Electron Spectrometer Baseline

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
AWAKE Electron Spectrometer Simon Jolly 7 th March 2013.
Advertisements

Joe Vinen Workshop on New Experimental Techniques for the Study of Quantum Turbulence, ICTP, Trieste, June 2005 Metastable He molecules and laser-induced.
Law of Reflection (Smooth Surface):
Linear Collider Bunch Compressors Andy Wolski Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory USPAS Santa Barbara, June 2003.
Synchrotron Radiation What is it ? Rate of energy loss Longitudinal damping Transverse damping Quantum fluctuations Wigglers Rende Steerenberg (BE/OP)
Pair Spectrometer Design Optimization Pair Spectrometer Design Optimization A. Somov, Jefferson Lab GlueX Collaboration Meeting September
Could CKOV1 become RICH? 1. Characteristics of Cherenkov light at low momenta (180 < p < 280 MeV/c) 2. Layout and characterization of the neutron beam.
GlueX Simulations Status Report on CD3 geometry Richard Jones GlueX Collaboration Meeting, Newport News, January 10-12, 2008.
Tagger and Vacuum Chamber Design. Outline. Design considerations. Stresses and deformations. Mechanical assembly.
Types of Analyses Single Collector –Uses only one collector or detector –This is the case with a Daly or EM Advantages: –Need only one detector –Peaks.
experimental platform
Tagger and Vacuum Chamber Design. Outline. Design considerations. Stresses and deformations. Mechanical assembly.
AWAKE Electron Spectrometer Design Simon Jolly 4 th September 2012.
Electron Spectrometer Progress Report Simon Jolly 19 th October 2012.
Creating Light. Light as a Wave Light (or electromagnetic radiation), can be thought of as either a particle or a wave. As a wave, light has a wavelength,
Status Report on Mk.II Pepperpot Simon Jolly Imperial College 13 th June 2007.
The impact of undulators in an ERL Jim Clarke ASTeC, STFC Daresbury Laboratory FLS 2012, March 2012.
Spectrometer Optics John J. LeRose. The Basics Charged particles moving through static magnetic fields.  Magnetic Rigidity Local radius of curvature.
AWAKE Electron Spectrometer Simon Jolly, Lawrence Deacon, Matthew Wing 28 th January 2015.
The Overview of the ILC RTML Bunch Compressor Design Sergei Seletskiy LCWS 13 November, 2012.
Simulations of the double funnel construction for LET. Comparison with a single funnel The aim was to optimise the double funnel configuration to give.
A 3 Pass, Dog-bone Cooling Channel G H Rees, ASTeC, RAL.
SHMS Optics Studies Tanja Horn JLab JLab Hall C meeting 18 January 2008.
Electron Spectrometer Work Package Simon Jolly 19 th May 2014.
Optimising Cuts for HLT George Talbot Supervisor: Stewart Martin-Haugh.
DECam Daily Flatfield Calibration DECam calibration workshop, TAMU April 20 th, 2009 Jean-Philippe Rheault, Texas A&M University.
1 FFAG Role as Muon Accelerators Shinji Machida ASTeC/STFC/RAL 15 November, /machida/doc/othertalks/machida_ pdf/machida/doc/othertalks/machida_ pdf.
BES-III Workshop Oct.2001,Beijing The BESIII Luminosity Monitor High Energy Physics Group Dept. of Modern Physics,USTC P.O.Box 4 Hefei,
EMMA Extraction / Diagnostic line Bruno Muratori STFC, Daresbury Laboratory 01/09/08.
Lecture 9: Inelastic Scattering and Excited States 2/10/2003 Inelastic scattering refers to the process in which energy is transferred to the target,
Tests of spectrometer screens Introduction Layout Procedure Results Conclusions L. Deacon, B. Biskup, S. Mazzoni, M.Wing et. al. AWAKE collaboration meeting,
New Groups and Seating Lab 3: Optics next week, Lab to be posted this weekend. HW 8: Correction problem + paragraph on paper topic/resource. Use this time.
Calibration of energies at the photon collider Valery Telnov Budker INP, Novosibirsk TILC09, Tsukuba April 18, 2009.
Electron Spectrometer: Status July 14 Simon Jolly, Lawrence Deacon 1 st July 2014.
MEIC Detector and IR Integration Vasiliy Morozov, Charles Hyde, Pawel Nadel-Turonski MEIC Detector and IR Design Mini-Workshop, October 31, 2011.
Issues Concerning Different Beam Lines Integration C. Bracco, E. Gschwendtner, B. Goddard, M. Meddahi, A. Petrenko, F. Velotti Acknowledgements: WP3 and.
SL/BI 16/05/1999DIPAC’99 -- JJ Gras -- CERN SL/BI -- Adaptive Optics for the LEP 2 SR Monitors G. Burtin, R.J. Colchester, G. Ferioli, J.J. Gras, R. Jung,
Detector / Interaction Region Integration Vasiliy Morozov, Charles Hyde, Pawel Nadel-Turonski Joint CASA/Accelerator and Nuclear Physics MEIC/ELIC Meeting.
RFQ Exit Bunch Modelling Simon Jolly 25 th July 2012.
Basics Reflection Mirrors Plane mirrors Spherical mirrors Concave mirrors Convex mirrors Refraction Lenses Concave lenses Convex lenses.
Hybrid Fast-Ramping Synchrotron to 750 GeV/c J. Scott Berg Brookhaven National Laboratory MAP Collaboration Meeting March 5, 2012.
Narrow plasma & electron injection simulations for the AWAKE experiment A. Petrenko, K. Lotov, October 11,
Tagger and Vacuum Chamber Design Jim Kellie Glasgow University.
AWAKE Electron Spectrometer Simon Jolly 6 th November 2013.
Scanning Electron Microscope Eee-Jay Rodriguez. The Structure of the Microscope Inside Outside.
Further SR Studies for the Electron Polarimeter M. Sullivan for the JLEIC Collaboration Meeting Oct. 5-7, 2016.
y x Vincenzo Monaco, University of Torino HERA-LHC workshop 18/1/2005
JLEIC MDI Update Michael Sullivan Apr 4, 2017.
Optics: Reflection, Refraction Mirrors and Lenses
Structure and Function
Options and Recommendations for TL and Dumps
The Interaction Region
Large Booster and Collider Ring
Spectrometer Layout (Isometric View)
Update on GEp GEM Background Rates
Electron collider ring Chromaticity Compensation and dynamic aperture
Light Big Idea: Electromagnetic Radiation, which includes light, is a form of radiant energy possessing properties of both waves and zero-mass particles.
PES 1000 – Physics in Everyday Life
Light Big Idea: Electromagnetic Radiation, which includes light, is a form of radiant energy possessing properties of both waves and zero-mass particles.
Refraction and Thin Lenses
Rays, Mirrors, Lenses, and Prisms
ELENA Extra Low ENergy Antiproton Ring
Collider Ring Optics & Related Issues
Magnetic Fields and Forces
Unit Physical Science Systems
Remote sensing in meteorology
Magnetic Fields and Forces
Some of the Points Raised During my JLAB Visit
More on MEIC Beam Synchronization
JLEIC Electron Ring Nonlinear Dynamics Work Plan
Presentation transcript:

