The Cost savings on an Ecosystem Restoration project if the area is treated with Microbes First The example used for this comparison was the Stevenson.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Water Quality Trading – Point Source for Non-point Source Sediments: Piasa Creek Watershed Project Illinois-American Water Company & Great Rivers Land.
Advertisements

Treatment of Slaughterhouse Wastewater
DREDGING YOUR DOCKS 2013 Supported by: USACE Galveston District U. S. Coast Guard Sabine Neches Navigation District.
In the early 1900’s man began to change this delicate system. It started with a series of canals and levees that were built to provide flood control and.
Stabilization Ponds CE General Characteristics Quiescent and diked Quiescent and diked Wastewater enters the pond Wastewater enters the pond Organic.
Florida Water Forum Everglades Restoration June 3, 2011.
Expedited Projects + Innovative Teamwork = Measurable Improvements to the Health of Lake Okeechobee and the St. Lucie and Caloosahatchee Estuaries.
Kickapoo Creek Corridor Restoration Project “One Project…. …many goals (and how 319 helped fund it)” Kaskaskia Engineering Group Mary Lou Goodpaster Bryan.
Membrane Softening Water Treatment Plant completed in –Upper Floridan groundwater wells provide the source water for treatment. –Treatment process.
Water Resources Report Rob Montgomery River Flow & Lake Levels TMDL Study Floodplain mapping revisions Dredging 101.
Kissimmee River Restoration Contract 13B Florida Department of Environmental Protection Permit No.: EI Aerial Photos Taken April 1, 2009 By.
Rainwater Conservation System Town of Cary Senior Center Facility.
Dredging, Disposal Management and Impacts on Lake Sediments US Army Corps of Engineers.
Water Treatment Plant No. 2 Concentrate Zero Liquid Discharge August 30, 2011.
Water: Its Important! Mr. Ellis. Do Now Why do you think water is important? What does it do for you? Why do you think water is important? What does it.
Limited Proceedings Water & Wastewater Reference Manual1.
TMDLs on the Clearwater River Fecal Coliform Impairment of the Trout Stream Portion of the Clearwater River By Corey Hanson Water Quality Coordinator Red.
Water Pollution Chapter 22 Lara, Nanor, Natalie, Sosi, Greg.
EARTH’S WATER FEATURES
A Constructed Wetlands to Enhance Final Treatment of Waste Water from a Poultry Processing Plant J. B. Hess 1, J.P. Blake 1, K.S. Macklin 1, T. Smith 2,
Ed Dunne, Ph.D, Division of Environmental Sciences, SJRWMD P.O. Box 1429, Palatka, FL 32178; ph:
CWPPRA New Orleans Land Bridge Shoreline Enhancement and Marsh Creation Project Project Kickoff Meeting April 15, 2015.
Environmental Issues. Pollution n The presence of a SUBSTANCE in water, air, or soil that makes them OFFENSIVE to humans.
Water for Texas U.S. Conference of Mayors Water Board Meeting West Palm Beach, Florida Nov , 2008.
Surface Water Supplies Joe Zulovich Extension Agricultural Engineer Commercial Agriculture Program.
Urban Storm Water Runoff and Inland Lakes: A Tale of Two Cities Jarron D. Hewitt and Martin T. Auer Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering,
Regional Water Availability Rulemaking Chip Merriam Water Resources Advisory Commission February 8, 2007 Chip Merriam Water Resources Advisory Commission.
TMDLs on the Clearwater River Fecal Coliform Impairment of the Trout Stream Portion of the Clearwater River By Corey Hanson Water Quality Coordinator Red.
Central & Southern Florida Project George Horne Deputy Executive Director Operations & Maintenance Resource Area.
STORM WATER STORAGE AND TREATMENT
District of Columbia TMDL Schedule and Update D.C. Department of Health Water Quality Division March 2004.
5.2 Detection and Monitoring of Pollution
Methods of Monitoring Pollution. Direct Performed by monitoring the level of the pollutant itself Performed by monitoring the level of the pollutant itself.
Use and Effectiveness of Municipal Water Restrictions During Drought in Colorado Bobbie Klein and Doug Kenney 2002 Drought – the Context Study Methodology.
Port of Hood River Recreation Committee Meeting April 2, 2007 By: Andrew Jansky, P.E. Flowing Solutions Images are property.
Impacts of Livestock Waste on Surface Water Quality By the North Dakota Department of Health Division of Water Quality For the Livestock Manure Nutrient.
Culler Lake Bathymetry: Potential Changes Following Dredging Spring 2013 Sampling Methods Class: J. Bruland, M. Dybala, N. Gunther, A. Hoffman, J. Jones,
Beth Kacvinsky - Lead Project Manager Office of Everglades Policy and Coordination March 1, 2016 IRL-S / C-44 Overview.
Chesapeake Bay. Is the largest estuary in the United States The Bay’s watershed is 64,000 square miles (60% forested) and covers parts of 6 states These.
Marine Biomes. 2 Types of Marine Biomes Freshwater –Rivers and Streams –Lakes and Ponds Saltwater –Ocean –Estuaries.
Rivanna Water & Sewer Authority Presentation to City of Charlottesville Workshop South Fork Rivanna Reservoir (SFRR) Dredging Concept Review May 6, 2008.
C ALOOSAHATCHEE & E VERGLADES R ESTORATION Jennifer Hecker, Director of Natural Resource Policy.
Placido Bayou 2 year update followed by 5 year alum budget
Chapter 14 Water Pollution.
Richland Creek Water Supply Program Briefing
Welcome, See updated details at
Designing Around Seasonal High Groundwater
Jemtegaard Trail Project was originally funded by a Safe Routes to School (SRTS) which is a federal grant administered by WSDOT Total funding for design,
Waters of the United States and Other Wetlands
2017 American Waters Resource
Storm Water Storage and Treatment
Eutrophication & Management
Environmental Issues.
Chapter 14 Water Pollution
Harris Chain of Lakes Restoration Council Brief
Consensus Forecast and Water Resource Comparison
5.2 Detection and Monitoring of Pollution
Eutrophication & Management
Human dependence Practice questions Human.
Permitting Requirements for Lagoons
Florida Water Forum Springs and Estuaries Drew Bartlett
5.2 Detection and Monitoring of Pollution
Beth begins with $10 in the bank and
ECOSYSTEM RESTORATION
Study Guide Questions:
Eutrophication & Management
Consensus Forecast and Water Resource Comparison
The Water Cycle Notes science doodles page.
Space Coast TPO State Road (S.R.) 528 Update
Presentation transcript:

