15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Building Civic Life on the New Frontier Submitted by:- Maulika. R. Kapoori ( )

Advertisements

Building up capacity for Roma inclusion at local level Kosice, November 6 th, 2013.

Struggling to Make Ends Meet In America: What can we do? Susan Jakes (919) Robin Roper (919)

POWER TO THE PEOPLE How NFP boards can produce better outcomes by inviting stakeholders to have a say in their decision-making.

New governance concepts An annotated bibliography by Emilien Gruet.

Lorelei L. Hanson Gloria A. Filax Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences ALBERTA CLIMATE DIALOGUE (ABCD) PROJECT - CONNECTING TO ARBRI.

Designing engagement Wendy Faulkner Talking Tweed.

Renée A. Daugherty, Ph.D. and Sue E. Williams, Ph.D. Developing Effective Leaders Citizen Engagement through Public Deliberation.

Public Engagement in a Multi-Stakeholder World Don Lenihan June 2008.

Four Historical Perspectives on Deliberation

Mapping the Practice of Online Deliberation Edith Manosevitch, PhD Emek Yezreel Academic College, Israel The Fourth International Conference on Online.

Assessing Impacts of Citizen Engagement Through Public Deliberation Presented by Sue Williams, Ph.D. Ron C. Powers, Ph.D. Renée Daugherty, Ph.D. Wendy.

Public Engagement: Perspectives and Experiences in North America Tina Nabatchi, Ph.D. Maxwell School of Citizenship & Public Affairs Syracuse University.

DEMOCRATIC CULTURAL POLICY: WHICH DEMOCRACY? WHICH CULTURE? WHICH POLICY? Clive Gray De Montfort University.

Democracy What is Democracy?.

The David Mathews Center for Civic Life Mission: The Mathews Center is a 501 (c)(3) non-profit, non-partisan, tax- exempt corporation that works with.

1 Community Problem Solving Through Deliberative Democracy.

T HE CHALLENGE OF A E UROPEAN PUBLIC SPHERE : D ELIBERATION AND THE ROLE OF ICT S. Dr. Georgios Papanagnou.

Public Administration Department

Techniques in Civic Engagement Presented by Bill Rizzo Local Government Specialist UW-Extension Local Government Center

Local Government Programming In-service October 22 & 23, 2014 Deliberative Governance: Civil Discourse and Public Engagement Presented by Bill Rizzo Professor.

June 2002USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service1 Critical Meeting Elements: Preparation to Minimize Conflict.

Canada/US Experiences in Public Involvement Learning from our Neighbours C2D2 Presentation Miriam Wyman and Sandra Zagon Collaboration Practitioners Network.

Citizen involvement – the Danish way A brief history – three waves The democratic perspective Possible new directions

Meaningful Citizen Engagement Tim Woods March, 2009.

HUSSEIN AMIN JUNE 2008 Innovative Strategies for Engaging the Press, Policy, Policy-Makers and the Public: Some Debated Points.

Leading the Way Toward More Collaborative Local Governance.

Toward More Civil, Productive Public Discourse A brief orientation for ABA Mediation Week, 2011 Matt Leighninger Deliberative Democracy Consortium

How to achieve impact? CIPAST in Practice – Doing Citizen Participation Pierre-Benoit Joly, INRA/TSV.

Finding Workable Solutions Prevent │ Collaborate │ Resolve.

1 Welcome to Oklahoma Moderators and Recorders Academy Prepared by: Renée Daugherty, Ph.D. Oklahoma State University.

1 Civic Engagement through Public Deliberation Renée A. Daugherty Oklahoma Partnership for Public Deliberation.

DELIBERATION JACQUIE BURGESS DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY, UCL EUROPEAN RESEARCH 2002 CONFERENCE.

Iris Young Inclusion and Democracy. Iris Young Professor of Political Science at University of Chicago Critical and Feminist Perspectives Written a variety.

Purpose of Deliberative Issues Forums  Provide productive spaces for public discourse on complex issues  Encourage conversation that identifies underlying.

Deliberation The Work of Making Choices Requires individuals and groups to grapple with values and the tensions among those values 1.

Dialogue & deliberation Oliver Escobar University of Edinburgh & What Works Scotland St Andrews, 21 st March 2015.

What is Public Deliberation? Deliberation is an approach to politics in which citizens, not just experts or politicians, are deeply involved in public.

Colorado State Extension Community Collaboration Training Program January 2013 Session: To Deliberate or not to Deliberate? Trainer: Martín Carcasson,

Education for intercultural citizenship in the Euro- Mediterranean region Alexandria Annual Education Convention.

Role of welfare services for participative citizenship in Finland Kati Närhi, Tuomo Kokkonen and Aila-Leena Matthies University of Jyväskylä, Finland Kokkola.

