Doctoring the Nation: The Rise and Fall of Eugenics

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Topic 3: Ideas of Race in the late 19th and 20th Centuries
Advertisements

Global Dynamism Index (GDI) 2013 summary report Model developed by the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU)
Kill or Cure. 1. To examine the role of psychological medicine continuing the process of ‘doctoring the nation’ that we looked at in relation to eugenics.
HIST3025 Hitler and the National Socialist Ideology Lecture 9: Eugenics 25 April 2013.
Kill or Cure.  1. Introduce eugenics as a prime example of ‘doctoring the nation’ between the 1880s and 1940s  2. Demonstrate that this went beyond.
Demographic changes in the UK, Part 1 Joan Garrod
Demographic Transition Model
Population Futures!. Different Assumptions  Different Predictions  Different Future 3 fundamental factors that affect the size of any population ◦fertility.
1 Essentials of Migration Management for Policy Makers and Practitioners Section 2.2 Migration and Demography.
PROCESSES, CYCLES, AND POLICIES OF POPULATION CHANGE
Eugenics = “well-born” Francis Galton 1860s Genetic determinism. Concern about which heritable traits are spreading thru the human population. Policies.
C H A P T E R Innisfree McKinnon University of Oregon © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Lecture Outline The Future of North America 19.
Why did the Liberal Government introduce the Welfare Reforms?
Key Issue #2: Where Are Migrants Distributed? 3% of world are international migrants (mostly in U.S) Global Migration Patterns o Net-out migration – Asia,
Birth Rate and Death rate are both high. Population growth is slow and fluctuating. Reasons Birth Rate is high as a result of: Lack of family planning.
How do countries go through stages of Population Change 23 October 2015 Learning Objectives: To identify characteristics of populations at different stages.
Internationalisation of Finnish Public Research Organisations Dr. Antti Pelkonen Senior Scientist, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland
Medical Experimentation and African American Women By, Saba Tanvir.
Think About What policies might help address the population issues in your region?
DATELECTURER 3/5/2013 Aaron Pascal Mauck MA, PhD Internationalism and Health Lecture: Reproductive Health in the Interwar Period.
MIGRATION Chapter 3.
INTERNATIONAL TRADE LECTURE 1: The World of International Economics.
Chapter Five Processes and Cycles of Population Change.
Mental Health in Canada Historical Perspectives. Defining Words Mental Health Movement Mental HygienePatient Rights ExclusionWork Therapy MarginalizationShock.
Roots. Demography Demography is the study of population characteristics Changing population trends in the UK is an important topic for Geographers to.
EUGENICS AND RACIAL PURITY. WHAT IS EUGENICS? ‘The science of racial fitness though correct breeding and a healthy environment.’ ‘The science of racial.
What is the Demographic Transition Model (DTM)? The demographic transition model explains the transformation of countries from having high birth and death.
Chapter 27 The Age of Anxiety. Uncertainty in Modern Thought In what different directions was philosophy moving in the first half of the 20th century?
Roots. Demography Demography is the study of population characteristics Changing population trends in the UK is an important topic for geographers to.
Eugenics. Defining eugenics: “Improving human genetic qualities” Eugenics is a social philosophy which advocates the improvement of human hereditary traits.
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF COMMUNITY HEALTH NURSING
For more course tutorials visit
 Demographic Transition Model.  The demographic transition model shows population change over time.  It studies how birth rate and death rate affect.
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
Exam Paper 2 Topic 5 Cold War
What is the Demographic Transition Model (DTM)?
Chapter 2 Key Issue 2 The Demographic Transition Model
What can we tell about Population?
The Three Economic Questions And The Four Economic Systems
Human Population 3.
Imperialism Blitz.
Demography: Population Studies
Why do states cooperate with each other
Colonization, Decolonization, & Imperialism
AP Review: Unit 5.2 (Industrialization)
The History of Humanity
GCSE Paper This presentation goes through paper one detailing the different question types and what you are required to do with each one. Paper One will.
Demographic and Democratic Transitions
World Geography 3200/02 Start 6.2 Population Growth.
SOC 315 Education for Service-- snaptutorial.com.
Post-War Mental Health
Chapter 7: Population Futures
OUR COUNTRY AS A CITIZEN OF THE WORLD
Introduction to Brave New World and 1984
Key Foci for Paper One Theme 1: Political and governmental change, 1918–89 In studying Theme 1, students need to understand the changing nature of the.
The History of Humanity
“New” Imperialism: Causes.
LIVINGSTON HIGH SCHOOL SOCIAL STUDIES DEPARTMENT
CHAPTER XIX Internal Troubles, External Threats: China, the Ottoman Empire, and Japan 1800–1914
제목 WHY STUDY EUROPE? Prof. Dr. Kyu Young LEE September 19, 2017
Higher History:Essay Skills
Higher History:Essay Skills
What can we tell about Population?
THE DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Theory and Practice in Canada
29.3-Continued World at War
Authority and Government
Doctoring the Nation: The Rise of Eugenics
Global Stratification
Presentation transcript:

Doctoring the Nation: The Rise and Fall of Eugenics Kill or Cure Doctoring the Nation: The Rise and Fall of Eugenics

Aims/Structure of Lecture 1. Introduce eugenics as a prime example of ‘doctoring the nation’ between the 1880s and 1940s 2. Demonstrate that this went beyond Nazi Germany 3. Examine the reasons for the rise of this mode of ‘doctoring the nation’ 4.Consider reasons for its particular association with Nazi Germany 5. Postscript looking at whether the war saw the end of eugenics

