Defining and Measuring the Middle Class Steven Pressman

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Setting the Stage President’s Symposium Confronting Inequality: Political, Educational, and Social Consequences & Remedies May 11, 2012 Kristin J. Kleinjans.

Advertisements

1 Income Inequality in Rich Countries A B Atkinson, Nuffield College, Oxford ECINEQ Conference Mallorca July 2005.

Theodore Mitrakos Bank of Greece & Panos Tsakloglou Athens University of Economics and Business & IZA INEQUALITY, POVERY AND WELFARE IN GREECE: FROM THE.

Two Worlds of Ageing: Spatial Microsimulation Estimates of Small Area Advantage and Disadvantage Among Older Australians JUSTINE MCNAMARA, CATHY GONG,

Chapter 6 Economic Inequality.

Is Inequality Increasing? Presentation for Parliamentary Library Vital Issues Seminar, 10 October 2012 Peter Whiteford, Crawford School of Public Policy.

% of Households Lowest 20% Second 20% Middle 20% Fourth 20% Richest 20% % of Income This model shows the distribution of income across households.

Inequality and Redistribution in the Australian Welfare State

© 2003 By Default!Slide 1 Inequality Measures Celia M. Reyes Introduction to Poverty Analysis NAI, Beijing, China Nov. 1-8, 2005.

BANCA D’ITALIA E U R O S I S T E M A Trade and Wage Inequality, Mirage or Reality? Gian Maria Tomat New Directions in Welfare July 2011, OECD,

Income inequality and poverty in Poland and Romania Daniel Mortazavi Isabel David João Sousa Renato Alves.

Poverty: Facts, Causes and Consequences Hilary Hoynes University of California, Davis California Symposium on Poverty October 2009.

McTaggart, Findlay, Parkin: Microeconomics © 2007 Pearson Education Australia Chapter 18: Economic Inequality and Redistribution.

Introduction to Economics: Social Issues and Economic Thinking Wendy A. Stock PowerPoint Prepared by Z. Pan CHAPTER 20 POVERTY AND THE DISTRIBUTION OF.

Centre for Tax Policy and Administration Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Trends in Top Incomes & Inequality, and their implications.

Distributional Analysis of Tax Policy: Theory and Practice Joseph Rosenberg Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center February 20, 2014.

The effect of uncertainty on fuel poverty statistics Laura Williams, Department of Energy and Climate Change GSS Methodology Symposium, 6 th July 2011.

New Labor Trends Over the past 15 years Labor has significantly changed Globally: Globalization: “free trade” with other countries Collapse of Soviet Union.

New Labor Trends Over the past 15 years Labor has significantly changed Globally: Globalization: “free trade” with other countries Collapse of Soviet Union.

Analysis of unemployment and monetary poverty in European countries Analýza nezamestnanosti a monetárnej chudoby v krajinách Európy Ing. Iveta Stankovičová,

Michael Rogan & John Reynolds. Content International context International Labour Organisation SA context Income, wages & earnings over post-apartheid.

Agenda item 13 Expert Group on Disparities in National Accounts Meeting of the Advisory Expert Group (AEG) on National Accounts Luxembourg, May 2013.

Chapter 10. Lorenz Curve and Gini Coefficient Measure distribution of thing your interested in. E.g.   Share of largest firms in an oligopolistic industry,

Cumulative impacts of austerity measures and the distribution of economic outcomes John Hills Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of.

Key issues for a better measurement of income and employment Berkeley Hill, University of London.

Introduction to Sociology: Social Inequality Siniša Zrinščak November 18, 2014

1 Shrinking middle classes: Public policies and polarization of incomes Louis Chauvel with Eyal Bar-Haim University of Luxembourg

Measure distribution of thing your interested in. E.g.  Share of largest firms in an oligopolistic industry, e.g share of top eight, sixteen etc  distribution.

Journal Question: February 10, 2015 How much of the US wealth do you think each group has? Top 20% Second 20% Third 20% Fourth 20% Bottom 20% What should.

1 Measuring Poverty: Inequality Measures Charting Inequality Share of Expenditure of Poor Dispersion Ratios Lorenz Curve Gini Coefficient Theil Index Comparisons.

Income Inequality in Serbia Gorana Krstić, Faculty of Economics, University of Belgrade Conference: Understanding inequality in Southeast Europe: Taking.

 What is the difference between wealth & Income?  How do you measure wealth?  What are assets & debts?  What does it mean to be wealthy but little.

