Success factors of the pension reform

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
What is the EU Budgets role for the EU internal market? Jorge Nunez Ferrer Conference Europe in the Global Economy.
Advertisements

Anna Nechai, PhD Legal and Pension Expert
1 Australian superannuation data APRAs data collection and publications 24 April 2013.
International Conference on Small States and Economic Resilience April 2007 Valetta, Malta Islands and Small States Institute Government intervention.
Labor market and social protection in Slovakia Project „EU Enlargement and its Impact on the Social Policy and Labor Markets of Accession and Non-Accession.
UNBC Pension Plan Financial Statement Highlights 2005 and 2006 Presented by: Colleen Smith Chief Financial Officer (Acting)
INTERNATIONAL NETWORK OF PENSION REGULATORS AND SUPERVISORS CENRTAL AND EASTERN EUROPEAN REGIONAL NETWORK Investment of Pension Funds: Challenges for the.
The Hungarian Pension Reform: Do We Need an Extra Pillar? Fehér Csaba* Presented by: Kóbor Ádám* *Views expressed in this paper are those of the authors.
Developing Corporate Debt Market in India The 3 rd Invest India Debt Market Round Table May 6, 2003 Rakesh Mohan Deputy Governor Reserve Bank of India.
ECON 216:Economy of Ghana II Lecture 3: The Financial Sector & Monetary Policy I.
Sirlis Sõmer Ministry of Social Affairs Disability Policy Challenges.
PENSION REFORM EXPERIENCES IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Ministry of Economy, Labour and Social Policy, Poland Kiev, May 28th,
The Third Way: Legacies of the Clinton Administration and Prospects for the Future Tokyo December 12, 2000.
Atlantic Connection Conference Shared Risk Plans, July 9, 2014.
FINANCE FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT (FED) PROGRAM LAUNCH EVENT July 17, 2013.
Ivica Chačaturianová Gabriel Hinzeller Association of Financial Intermediaries and Financial Advisors 30. April 2008, CIFA - VI. International Forum.
New Pension Reform in Chile: Some Comments Heinz P. Rudolph The World Bank November 27, 2006.
How to arrange the pay out of pensions: Going Dutch Gaby Schellekens, Directorate of Industrial Relations Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment The.
The Trends and Challenges for Private Pension Funds Denise Lamaute Sofia, Bulgaria February 16-18, 2005.
0 TIAA-CREF: A BRIEF HISTORY A LOOK AHEAD Scott Evans Executive Vice President, Asset Management TIAA-CREF October, 2007.
Martin Bruncko Zrenjanin, Serbia 23 February, 2009 THE ROLE OF ICT POLICIES IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF KNOWLEDGE-BASED ECONOMY The Experience of Slovaki a.
1 Current issues in the Polish mandatory pension funds market Dariusz Stańko Warsaw School of Economics The Private Pensions Day, 5 th edition Sinaia,
FINANCIAL REGULATION AND THE G20 IS THERE A GAP IN THE GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE? MIKE CALLAGHAN LOWY INSTITUTE 1.
Fiscal Transparency at Local Level Baki Kerimoğlu 7 June 2005, ISTANBUL.
PrimAmérica CONSULTORES Investment of Pension Funds: Challenges for the Regulation* Augusto Iglesias Palau PrimAmérica Consultores May, 2004 * Presented.
Conclusions are the author's 1 The Effectiveness of Multi-Pillar Pensions– A Precautionary Tale NASI Conference Emily S. Andrews World Bank (retired) January.
FUNDED PENSIONS IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Design and Experience Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Cancun, May 15th, 2003.
Labour market statistics Labour Policy Information and Analysis Department Kadi Siimer.
Regulatory Institutions in Turkey. Regulatory Institutions Central Bank of Turkey Banking Supervision and Regulatory Institutions Capital Markets Board.
1 FIN 408 International Investment Factors affecting Risk and Return Size and Number of International Open-end Funds Global market Correlations Correlation.
New Bulgarian Multi Pillar Pension System: Legislative Development Bulgaria, Sofia, February 16 th and 17 th, 2005.
REFORMING HIGHER EDUCATION IN EUROPE – CONTEXT AND BACKGROUND Sjur Bergan Head, Dept. of Higher Education and History Teaching Council of Europe.
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION MPA503 PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ADMINISTRATION.
Introduction to round table panel Cezary Mech PhD President of Association of Capital Market UNFE, Poland.
FUNDED PENSIONS IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Design and Experience Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Geneva, October 9th, 2003.
SME Financing to Promote Innovation in Korea Soon-Yeong Hong.
Ivan Mikloš Deputy prime minister of the Government of the Slovak Republic responsible for economic affairs Bratislava 22 November 2004 COMPETITIVENESS.
Investment Regulations and DC Pensions Pablo Antolin, Financial Affair Division, OECD Asset allocation in uncertain time – CAMR Cass Business School, London,
Reforming the Second Tier of the U.S. Pension System: Tabula Rasa or Step by Step? Sandy Mackenzie & Jon Forman for Savings and Retirement Institute Washington,
ICT Solutions for achieving Smart Regulation The Dutch Programme
Redistributive Impact of Pension Systems Anita M. Schwarz Lead Economist Europe and Central Asia Region World Bank.
Project: EaP countries cooperation for promoting quality assurance in higher education Maria Stratan European Institute for Political Studies of Moldova.
Financing pension system in a country in transition - Poland Zofia Rutkowska Polish Social Insurance Institution - ZUS.
HIGHER EDUCATION IN EUROPE – AN OVERVIEW OF DEVELOPMENTS Sjur Bergan Head, Dept. of Higher Education and History Teaching Council of Europe.
Governor Erkki Liikanen Bank of Finland
The main directions of the Strategy
Programmatic Technical Assistance Partnership
 CIS 7 Poverty and Growth Conference Investment Climate and Financial Sector Reforms EBRD 1.
Pension Reform Workshop Leogrand Hotel Chisinov, June 2008
Current Fiscal Policy and Expenditure Management in Korea
Types of Financial Institutions, Interest Spread, Risk/Return Relationship, and Savings options SSEPF2:a-d.
ZHANG Juwei Institute of Population and Labor Economics
European External Investment Plan
Irena Risteska Ministry of Labor and Social Policy
Pension reform and private pension funds in Poland: Goals and Facts.
Practicing law in transforming Indonesia
Private sector development and SDGs in Albania
Old-age pensions in Poland and worldwide
Agnes Fridely Legal Officer “Insurance and pensions” Claudio Collovà
SLOVAKIA : OLD-AGE PENSION SAVINGS („II. PILLAR“)
Monday, March 27, 2017 Objective: Students will be able to examine the types of accounts available to consumers from financial institutions and the risks,
4.8 The Balance Between Markets and Intervention
Monday, November 16, 2015 Objective: Students will be able to examine the types of accounts available to consumers from financial institutions and the.
Tradeoffs in Negotiations Creating a win-win outcome
Conditions for Successful Pension Reforms Comments
Financial Institutions
INVESTING.
How to help all to participate in the benefits of the IS and the KE
A reality check on Funded Pensions
Klaus Deininger, World Bank, US Denys Nizalov, KEI at KSE, Ukraine
Presentation transcript:

