Limiting Indications for Varicose Vein Surgery to Maximise Service Provision in an Era of Restricted Funding; An Audit of Compliance at the GCHHS Manoharan.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Comparator Selection in Observational Comparative Effectiveness Research Prepared for: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)
Advertisements

Introduction to Standard 5: Patient Identification and Procedure Matching Advice Centre Network Meeting Nicola Dunbar March 2013.
Varicose Veins: More Than Just a Cosmetic Problem
Management of Leg Ulcers
British Association of Day Surgery The Future of Day Surgery: The Ambulatory Pathway Ian Smith, MD, FRCA Senior Lecturer in Anaesthesia.
Narelle Marshall (AARCS Nurse) & Darlene Saladine (Acute Pain Service Nurse) November 2012 ‘A Multidisciplinary Approach to the Prevention of Pressure.
Outcome of angioembolisation for blunt renal trauma in haemodynamically unstable patients: 10 year analysis of Queensland Public hospitals ) Introduction.
The Health Roundtable 3-3b_HRT1215-Session_MILLNER_CARRUCAN_WOOD_ADHB_NZ Orthopaedic Service Excellence – Implementing Management Operating Systems Presenter:
The Scope of Musculoskeletal Disease Treatment and Costs Prof Stephen Graves University of Melbourne.
Lower Extremity Venous Disease: Peripheral Venous Insufficiency
Venous Reflux Disease and Current Treatment Modalities VN20-03-B 10/04.
A Comparison of Treatment Options - The Efficacy of Endovenous Laser Ablation and Radiofrequency Ablation Therapy in the Treatment of Symptomatic Venous.
Stroke Units Southern Neurology. Definition of a stroke unit A stroke unit can be defined as a unit with dedicated stroke beds and a multidisciplinary.
The National Mastectomy and Breast Reconstruction Audit Key findings of the Third Annual Report Slides produced by the MBR Project Team. © The National.
New Treatment Options for Varicose Veins Minimally Invasive Techniques to Remove Varicose Veins Dr. Shannon D. Thomas FRACS Vascular, Endovascular and.
Revised for 2013 Shannon Hein RN, CPN(C).  published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal in May 2004  Found an overall incidence rate of adverse.
M Purpose Improvement Tools/Methods Limitations / Lessons Learned Results Process Improvement Improving Hospital-Acquired Pressure Ulcers at Discharge.
A Comparative Audit of Total Abdominal Hysterectomy, Subtotal Hysterectomy, Vaginal hysterectomy and Laparoscopically Assisted Vaginal Hysterectomy in.
What is interventional Radiology? By: Amber Smith.
CHIRPs: An adaptation of Enhanced Recovery for Paediatrics. Julie Jolly Modern Matron.
Varicose Veins Power point by: Laurie Harriet Amber Gabby.
Implementing Clinical Governance COMPASS Consultant Outcome Indicators Programme.
Diagnosis Recitation. The Dilemma At the conclusion of my “diagnosis” presentation during the recent IAPA meeting, a gentleman from the audience asked.
JCIA Update (April – May 2011). KFSH&RC Mission JCIA accreditation is designed to create that culture. KFSH&RC provides the highest level of specialized.
National Stroke Audit Rehabilitation Services 2016
Title of the Change Project
Rome 2016, UIP chapter meeting Endovenous laser and radiofrequency ablation. Comparison with stripping and foam sclerotherapy George Geroulakos Professor.
The potential of Interventional radiology
A.A.Elmghrbee, K.Bilal, P.Whitear, A.E.P.Cameron, Abu Own,
The Second Patient Report of the National Emergency Laparotomy Audit
Title of the Change Project
HEALTH ECONOMICS BASICS
Oesophago–Gastric Cancer
Venous Thromboembolism Prophylaxis (VTE)
Implementation of an ERAS Program for Gynecological Oncology Surgery
Dr Mohamed Ouda MRCGP 1-Reason for choice of audit 3-Standards set
Is There a Need to Address AF in patients Undergoing Valve Surgery?