The Cost savings on an Ecosystem Restoration project if the area is treated with Microbes First The example used for this comparison was the Stevenson Creek Ecosystem Restoration project in Clearwater Florida. The Project was scheduled to be a one year project. It took 12 years to design, permit and get under contract and it took seven years to complete the work and three contractors were terminated.

COST TO REMOVE ORGANIC MATERIAL PRIOR TO DREDGING Current estimates indicate 80% of the material in the Stevenson Creek project is organic muck which equates to about 105,600 CY of the 132,000 CY in a 29 acre area that could be eliminated prior to dredging. This quantity of material could be eliminated in approximately 1.5 years of treatment at a cost of $137,750. This is a little more than $28,000 / acre to a depth of 2.5 to 3.5 ft. Improvements could be easily noticeable with the first four months. But, lets see what effect this has on cost to complete when the organics are removed first. Remember that our very conservative estimate of cost is $4.9 M.

New Estimated Project Cost Mobilization & De-Mobilization $270,000.00 Construct a Temporary De-Watering Area $0.00 Survey & Layout $32,000 Construct Littoral Shelf $525,000.00 Dredge Est 32,000 CY ($12.50/CY) $400,000.00 Truck Dredge Spoil $0.00 Water Quality $12,000.00 Elimination of Organics $137,750.00 ESTIMATED TOTAL COST $1,376,750.00 Original Contract amount $4,900,000.00 SAVINGS TO TAXPAYERS $3,523,250.00

CONCLUSION In the preceding pages we have shown a cost savings of approximately 72% or $3.5 Million. Even if it is half as much as shown it results in a substantial savings that cannot be ignored. In addition to these savings our microbial technology will significantly reduce COD, BOD and TSS as well as control and eliminate associated odor and assist in the control of algae growth and nearly eliminate fecal coliform in Stevenson Creek. We also are convinced there are many other costs that will be significantly reduced if not eliminated such as real estate that would otherwise be needed for the dewatering process and storage of dredge material. This process can be used in virtually any water body or area that is normally inundated and could be used to reduce organic material in existing spoil areas as well as streams, lakes, rivers, canals and retention ponds.