Success factors of the pension reform Lauri Leppik PRAXIS Center for Policy Studies

Similarities of Estonian and Slovak pension reforms Three pillars Basic institutional set­up of different pillars Personal scope

Differences of Estonian and Slovak pension reforms Size of the second pillar contribution rate: Slovak 9%, Estonia 6%=4+2% Qualification rules for benefits Prudential rules Estonia: no limits on investing abroad Slovak: higher allowed share of equities in growth funds Guarantees Estonia: no absolute or relative rate of return guarantees Slovakia: relative rate of return guarantee

II pillar - contributions

Joining the second pillar

Participation in the second pillar Share of population Age

Opinion poll in April 2002 6 % - intend to join in 2002 20 % - intend join later 33 % - do not know 41 % - probably or surely will not join

Background factors Broad political support Financial market infrastructure Confidence in financial institutions The role of the Minister of Social Affairs

Key factors for successful implementation Attractiveness of the reform Emphasize the opportunities of the second pillar rather than failures of the state pension system Selling of the reform Proper role division between the state and financial institutions Transparency Efficient implementing bodies and infrastructure

Internet In Estonia, it is possible through Internet to: to join the second pillar to choose a pension fund to check the balance of the pension account to see the investment portfolios of pension funds to compare the performance of different funds

www.pensionikeskus.ee