1. Eugenics as a way of ‘doctoring the nation’

What was eugenics? Term coined in 1883 by British scientist Francis Galton (1822-1911), cousin of Charles Darwin Galton builds on work of Darwin to extend interest in variation, the role of heredity, and the question of (un)natural selection when it came to man

Eugenics becomes a science and a movement 1904: setting up of the Eugenics Record Office (later the Eugenics Laboratory) at UCL 1907: Eugenics Education Society founded (from 1926 The Eugenics Society) 1908 first edition of the Eugenics Review Eugenics Society never more than 1000 members (high proportion of professionals) but influence of idea extends much further

Eugenics as a prime example of ‘doctoring the nation’ Interested in the variation of qualities (eg intelligence) across a population Draws attention to those at either extreme Theory of heredity offers clue to how the society might adjust the mean to minimise social problems and maximise ability of population

Positive eugenics Encouragement of the fit to breed: education and propaganda Leads to consideration of incentives Consideration of marriage advice and certificates of fitness Encourages use of mental testing to create a ladder of opportunity in education Often meritocratic

Negative eugenics Birth control Immigration control Sterilisation Segregation ‘Euthanasia’ Particular focus on ‘mental defectives’, ‘feeble-minded’, mentally ill, physically handicapped

2. Demonstrate that this went beyond Nazi Germany

Compatibility with liberal regimes British roots and continuing leading role Support from leading writers and intellectuals including many on the left such as H.G. Wells and George Bernard Shaw British Mental Deficiency Act 1913 USA, Canada, Australia: immigration control USA: introduction of sterilisation in large number of states by 1930s

Compatibility with social democracy Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden all introduce eugenic laws in 1930s By 1970 estimated 170,000 sterilised

Becomes an international movement International eugenics conferences beginning in London, 1912 Part of being a modern nation

Global Perspective Britain, South Asia, Australia, New Zealand, China and Hong Kong, South Africa, Kenya, South East Asia, Germany, France, Holland and Dutch East Indies, Scandinavia, Southern Europe, Eastern Europe, Russia, Japan, Iran, Cuba, Puerto Rico, Mexico, Brazil, USA, Canada

3. Reasons for the rise of this mode of ‘doctoring the nation’

Science and pseudo-science Victorian cult of measurement (Galton) Longer-term cultures of breeding Emerging science of heredity Modernist attractions of science of eugenics Science or pseudo-science?

The demographic transition From late 19th century a fall in fertility in western nations Concern in Britain about decline being most marked in middle-classes and among professionals In France, fear of overall population decline by early 20th century (encourages positive forms of eugenics) Moral objections to birth control focus attention on segregation and ‘treatment’ Link to women’s groups, birth control advocates, and even sexual liberals

Nation building era Heightened concern about international competition and ‘national efficiency’ Era of nation building & interest in defining the nation (eg post WWI) Immigrant nations concerned about racial mix

New ways of seeing /ranking population Population problems and differences exposed by rise of mass education, and growing scale of asylums, prisons, workhouses Emergence of new tools such as the social survey and the psychological test to rank individuals

The challenges of a welfare state Explaining failures: the ineducable; the recidivist, the unemployed Opportunities for new experts to test, identify, segregate, and treat the unfit Growing concern about the capacity and cost of solution of segregation (particularly as welfare state faces economic crises of war and depression, and as it becomes more ambitious)

4. Nazi Germany: an exceptional case?

Why Nazi Germany stands out Importance of ideology of national fitness and purity to politics and culture: ‘the ‘racial state’ Leader in psychiatric and genetic science Opportunities from a sympathetic state Degree of economic problems via depression and mobilisation of economy in WWII Scale of sterilisation policy (375,000) Use of ‘euthanasia’ for mentally handicapped (Action T4 – 70,000)

Yet German eugenics has roots before Nazi era Sterilisation Law introduced before Nazis come to power Follows example of USA Eugenics and an interest in ‘race hygiene’ well established (1st society 1905) Germany already a leader in eugenic sciences of psychiatry and genetics, eg via Kaiser Wilhelm Institute (and has financial support from Rockefeller Foundation into 1930s) Deaths of mentally ill in German asylums in First World War (140,000)

Concluding thoughts Strong position of science in German culture Key importance of a regime able and willing to ignore rights of individual (compulsory rather than voluntary sterilisation); and of limited opportunities for organised opposition Key importance of wartime situation in radicalising situation, though most extreme policy of euthanasia still remains secret and encounter opposition But far from unique in seeing eugenics as a tool to ‘doctor the nation’ Broader structural factors: demography; nation-building; economics and welfare; medical science; new visibility

Postscript: the End of Eugenics?

The post-war reckoning At post-war Nazi trials the question of medical experiments is subject for prosecution, but eugenics itself in fact attracts little attention Not until 1970s and 1980s and a new generation of historians does it come into focus

Persistence? Policy of sterilisation for eg mentally handicapped continues in some countries well beyond WWII, eg in Sweden until 1970s In Britain, abortion and sterilisation legalised in 1960s/70s as a form of voluntary birth control (along with contraception can target the ‘problem family’) Subsequently, techniques of prenatal screening used to prevent birth of handicapped, though without the language of eugenics

In Britain, a eugenics society continues after WWII, though one that makes efforts to distinguish itself from acts of Nazis In science, interest continues under the banner of ‘human genetics’ Far more potential now for eugenics than in first half of the century, but largely in hands of medical consumer rather than the state