2.4.1and unit content Students should be able to: Define national income and show that it can be seen as a circular flow (and draw this) Explain.

Fig Inequality and the Redistribution of Income. fig Ratio of income shares of bottom 40% to top 20% of households (after taxes and benefits)

14 October 2016 Christian Daude

(co-author: Santiago Sanchez) LIS/LWS Users Conference

More Necessary and Less Sufficient: Age-Period-Cohort Approach to Overeducation in a Comparative Perspective Eyal Bar-Haim, Anne Hartung and Louis Chauvel.

Vito Peragine| Università di Bari SAPIENZA UNIVERSITÀ DI ROMA

How Inclusive Has Development Been In Pakistan?

Middle Class Fortunes in Western Europe and the U.S.

Changes in Poverty Reduction and Fiscal Redistribution in Comparative Perspective: Longitudinal Evidence from the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) David K.

INEQUALITY TRENDS IN THE EU SINCE THE CRISIS

Inequalities of Development Lorenz Curve

@ LIS … We gather income datasets, based on household surveys, from a large number of countries; we harmonize them, and we make them available to researchers.

Social Expenditure across OECD countries: concepts and indicators

Defining & Measuring the Middle Class

Analysis of results.

Chapter 11 Social Class and Consumer Behavior

Business Economics (ECO 341) Fall: 2012 Semester

LIS conference 27th – 28th April 2017 Charles-Henri DiMaria - ANEC

Chapter 11 Social Class and Consumer Behavior

Bank of Greece Conference on

FISS 2017 Inequality in the European Union

Emilia Niskanen and Timothy Smeeding, Luxembourg Income Study

Cost-sharing in higher education

Louis Chauvel, University of Luxembourg, IRSEI

Wiemer Salverda AIAS, University of Amsterdam

Public policy and European society University of Castellanza

Chapter 3 What Economics Do.

Chapter 11 Social Class and Consumer Behavior

An examination of the purpose and techniques of inequality measurement

Presented by Jorrit Zwijnenburg (OECD)

Asset-based Reallocations

HELLENIC STATISTICAL AUTHORITY

Why are some people rich and some people poor?

Capital Accumulation, Private Property and Rising Inequality in China,

An alternative vision for the global and European economies

Poverty and household spending in Britain

Changes in Income Inequality in Lithuania: The Role of Policy, Labour Market Structure, Returns and Demographics Comments by Anna Lukyanova IARIW-HSE.

Presentation transcript:

Defining and Measuring the Middle Class Steven Pressman Comments by Anne Hartung, University of Luxembourg

The paper in a nutshell Aims Epistemology/academic discourse: Find a “good measure of middle class” Apply this definition to LIS data (and show its evolution over time?) Contributions Focus on the middle while most research looks at the bottom and the top of the income distribution Critical, detailed review of different definitions and operationalisation of middle class Evolution of middle class over a long period of time

Income-based definition of middle class Two “categorical” approaches Proportion of the distribution (between 20th and 80th percentile) Percentage of median household income Here: Based on Pew Survey (US, 2010) “How much income was necessary for a typical four person household to be middle class”: 67-200% Disposable household income Cash and near-cash earnings, capital income, private income, public transfers, less direct taxes

Drawbacks of applied definition Based on US perception of middle class 2010 – but is the understanding of middle class (living standards) really constant over time (crisis?) and across regions/neighbourhoods and countries? The necessary income for middle class varies across time and countries, e.g. expenditures for housing, education, etc. What is then the advantage relative to the first approach (middle quintiles)? How arbitrary are these thresholds and what is the relative advantage to continuous measures of the middle class? Can this measure help to locate the middle class?

Income hierarchy in six countries Source: Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) Database Chauvel, L. 2016. The intensity and shape of inequality: The ABG method of distributional analysis. Review of Income and Wealth.

Ignored but important facets of middle class Focusing on disposable income ignores important facets of middle class (which however can be estimated with the LIS data) Growing relevance of wealth relative to income (Piketty 2014) Housing prices relative to income (Mack and Martínez-García 2011, Bradbury 2013 using LWS) Intra-household earnings ratio Labour stability …

Suggestions in sum Further potential to contribute to the debate: Compare definitions against each other and point out implications (cf. aim of finding a “good measure”) Relate empirical analysis to current debate on a broader range of aspects of middle class (possible with LIS) Facilitate international comparison and relate to finding to Gornick and Jäntti (eds) 2013 Income Inequality: Economic Disparities and the Middle Class in Affluent Countries