heals
TYPES OF SATIRE FORMAL/DIRECT INDIRECT Directly addresses audience or reader; openly criticizes topic Classified as “Horatian” or “Juvenalian” INDIRECT Relies on ridiculous behavior of characters
TYPES OF FORMAL SATIRE HORATIAN Ridicules gently Often laugh-out-loud funny “Satirical physician” JUVENALIAN Derides subjects harshly and bitterly Abrasive “Satirical executioner”
Parody Humorous imitation of another work Generally, original work is serious Humorously imitates style, key ideas, form Often tackles “inappropriate” subjects Typically light-hearted or good-natured May also mock shared/universal experience
Differences Between Satire & Parody Satire invents fictitious situation Purpose: ridicule people, events, or ideas May include existing elements/real details Parody imitates or mocks existing work Purpose: Points out flaws of the original work Absurdly exaggerates its characteristics
Keys to Writing Humorous Arguments Humorous Techniques/Devices Timing Details Incongruity
Humorous Techniques/Devices Irony Verbal (sarcasm, understatement, exaggeration) Situational (unexpected) Hyperbole (exaggeration) Understatement or meiosis Litotes (uses opposite: not a bad singer, not unhappy) Jargon Using expressions from particular group or field
Timing Use current events or topics Audiences need to understand references Build suspense, then drop punchline
Details “And before you accuse me of being some kind of sherry-sipping ascot-wearing ballet-attending MacNeil-Lehrer-NewsHour-watching wussy, please note that I am a sports guy myself, having had a legendary atheletic career consisting of nearly a third of the 1965 season on the track team at Pleasantville High School (“Where the Leaders of Tomorrow Are Leaving Wads of Gum on the Auditorium Seats of Today”). -- Dave Barry
Details Precise details add to humor Consider the difference: “And before you accuse me of being some kind of wussy, please note that I am a sports guy myself, having had an athletic career on the track team at Pleasantville High School.”
Incongruity Juxtaposing diction Colloquial expressions for lofty figures or situations Overly formal language Combine pop culture with “higher” subjects Real current events or literary references Consider bizarre “What ifs”