Electron Spectrometer Baseline Simon Jolly 26th March 2014

Spectrometer Requirements AWAKE will pass 450 GeV protons through plasma to create wakefield. 5–20 MeV(?) electrons injected into plasma to “witness” proton driven plasma wakefield. Protons and electrons collinearly ejected from plasma: must be separated before measuring electron energy. Spectrometer must measure energy and energy spectrum of electrons to infer behaviour of proton driven wakefield. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Spectrometer Limits What is the energy of the proton beam? 450 GeV. What is the beam stay clear for protons? 7 cm (14 cm diameter). What is the mean/maximum/minimum energy of the accelerated electron beam? We don’t know… What is the energy spread of the electron beam? We don’t know… What is the size/emittance of the electron beam? We don’t know… How stable is the electron beam pulse-to-pulse (and therefore how repeatable is the measurement? We don’t know… Although judging by previous plasma wakefield experiments, it’s not likely to be repeatable at all… 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Spectrometer Specifications As such, we need to measure the energy and energy spread of an electron beam with unknown energy, energy spread and emittance, that is likely to have large variations pulse-to-pulse, to (better than) 1%… This is not easy! In fact, it’s impossible… Large pulse-to-pulse variation means we need to capture as many energies as possible in each shot: must be able to resolve energy spread as well as energy and accept a range of energies, probably 0-5 GeV. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Spectrometer Options Several ways to measure energy in single shot. Direct measurement of particle energy through absorption and conversion to scintillation light (calorimetry): Best way of collecting all energy from individual particles. Very difficult to measure more than one particle without highly segmented calorimeter. Penetration depth in material of known density (dosimetry/sampling calorimetry): Can measure multiple particles at once: measure number of particles or temperature rise at given depth. Can only cope with a few particles with sampling calorimeter and energy resolution low (5%). Need lots of particles for dosimetry measurement. Use magnet to introduce energy-position correlation: Can measure many particles at once. How many depends on detection technique. Tracking gives fewer particles with greater capture efficiency. Scintillator screen allows many more particles but needs more for light output. Susceptible to magnet aberrations: energy measurement depends on optics of system. Like other plasma wakefield experiments, we chose option 3… 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Magnet Options (1) C. P. Browne and W. W. Buechner, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 27, 899 (1956). In an ideal world — with a point-like electron beam with zero emittance — all we need is a smoothly varying magnetic field with a single maximum: make sure low energy beam gets bent more than high energy beam. We, of course, are not in an ideal world… Browne-Buechner spectrometer design provides one-to-one correspondence between position on screen and energy: Corrects for divergence by changing path length such that all energies focussed to a point. Energy range limited to 0.5 E0 – 1.2 E0. For E0 = 3 GeV, need 3 m magnet radius with ~5 m screen… 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Magnet Options (2) Next best option would be to use circular magnet: Without specific Browne-Buechner screen, you won’t get rid of divergence, so there will be some smearing from emittance. Electrons still leave magnet at 90° angle so no issues with sharp edges of fields. Would need custom magnet design. Still requires big magnet to reach integrated fields we require. Difficult to support such large fields with this magnet geometry. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Magnet Options (3) C-magnet would give larger dynamic range for given field. Smaller than circular magnet. Beam can escape one side. Half of magnet not wasted. Difficult to get 1.5 T fields due to missing half support. No longer have 90° exit angle so need to be careful about fields in these regions. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Magnet Options (4) But: we already have a magnet, don’t we…? Yes, with a but… MBPS dipole available for free from CERN: free should not be underestimated… 1.82 T field with 1 m effective length but only 300 mm wide. Field starts to fall off rapidly outside good field region: reduces reliable energy range at exit. Danger of running through nonlinear field regions, particularly for low energy trajectories where spatial spread is larger (but convolution with emittance larger also). 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Square Dipole Trajectories 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review MBPS Magnet 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