Title of the Change Project
A prospective study of endoscopic radiofrequency application (STRETTA) for gastroesophageal reflux disease: Early UK experience N Hamza, D Kamali, S Punnoose,
DCD Hope, H Wang, R Anders, P Villa, C Kong
Introduction Methods Results Conclusions
NICOR A NICE Commissioned Pilot of Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) for Ablation of Cardiac Arrhythmias Withers KL 1, Patrick H 2, Cunningham.
Improving Preoperative Analgesia for Fractured Neck of Femur – A Retrospective Analysis of an Ultrasound-guided Fascia Iliaca Catheter Service F Eljelani¹,
Oesophago–Gastric Cancer
F Eljelani, J Womack, B Goodman, A Blackburn, MK Varma
Value of Pharmaceuticals in Managed Care Pharmacy
Compensation Committee 2017 Goals – Updated
Insert Objective 1 Insert Objective 2 Insert Objective 3.
Annual General Meeting
Progressing and discharging patients from the intensive care
The Utilization of Sequential Compression Devices Among Pregnant Women
The potential of Interventional radiology
OUT-PATIENT IN A BED (OIB) PROCESS.
Aim and Key Driver Diagram
Specialised Commissioning Improving specialised services for severe intestinal failure adult patients What will this mean for you?
GMHC Board of Directors November 14, 2016
  Retrograde Injection Technique for Endovenous Chemical Ablation of Varicose Veins, A Case Study     Steven T Deak, MD, PhD, FACS Hungarian Medical Association.
Background 30% of acute hospital days used by patients in the last year of life 75% of people will be admitted to hospital in the last year of life Location.
Victoria Gemmell1 Professor Alex Mullen2
P8-2 Rezum water vapour thermal therapy for benign prostatic hyperplasia: early results from the United Kingdom Max Johnston1, Tina Gehring1, James Montgomery1,
Retrograde Microfoam Ablation of Superficial Venous Insufficiency:
What is Patient Blood Management?
The Patient Experience Mr John Hitchman RCoA Lay Representative
19,628 operations in NSW for LSS between 2003 and 2013
APHA Facts on Private Hospitals
Clinical Case Symptomatic CVD without varicose veins
An Audit of Nutritional Trace Element Requesting Within York Teaching Hospitals Roger Bramley.
Diabetes Self-Management Education and Support: Component of Standard Diabetes Care 1, 2 “… Ongoing patient self-management education and support are.
DCD Hope, H Wang, R Anders, P Villa, C Kong
Presentation transcript:

Limiting Indications for Varicose Vein Surgery to Maximise Service Provision in an Era of Restricted Funding; An Audit of Compliance at the GCHHS Manoharan B, Jackson M & Butcher W Gold Coast university Hospital, Southport, Australia Introduction In 2011 Queensland Health implemented the Scope of Publically Funded Services Policy to improve effectiveness of health services through re- allocation of resources to priority areas. The treatment of uncomplicated varicose veins no longer attracted funding under the Activity Based Funding (ABF) model. The exceptions are varicose vein patients with significant dysfunction or disability, or venous ulcers. As the exact scope of the change was never formally defined, local policy was formulated at the Gold Coast Hospital (GCH). From January 2013 surgery was only offered for, Patients with lipodermatosclerosis or with acute or recently healed venous ulcer Patients with spontaneous bleeding from varicose veins Patients with superficial thrombophlebitis Patients with venous eczema Australian data has previous shown that the cost of inpatient management of venous leg ulcers can amount to over $12,000 per admission, with variable results/improvement of the ulcers upon discharge. These patients usually require ongoing follow up in out patient settings and ongoing community based wound care (Gruen et al, 1996). Add acknowledgements Conclusions Better case selection and also shifting appropriate cases to Outpatient management (i.e. Sclerotheraphy) has allowed us to ensure maximum benefit from limited funding and reduce inpatient days. Complicated varicose veins will be treated with the imperative being to heal or prevent ulceration Careful patient selection and increased provision of outpatient management has allowed us to continue varicose vein management provision in complex patients