Christine Flynn Organisational Consultant 15 August 2016.

Facilitating dialogue and deliberation

CAN’T MAKE THE MEETING? NO PROBLEM!

QUALITIES OF AN ADVOCATE

Baylor University Civic literacy & skill building

Nadjeli Babinet Rojas Sustainable Development Director

Professional Learning Communities

Commissioning A short introduction

E-Governance: Communication Strategy for Greater Citizen Participation

Public Participation for Executives and Decision Makers

Collective Impact Fall 2017.

FACILITATING DELIBERATIVE FORUMS—AN INTRODUCTION Summer 2016

From Confrontation to Dialogue

Finding the Civic Learning in Your Classroom

Key Drivers Accelerating pace and unpredictability of change

Regulatory Action on the field of eDemocracy from an ethical perspective Evika Karamagioli Deputy Director , Gov2u.

Chapter 15 © Routledge/Taylor & Francis 2014

Report to the CAN Board of Directors

Dialogue Guides Models for Stakeholder Interaction Around Issues

The Pathfinder is building on the take part network (the learning framework) funded by the Department for Communities and Local Government and managed.

Environment and Development Policy Section

democracy DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY Matt Bennett

Art of Diplomacy Newport Beach Marriot Hotel

Civic Involvement, Participation, & Skills

Focus on Children - a gradual shift towards a more child-inclusive mediation approach in family disputes Julia Radanova, attorney-at-law and mediator,

Innovation in Democracy Programme

GOVERNANCE For sustainable tourism

Community Mobilization: Garnering public support for your housing plan

Presentation transcript:

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

Political Map

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

Sam Kaner, Facilitator’s Guide to Participatory Decision-Making

Not allowing enough divergent opinion False consensus (dissent not heard, decisions likely either faulty or unsustainable)

Exiting groan zone too early False polarization (sparks misunderstanding, distrust, unsustainable one-sided solutions, fact wars, spirals of conflict)

frustrations with process, Getting stuck in groan zone Paralysis by Analysis (no decisions, frustrations with process, chilling effect for future engagement)

The Toolkit Tools for divergent thinking Tools for “working through” Tools for convergent thinking

The Cycle of Deliberative Inquiry (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue) Issue Analysis Convening Reporting Action Facilitating Interactive Communication (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue)

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

Handout

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

Democratic Communication Decision-makers/ Politicians Public/ Advocates Experts The deliberative practitioner Throgmorton, “The Rhetorics of Policy Analysis,” 1991

Passionate Impartiality The recognition of the tension between: Impartiality Honoring Equality and Inclusion Honoring the importance of good data

The Cycle of Deliberative Inquiry (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue) Issue Analysis Convening Reporting Action Facilitating Interactive Communication (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue)

Passionate Impartiality Growing Resources for Passionate Impartiality Networks of deliberative practitioners and college and university centers and institutes (NIF, UNCG, ADP, Democracy’s Commitment) National organizations (NCDD, DDC, Kettering, Democracy Imperative, AmericaSpeaks, Public Agenda, Everyday Democracy, etc.) For profit and non-profit firms (Keystone, Meridian, Place Matters) Conflict management and community mediation programs Extension programs Public libraries Community organizations (United Way, community foundations, public libraries) IAP2’s push to move from PR to P2 (Public Participation) Governmental resources (National League of Cities Democratic Governance program, Institute for Local Government, Policy Consensus Institute)

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal

The Cycle of Deliberative Inquiry (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue) Issue Analysis Convening Reporting Action Facilitating Interactive Communication (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue)

Sam Kaner, Facilitator’s Guide to Participatory Decision-Making

The Three Ds Debate Dialogue Deliberation Contest Compete Argue Promote opinion Seek majority Persuade Dig in Tightly structured Express Usually fast Clarifies Majoritarian Explore Exchange Discuss Build relationships Understand all Seek understanding Reach across Loosely structured Listen Usually slow Nondecisive / non-decisional Choose Weigh Decide Make decisions Seek overlap Seek wisdom/judgment Framed to make choices Complementary

http://www.ncdd.org/files/NCDD2010_Resource_Guide.pdf

The Cycle of Deliberative Inquiry (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue) Issue Analysis Convening Reporting Action Facilitating Interactive Communication (Deliberation/Debate/Dialogue)

15 Key Aspects of the Deliberative Perspective 1. Tough choices 2. Public Judgment 3. Democratic governance 4. Inclusivity and Equality 5. The role of citizens 6. The role of government 7. The role of experts 8. The role of the media 9. Faith in human nature 10. Wisdom of crowds and co-production of knowledge 11. Interactive communication 12. Passionate impartiality 13. Balancing individual interests and the public good 14. Legitimacy 15. Striving for an unreachable ideal