MBPS Magnet: Good Field Region? 300 mm 1000 mm 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Multiple Magnets Meeting last week at with Allan Gillespie and Silvia Cipiccia from Strathclyde, plus Jim Clarke from Daresbury. Circular dipole unfeasible due to size and necessary field strength. Concerns about the convolution of emittance with energy measurement for single square dipole: leads to smearing of energy and reduction in resolution. 2 magnet design acts like a drift and cancels out issues from magnet edge effects: you take out whatever you put in, with just the position spread left. Don’t try and measure low energies with high energy spectrometer… 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Spectrometer Chicane: 4 Magnets 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

2 Magnet Spectrometer (A. Gillespie) Advantages: It can have a very broad momentum "bite" (say +/- 50% of p0 ) due to the reversed field in D2 and the rectangular pole shapes. It suffers from very few chromatic aberrations, because it is translationally-independent in the x-direction It is (relatively) compact for the same reasons Provided dipole D2 is made wide enough, it could accommodate rather large variations in electron momentum/energy, and could be modified later for lower electron energies (say 50-300 MeV) simply by reducing the induction below 1.5 T and decreasing the distance lambda from 0.5 m (which is rather arbitrary in any case) The quadrupoles Q1 and Q2 can be used to adjust the H and V focussing conditions e.g. you could arrange point-to-parallel optics in the V (y) plane, and point-to-point optics in the H (x) plane, if the large momentum allows this (?). Disadvantages: The large (17.5°) bend angles might produce V focussing at D1 exit and D2 entrance that is too big a variation across the large delta-p (+/- 50%), in which case theta must be decreased towards 10°. The largish x and y emittances from the plasma channel may screw up the optics at the focal plane, reducing the momentum resolution. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Outcome of Daresbury Meeting 2 magnet design would give better energy resolution than single square magnet design. Adds in an extra variable to adjust: distance between magnets (fields must be matched). Second magnet either needs to be big or accept reduction in single-shot energy spread acceptance. Will need to do tracking simulations (MAD-X/GPT/BDSIM) to characterise performance. Perhaps go for 2-stage approach: Use single magnet with large momentum acceptance to get a general idea about energies produced from plasma. Add second magnet to make precision measurements once we know what energy range we’re looking at. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Experimental Layout Design really split into two sections: Dispersive part (magnet + input beam simulations). Collection part (screen and camera system). Can design the two largely independently (so long as you keep sizes in mind): Magnet simply has to deliver electron beam with monotonic energy-position spread to some point downstream. Electron position measurement doesn’t need to know about how beam dynamics is produced upstream, merely what energy-position correlation is. The third part is unique to AWAKE: transitioning from vacuum pipe to air. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Windowed Beampipe 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Windowed Beampipe: Camera Position 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Vacuum Vessel 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Light Tight Vessel 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Off-Axis Camera + Focussing Mirror 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Scintillator Screen Default scintillator choice is Lanex: Manufactured by Kodak. Used in Medical Physics as X-ray phosphor for imaging. Gd2O2S:Tb – Gadolinium sensitiser, Terbium dopant activator/wavelength shifter. Phosphor grains on reflective backing. Properties don’t seem to be well documented/studied… Need to simulate light production (photons per MeV conversion efficiency) to ensure we have enough photons emitted in direction of camera. Procuring GadOx samples from Applied Scintillation Technologies: Variants of Medex screens (AST trade name for GadOx medical x-ray phosphor screens). More phosphor = higher light output = lower resolution. Need to compare results from Geant4 simulations with experimental tests using known source. 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Vac. Chamb. (grey)

Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review Conclusions Simulation results for scintillator light output reasonably promising: Can collect light from all electron hits with camera at 0.7 m. Can still reconstruct energy spectrum with camera further away without focussing lens. Need to refine vacuum chamber dimensions: where is transition between vacuum and air for electrons? Magnet still a concern: Is MBPS going to give us large enough field region to measure sufficient energy range? Would we be better designing our own magnet (£100k per magnet at least…)? Would 2 magnet “chicane” spectrometer give better performance? Would certainly reduce energy acceptance… Difficult to give precision measurement of 0.01-5 GeV beam… 26/03/14 Simon Jolly, UCL, AWAKE Spectrometer Review