requiring treatment in an era of funding shortfall. Figure 2. typical Setup of a Radiofrequency Ablation procedure done with ultrasound guidance. Photo Courtesy of the Miami Vein Center. Discussion We found that since the change in policy (end of 2012), except in cases where patients with indications such as pain/cosmesis were added to surgical waiting lists before the policy change, that the indications were being adhered to. The length of stay in hospital and complication rate were excellent in comparison to external benchmarks. In 2013, 96% patients were discharged on the same day as their procedure, compared to benchmark of 85% at the NHS in the United Kingdom. The incresing number of Bilateral surgeries reflects good use of resources (bilateral surgery is only marginally more expensive). In general only one leg will have a clear indication, however, with a two surgeon team bilateral surgery where indicated seldom adds more than a few minutes to operating time It is important to know that although the majority of varicose veins are in some way symptomatic, it is unusual for varicose veins to cause symptoms that interfere substantially with the activities of daily living. Varicose veins also very rarely precipitate major health problems, and therefore, apart from pain there is no imperative to treat varicose veins. Figure 1. Case Mix for time period between 2011 and 2013 looking at relative percentages of Classical Varicose vein Surgery (VV) compared to Radio Frequency Ablation. A number of Sclerotheraphy proceducres were performed in 2011 an 2012 in the setting of operative theatre however since 2013 onwards were wholly performed in an outpatient setting and thus excluded from this graph. Methods and Results METHODS: An audit of practice at the Gold Coast University Hospital (October 2013-December 2013) and the old Gold Coast Hospital (2011- October 2013) was conducted from 2011-2013 to compare changes to service delivery and outcomes based on the new policy. As sclerotheraphy provision (for high risk surgical patients) is now performed in the outpatient setting it was excluded from this study. Data was obtained from the National Australasian Vascular Audit (AVA) database and where possible supplemented with information from Hospital patient records, imaging reports and operative notes. We also investigated the utilisation of Radio Frequency Ablation (RFA) at our Institution. RFA is an image-guided minimally invasive treatment alternative to surgical stripping of superficial venous reflux. RFA does not require an operating room or general anaesthesia and has been performed in an outpatient setting by a variety of medical specialties including surgeons and interventional radiologists. Rather than surgically removing the vein, RFA works by destroying or ablating the refluxing vein segment using thermal energy delivered through a radiofrequency catheter. At our institution, RFA is still performed in an operating theatre environment, but generally under Sedation and local anaesthesia and same day discharge. RESULTS: 158 procedures were performed in 2011, 72 in 2012 and 59 in 2013. Between 75%-90% of cases wee conventional varicose vein surgery, compared to Radiofrequency Ablations (5-21%). In 2013, 51% of cases were bilateral compared to 33% (2012) and 44% (2011). 95-100% of all patients had day surgery with no overnight admission. Median Hospital Stay was 1 day in all year groups analysed. In 2013, 3% of procedures were for recurrent varicose veins compared to 7% (2012) and 13 % (2011) highlighting the growth of Outpatient Sclerotheraphy in managing this patient group. ASA scores have increased across the years (6% ASA 3&4 in 2011, 12.5% in 2012 and 18.6% in 2013) highlighting more complex patients being selected for. There were no complications documented for any of the cases. Figure 3: Relative % of cases in each year shown as main indication for surgery. As expected Pain as an indication decreased over the period of the study (49% to 4%) however Thrombophlebitis and Lipodermatosclerosis both incresed as a relative rpoportion. References Gruen R, Chang S & MacLellan D (1996). ‘Optimizing the hospital management of leg ulcers.’ Aust N Z J Surg. Mar;66(3):171-4.